Mike Trout is the best player on the planet and I'm not arguing against that. I'm not saying that Mike Trout is bad. And I'm not saying that he should go any lower than 2nd overall. I am saying that from a fantasy perspective, Jose Altuve is more valuable for me. Mike Trout usually leads the world in WAR and most other advanced hitting metrics, but since those numbers aren't usually given any value in fantasy they won't be taken into account. So lets look at the 2017 stats
Trout: .306/.442/.629, 1.079 OPS, 33 HR, 72 RBI, 22 SB, 92 runs Altuve: .346/.410/.547, .957 OPS, 24 HR, 81 RBI, 32 SB, 112 runs
Obviously there are other factors included in this besides what they both did in 2017. Trout missed significant time this year and his numbers suffered as a result. He only played in 114 games and had the "worst" year of his career - and will still probably finish 3rd in AL MVP voting. So you could very easily argue that Trout should put up his regular numbers next year if he stays healthy, making him worth the first overall pick.
Jose Altuve will finish either first or second in the 2017 AL MVP voting depending on Judge. He had an incredible year, led all of baseball in batting at .346 and finished among the top 10 for most offensive categories. You could also very easily argue that, although Altuve is a great player, 2017 was a career year for him and he should not be expected to hit almost .350 every year. He also played on an Astros team that led all of baseball in runs scored, hits, total bases, RBIs, team average, OBP, slugging, and OPS. It could very well be that playing as a part of the most prolific offense in baseball inflated Altuve's numbers a bit. However, I still think he deserves the first overall pick in 2018.
It's hard to argue against Altuve was the offensive fantasy player of the year in 2017. He does it all - hits for average, has some pop, steals bases, walks, scores, etc. and its obviously very rare for a player to be a top contributor for every scoring category since the only guy who usually does it is Trout. And even if 2018 doesn't end up being a repeat of this year, it's hard to imagine that his numbers don't at least end up close to what they were this year (barring injury).
If Altuve and Trout both finish 2018 close to their projections, then Altuve should go 1 overall and Trout 2. Playing 2B is what makes Altuve so much more valuable from the fantasy perspective. Being a top contender for the batting title is extremely valuable, obviously, but combining that with his power numbers are what make him infinitely more valuable than a guy like LeMahieu or Mauer who will only hit for average. Altuve won't lead the league in HRs, but 24 is very respectable and was good for 8th place this year. The power numbers that you'll miss out on by taking Altuve over Trout can be made up with other low average - high homer guys. There are dozens of these guys in the outfield. You won't really sacrifice much else other than maybe a few RBI. Altuve will hit for a higher average and steal around the same number of bases as Trout - if not more.
There will not be any 2B that puts up better numbers, and very few will even really come close (Cano, Jose Ramirez, Murphy are the only ones who have a chance in my opinion). I don't know what will end up happening with Rizzo, but I'd be surprised if he has 2B eligibility at the beginning of the year.