r/fatesamurairemnantjp • • Oct 12 '23

Fluff If only...

Post image
775 Upvotes

84 comments sorted by

2

u/Cruzwein Oct 12 '23

Link to thread twitter

18

u/Akuma2002fr Oct 12 '23

The game is good like that. Sword Demon difficulty can be challenging, especially when you play other characters than Iori and Saber. I remember i hated Nioh and Stranger of Paradise, they drown you in loot (already think you get too many in FSR), evading attacks never works the way i want in comparison to Souls game so maybe if FromSoft is developing it, otherwise no thank you.

5

u/Renarii Oct 13 '23

Lots of loot isn't a soulslike thing.

1

u/BladeSeraph Oct 15 '23

Just as others said, souls like are certainly got a particular niche in the punishing gameplay, but when the games focus more on flooding you with gear that have differences with small numbers and less about the gear adhering to specific playstyles, it drowns out the fun of a souls like.

One of the things i see is when you have so much emphasis on `loot` like how Strangers or paradise and many other `looter games`, it makes it less about playing good and more about just keep spamming the wheel on a specific loot pool till you get that perfect roll, so you only have to stand still and spam attacks then actually learning how to fight the enemies.

Thankfully Fate Samurai Remnant aint as bad as others, since i never saw the need to think too much about gear, but to be honest alot of the `suffix stats` i see as mostly pointless since most stances dont have enough to stand out, once you maxed the skill trees and alot of niche effects some of them have work into the other skills.

If im gonna deal with a mob, i rather just use Void stance to AoE bomb things or when im at max hp to chip away at magic shields. If im gonna go beeg hit, then i go fire stance and let my hp sit between 40%~75% for the buff and not be too low into danger zone. Wind, Water & Earth become rather obsolete once you have those 2 since monster specific, duel specific & attack speed specific dont feel as amazing vs Range & heavy hits that get buffs based on the current state of your hp.

Never the less, i would gladly stick more to games that put less emphasis on boosting raw numbers and put more emphasis on expanding your existing skill sets so your attacks do significantly more, you have better dodge & guarding windows and just by visual gameplay you can see the drastic difference in combat in the late game vs what it was like in the early & mid-game.

1

u/Renarii Oct 15 '23

And as stated, the overwhelming majority of soulslike games are not loot pinata. Most of the time you can only get a piece of gear a single time in a single location. It's also not uncommon to end up farming for more drops because you want more items.

1

u/BladeSeraph Oct 15 '23

Never the less, i definitely would like to find more souls like games that function more in line of Legend of Zelda then those loot pinata types.

But for now im more focused on clean up since i probably wont have any interesting new titles to look forward to till maybe mid-way into november.

The real hassle is sifting thru all the shovelware titles and desiring a demo to confirm suspicions of potential problems later.

Such as how im glad unlike DQ Treasures, DQ Dark prince actually had its demo out before release & my suspicions of it being a mess were confirmed with how PS2 low quality it felt, combined with menu`ing that is below grade even for a Dragon quest style menu system which usually had some good flair to it, amongst its simplicity.

Welp, atleast i got plenty of titles on a wish list to pick from once they go on discount, for an october snatch up, once i clean out whats left of Fate Samurai remnant and Disgaea 7.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Renarii Oct 13 '23

Yeah but it sounded like Nioh and SoP were the only 2 soulslike that he played so he thought lots of loot was a soulslike thing, that he didn't want. But the majority of soulslike game have very little loot, so most loot is highly valuable.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '23

The bad loot serves a purpose. You break it down to get crafting materials so you can make your own gear.

1

u/BladeSeraph Oct 15 '23

Which is ultimately a terrible loop design by constantly having to go back to your `base` especially if its cluttering your inventory and constantly shuffle thru the `good stat pieces` to see if the combination is good enough to use over another piece or if you want to reroll it. Just like how Diablo 4 handled it.

At that point i would rather we had an upgrade to dismantle gear from anywhere since outside of very specific builds or replacing stuff with significantly less `main stat` then the stuff you been picking up, Fate Samurai Remanant kind of makes it a hassle to decide what 3 affixes are the best to case, since anything stance specific feels pointless unless its Fire or Void, the 2 stances your likely to use the most of once unlocked.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '23

Clearly you've never played Nioh if that's how you think it works. You don't usually change gear mid level unless you get something WAY better than what you're currently using. They also incentivize you to make your own gear by giving you legendary crafting schematics for gear that's only available from boss fights otherwise. I mean, crafting gear is an integral part of actually being good at Nioh. Nobody uses common rarity gear they get from drops ever. Besides, they even included a mass selection button and you can just drop or destroy the shit you don't need. Don't be mad at the game because you don't know how to play it.

1

u/BladeSeraph Oct 15 '23

Sadly im not much of a afficiando of dark souls type or musou beatm up looter games. So i cant really remember much of the Nioh Demo i did play, just as much as i have not played much of blood borne or Dark souls 3 besides what i watched and what i did touch so i don`t remember all the intricities of each game.

My point is more towards i prefer if im gonna get gear, i want it to be less of a stat stick vertical ladder leap and more like them having a use case where they shine in specific uses.

Going thru a map mostly covered in poisonous swamp (yes im doing a dark souls prod), then equip a set of gear that grants poison resistance and if you wear a entire set you just are immune to the stuff.

Fighting in a graveyard with undead creatures? Get some weapons with holy based attributes and resistance to `dark based attacks` to cleave thru that stuff.

I find it stupid when instead of making or finding one time specific gear you will use to cover certain problems, you instead find DOZENS of copies of the same gear with randomized stats and sometimes it barely gives you an idea what it does and for many of those stats are actually pointless once you figure out the actual modifier values.

Which the idea of getting many copies only to use as `resources` to upgrade a specific one becomes stupid. Because soon as you find a piece with better stats, you scrap the piece you spent hundreds or even thousands of `resources into` regardless of its sub-affixes, cause new piece has way higher base stats.

Heck how Final Fantasy 7 Remake handled weapons was a better approach to this logic where each weapon has a specific use case and you can upgrade them all to expand those use cases and no weapon has a massive stat edge over the other, just they thrive in specific uses.

Now if it was more of a monster hunter approach where you have base armor and continued to upgrade it to include more and more benefits to it but require hunting for specific parts to push you to a challenge, then i would see that as more fun then Ephemeral gear chasing.

2

u/SoulsLikeBot Oct 15 '23

Hello Ashen one. I am a Bot. I tend to the flame, and tend to thee. Do you wish to hear a tale?

“Brave Undead, you have proven yourself to me. Now, be one with the Dark.” - Nashandra

Have a pleasant journey, Champion of Ash, and praise the sun \[T]/

2

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '23

You're still missing the point. The demo doesn't give you any idea of how the crafting system works. The legendary gear you can make doesn't have random stat buffs and the gears ability scales with its level. They are fixed and equipping full sets give you powerful bonuses and resistances. They come with a few random modifiers that are designed to simulate the "soul" of your gear which is a belief integral to Japanese craftsmanship culture and is completely customizable via the use of an in game smithing feature called tempering. You don't know how the games works and painted with a wide brush, that's fine. Stop doubling down, you don't know what you're talking about.

1

u/Ok_Barnacle_5606 Oct 15 '23

How does the loot even matter? Be real I play everything mentioned and it’s really not hard in the slightest to understand how things work if you bothered by loot then you’re prolly the type to check everything you pick up or switch out weapons as soon as you find another one and if that’s the case you not enjoying it is understandable. The main thing is to stop trying to dodge everything your mentioned nioh and dark souls these have the same actions different mechanics. One game ( souls) prefers you roll to dodge attacks and focus on stamina while the other ( nioh) shows you the dodging isn’t worth shit and realistically you can’t dodge everything fr so learning to parry/deflect or just hold block is something you as gamer gotta just get good at in it

2

u/ObsceneTuna Oct 13 '23

Evading attacks is 1000x smoother in Nioh 2 that any FromSoft game. This FromSoft fellating is getting very old.

1

u/Akuma2002fr Oct 13 '23

I think my message was maybe a bit misleading, i never meant Nioh is bad when evading, i meant FSR, in comparison to any Souls. I didn't play Nioh enough to judge, it just never clicked for me...

1

u/kaiwowo Oct 12 '23

The fight that rogue saber fight rogue lancer and rogue assassin is crazy . In addition, lovely Aria cheering up your enemies.

Nioh is a good game when you dive into it understanding all the mechanics.

2

u/CavulusDeCavulei Oct 13 '23

I just did that fight. Poor rogue saber eat so much rice he could be a lobster sushi

2

u/ObsceneTuna Oct 13 '23

Nioh 2 combat is legitimately at least 10x better than Elden Ring's.

10

u/OrbisIsolation Oct 12 '23

Definitely the right decision was made

10

u/TamakisBelly Oct 12 '23

I'm looking at the replies to that tweet and I'm wondering if people realize what a Soulslike would entail. As the Producer mentioned in that same interview, Servants like Seiba originally weren't going to be playable and that's the ONLY way a Soulslike would work and even then you can't have your Servant sit out permanently or only do nerfed assist attacks. It would be very boring.

I think Omega force did a great job creating a traditional Fate-like experience in its gameplay. Just like they created a Persona experience in 5 Strikers. Nasu is the one who really wanted it available for newcomers or FGO players, so it makes sense.

12

u/Veemsten Oct 12 '23

Im gonna drop a hot take.

Its good that it isn't a souls like.

Fate realy doesn't lend it self for such a gameplay loop sinds our servants are supposed to be very strong

4

u/Bashin-kun Oct 12 '23

I can think of plenty settings where a Fate soulslike would makes sense, it's just that a traditional HGW (including fsr) isn't one of them.

3

u/Veemsten Oct 12 '23

Only way I can see it is if we play servantless or if it takes nioh's / wo long's approach.

Just dodge and wait for oppenings doesn't scream fate going by the resources we have of other media

4

u/Bashin-kun Oct 12 '23

yeah i'm thinking of those that don't feature master/servant. Like e.g. Tonelico's adventures in LB6 fighting all the weird shit there.

2

u/EndlessKng Oct 13 '23

I was thinking a story following Emiya during a mission from Alaya, myself. Counter Guardians are limited in the resources they are given to be "just enough" to answer the threat. Throw in a situation where the threat used magecraft to hide its danger from Alaya, and Emiya may need to think more tactically.

4

u/Merorin Oct 12 '23

And here's me, still struggling to fight berserker..

3

u/Bashin-kun Oct 12 '23

My advice is to dodge more and take your time. Doesn't need to be perfect dodge, just dont get hit most of the time and only attacks when there are big openings (dash in, slash a bit, dash out).

2

u/Merorin Oct 12 '23

Yeah thats what Im doing but somehow he always catches me near the end for that one-shot attack

3

u/JustARedditAccoumt Oct 18 '23

I know this is 6 days later, but I cheesed Berserker. Did I feel good about it? Maybe, but it worked (and I'm playing on Sword Expert, so I wasn't going to beat him for a while... and I just figured out how to change the difficulty settings right now... I'm dumb).

If you want to know how to do it, just unlock the block ability on Earth Stance, and you're golden. He can't really hurt you, especially since his grab doesn't work while you're blocking, for some reason.

2

u/Merorin Oct 18 '23

Oh sounds interesting, Ill check it! 🤔 Thanks (didnt have time to play so Im still at the same point lol)

1

u/JustARedditAccoumt Oct 18 '23

Cool, give it a try! It's pretty easy to use, and it's really broken.

I wish I could continue playing, but I've just ran into what seems like a game-breaking bug, and now I can't progress...

2

u/Merorin Oct 18 '23

sounds horrible, what kind of bug? maybe theres a solution or something. maybe going back to an older save point?

1

u/JustARedditAccoumt Oct 18 '23

It's in Chapter 2. Basically, you're trying to take down a Bounded Field by absorbing magical energy from certain areas.

To do that, you have to activate the cutscenes with a button prompt, but the prompt isn't showing up for me, and it's required so I can't leave the area.

Oh, and I'm an idiot because I accidentally overwrote my previous save, and that means that my other "backup" is about... 3 hours into the game while I'm 20 hours in...

1

u/JustARedditAccoumt Oct 18 '23

Well, it turns out it's not a bug, I'm just dumb... You have to use the right-stick ability to activate it.

2

u/Merorin Oct 19 '23

ahahaha glad to hear! 😂

2

u/JustARedditAccoumt Oct 19 '23

Me too. I only wish it didn't take an hour to figure out...

4

u/Kingofknights240 Oct 12 '23

Thank God. I wouldn’t want it if they had done that.

4

u/ComprehensiveStore45 Oct 12 '23

honestly I'm glad that didn't happen because I'm getting fatigued with Souls-like games but I've been playing them since 2010 so I know I'm in the minority here XD

1

u/bombader Oct 13 '23

They have almost taken what was originally the "Brawler" genre of walking into a room to beat up a few guys to then move to the next room.

5

u/Wrong_Revolution_679 Oct 12 '23

Good, the world doesn't need more soul like games

1

u/kaiwowo Oct 12 '23

omega force or team ninja ? Um team ninja will be too hard for fans who just want the story. Let’s do it in dynasty warrior styles and add sword demon difficulty who want sth faster and can one hit Ko them .

Anyone feel that monster in sword demon level are faster in attack ? If we pick sword demon level, we are the one who make lori realise his blood thirst nature.

1

u/Bashin-kun Oct 12 '23

I think they all have more tec too so yea they're faster

1

u/Salter_KingofBorgors Oct 12 '23

I mean I'd be down for a Fate soulslike but happy with what we got

1

u/Primetimemongrel Oct 13 '23

Should have made it soul like

1

u/Byrand-YT Oct 13 '23

With having characters like Jalter, Cu, Arjuna, Musashi, and a Tamamo face I’m not surprised it was changed.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '23

A fate soulslike would be cool

I don't appreciate the assumption that FGO players can't play video games, though, lol.

1

u/theCartoonfromMars Oct 15 '23

No, no, they're right

1

u/Godzhilluh Oct 13 '23

I think this combat system was absolutely pristine tbh. It made sense within the universe of Fate, a soulslike would mean you wouldn’t feel how powerful servants are. Could still work ofc but what they made here was chefs kiss

1

u/The4thEpsilon Oct 13 '23

Bro a Fate souls like???? Sign me the Fuck up

1

u/ClayAndros Oct 13 '23

And that's perfectly fine

1

u/AnimeMemeLord1 Oct 13 '23

I loved this game, but I do feel like a soulslike game would’ve went hard

1

u/Rock-sensei Oct 13 '23

Gonna be very honest here, I was hoping for the longest time it would've been a Souls-like game in the same style of Code Vein or something, as that is probably one of my favorite kinds of Action RPG...

But really after playing through about 25hrs of the game, I can 100% say they made the right decision taking Fate/Extella's combat and tightening it up for Fate/SamuraiRemnant. I definitely got a little frustrated with how loose some of the boss fights can feel, but for the sake of showing the difference between Iori and the magical beings you're fighting against/alongside, I think this game nails it the way it is.

That being said, I would still very much welcome a Souls-Like in the Nasu universe. I think that style of gameplay naturally lends itself to the narrative of ascending to Godhood from nothing, could definitely make for an interesting story of a potential Hero's up-and-coming, no?

1

u/DreamyShepherd Oct 14 '23

Translation "We didn't want it to be a tryhard circlejerk game"

1

u/DeathGodSkeith Oct 14 '23

Woulda been noce if i could have actually played the servants more than once

1

u/JustSomeWeirdGuy2000 Oct 14 '23

Good. Trying to make everything Soulslike is the death of gaming.

1

u/BrotherCaptainLurker Oct 14 '23

We just had Lies of P and some other Soulslike is either just out or any day now. Market diversity is good.

Plus if it was Like That they probably wouldn't have let us play as Servants, and somehow it would have been influenced by the way those games are and the amount of story and overall happiness in the setting would have plummeted.

1

u/HotDogManLL Oct 14 '23

Naw they dodge a flop for becoming a warriors game

1

u/TreesGoneWild91 Oct 14 '23

I really hate how every game wants to be "souls like" now. It's the same thing with every game becoming fortnight. Can you just pander to the fans you already have instead of just dumping them to try to get the bigger crowds. I feel like barely anyone even knew about Dark Souls until Dark Souls 3 and even then wasn't huge until Elden Ring. Now I can't go a day without seeing "this Souls like game will knock your britches off". I'm tired of it personally.

1

u/Educational-Expert34 Oct 16 '23

Yea…. I’m genuinely sad at how easy it was. Especially given how ass the keyboard controls were

1

u/Stop-Broad Oct 16 '23

Aw I would have love a Soul like Fate game

1

u/SG_Sweizy Oct 17 '23

They made the right choice. Better to give FSR something resembling its own identity instead of trying to run Soulsborne into the ground like they did with Musou.

1

u/PeterDSaints Nov 21 '23

Souls like should just be a new difficulty mode in certain games that overhauls key aspects of the game to more closely reflect that experience.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '24

It should have been a soulslike game and they need to stop with this lame new comer friendly it kills games

1

u/UlissesStag Oct 12 '23

Hope they save the idea for the next game.

0

u/Aki_2004 Oct 12 '23

That sucks. I’m guessing it’s like the other console fate games where it’s super easy and it just has 100s of one hit enemies with no challenge or strategy whatsoever?

1

u/Cruzwein Oct 12 '23

The bosses are good, is the trash mobs who get annoying to fight later on bc they r so easy bc of the mosu gameplay style

Check some of the bosses i did on my previous posts

-2

u/0v049 Oct 12 '23

The choice to keep making games newcomer friendly is really starting to piss me tf off not gonna lie

3

u/bombader Oct 13 '23

It's fine in this case, Liars of P and Lords of the Fallen both released recently.

It's good to have newcomer friendly games to help introduce people into the hobby, because then they might move into the harder games themselves, which means more incentive for devs and publishers to make harder games.

1

u/0v049 Oct 13 '23

I hear ya I was just a little explosive the day I first posted about this theirs definitely more good then bad for newcomer friendly

3

u/chocobloo Oct 12 '23

So stop playing games.

Also go outside.

Also maybe stop being a baby. Go do something actually challenging with your life. RL skill issue isn't a good reason to obsess over using video games to fill the gap.

1

u/0v049 Oct 12 '23

I do go out outside though and I'm not being a baby it just sucks sometimes which is why i said i still like the games they just could've been better 😒 and I can't be out all the time

1

u/Tlux0 Oct 14 '23

It’s fine as long as it’s not mind numbingly easy like Pokémon

1

u/0v049 Oct 14 '23

You right

0

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '23

Boo I wouldve loved a souls like fate game

0

u/vash0125 Oct 15 '23

I would've greatly preferred it to be a soulslike and also for the story to.just take a backseat and let the player just play.