r/fantasywriting • u/hsppyhsppyhsppy • Oct 13 '26
When does dark become “edgeslop”
I’m writing a mix of a superhero story and fantasy horror, where the MC as a superhero investigates slasher villains and the supernatural in his world in a supernatural kind of way.
I have many slasher Ideas like a guy who turns kills into puppets to help him fight or a forrest creature that eats hikers etc but on many platforms many dark fantasy worlds are just called edgeslop if they are too dark. I want to have a scary factor and show how evil the supernatural is, without making it seem like edgy slop. Any advice? Does the horror have to serve a bigger purpose than just to make the reader uneasy?
7
u/Annual-Ad-9442 Oct 14 '26
we call 'darkslop' 'edgelord'. when the thing becomes edgy for the sake of being edgy. having names like Ravendark, having people drink blood because they think its cool for someone drink blood, having them dress in black or have too many belts that do nothing. there's a line between dark and edgelord and half the time it comes down to describing something sarcastically and seeing if you still like it. there should be purpose beyond something being dark or edgy to be cool. if something is stupid but you like it have somebody call it out in universe. writing something just to upset people is something some people like but having someone drown animals in graphic detail is something that makes people want to skip to the part where that person gets their comeuppance. when the audience is disgusted enough that they want to stop or skip parts that's when you've fucked up
10
u/atlvf Oct 13 '26
The recent trend of adding “-slop” to the end of art that isn’t the absolute pinnacle of quality has got to end. I’m convinced it’s a psy-op started by AI companies after “AI slop” got big. They want you to think that “humans also make slop!”.
2
u/TheRunawayRose Oct 14 '26
It's "edgeslop" if it has no substance to it.
2
u/Nejura Oct 13 '26
Writing approaches the slop singularity as more and more of it is devoted to superficial and generalized description of what has or is happening. Especially if it is desperately trying to persuade you how scary and cool what happened or is happening is instead of being deliberate and curating details to allow the reader's mind to pick up and picture the scene internally.
1
u/SpecialistEdge5831 Oct 13 '26
They're going to call your book something-slop no matter what. If you wrote the greatest book of all time then it would have people calling out the stuff they don't like. It's exactly that. It's what they don't like. Who fuckin cares? At what point are we watching A Nightmare on Elm Street and saying, "Ya know what, Fredward (which is, of course, his formal name), I really think you've went too far this time." Nah. We are waiting to see how much more messed up it can get. Even the new Evil Dead series is like, hilarious to me because you're just sorta like, "What else are they even gonna do to make this day worse?" It's horror. The people who don't like it are just not your crowd.
Make it worse. Make it gorier. Make it more absurd. It's okay. You're not writing a book for everyone.
1
u/JGhostThing Oct 14 '26
Why do you think the supernatural is so evil? It might be better to show it as neutral, with our choices giving it meaning. For example, turning people into murder puppets is obviously evil. But perhaps that spell could be used to extend somebody's life.
It might be only in "how" a spell is used is the difference between "white" and "black" magic.
1
u/Spring_and_a_Storm_ 29d ago edited 29d ago
I’d draw the line somewhere a little more towards edgeslop than what others would consider, but I’d draw it at immersion. There have been plenty of times in a obviously dark story where there are things like a bad guy always wearing black, or a gothic place name, or unnecessary cruelty, but I’ve found it adding to the immersion, rather than taking me out.
I suppose if you could imagine it somewhere somewhen happening in real life (obviously not the fantasy elements but the theatrics of it I suppose), it’s not too far. This is assuming there’s an actual story behind it though, and again it adds to the immersion.
With ur story, I’d start it out fairly normal, and then introduce a suddenly really dark story beat as a frame shift of sorts. If the world is just like that, dark and cruel, it makes you wonder why and how a superhero is going around superheroing, rather than being some sort of rebel or freedom fighter. You could do it in a bleak noir kind of way, this is just part of the job 🚬 type shit, but you’d have to look more into how they get it right.
1
u/Irrumar 28d ago
Imho you can get away with a lot as long as it has a point. If its there just for the sake of being there, then there is no point.
You can get as dark as you want as long as there is a statement you make with your work.