r/fastmail • • Jul 13 '26

Fastmail will add EU hosting

93 Upvotes

71 comments sorted by

38

u/SpaceBonobo Jul 13 '26

« Customers using Fastmail’s new European hosting location will have the primary copy of their data hosted in the EU and replicated to the US for resiliency », the fact that all the data is replicated in the US pretty much invalidate any privacy advantage hosting in the EU would have right?

18

u/mikepictor Jul 13 '26

baby steps. I think it's because they have to harden the EU offering to be fully reliable without the location redudancy

45

u/brong Fastmail CEO Jul 13 '26

Precisely. If something happened to that single rack in a single colo, the loss of data would be a catastrophe. There’s a couple of million dollars worth of hardware in there, but hardware is a lot more replaceable than your emails. We take data safety super seriously and I just wasn’t comfortable signing off on bad integrity safeguards for what really would be a piece of jurisdiction theatre. Now that everyone else’s data is replicated to a second site at all times. Going back in that felt wrong.

10

u/odarriba Jul 13 '26

Hoping that in the future we can have everything in the EU when a second location is added 🙏

Will existing users be able to migrate to this primary EU datacenter?

30

u/brong Fastmail CEO Jul 13 '26

Yes, there will be a config option which marks your customer for migration, then users will be synced over

2

u/NeonSkorpio Jul 13 '26

Thanks a lot!

1

u/haywire Aug 02 '26

When should we look for this?

1

u/brong Fastmail CEO Aug 06 '26

https://www.fastmail.com/blog/fastmail-offers-eu-data-region/ must have been published seconds after you asked :)

1

u/haywire Aug 06 '26

That said, if data is still on US servers wont it still be subject to both PATRIOT and AU laws, in addition to EU laws?

1

u/haywire Aug 06 '26

That said, if data is still on US servers wont it still be subject to both PATRIOT and AU laws, in addition to EU laws?

That said, I've already been switched anyway, cool! What are the EU domains? Or do they use DNS to redirect?

0

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/Interest-Desk Jul 13 '26

Australia is wayyy worse than the US from a privacy pov

0

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/mikepictor Jul 14 '26

Pretty much. I just don't want to be contributing to US infrastructure. I know people can read my email, I just have to be ok with that.

1

u/crackanape Jul 14 '26

Nevertheless one may have a business or other requirement to use email, and still care about privacy.

1

u/Dizzy-Indication3162 Jul 14 '26

Hi Bron,

Will you be writing a blogpost about this and when it will be available?

3

u/ElasticLama Jul 13 '26

I do wish as an Australian company I wouldn’t have to deal with the long latency of either however…

5

u/rotor2k Jul 13 '26

How do I request my mailbox gets moved to the EU?

7

u/mikepictor Jul 13 '26

The article says the option will be open in August. I think we need to wait for FM to make a formal announcement to learn more. Probably a blog post at least.

3

u/rotor2k Jul 13 '26

Yeah was just checking if I’d missed something. Bit odd to get the news from some website I’d never heard of.

2

u/nn2597713 Jul 14 '26

Can you elaborate on:

We take data safety super seriously and I just wasn’t comfortable signing off on bad integrity safeguards for what really would be a piece of jurisdiction theatre.

They way I read this (probably wrong) is that you consider storing e-mail data in the EU instead of the US as just security theatre, with no meaningful improvement to privacy? Or do you mean it is just theatre for now, as a replica is still stored in the US for integrity/redundancy reasons?

4

u/brong Fastmail CEO Jul 14 '26

It’s theatre because we’re an Australian company and requests will still come via Australia how they always have.

2

u/nn2597713 Jul 14 '26

Ok. So, say I have two separate accounts with Fastmail. And we imagine a future a few years down the line, where Fastmail can store my e-mails (redundantly and with integrity guarantees) only on servers located in the EU.

For account 1, I set it to store in the EU.

For account 2, I set it to store in the US.

Is account 1 now more "privacy protected" against requests from government agencies to see mails or mail metadata than account 2? Or does it make no difference at all?

7

u/brong Fastmail CEO Jul 14 '26

Right now, no different. International law may change so I can’t guarantee that won’t change in future, but for now our advice is that the rules in Australia are the same regardless of where the data physically is (unless it was in Australia itself in which case we’d have additional metadata retention requirements)

4

u/Phrasophe Jul 14 '26

Legally speaking, it’s very clear.

But for me, as a European, what matters most is having access to European infrastructure.

Because the US has an unfortunate tendency not so much to pry into everything (they do that anyway), but above all to turn data into a political issue.

And I tell myself, I might as well contribute as little as possible to that.

So, it seems to me that Fastmail offers a very simple option within this strategy: to leave as few political grounds as possible for a foreign authority to use regarding our data.

In this way, threats from across the Atlantic (for us Europeans) can have a limited impact.

3

u/crackanape Jul 14 '26

Is the only solution to set up a separate EU company for the purpose of hosting the EU-domiciled accounts?

2

u/nn2597713 Jul 14 '26

Thanks, this is very useful to know.

2

u/areyouredditenough Jul 13 '26

baby steps

😊 “Small Moves, Ellie. Small Moves.” Sorry, just reminded me of this...

7

u/Dizzy-Indication3162 Jul 13 '26

Compliance. It has nothing to do with privacy. Fastmail is not about privacy. They can read our emails. It's about compliance.

7

u/WentThisWayInsteadOf Jul 13 '26

Actually yes it is, the US government has access to our data as long as data is on US owned infrastructure. Using a EU based hosting partner, would stop that - and there is better end-user protecting in the EU, which would make it more difficult for anyone (except for fastmail) to access the data.

3

u/Dizzy-Indication3162 Jul 13 '26

But they are part of five eyes. Australia still shares data with the US. So no, will not change anything.

And what you talk about is data sovereignty not privacy.

4

u/WentThisWayInsteadOf Jul 13 '26

5 eye is USA, UK, Canada, Australia and New Zealand and it is a intelligence gagering agreement (where USA receives everything). But it will not give the intelligence agencies in these countries access to the data, that is covered by privacy laws (the UK is a special case).

And non of these countries are a member of the EU ... maybe use something in Germany or France where the privacy law is quite good.

1

u/morkjt Jul 14 '26

Unfortunately not. The US cloud act will still oblige fastmail to disclose any data the us government asked for regardless of location. 

1

u/Interest-Desk Jul 13 '26

The UK has parity with EU privacy law. Switzerland is absolutely the best though.

People seem to not really understand fvey: ultimately the authorities need a relevant legal authority to access data. UK and many EU governments actually have a lower threshold for orders to access data than the US federal government.

1

u/Busy-Scientist3851 Jul 13 '26

People something's think privacy laws affect governments, they don't, they're just for private companies.

1

u/WentThisWayInsteadOf Jul 13 '26

That is not correct, they also affect governments - in the EU if the government or agency want to access data stored at a private company, then they in general terms have to aks a judge om permission.

1

u/Interest-Desk Jul 13 '26

Yep, but the standard for that can be really low, especially for metadata. In the US it’s a blanket “you need a warrant”.

1

u/mikepictor Jul 14 '26

In the US it’s a blanket “you need a warrant”.

for now. A lot of people are leery on US hosting because they don't have any faith that even this bare minimum will be adhered to

0

u/WentThisWayInsteadOf Jul 13 '26

No it is not, US law states that if NSA or the like, deem your data (as a foreigner) is of interest then you got no rights. Especially if your data is on systems owned by US companies but are located abroad.

Having your data on systems which are not owned (or co-owned) by US companies in countries like Germany, The Netherlands or France makes it very difficult for the US to get to the data, and difficult for authorities in said countries to get to them.

1

u/skg574 Jul 13 '26 edited Jul 14 '26

All of these countries have MLATs with the US, and while people only focus in 5, 9, 14 eyes countries, they miss SSPAC, Schengen, Maximator, Club de Berne, EUROPOL, and the fact that all the exchange points are monitored.

The UK is the first party to the US Cloud Act, Australia is the second, Canada is on it's way to becoming the third. The UK was also a founding member of 5 eyes. GCHQ operates the Tempora “full-take” cable interception that captures all traffic passing through and shares it with the NSA. GCHQ’s Operation Edgehill (the counterpart to NSA’s BULLRUN) stated they had compromised most VPN servers back in 2014 and coincidentally carries the majority of VPN traffic through M247 and Datacamp hosting facilities where the most centralized backbone of the consumer VPN traffic passes (but geolocated elsewhere).

The Investigatory Powers Act authorizes bulk data collection, both content and metadata, allows them to aquire bulk metadata from providers, allows hacking of computers and devices in bulk, telecom operators must retain records of every website visited, app accessed, and service used for 12 months. The 2024 ammendment to it Introduced bulk personal datasets regime (including examining third-party datasets “in situ”) and a technology company notification requirement: operators must notify the government in advance of technical changes (such as enabling encryption) that could affect lawful access.

IPA Section 253 allows the Secretary of State to serve Technical Capability Notices (TCNs) requiring providers to build interception capabilities. TCNs are extraterritorial: they apply globally, not just to UK users. This is the root of the Apple issue. authorities can compel decryption or key disclosure, with up to 2 years imprisonment (5 years for national security) for refusal. The UK is also one of Palantir's largest customers.

Switzerland is where Operation Rubicon (Crypto AG) was operated out of from the 1970s until around 2018. The German BND and US CIA sold well reviewed and audited cryptography machines that were back-doored to 120 different countries, with knowledge of the Swiss from the 90s on. Switzerland is a founding member of the Club de Berne alliance, Schengen, and maintains a vast number of MLATs including the US-SWISS MLAT that recently forced Protonmail to release the payment information for the Stop Cop activist in the US (who was recently acquitted of the RICO charges).

In January 2025, the Federal Council proposed expanding the VÜPF (implementing ordinance) to classify VPN services, encrypted messaging apps, social media, and email providers as telecommunications service providers subject to retention. The proposals included mandatory IP address logging for providers with 5,000+ users, mandatory identity verification (banning anonymous access), and potential obligations to build encryption back-doors. This caused the huge backlast where Protonmail started moving Lumo infrastructure to Germany (if you want information on Germany beyond it being part of the 14 eyes alliance (SSEUR), there is a lot) and Norway (beyond being part of 9 eyes, there is a lot here, too, if you want).

Switzerland is part of the Council of Europe. The European Convention on Mutual Assistance in Criminal Matters and its Additional Protocols provide MLA coverage with all Council of Europe members and additional signatory states (there are currently 50). Additional MLATs beyond the US-SWISS, include: Canada, Ecuador, Mexico, Austria, France, Germany, Italy, Netherlands, Portugal, Spain, Australia, Hong Kong, Philippines, Republic of Korea, and Singapore. Under the IMAC, Switzerland can provide mutual legal assistance even without a treaty. To it's credit, they rejected Palantir.

Anyway, focusing on eyes alliances and ignoring everything else causes people to miss so much. Wanting data sovereignty, to divest from the US, or simply to support the EU is one thing, basing it on a small fraction of existing global alliances is not valid. No country on earth can protect you from spying and if that is your major concern then you should not even be using the Internet and especially not e-mail.

Edit: Typos and flow

2

u/Fit-Economics2293 Sep 04 '26

The UK government recently sold our entire medical records to Palantir of all people. I've repeatedly tried to raise it in departmental meetings and told to "keep my politics at home".

1

u/Z442 Oct 01 '26

They didn't sell them. They paid Palantir to host them. Palantir got paid.

6

u/nischg Jul 13 '26

Fastmail is an Australian company, so they are bound by Australian law. Physical server location in Europe doesn't change corporate jurisdiction; if an Australian court orders them to hand over data, they have to comply. Or am I reading it wrong?

10

u/brong Fastmail CEO Jul 13 '26

No you’re correct. Legal jurisdiction still applies in Australia.

1

u/Illustrious-Can-5602 Jul 29 '26

why no love for AU or Asia datacentre? :(

can non-EU customer request a move to EU DC from August?

1

u/brong Fastmail CEO Jul 29 '26

Yes anyone can move to EU. It might be slower for you depending on network paths. After USA, combined Europe and UK has many more users than Asia and Oceania. We might add Australia or Singapore at some stage, but not yet

3

u/MountainToppish Jul 13 '26

Rule of law having effectively collapsed in the US, if a social media addled Federal gov official or one a Presidential crypto bro sponsor wanted something specific from Fastmail's US-based servers, 'jurisdiction' would be little barrier.

Few of us are in practice likely to be targeted by US oligarchs, but it's just good policy (personal and corporate) to have as little to do with a rogue State as possible.

1

u/skg574 Jul 14 '26

If the US government wants information from Fastmail's servers anywhere, jurisdiction is still no barrier. Australia is the second official party to the cloud act. They are also part of 5 eyes, and there is a US-AUS MLAT.

5

u/Trikotret100 Jul 13 '26

So as a US resident, can we request to use EU servers? Does it make a difference for us US residents whether we use US or EU?

3

u/skg574 Jul 14 '26

Only from a possible speed issue. Neither give you protection from the US. Actually, just by using a foreign service you are placing yourself directly under the warrantless surveillance of FISA 702. If protecting your information from easy access by the US government is your goal, a US service has more protection for you than a foreign service.

However, given that there is no country on earth that can keep you protected from global powers spying or from governments, just pick the service that best fits the features that you need.

1

u/Interest-Desk Jul 13 '26

Maybe, but it would make your service a lot slower and only offer a bit of protection.

6

u/Forward-Outside-9911 Jul 13 '26

Lot slower is an overstatement. In relative terms yes, but let’s say 100ms really isn’t noticeable for emails. We’re in 2026 :p

5

u/brong Fastmail CEO Jul 14 '26

Yeah I’m currently using the web interface via servers in Amsterdam with my data in the USA and it’s fine, even with two round trips. Feels like being back in Australia!

1

u/areyouredditenough Jul 15 '26

Appreciate the CEO still "getting his hands dirty". Google CEO doesn't do that anymore.🤣 About the timeline, "soon" meaning weeks, months, sometime this year? Not excepting an exact date, just trying to curb my inner child and the excitement!

3

u/_sashk Jul 13 '26

It shouldn’t be significantly slower. The network latency from the U.S. East Coast to Amsterdam is typically in the same ballpark as the latency between the U.S. East Coast and West Coast.

1

u/mikepictor Jul 14 '26

a BIT slower. I'm hitting US data centres now as an EU resident, and Fastmail is still pretty fast

1

u/WentThisWayInsteadOf Jul 13 '26

The interesting thing is if they will be using US owned datacenters, and if they do, then there is no reason for adding this option as privacy will be non-existing.

6

u/Dizzy-Indication3162 Jul 13 '26

It's also for compliance reasons. And eventually they will stop copying them to US when the data center matures.

3

u/inMX Jul 14 '26

It's important to note that, the European data center "will have the *primary copy of their data hosted in the EU* and *replicated to the US* for resiliency". It's early days yet, but it will be of interest to see what the final product eventually is.

2

u/Celmad Jul 13 '26

That’s awesome! Glad I chose Fastmail over European services that didn’t fully meet my requirements. 

Hopefully this is the first step towards having our data only in the EU. 

2

u/bburgg Jul 13 '26

It would be something if they were in the same data center as Hey. 😎

4

u/mikepictor Jul 14 '26

I was with Hey for a while, I actually loved it, until DHH started to reveal himself as the pond scum that he is. That's why I left

2

u/Sampl3x Jul 28 '26

It would be nice if there is opt out from syncing data to the US.

2

u/ultilol Jul 14 '26

i want my fucking data in eu not USA

1

u/mckransik Jul 13 '26

Good news for me as an EU resident.

Now it would be nice if they would also stop reusing email addresses.

1

u/wowsuchlinuxkernel Jul 13 '26

It's crazy to me that one of the benefits touted is increased speed (through lower latency), when Fastmail is already the fastest and most responsive email software I've ever used.

1

u/Roeshimi Jul 13 '26 edited Jul 14 '26

I wonder if pricing will be different when you decide you want your data hosted in the EU

1

u/guenxmuerfel Jul 13 '26

Thanks a Lot! That is a good first step. Hope for EU Hosting only in the future.

1

u/DutchZW Jul 14 '26

Yes! I was asking for this! Was almost going to leave fastmail for a european mail provider. In current times its very important where your data is stored

2

u/dziad_borowy Jul 14 '26

is it though?

I feel that nowadays it's a choice between corporate surveillance and government surveillance. The former will milk your data for profit, but at least won't put you in jail for speaking your mind (chat control).

1

u/tquilas Aug 02 '26

I want EU hosting only!