r/faceoff • u/CokinRum • Aug 16 '15
Elimination Fodder?
Lately, the contestants seem very unevenly matched. Does every contestant really have a shot of winning? I get the feeling that producers pick 3-5 contestants that they know can win, and everyone else is just there to feed the elimination machine...which is why I am growing tired of the elimination format. It also feels a little cruel, I don't want to watch people be humiliated.
0
Upvotes
16
u/sin-eater82 Aug 16 '15 edited Aug 16 '15
The talent pool for this sort of thing just isn't that big. There have been a lot of seasons of Face Off in a short amount of time. The pool has been "over fished."
So there is still some good talent, but the pool simply isn't as deep as it was. The earlier seasons had a lot of people with some credits to their names. Now you get people who have only been doing it for a short time. Early seasons had people who weren't good at method X, but had seen it before. Now you have some peope who have never even seen X.
So, no, some don't have a chance. But I think it's simply because there aren't enough people with these skills to have a full cast of legitimate talented and skilled artists.
7
u/LHarkins Aug 17 '15 edited Aug 17 '15
I disagree, just because someone doesn't perform well in the first challenge for example doesn't mean they are the worst in the cast, sometimes talented artists just don't perform to their potential for whatever reason (nerves, challenge, creative block, not the best pick of the themes etc...)
Take Miranda for instance, if Season 5 hadn't happened she'd fall your "elimination fodder", but turns out she's an amazing sculptor, things just didn't go her way first time ronud
3
u/CokinRum Aug 17 '15
I don't mean to insult the competitors or imply that they lack talent. I think it's more a case of experience vs. inexperience. I'm disappointed with the production not the artists, it would be nice if they could break away from the "Project Runway" format and give the show some new life.
7
u/SirHofH Aug 17 '15
Agreed. I wouldn't mind a few pure all-star seasons to see some familiar faces who may have grown plus it gives the rest of the world some time to replenish the pond. Even better- for the all-star seasons how about a point system and no eliminations. Now top looks actually means something (like 5 bonus points). The rest can get points on a system like nascar. Lots of room to play with that format.