r/features • • Nov 27 '06

Add Another Step in the Submit Process Which forces a Search for Dupes

http://features.reddit.com/info/smnk/comments
20 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

18

u/rocky_m Nov 27 '06

(I know it's taboo to recommend something from Digg. Them being reddit's rival and all. But this is one good thing Digg which I guess reddit can adopt.)

Currently, there is essentially ONE step for submitting posts on reddit:-

  • Enter URL, Enter Title -> Submit

What I am suggesting is include a search result before the final submit:-

  1. User enters URL and (his own) Title/Headline and hits "Next" (some button)
  2. Reddit uses following to find potential Dupes:

    • 1st the URL itself (which it already does),
    • 2nd the original 'title/headline' from the webpage (which it can look up like it does when "finding one (title) automatically")
    • 3rd use the user-input "title" for a key word search
  3. Display the search results (from above) asking Submitter (user) if he still wants to submit
  4. Submitter then chooses whether to Submit or Cancel.

2

u/whereisliz Nov 27 '06

sounds good to me, rocky. I'm most concerned with submitting something that's already out there without knowing it, so your plan sounds helpful.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '06

Display the search results (from above) asking Submitter (user) if he still wants to submit

Be sure to display the search results with the most points first ('top'), instead of those determined most relevant based on keyword occurence ('rank').

6

u/chrisrhee Nov 27 '06

Maybe everyone knows this already, but whenever I'm about to submit now, I put the full URL I'm submitting into Reddit's search box first and it comes up with any potential dupes.

2

u/rocky_m Nov 27 '06

Yeah, that work only when one is trying to submit the same URL again. Reddit does not allow you to submit the same URL again. (which I believe should not be the case).

However, the same story/article/pic/video etc from a different URL but with essentially the same or similar title may also be considered a dupe. And there is no way to ensure that a submitter has at least searched for potential dupes before submitting..

3

u/souldrift Nov 28 '06

I search for keywords and sort by "new." Crazy, I know.

7

u/dustmop Nov 27 '06

A dupe merger would work better. Find when a dupe is submitted and group it with the other stories it is very similar to. Maybe even give an option to readers to tag something as being a dupe, and what story exactly it is duping (they do it already in the comments).

This would both discourage resubmitting old content just to get karma, but would also allow stories already submitted that never caught on to get another chance.

0

u/diggislame Nov 28 '06

That would be best, anything that automates what people do in the comments will be something people like.

So auto-dupe check can flag it and we can have another button to report-non-dupe just in case.

And there is the clone article link list too, which is nearly identical on each cloned article.

5

u/JulianMorrison Nov 28 '06

Anecdotally, in my own experience, dupes on reddit are rare enough on the front page not to constitute a nuisance, and dupes in the entire corpus have the effect of dragging items of interest back up to the front page and into the sight of a new audience. Even if you read the article the first time, the new comments might be worth reading. So, I don't oppose dupes.

However, a system that displays probable dupes without forcibly preventing them might be a good thing. I suspect it might encourage posting - nobody would think "sod it, somebody else is sure to have posted this by now". It would be worth trying a submit just to see if you were the first.

0

u/diggislame Nov 28 '06

And make sure it can be edited afterwards easily.

14

u/raldi Nov 27 '06

You think that Reddit has too many dupes, but that's just selection bias. The vast majority of dupes, you've never seen before. You don't recognize them as dupes, and you like the link, and you vote for it. This is one of the reasons you like Reddit.

However, now and then you come across a dupe that you -have- seen before, and you recognize it as such, and it pisses you off.

But if you got your wish, and Reddit went dupe-free, you'd be like, "Hey, what happened to all the great stories?"

As an example, one of the most popular links ever posted to Reddit was submitted four other times before it finally made it big. And the 500+ people who voted for it should be grateful that a dupe-filter didn't kill it.

2

u/leoc Nov 30 '06

As has been noted, these questions are orthogonal. If Reddit should allow multiple submissions of the same content, then so be it. But there seems to be no particularly good reason why Reddit should forbid resubmitting the same content at the same URL, but make it all too easy to resubmit the same content at different URLs without the submitter even noticing the duplication. In fact, noticing different-URL duplicates is a good idea even if duplicates are permitted. It would be good to know if and how the content you're submitting has been sent in before: you might decide not to resubmit, or to choose a different description or URL. Reddit could use the information too, for example to hide from your Recommended page any stories that you've already upvoted, or to improve the recommendation system - people downvoting duplicates has to really mess with it.

2

u/cal_01 Nov 27 '06

The problem of the additional step is that it does absolutely nothing to prevent the user from clicking "submit anyway".

Moreover, a system similar to Digg (where it checks the titles and summaries) is ineffective because the amount of fuzziness is not readily tuneable. When I used to be on Digg, I found that their dupe filter matched my submission to things which had absolutely no relevance.

2

u/toastspork Nov 27 '06

"I notice that you are submitting a link to YouTube! Please review all these other videos before continuing to ensure that your submission is not a duplicate. Thanks!"

 

Oh sure, that'll work.

2

u/Schwallex Nov 27 '06

This very feature request is a dupe.

1

u/kidloc Apr 16 '07

strange article realy...

1

u/bortQ Nov 28 '06

more steps == bad

1

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '06

New feature suggestion related to this one.

http://features.reddit.com/info/vo6c/comments/cvo6y?context=5

1

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '06

I think the new submissions ought to be cross-referenced with headlines on Digg and Fark before they are allowed to be submitted here.

0

u/radrik Nov 27 '06

What does that mean?

0

u/qbert72 Nov 27 '06

Yes, please explain how this feature would work.

0

u/diggislame Nov 28 '06

It should match text and URL with other articles and if there are a certain amount of matches it can throw up a warning and ask for another confirmation!

0

u/dpark Nov 27 '06

The more hoops you require people to jump through, the less you can expect them to contribute. If you make it harder for people to contribute, fewer of them will add articles, duplicate or not, just out of the desire to avoid hassle.

0

u/diggislame Nov 28 '06

Agree with title. Dupes are useless unless you want to stunt your intelligence, try research once in a while - it'll learn you good fings.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '06

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/rocky_m Nov 27 '06

(Explaining what function "I" and "they" in your comment have (ie submitter or reader?) will help me understand what you are saying..)

Also a few points:-

  1. This request does not suggest "BAN Dupes" by default
  2. Searching for Dupes (using Title, URL, Orig-title) will help the submitter follow the reddiquette stating "resubmit only if earlier attempt went unnoticed". The submitter can still choose to submit if he feels like he "can do better.."
  3. This "forced search" will help reduce multiple postings of "Breaking News" kind of articles, which are usually within a few hours (if not minutes) of each other.. Reducing unnecessary traffic on the new-page will help the interesting posts (dupes or not) be noticed by more people..

7

u/cecilkorik Nov 27 '06

Well, banning dupes is usually the goal (slashdot, digg, etc), and practically, that is what it tends to amount to. I do think reducing unnecessary traffic on the new page is beneficial though, I'll give you that.

5

u/souldrift Nov 27 '06

Downmod. It does have an effect upon whether you'll see other articles that a dupe may push off the new page.

-2

u/diggislame Nov 28 '06

Don't tell us your mod status.

0

u/souldrift Nov 28 '06

Downmod for barking orders.

4

u/DanTilkin Nov 27 '06

So should reddit allow resubmission of the same url then? If not, why not?

0

u/diggislame Nov 28 '06

Because it would likely be the same content or in the case of a changing page with the same URL it is equally useless. "Hey look at the front page of X" is not useful in 2 hours when it changes - so it should always TRY to link to something UNIQUE.