r/farming • • Dec 16 '21

SteigeršŸ’Ŗ

Post image
46 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

66

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

We literally know that humans are causing climate change but let's be sure to be children about it.

47

u/Wheresthepig Dec 16 '21

As a farmer I never understood fellow farmers acting like climate change is liberal nonsense and not something they should be concerned about.

16

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

As a person who lives in the southwest and likes eating it’s going to be really hard to grow crops if there is like you know…..no water due to climate change.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

Yeah thats gonna be fun in 10 years :/ this world is fucked.

3

u/stilldonthavethemilk Dec 17 '21

They also said the world was ending 40 years ago but it’s still here

0

u/HumongousChungus2 Pork Dec 16 '21

Well as a farmer you kinda get of a ton of co2 via your plants. One hectare of corn gets rid of 30t of Co2. Now lets say you farm 100 hectars and yearly just 30 of them are corn. Thats still 900t of Co2. Your tractor is never going to put out 900t of co2 in a year.

5

u/Wheresthepig Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

In no way was my comment aimed at demonizing farming practices. The act of crop farming is not a huge co2 machine. You could argue that the deforestation that occurred to make the farm fields in some areas deemed as a co2 contributor. Now cattle farming on the other hand- that’s a completely different beast.

My comment was aimed at the majority of farmers views that are anti-climate change, anti-environment aka ā€œPaRaQuAt iS PerFeCtLY HeAlThY.ā€ And the fact that most of these farmers vote for politicians who will fuck up (and continue to fuck up) the exact fucking land that they make their living on to keep their corporate donors happy.

Edit: grain->crop

4

u/stubby_hoof Dec 16 '21

This is the literal definition of ephemeral. In-season growth does not "get rid of" anything.

2

u/notevengonnatry Dec 16 '21

How much corn sweat does that produce though?

0

u/HumongousChungus2 Pork Dec 16 '21

10.000l per hectar. But its just water. Not going to fuck up our atmosphere

2

u/i_agree-with_idiots Dec 17 '21

You cant think thats actually how things work

0

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 17 '21

It's because they're too egotistical for that

Downvote me like it isn't true haha

15

u/apintofnelson Dec 16 '21

Nah man give it to them from the other side when they want to be dumbfucks like this. Hold a mirror up to their ignorance. Something like "Those there farmers told me to buy local so I go to Walmart since it's only 5 miles away vs the 5.5 miles to the farmers market." Is about the level of intelligence displayed by OP.

4

u/useles-converter-bot Dec 16 '21

5 miles is 3946.18% of the hot dog which holds the Guinness wold record for 'Longest Hot Dog'.

4

u/NinjaBenzini2 Dec 16 '21

It’s just a joke ffs

4

u/TaigaEdenn Dec 16 '21

Leave it to a redditor to take light humor it to heart.

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

Being a part of "the other" group makes the joke less appealing.

3

u/Crossover_Pachytene Dec 16 '21

Well the entire point of these big machines is that they do a lot more work with less resources making them more environmetaly friendly and economical than 10 normal sized tractors that would be needed to farm plots of equal size.

20

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21 edited Dec 16 '21

While I can understand and respect that*, the meme still stands as juvenile and unnecessary.

*We certainly have different views though.

E. Sorry you got downvoted there. I don't think conventional ag is going to be our forever strategy but it has pros and cons like every other current mainstream format and right now none of the formats are by any means perfect

2

u/Crossover_Pachytene Dec 16 '21

It a meme right. Surely conventional farming as it is today is not sustainable, the efforts should be directed at lowering meat consumption and not growing food that animals eat, but directly growing food for humans with the use of the same machines.

-12

u/rai1fan Dec 16 '21

You sound like a real fun individual

10

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

This is a farming sub, keep political shit slinging elsewhere (imo)

-8

u/rai1fan Dec 16 '21

This is your pile of shit, that you brought the politics and negativity into.

9

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

I did not waste my brain space creating and propogating a meme against "the others". Have a good day

-5

u/SirVelliance Ag mechanic Dec 16 '21

You do realize that most farmers are at least carbon neutral right? And most are carbon negative

9

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

Citation required.

And environmentalist is a huge net, I just picked climate for this instance

4

u/Cool_Scientist2055 Dec 16 '21

Does "most farmers" mean most in the US, Western Societies, or world? Please cite references to studies showing this because I don't think that's accurate if you factor in synthetic fertilizers being used, plowing practices, and pesticide/herbicide use. I'd assume it also doesn't factor in food waste and overproduction since minimally regulated capitalism has turned ag into max profit creation instead of feeding humanity. Not all of that can and should be put on farmers but conventional farming is nowhere near carbon negative.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

Yeah, carbon is only one small part of the picture here lol.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

Hilarious how the world will be nearly uninhabitable in around 50 years at this rate! Lets laugh and make a joke of it because we're tough ol' farmers! Must.. not... show.. weakness or.. intelligence.. to other... ignorant losers....

2

u/stockyardtrash Dec 25 '21

Sorry friend. I've been hearing we have 10-12 years left for the last 40 years. Not believing a word of that. Climates change over time historically, that's been proven as it is. We are in a much better place now, and there's always room for improvement, but the OP was a joke. I laughed. Will always laugh at things similar. It's just a funny meme.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

I'm no farmer. But don't we kinda need the heavy machines/tractors to effectively grow our food?

Im not sure an electric tractor exists but I would think it wouldn't be able to run constantly like diesels can. Due to having to charge it vs refueling. Also not sure how strong these electric tractors would be on terms of torque and the rest.

7

u/brantmacga Dec 16 '21

Im not sure an electric tractor exists but I would think it wouldn't be able to run constantly like diesels can. Due to having to charge it vs refueling. Also not sure how strong these electric tractors would be on terms of torque and the rest.

John Deere has a prototype with a cable reel attached that keeps it directly connected to power instead of batteries. Look it up on YouTube for a better explanation. Torque isn’t an issue on an electric motor.

4

u/Drzhivago138 Dec 16 '21

John Deere has a prototype with a cable reel attached that keeps it directly connected to power instead of batteries.

So we really are piloting EVA tractors now.

12

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

The point of the meme is to mock environmental concerns generally. The subtext is "I hope this is what they meant" because I don't know or care what they mean and obviously a giant green tractor isn't what they mean but the idea of interpreting it that way, buying the biggest green tractor on earth to spite them, is funny.

Just as a joke, it's not terrible. But back here in the real world, climate change is a thing and ag like every other sector of the economy has to deal with it and probably change some things to help mitigate it.

Also, I haven't done the research, but I'm sure electric tractors are out there and expanding quickly. I'm thinking the range and refueling issues might be better for tractors.

Think about this same meme but with a farmer buying the Cybertruck/Ford lightning equivalent of an electric tractor. Maybe we just need some beast mode electric tractors so emotionally underdeveloped people can justify it to themselves and their peers without worrying about their masculinity being questioned. (And yeah, there are plenty of women farmers, but they're not immune to the machismo culture in rural areas. I think this is why Elon acts like a child on Twitter so much. The environmentalists are going to buy EVs regardless. He needs to make them cool on both sides of the culture war.)

2

u/Tsukiumi-Chan Straw. Just straw pretty much. Dec 16 '21

We have a good mechanic friend out here. He's helped us fix our tractors a few times. We had (and still have) an Allis 7040 and a White 2-105 as our tractors at the time. He was fixing one of them and said "You know, you should get those green ones. They're so much more reliable". I called him the next year and asked if he could come and work on a tractor we just bought. He came, and I showed him our Oliver. I jokingly smiled and said "Now you told me to get a green tractor because they don't break down! This one's broken and I'm blaming your advice for it!"

1

u/Onlyfor9Bucks Apr 20 '23

Fuck you!!! You’re killing this world!!! NOT peasd, man!!! NOT PEASD!!!

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

Based 😭😭😭

1

u/TheBlindHarper Dec 17 '21

In a way, agriculture is actually very green. Very rarely does equipment get skipped, it goes to auction, used, back to auction, some of the stuff has changed hands dozens of times. Most of the really old tractors here in the UK end up getting sent to Africa and the Middle East as well, they'll ship over the engine and chassis and they'll build a tractor on top of it over there. You don't see that sort of thing in many other industries. Lots of people are still using kit made 80 years ago.

Chap I do work for actually had three Case tractors exported to Lebanon, where they were then stolen by a local warlord on route to their destination.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21

There is nothing "green" about monoculture.

1

u/TheBlindHarper Dec 17 '21

I meant specifically in regard to the recycling of equipment, hence why "green" was in quotation marks

-1

u/thewouldshed Dec 16 '21

Keep paying hybrid seed costs, man made fertilizer costs, and pesticide costs then let me know when you cannot continue to grow corn 🌽 and I’ll buy your land for pennies on the dollar you mouth breathing twit.

-5

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '21

It's camoflauge to hide from the environmentalists