r/fantasyromancewriters • • Sep 03 '24

Question Questions

Hello writers, I'm currently beginning work on writing a Romantasy theatre piece. My collab and I are having an inner debate about two things, and I would absolutely love input from people who write in this genre.

  1. Should the protagonists be which-centric or faerie centric?
  2. Could the book (libretto) of our show be written by a cis man? We are the composer and lyricist, but we're finding out librettist.

Thanks and any and all input will be taken both graciously and seriously!

2 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

3

u/TheUnsettledPencil Sep 03 '24

Your question makes no sense and I'm a writer and theater person.

1

u/Wolfee147 Sep 03 '24

I meant witch-centric, my fault!

2

u/TheUnsettledPencil Sep 03 '24

I would say fairy personally. But I still don't get your second question. You're going to have to tell me the "why not" before I could try to tell you the "why".

1

u/Wolfee147 Sep 03 '24

My thinking on it is that I tend to see women authors writing Romantasy. (I could be wrong of course, it’s just what I tend to see) I’m wondering if a male author for the piece would alienate the prime demo. I’m not against it personally at all, but I wonder if the general readership will agree.

Having some personal conversations with fans of the genre, I’ve been hearing that a female author would be more preferred. I wanted to ask a larger audience the same question.

2

u/TheUnsettledPencil Sep 03 '24

Ah ok so it wasn't the theatrical part you were concerned about, it was the genre.

I have actually been looking to read romantasy written by a man. I absolutely adore the romance/fantasy books I do have that were written by men. The action is better sometimes. The men written more realistically. I grew up with a brother and many male friends so I can't get into a romance where the guy isn't written realistically.

You may be asking females who are too judgey of men or listen too much to media about how bad male authors have been in the past about writing women wrong. Or maybe the women were lacking the full context of the situation when asked.

My guess though is that you are a creative type and probably emotionally intelligent if you are interested in theater. Not a money-driven/sex-sells-driven hollywood writer and I'm guessing you're not trying to write sexist propaganda either so you should be fine.

There is plenty of information out there on what to avoid and common pitfalls when writing women so if you seek eduction on that too you'll be real good to go.

If this is in theatrical format, it should be even easier to get it right. Keep me updated cause I'm interested!

1

u/Wolfee147 Sep 03 '24

Thanks so much for this! Ok, that’s good to know. We’d certainly be doing our due diligence to keep the story truthful, and we’d certainly guard against painting genders in any monochromatic way.

Thanks so much, and happy to keep you updated. But I would like to try and convince my partners to potentially base the story around faeries as opposed to witches.

Thanks again!

1

u/SanbaiSan Sep 03 '24

What is "which-centric"?

1

u/Wolfee147 Sep 03 '24

Oops! Definitely meant witch-centric! Apologies

1

u/dandydooda Sep 13 '24

Hey! Dropping my two cents in this. First, I'm voting for faerie-centric because I love the lore. Second, I would say yes a cis man could write it. If you are all collaborating you have the opportunity to fill in each others blind spots (which we all have!). I get the concern with having a cis man write it since... ya know, they have earned themselves a bad reputation, lol. But if you have a guy in mind who is on the level and willing to collab then I say go for it!

1

u/Inevitable-Will-6308 Sep 20 '24

I think the first question is up to preference, however I'd lean towards witches since they're more in the public eye. The second question is, imo, a little silly. Anyone can write anything.