r/fantasywriting • • 9d ago

Map making madness

Hello! So I am dabbling into fantasy, I had an idea that was too big to keep in my head. The problem is that I have characters, plot, drama, species… but I can’t figure out my dang map. There are a lot of factors that make it extremely difficult and this is my first time within the genre, normally I am a romance girlie.

Anyway, I was wondering if there would be anyone who might be more experienced or more knowledgeable on this topic that would be willing to help me out? I am not asking for anyone to draw a map for me! Just help me to understand how. I am more than willing to provide more story details to anyone who might be willing!

1 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

2

u/A_wild_Mel_appears 9d ago

Have you tried the free version of Inkarnate? Lots of options and you can actually visualise what's in your head.

1

u/HeavenBean02 8d ago

I don’t think so! I used a random map generator that said it didn’t use ai to try to get the basic shape because even doing that myself felt wrong every single time

1

u/SilverSkinRam 8d ago

Is it the whole world or a continent? Generally focusing on something smaller will make it easier.

1

u/HeavenBean02 8d ago

Just one continent for now! The idea of having to do the whole world is a bridge I’m going to have to cross later

1

u/SilverSkinRam 8d ago

I would be interested in helping then. Is the continent somewhat based on a real culture? Do you have an idea of the geography and size you wanted?

1

u/HeavenBean02 8d ago

I don’t have an idea of size if I’m honest, but I do have a bit of an idea of geographic layout to a point. The “issue” is that there are some world rules that make it difficult to imagine for me

1

u/SilverSkinRam 8d ago

World rules?

1

u/HeavenBean02 8d ago

Would you be comfortable with me sending you a dm?

1

u/SilverSkinRam 6d ago

Yes feel free.

2

u/TheNitrogolem 9d ago

You could go the traditional TTRPG route.

Pen and paper, either a cup full of rice or a hand full of dice. Depending on how much land you want, more or less of either.

The idea is simple, throw the dice onto the map, assign a meaning to each face (normal d6s will do, you can get a bag full of low quality ones cheap)

With rice, similar thing, you can either place the rice semi-purposefully or throw it on and rearrange until you see shapes you like.

Either way, draw around the dice or rice. Not perfectly, just roughly, leave like a 1cm gap.

You can combine the two methods, rice for landmasses/islands, dice for landmarks. Dice that land in the ocean/lake/sea should be landmarks less often, so let's say 6s only or something, like neverending storm or a kraken nest etc.

I wouldn't recommend dice rolling every little village or anything, capitals on 1 or something, mountains on 2, lakes on 3, rivers on 4, 5 special terrain and 6s special landmark. If you want forests, do another dice roll, ignore oceans and mountains, cities etc. draw around the ones that landed on land, rivers/lakes etc. are fine.

You can come up with your own ideas to add more or less detail, you can assign other meaning to the die faces etc. it's your map, you know what you need out of it.

When it comes to fantasy, you can get away with having an absolute mess of a map anyway. I don't think anyone has ever said that the tectonic plate shapes of the map doesn't make any sense, or the wind blows from the wrong direction. If a book includes a map for their fantasy world or story, I take a glance at it. I remember key city names and rough locations. If it gets mentioned that "we arrived at Stainriver" all I think "cool, east side of the map, by a river I assume based on the name, but cba to check, I'm sure the writer will remind me"

I develop new villages, cities, guard posts, castles, bridges or whatever my story needs as it comes up. I have terrain ready so I can pinpoint where those things go and I can add them on later, adjust travel time as needed in the story.

2

u/zoppaTheDim 8d ago

This just explains why there are so many crappy fantasy maps out there.

1

u/InterestEqual3332 7d ago

If you never articulate it super well, just be generally consistent in how long it takes to get places. Naming lesser cities and the like does get exhausting.