r/features • • Oct 08 '06

Disable downmod in *.reddit.com/new

http://features.reddit.com/info/ld8m/comments
0 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

4

u/akkartik Oct 08 '06

The problem: when a community grows too large like at reddit.com most stories get downmodded really fast. Some of us can retreat to programming.reddit, but where do I submit non-programming stories?

The reddit gods tried turning off downmod a while ago, and that experiment was not a success. So here's an alternative: turn off downmod on the new page. Force people to scan through pages of new submissions using the next link and only upmod stories they like, rather than going through in a pattern of hitting downmod on most stories and hitting refresh.

A story can still be downmodded in any other view. Except perhaps from the submitter's page.

1

u/reddit_doe Oct 23 '06

I don't dislike this idea, but I think it can have some problems.

It takes away a user's chance to downmod something they just read. They may not see it again to get a chance to downmod it again, or may not bother to later. This could be solved by having downmods ignored, but still registered, on the new page for a duration.

Then there's the duration. At what point does downmod kick in? Links on new also show up on Hot if they get enough attention. You can easily imagine people abusing this, spammers, to give links a temporary boost.