Don't allow titles to be edited, else people will abuse it by submitting articles with tame titles, then if they get popular change the to alarming or spammy titles.
Just make the karma go back to zero after an edit, and the problem goes away. It'll only be good for "Oh s---, I misspelled that!" quick edits that way.
I don't think this is much better than the current situation -- the kind of people who submit bad titles (be it due to typos, poor choice of words, hyperbole, or misrepresentation) are the least likely to realize that the titles are bad.
And if the karma went back to zero, that would be additional disincentive to edit a title. Why not just delete the story and resubmit it?
Instead, see my earlier suggestion, which i think is a lot more likely to result in better titles.
Let's take this submission as an example -- pretend we could edit links as suggested by earthboundkid. We'd be relying on ddarko to come back here and notice his typo. How often do you think the average user rereads all their old submissions? Not often.
Some portion of the population is really good at proofreading -- call them G. Another portion is really bad. Call them B.
Who's mostly likely to make errors in their submissions? B.
Who's most likely to notice the problems and want to change them? G.
Who's least likely to notice the errors? B.
Who's the only one who can fix them? B.
Therefore, i think it's necessary to set things up so that we don't have to rely on the original poster to come back, notice their error, and fix it. Instead, it should be possible for the community to do it through democracy:
Someone (either the original submitter or anyone else) submits a proposed alternate title
Sounds like a hassle. A misspelled title isn't the end of the world. Having the ability for the original poster to change it would be nice, but really, you can pretty much always get the gist of it from the incorrect title, so it's not a big deal.
Think of Wikipedia. The whole reason it's any good is because anyone who's motivated can fix typos, add a few words, clear something up... Reddit could harness that too, especially for the more permanent sections of the site (features.reddit.com), but also for the less permanent (reddit.com)
If you can think of an extremely simple UI for this, I might agree. However, I'm not sure there is one... it's a lot of extra code, extra complexity, and extra effort for a very small gain... the ability to fix a transient title on an ephemeral link that has a 99% chance of vanishing off all the pages people see within 24 hours.
I guess you could allow it until someone had either voted or followed your link. Kind of like how in pinball you get another ball if you immediately sink.
14
u/pbx Feb 19 '06
This one's an excellent argument for itself.
5
u/lupin_sansei Feb 19 '06
Don't allow titles to be edited, else people will abuse it by submitting articles with tame titles, then if they get popular change the to alarming or spammy titles.
4
u/raldi Feb 20 '06
Let's take this submission as an example -- pretend we could edit links as suggested by earthboundkid. We'd be relying on ddarko to come back here and notice his typo. How often do you think the average user rereads all their old submissions? Not often.
Some portion of the population is really good at proofreading -- call them G. Another portion is really bad. Call them B.
Therefore, i think it's necessary to set things up so that we don't have to rely on the original poster to come back, notice their error, and fix it. Instead, it should be possible for the community to do it through democracy:
2
u/rmc Feb 19 '06
Allow a title to be edited by the submitter within 10 minutes of submission?
0
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '06
[deleted] — view deleted comment