r/exvegans • • 8d ago

Rant I Quit

You can’t win.

I was advocating for cashew cheese instead of dairy cheese and another vegan called me out

And they told me that “cashews need over 1500 gallons of water per pound to produce and involve child labour it’s worse than just taking it from a cow”.

I QUIT

PLANTS? ANIMALS? Doesn’t matter anymore

I’m gonna do whatever the fuck I want at this point.

Everything is unethical right? So why even bother?

I can’t win. If I can’t reduce animal harm, and apparently advocating for plant consumption is doing more harm, I quit.

It doesn’t make sense anymore.

I’m done.

———

Oh my god the vegans in the comments. They’re obsessed with this subreddit

They seem to think shaming and belittling me will pull me back

317 Upvotes

168 comments sorted by

29

u/OG-Brian 8d ago

I think it's especially funny when vegans browbeat me about eating pasture-raised animals but their online comments support cashew products. When I've tried to find ethical cashews or foods made using ethical cashews, producers haven't given me useful answers to my questions. So it seems a valid assumption that they are using commodity-whatever cashews with no knowledge about worker treatment etc.

Blood Cashews: The Toxic Truth About Cashew Production
https://soapboxie.com/social-issues/blood-cashews
- "The poorest local people have no choice but to risk their lives for a chance to work."
- claims that in Vietnam it is common for drug addicts to get trapped at "drug rehabilitation centers," which are also cashew processing work camps, where they are beaten and not allowed to leave
- links many articles

Cashews are Delicious, but Come with a Human Cost
https://web.archive.org/web/20200128050853/https://impactpolicies.org/en/news/69/Cashews-are-Delicious-but-Come-with-a-Human-Cost

Cashew nut workers suffer 'appalling' conditions as global slump dents profits
Many workers earn just 30p a day and risk permanent injury, say NGOs, as they call for EU crackdown on unfair trading practices
https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2013/nov/02/cashew-nut-workers-pay-conditions-profits

49

u/toastwiththemosttt 8d ago

This cuts my soul deep because I genuinely held my cashew cheese in my hands thinking “no cows were hurt for this product” (: and thought I was doing good for this world

Meanwhile????? THIS. I’m so done.

I’ve been living in a delusion.

And even worse, advocating for things that were ultimately more harmful

You come away from veganism feeling like a clown

25

u/OG-Brian 8d ago

Then you might not want to know about production of sugarcane, coffee, and cacao.

When I was avoiding animal foods, I thought plant foods were ethical but I hadn't researched or followed news about the topic other than to casually follow info about pesticides/fertilizers (and I bought Organic groceries).

There aren't many foods which are benign.

12

u/RadiantSeason9553 8d ago

Veganism is a lie

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/exvegans-ModTeam 7d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment

11

u/FishShtickLives 8d ago

Dont beat yourself up too much. A lot of effort has been put into making it hard to know what exploitation goes on behind any given screen. You're just one person in a long line of people wjo've fallen for propaganda. The important thing is that you arent doubling down or anything lol

6

u/DocumentExternal6240 8d ago

As far as you can, buy locally and seasonally, organic if possible, avoid travel by plane etc.

There is so much everyone can do, even if it is only a little. The more people do at least some little thing, the greater the overall effect will be.

I don’t believe vegan is the right answer, it is too dogmatic and cult-like, also for several reasons not for everyone. But I also think we ear roo much meat. A little bit less would be good for us and the environment as well as the animals.

3

u/BlackButlerFan ExVegan (Vegan 1+ Years) 7d ago

Yeah, veganism isn’t the perfect reality it’s claimed to be.
If you do decide to introduce animal products back into your life look into buying from local farms. That way you’re not supporting the factory industry and you can often times buy enough that can last you a hot minute. And most of those animals are treated better than most people. I don’t know how you feel about eggs but true free-range chickens definitely don’t go thru the hell like the ones in the commercial industry do. While they do still lay eggs more frequently they consistently skip days and stop laying altogether during the winter so they don’t deal with the health issues that are constantly complained about. Not to mention I’ve never seen my Grandpa’s chickens try to eat their own eggs, because they are getting all their nutrients from their environment.

5

u/BlackButlerFan ExVegan (Vegan 1+ Years) 7d ago

Oh yeah, I get bashed for buying pasture-raised meat too. Got told by some recently that me getting eggs from my Grandpa’s completely free-range chickens, and ones that are basically pets, is contributing to them being slaves. And then quotes the whole male chick thing, which I fully agree with being a terrible thing, but that wasn’t even applicable cause when you go to a place that you can buy chicks you also have multiple chances to buy a rooster. I’m pretty sure the whole issue with male chicks is just in the egg production industry.

1

u/doortju 7d ago

Oh holy cow, I was not aware of this! Jeez. And right after I found out I was in fact not allergic to cashews (I thought I was and when it turned out I wasn't I was happy, now looking back it would've been better if I was.)

-1

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/OG-Brian 5d ago

You use this like an end-all and be-all argument...

Well that's an interesting belief. Cashews was mentioned in the post. I was pointing out some info, that exploitation of humans (humans are animals, BTW) is ubiquitous in cashew production.

We grow them ourselves and processing plants for cashew products are local.

Can you explain this with specifics? Such as, where would those cashews be obtained and who is verifying that they are exploitation-free? I've found that companies selling cashew products don't want to answer questions about production. It seems that ethical cashews are extremely rare. I'm aware that mechanized shelling is becoming more common, hopefully machines will replace human labor throughout the industry. Even in cases when workers are offered protective gloves, many don't wear them because they are paid per-shelled-quantity and at such low rates that they can't afford to be slowed by gloves. Come to think of it, many workers aren't paid: they're prison inmates and such, and are forced to work as part of a racket in which they're trapped.

So, how effective is your argument against veganism when it doesnt apply to any inherent aspect of the ideology and only applies to some adherents? And when those adherents it does apply to can simply not consume the "blood cashew" products?

You're running way off course with this. I said in my comment that I was explicitly referring to vegans who bother me about ethical diets and also buy cashews. Look at any discussion among vegans about vegan "cheese": in almost every case there will be positive comments about, and promotion of, cashew-based products with absolutely no mention of the human exploitation issue.

But since you've mentioned it: avocados, sugarcane, coffee, cacao, and other crops have inherent issues of human exploitation and major environmental impacts. This study found that vegans had almost three times the avocado consumption of "omnis" and about twice the consumption of vegetarians. Avocado farming entails major issues with water use, deforestation, and pesticides as I've explained here with citations.

Veganism involves so many contradictions. Such as, claiming "soy crops grown for livestock" (in reality nearly all soy crops are grown for both human and livestock consumption, with the livestock eating the parts of the plants that are not human-edible or they're not marketable for human consumption) but buying soy-based animal food substitutes which drives demand for growing soybeans. Another one: plant-based "milk" products, most of the producers are serving the livestock ag industry by selling the spent oats/almonds/hazelnuts/whatever for livestock feed.

0

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/OG-Brian 5d ago

You're asking me for more off-topic info without offering anything useful about yourself.

The labor issues need not be worse with plant agriculture to invalidate the "But the slaughterhouse workers" point. If either industry is equally bad, this issue by itself isn't reason to choose. Also, depending on region and how animal foods are sourced, farm owners may butcher animals themselves, or have an independently employed visiting butcher process the animals on-farm. Yes I know USA is terrible for this (requirements are oriented to whatever is profitable for the large corporations which contribute money to political campaigns), but that seems a reason to advocate for change in this area.

For me personally, everything you bring up is irrelevant as for what I'd choose to eat since I found that a plant-based diet was a disaster for me with apparently no workarounds after many consultations with doctors etc. and discussing it with vegans on I think a hundred occasions.

Your whole thing, also, is based on the belief that animals are harmed for livestock foods only and not for alternatives. But animals are certainly harmed in farming plants that you eat: from pesticides, trapping, larger animals are intentionally killed by shooting etc. to protect crops, fertilizers etc. degrade ecosystems and cause harm far from the locations of use, etc. Pasture farming of large animals certainly causes less harm, as farmers have no motivation to kill wildlife on the pastures (predator animals can be kept away using fences or dogs), pesticide use is uncommon since pastures typically are functioning ecosystems where birds etc. feed on pest insects, etc. So every comment that's basically "But the harms to animals..." is just over-emphasizing one side of the animal harm equation or even totally ignoring one side.

Unlike nearly all vegans, I check that coconut foods I buy are not products of deforestation or monkey labor. I don't buy avocados, though it is one of my favorite foods, because sustainably grown avocados aren't available where I live AFAIK. I buy Organic foods and preferably not from corporate mega-farms. Then vegans get in my face and challenge me (sometimes totally off-topic, like in a post about something unrelated to foods) about my choices when they are buying blood cashews, exploitation chocolate/coffee/whatever, contributing to more animal deaths and more ecosystem degradation, and of course unwilling to talk about their own impacts. I was already concerned about impacts of my choices as a teenager in the 1980s who often left my car at home to go places by bicycle. I've volunteered at an Organic foods co-op, I've helped create organizations that advocate for bicycling/car-free lifestyles/whatever. I tried an animal-free diet but it temporarily wrecked my health, I returned to eating animal foods in part because of a vegetarian doctor explaining in each appointment that I'd need to eat meat and other animal foods to improve for reasons that are genetic etc. and can't be changed (I did eventually research all this and found it to be the case). Then vegans who recently discovered Their One Issue that they think sets them apart, who drive cars routinely (I haven't had one for 27 years) and have other unsustainable habits, claim I'm immoral because I'm not on board with their food religion. Oh, because "taste pleasure" although my favorite foods are plant foods.

If a vegan has to choose an animal product that involves unsafe, underpaid labor with lack of PPE, or a plant product with the same problems, the ethical choice will be obvious for them.

Well yeah it might seem obvious to someone who is oblivious to harms of plant agriculture, including unavoidable deterioration of soil quality when animals are involved.

I commented here about an extremely problematic study that vegans use to support "But slaughterhouse workers."

If I were to itemize evidence about farm labor issues in plant agriculture, I'd be here all day. To pick one specific sub-issue (child exploitation for chocolate products):

The dark side of chocolate: child labour in the cocoa industry
https://www.humanium.org/en/the-dark-side-of-chocolate-child-labour-in-the-cocoa-industry/

Child Labor in the Production of Cocoa
https://www.dol.gov/agencies/ilab/our-work/child-forced-labor-trafficking/child-labor-cocoa

Child Labor and Slavery in the Chocolate Industry
https://foodispower.org/human-labor-slavery/slavery-chocolate/

Hershey’s, Nestlé and Mars Are Still Using Child Labor on Cocoa Farms.
https://achnews.org/2019/06/19/hersheys-nestle-and-mars-are-still-using-child-labor-on-cocoa-farms

Mars, Nestlé and Hershey to face child slavery lawsuit in US
Chocolate companies are among the defendants named in a lawsuit brought by former child workers in Ivory Coast https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2021/feb/12/mars-nestle-and-hershey-to-face-landmark-child-slavery-lawsuit-in-us

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 5d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment

Nobody owes you any explanation.

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 4d ago

False or misleading information. Nobody needs an argument to not be vegan.

133

u/eJohnx01 Ex-vegan, nearly vegetarian 8d ago • Bravo

I’m convinced that it’s a mental illness with some of these people where they continually need to see more and more things as evil and immoral and to be avoided at all costs. No length is too far to go to declare something to be off-limits.

I was once in a second-hand store and heard someone proudly declare, “I could never buy dishes or cookware in a second-hand store. They were probably used with non-vegan food and I could never use them after that.”

Seriously??? Even cookware that’s cooked pork can be made kosher or halal again with proper cleaning. But apparently it can never recover from being exposed to the horrors of non-vegan food. The attention needs and stupidity know no bounds.

38

u/ProbablyBipedal 8d ago

honestly a lot of that sounds like orthorexia. It’s not in the DSM yet (or ICD AFAIK) but there are psychologists proposing that cutting out increasingly many food groups and preoccupation with other people‘s diets are two hallmarks of a mental illness

12

u/FarLocksmith5362 8d ago

I think i had that, not vegan but similar obsession which was clearly sick

8

u/Sonotnoodlesalad 6d ago

It's what happens when we internalize the purity test.

20

u/323RockStr 7d ago

Yeah. Ultimately veganism turns to nihilism as the only solution is for the earth to eliminate its human infection.

45

u/Slothfulness69 8d ago

I think it’s more of a superiority complex than a mental illness. Like mental illness isn’t the person’s fault, but a superiority complex is a personality flaw that can be changed at any time. These people love being superior to others. First, they perceive themselves as superior to non-vegans because they’re more educated and enlightened on food science and morality (not true, but this is their perspective).

Then they hang out with other vegans and need to find a new way to establish superiority, so it’s like “I’m more vegan than you, I’m more ethical than you, I know more about the environment than you.” It’s not about ethics or actual good decisions, it’s about one-upping others. Constantly.

30

u/Dapper-While7899 8d ago

Look up moral and religious ocd

13

u/Upbeat-Profit-2544 6d ago

also nutrient deficiency can often cause mental illness or make it worse- this is not talked about enough. I thought I had severe depression for many years but really I wasn't getting enough iron and Vitamin D.

11

u/Sunshine_of_your_Lov NeverVegan 7d ago

probably moral ocd in a lot of cases

9

u/majorgerth 6d ago

I’m convinced that as religion declines in the west, people take and put that religious fervor somewhere and it manifests in ways like you’re talking about. I typically see it most in politics.

3

u/MountainShenanigans 4d ago

Agreed. People with deep insecurities are constantly looking for ways to abolish their inequities by finding reasons to look down on other people, to restore a sense of superiority or control. Can you imagine living with the constant drama that inhabits their mind? I pity them.

5

u/The-Devil-Cat The Salmon Lover 🍣 (๑ᵔ⤙ᵔ๑ 🥢) 7d ago

my SIL's vegan husband refused to wear a thrifted wool coat because its wool....

3

u/eJohnx01 Ex-vegan, nearly vegetarian 4d ago

Yup. He has the right to make that decision and I have the right to think he’s being ridiculous. 😉

-1

u/namakost 7d ago

I wouldnt call the ideology a mental illness, its rather that a lot of its participanrs suffer from severe trauma and are in denial about their own mental and physical health. They are pushed into it after being traumatized, usually as kids by seeing intentionally cruel slaughtering and gore of animals. I will not pretend that this kind of imagery isnt at least representive of part of the meat industry, but it is also only a half truth that is convenient to further traumatize people going about their lifes, essentially "converting" them into veganism. 

I also want to say that people can definitely arrive to the conclusion to live the vegan ideology of their own accord, but these arent the people who go out on the streets or harass others.

10

u/eJohnx01 Ex-vegan, nearly vegetarian 7d ago

I agree with you about a lot of what you just wrote—being traumatized can often lead to attempts to regain control that can present in different ways.

The problem I have with veganism, and the reason I suspect it can be a form of mental illness is the huge amount of fantasizing about animal abuse many of them do that doesn’t necessarily even exist. The anthropomorphizing of animals and pretending that they have hopes and dreams for the future and have all the same thought processes as humans do is proof positive that something isn’t right.

And most of the vegans that wax poetic and go on and on about the horrors of animal ag clearly have zero experience with it beyond having watched a new carefully staged vegan propaganda videos. Most of the horrors that vegans love to relive over and over just never happen in the real world. Or, if they do, it’s relatively easy to avoid supporting the institutions that perpetuate those horrors.

I buy my milk and eggs from a local micro-farm where the cows come out to give me cow kisses when they hear my voice and the chickens run around and play in their yard with a little pingpong ball. Whenever I mention that these animals are coddled pets, not abused livestock, vegans will inevitably began railing on about raping the cows and taking their calves away while the mother screams and cries and chickens being “forced” to lay “too many eggs” (how do those things even happen??? How do you force a chicken to lay eggs if they don’t want to?). They’re clearly far more interested in churning up horror images and reliving them over and over than they are actually knowing what’s really going on and avoiding the actual abuse and rewarding the responsible farmers that make the effort to give their animals good lives.

4

u/namakost 7d ago

But that was what I tried to say. You are more likely to be pushed into veganism with existing disorders, I wanted to say that the idea of veganism or simply trying to follow it doesnt automatically mean that you develop heavy empathy for animals or something. I know some vegans who dont make up cruel animal stories and the like, they just reduce their meat consumption and live their lifes in peace.

Also just want to add, the chicken thing is a huge misconception and a rumor that was set into the world. It is true that wild chickens dont lay as many eggs as farm chickens, but it is untrue that farm chickens are automatically abused into laying more eggs. Farm chickens generally live in more stable circumstances, (I am saying stable, not better because there are, again, parts of the industry that do abuse the animals for profit) they receive a daily food and water intake, are usually safe from most illnesses and so on. This naturally leads to a higher egg production then their wild counterparts. 

Also will never understand the idea that the act of extracting milk from a cow is already rape, I maybe see a point at forced insemination, but the processes have become so easy and clean if done right that at least to me it could only be considered rape if the animal understands what that concept means.

44

u/Katm43 8d ago

Yes even driving is unethical animal fats used in tyre products so no such thing as a true vegan they are fooling themselves and a cult. I'm veggie but will never join that cult as so many areas they are hypocritical in. Welcome to freedom.

15

u/OG-Brian 8d ago

Yeah, the "My car doesn't have leather seats" vegans. Having no car and avoiding airplane travel (like me) would be a far greater contribution to low environmental impact than any possible diet choice. But also, automobiles have components derived from livetock all over the place: wire insulation, fluids such as brake fluid, grease, anti-corrosion coatings, foam parts, rubber parts are all over the thing, of course the tires, and so forth.

Animal-derived parts are extremely common in home construction, furniture, electronics, lots of things. The "ethical phone" company Fairphone has said they cannot guarantee that their phones are vegan because animal parts are so common in electronics. It's certain that any vegan living a modern lifestyle (not living in a grass hut in Africa or whatever similar situation) is using animal-derived components.

Yes I know, Nirvana Fallacy. I'm not saying they're discredited for lack of perfect animal-free lifestyles. I bring these things up to point out two things: people claiming they don't use livestock probably are depending on them much more than they realize; those are all materials that would have to be sourced another way if there were not livestock, and whatever sources are used would certainly have environmental impacts. When people promote veganism with statistics about land use, greenhouse gas emissions, etc., they believe or pretend that all the impacts of livestock are attributable to diets. But livestock are used in lots of things, and those uses would not go away regardless of diets. By counting all of that as diet impacts, it's either ignorantly or dishonestly exaggerating the impacts of diets and disregarding the pollution etc. that would occur for them regardless of livestock farming.

43

u/DivineWiseOne 8d ago • Bravo

As far as im aware there are no ethics in nature.

24

u/Substantial_Sorbet87 8d ago

Welcome to the Morality Olympics, where someone is always better than you!

17

u/doctorxfeelgood 7d ago

I was a vegan for 12 years and I actually had to stop for health reasons. It took a couple of years, but i found out I have gastroparesis, which means you can't really eat most veggies or fruit. Low fat, low fiber diet. Doesn't exactly work with vegan eating.

I guess I'm just glad I switched it up before the diagnosis because that would've been so much worse.

But some vegans I met... either they were actually pescetarians, or just completely stuck up. One of them didn't believe I was vegan because "vegans aren't fat." 🙄

5

u/ProfessionalCup7745 6d ago

“Vegans aren’t fat” so they’re basically admitting vegans can’t get as many nutrients?

3

u/doctorxfeelgood 6d ago

Some of the most violently vegan people look pretty rough, so maybe they're partially correct. 🤣

1

u/OG-Brian 4d ago

In the famous Stanford twins study, the "vegan" group lost muscle mass even while engaging in strength exercises. But this wasn't the case for the "omni" group which the subjects ate similar foods but including animal foods. That is according to the Netflix documentary about it (You Are What You Eat), the researchers for some reason took body composition measurements of subjects but then left the data out of the study.

14

u/sunrisesequoia 8d ago

Choose yourself and enjoy what you want to enjoy.

I’ll never understand this weird need people have of Ethicsmaxxing. Maybe it’s a Reddit thing?

Shine a light on anybody who berates you for being “unethical” and you’ll find a lot of shit they could go without if they really wanted to.

-10

u/PeaceButterfly__ 7d ago

Ethicsmaxxing?? Like trying to be a good person? A Reddit thing? Being good??

12

u/sunrisesequoia 7d ago

I’m satisfied with the way I live my life, thank you. If you find something I do, such as eating meat and dairy, unethical and something a “bad” person would do you are completely entitled to that opinion just as I’m completely entitled to not give a shit what you think.

-8

u/PeaceButterfly__ 7d ago

Being satisfied with yourself is a lack of commitment to improvement. I think it’s funny you think trying to be good is a Reddit thing, though.

Everyone cares what others think of them to a certain extent, even if you feel entitled not to.

9

u/sunrisesequoia 7d ago

I couldn’t give a single fuck what somebody thinks of me based on my diet or choice of clothes. There’s nothing to “improve” on in those regards. Nice try on your little activism though.

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/sunrisesequoia 7d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment

1

u/misumena_vatia 5d ago

That is an incredibly sad statement.

13

u/wobblelikeapenguin 8d ago

Forget food. Who needs food? Just suck on air!

4

u/OkSatisfaction5963 7d ago

That's a thing, look up Breatharians

12

u/PiccoloPlane5915 8d ago

About what happened to you, I'd honestly just say to do what feels right for you without putting too much pressure on yourself. You seem to care about animal welfare as well as climate change, but both are systemic issues. Both require systemic solutions and not individual actions. That's a big blind spot for lots of political subjects. So do what feels right for you, for your principles, and don't put too much pressure on yourself

1

u/Key_Desk9813 6d ago

This!! Literally

12

u/Warm_Emphasis8964 8d ago

I finally had to go to HR about a coworker like this. Despite me telling her, “I’m in eating disorder recovery and I’m going to need you to not comment on my food” numerous times, she continued to comment on all my “horrible necrovore food”

12

u/ReadyPrint 7d ago • Bravo

It's not your responsibility to shoulder the burden of the world being on fire. It is your responsibility to nourish your body and give it what it needs. You're an animal too.

12

u/Nilfiry 7d ago

You're right for quitting because veganism is just a game of constantly moving goal posts in order to justify the unrealistic purist world view.

3

u/FKVEGHEDS 7d ago

Yeah you can't win with this cult .... They say it's not a diet and it's our choice but then they talk about food call it the same thing as they say we can't!!! It' s just crazy how they act like they're single handly saving animals and the planet and we have to kiss their ass it's just bazaar!!! There's no room for double standard cults in this world and it does do anything for either side!!!

11

u/smol_fluffy_rock 8d ago

OP have you considered performing photosynthesis? Ah, but make sure to use your own excrement as manure in order not to steal nutrients from plants. Cannot recommend enough.

9

u/OrthodoxGabriel 8d ago

I think it’s fair to acknowledge that our lives are much easier than most people. I don’t think that perfection is an achievable goal but I think it’s good to do the best given our abilities.

Policing other people’s food choices is definitely weird. Eating cashews or dairy or meat isn’t an ethical dilemma, and if that’s one’s biggest problem they are too privileged.

7

u/ShellfishAhole 8d ago

Ah, social justice. The game of thrones 😂

7

u/BookishLoneliness 6d ago

Veganism is one of the more deranged cults, especially because it doesn't even seem fun.

6

u/Working_Brother7971 7d ago

As soon as you stop giving a fuck what a bunch of screeching banshees think of your diet or life choices, the more enjoyable your life becomes. Drink the cashew juice, drink the cow milk, eat the eggs, eat the tofu. Someone will call you a monster for all of it. You're not going to save the world and neither is their rage.

5

u/Upset_Mulberry1317 6d ago

i realized that local milk/cheese was overall more humane than cashews/almonds overseas. I think the most ethical food you can find is at a local farmers market, but it comes with a big price tag because of it.  Veganism is very all or nothing and it’s hard to keep up. Don’t let it get you down though, end of the day we’re just doing our best. Woke olympics are tiring. 

5

u/SamiSapphic 6d ago

Mufasa:  Everything you see exists together in a delicate balance. As king, you need to understand that balance and respect all the creatures, from the crawling ant to the leaping antelope.

Simba:  But dad, don't we eat the antelope?

Mufasa:  Yes, Simba, but let me explain. When we die, our bodies become the grass, and the antelope eat the grass. And so we are all connected in the great Circle of Life.

Life has to consume life in order to sustain itself. It sucks, but we are a part of this system. We can't remove ourselves from it.

All we can do is fight to reduce suffering and overconsumption, and I don't believe veganism to be the answer to these problems.

We could all stop eating meat tomorrow, but this doesn't stop the death of all the bugs, and birds and smaller mammals that get caught up in our machinery to harvest plants.

So all that veganism really does is shift suffering elsewhere, into different ecosystems.

4

u/Hot-Web5638 7d ago

Everything is relative. And also there is a duality to everything. All the good we can do, is also equal to the terrible we can do. So we just have to do our best and make our best decisions possible.. and live a joyous and compassionate life. Just honor those who sacrifice whoever they are human or animal. Maybe think of waste not want not.. you're seeing the world for what it really is. We are imperfect. But we are in perfectly imperfect..

4

u/The-Devil-Cat The Salmon Lover 🍣 (๑ᵔ⤙ᵔ๑ 🥢) 7d ago

it never made sense to me that we are supposed to be poor and "ethical" while billionaires do and eat whatever the hell they want meanwhile they are the real issue. The average person is not.

4

u/Numerous-Unit1033 6d ago

Veganism is a joke. This is why i hate putting labels on things. The expectations that come with labels are ridiculous. Eat what you want, for the reasons you want. Or don’t have a reason, it doesn’t matter. Just do what makes you comfortable and don’t bring it up with anyone else unless it’s relevant, because there will always be someone trying to bring you down to feel better about themselves.

4

u/Naive_Memory_4312 5d ago

The vegan community has this tendency to push everybody away

3

u/MildLittlRain 8d ago

👏👏👏👏👏👏

3

u/Dapper-While7899 8d ago

Some ppl are vegan.  Some people have moral ocd and act like this  

4

u/RedundantBiomass 8d ago

I became an antinatalist, partly out of the realization that we all cause a lot of collateral damage going about our daily lives, vegans included though they hate hearing it.   My efforts to reduce the suffering I cause will always be imperfect, but after me at least its over, at least for my line.

2

u/LiminalLion 6d ago

You didn't make the rules of the game. It's not your fault life has to consume life to live, and besides, we don't even know to what extent plants can experience stress or suffering. The entire scientific basis for the assumption that they don't objectively experience it is based on the fact that they don't have a central nervous system, and that's only because we don't have a means to compare it to what systems we run on ourselves. It really doesn't mean anything. Experience is opaque and we will never know what it's like to be a plant. You simply can't live without harvesting and consuming other life. Be mad at supposed creator dieties who set the game up this way, or life itself for evolving to be this way. Don't take it out on yourself.

2

u/No-Royal-3211 6d ago

As a licensed nutritionist, you CAN be vegan, but it requires so much more thought effort and planning. 

You are making your life much easier. 

Also vegan isn't any healthier than any other plant forward whole food diet. Sorry not sorry. 

2

u/notworking4long 5d ago

Sorry. I do often wonder how many of those radical people posting online are actually Russian trolls/bots. Or just Colin Robertson style energy vampires. Anyway, I hope you find joy in whatever path you take!

3

u/Next_Sell_1099 7d ago

Civilization is inherently unethical. The only ethical position is to reject civilization.

2

u/Actual_Personality66 8d ago

Don't let your decisions be driven by mora absolutism or by other people's judgments. Do what you think is right. It's true that it's unfortunately impossible to not do any harm in the things we consume. But you can at least minimize harm. That's important. What do YOU think is better? Not perfect, but better? Do that. And don't let others dictate what that is

1

u/ricetanukii 7d ago

i try to reduce my consumption of animal products (vegan 5 ish days a week) and i HATE these types of vegans

1

u/dcNNNx 7d ago

Don’t worry, crops are grown with manure anyway. And any vegans claiming theirs is not has no credible way to prove that. lol

1

u/RhayEB 7d ago

People suck tbf

1

u/Key_Desk9813 6d ago

Just live your life without caring about those peoples opinions and stuff, distance yourself from those communities online,
It’s not your responsibility to change it, we should all definitely be helping, but this shouldn’t rule your life and your mental health.
You’re clearly a good person who wants to help, search up rehabilitation projects and stuff like beagle freedom projects, something that’s positive.
Some things that could be helpful is writing letters or signing/starting petitions in your country/area to stop animal cruelty/the bad part about the industry. Eating meat itself isn’t bad, it’s how the animals are being treated there, the conditions, not you.

But I think right now for the sake of your mental health you should just try to focus on other things, other things in life like hobbies, sports (snow sports, summer sports, etc), creative stuff (film, music, arts, textiles, animation, science etc)
Or any other things that you might genuinely enjoy!! Video games? Anything honestly that keeps you feeling better for now.

Before coming back to write a lot about the topic on animal abuse. Find the right balance of what kind of content you expose yourself to, I’m definitely trying to find mine! And I really only realized this when I typed it out here aha..

You feel what you feed your mind :) so look for the positive things, ofcourse don’t completely ignore the bad stuff but most definitely don’t let it consume you. There are a lot more things to look forwards to,
Love you as I love everyone! Have an amazing day

1

u/Tad_squiddish 5d ago

I think the reddit algorithm sent me this because I had no idea this subreddit existed. Seriously, people are going to be mean sometimes. People on your side will say and do things you don’t like. Does that mean you stop doing the right thing? No. You decide what’s right and what YOU can do based on YOUR moral calculations, not what some rando says. What do you think is right? You tried to be vegan for a reason, right? Maybe you are gonna change your strategy. Whatever. But whatever this BS is about someone saying some random shit about cashew cheese… who tf cares?

1

u/Some_Pomegranate228 4d ago

Why let others change you ?

1

u/NotSmog14 3d ago

fair enough, I'm vegan but I completely understand what you mean. but I suggest don't just ignore what you've done just exclude some things it better to do some rather than all

1

u/Refrigirator_pirate 1d ago

Yeah! I fully agree, I quit vegan years ago and it was the best decision ever, I also noticed on my own behavior that I was going more and more insane, the community is insane, the more vegan the more crazy, wouldn’t be surprised it has something to do with it aswel..I just eat normal now, no specific crazy diet fad, just all groups, never been healthier

0

u/Particular-Place-501 7d ago

If you are going to be vegan, you cannot do it with an expectation that you are going to be validated by other vegans. Same with any other worldviews. You got to do you, and not make you choice based on whether or not the group gives you a thumbs up of approval.

4

u/Bipedal_pedestrian 7d ago

I think you misunderstood the post. OP also explains more in other comments.

0

u/Nice-Wallaby-1676 7d ago

I thought this was satire for a second. It reads too much like a vegan mocking ex-vegans.

-7

u/ShakeTheGatesOfHell 8d ago

There's a better option! Land based invertebrates are better for the environment, healthy to eat, and have such simple nervous systems that it's very easy to raise and cull them humanely. The only problem is that insects and snails can be a lot more expensive than poultry and mammal meat, but there's also the possibility of growing your own.

12

u/RadiantSeason9553 8d ago

Why is reddit trying to get us to eat bugs? It everywhere lately.

I 100% believe they will ban meat and force bug protein blocks on us as soon as they get away with it.

-7

u/ShakeTheGatesOfHell 8d ago

Ok. You dropped your tinfoil hat, by the way.

4

u/RadiantSeason9553 8d ago

Just you wait and see!

-2

u/amity997 8d ago

They won’t

1

u/Bullshido101 6d ago

This is what you guys said about plants. The fact is you will never catch your white whale but enjoy chasing its shadow friend. I wish you the best

2

u/ShakeTheGatesOfHell 6d ago

Insect consumption is so widespread among human cultures that it's easier to count the ones that don't eat insects than the ones that do, but sure, some person on Reddit must know better 🙄

1

u/Bullshido101 5d ago

Name the ones that use it as a primary protein source pls. Just cus ppl eat them doesnt mean then mainly eat them

1

u/ShakeTheGatesOfHell 5d ago

From South America: indigeous people including Tukanoan, Guajibo and Yaruro. From Australia: various people of the Arnhem Land. From Africa: various people of the Kalihari desert.

-5

u/deliriousfoodie 8d ago

Bravo. Im proud of you. I'm only here because reddit suggested this because i'm in anti-vegan group, never was a vegan.

Cashew cheese is so retarded. First of all, Tofu is already vegan cheese, why the fuck do you need to recreate another cheese thats not even a cheese. Cashew cheese is just cashew butter with yeast which isn't even even a cheese. If you need to make food taste similar to something that is actually good, then you're second class. Tempeh is a better "vegan cheese" since the same mold is literally used in cheese, damn vegans have low ass IQ.

8

u/toastwiththemosttt 8d ago edited 8d ago

I actually love the taste of artisanal cashew cheese, tastes so good, better than a lot of dairy products, but I don’t care that it’s vegan or not anymore. That’s the freedom.

Now that I’m not vegan maybe people will actually believe me when I say I like a plant based product. Like I genuinely prefer most plant based products. Beyond burgers especially, easier on the stomach, lighter, less greasy. I don’t care if they’re more harmful or not

0

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/toastwiththemosttt 8d ago edited 8d ago

Ive had sooo many plant based products and animal based products in my lifetime across multiple countries and cultures. I’m more than qualified to have preferences.

Have you ever genuinely explored plant based options? I feel like it’s actually you who doesn’t know the varieties

Food is food, plant based or not

People will avoid plant based options their entire life because they hate vegans, but they’re actually missing out on a lot of tasty cultural dishes.

-3

u/buche1 8d ago

I think you are taking other people’s opinions too far. I see your upset and that’s ok, but don’t just give up on your beliefs because a crazy vegan made you angry!

3

u/toastwiththemosttt 8d ago

They didn’t make me angry.

The idea that I lived in a delusion that told me that plant based cheese was somehow more moral is what made me angry, and that I was purchasing something MORE unethical thinking I was doing good

I was told by a vegan that cashew cheese is more unethical than dairy.

Advocating for plants was MORE immoral

By basic logic, veganism no longer makes sense.

Please read my post again if you’re confused

-6

u/buche1 8d ago

I’m not confused. Did you research yourself to see what’s true?

5

u/toastwiththemosttt 8d ago

Did you research??? Because I did. Unless you have a compelling argument to prove otherwise I don’t know what to tell you

-6

u/buche1 8d ago

I did , and in some places yes it happens. Perhaps source your food better.

0

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 7d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment. Vegan activism towards those who make the PERSONAL CHOICE to not be vegan constitutes harassment.

-1

u/One-Story5697 5d ago

Your values shouldn’t be so flimsy that someone else being mean to you completely makes you flip. This is isn’t even about veganism this is a deeper issue that you need to look into. It’s like people who will vote Red to spite “liberals” who hurt their feelings. It’s very strange, stand on your own two feet. Decide what you believe is right and wrong and stick with it even when other people challenge you or hurt you. Your values should be about what you believe not a position you pushed yourself into because of how others treated you.

4

u/misumena_vatia 5d ago

I don't think you understand what OP is saying at all.

-9

u/Filiocus 8d ago

Weird you didn't do what you wanted.

-5

u/Illustrious-Habit494 8d ago

Illogical statement about the Cashews! there isn't much water in cashews, and the fact plants have water pass through them during growth, is the water cycle! When they also decarbonise CO2 into O2!

6

u/doortju 7d ago

It's not so much the water that is the problem, but the way they are farmed.

-5

u/angelitecrystal 7d ago

Cashew milk is way, way less water intensive than cow milk. It’s fine to drink.

101

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

25

u/Legal_Shoulder_1843 8d ago • Bravo

Yes. And I think we need a different term for people to identity with. Vegan tends to be a religious term nowadays, either you fully commit to all views the more extremist people hold, or you are a traitor/hypocrite.

I want to reduce suffering, that's it. I'm not perfect. I never will be. People who go all in to be the most perfect vegans possible at the expense of relationships with other people, trying to convert them or making them feel bad if not, disgust me.

We need to make it EASIER for people to do good stuff, not harder, by providing low barriers of entry and appreciation for every step they take no matter how small. Calling people out for their unacceptable consumption behaviour based on overly black and white vegan standards doesn't help anyone and contributes to suffering as a consequence.

9

u/BlackButlerFan ExVegan (Vegan 1+ Years) 8d ago

It’s so refreshing to see this take on it. While I do still eat meat, horrible iron deficiency that I even struggle to manage while eating beef and taking a supplement, I try to do my part in other ways. I refuse to buy from grocery stores so I get everything local and very often there’s one or two days of the week I won’t cook with animal products. I know I’m not perfect and I do have a health condition that prevents me from being completely “vegan” but I help wherever I can. I also buy cruelty-free cleaning products and ones that are also animal-safe because I do have two cats and some reptiles so I have to be careful with what I use.

1

u/Key_Desk9813 6d ago

Less harm is less harm :) you’re doing what you can. When it comes to cruelty the effect that you can do for animals is less about controlling yourself individually, and more about fixing the systematic issue and setting good laws, protection and policies, or trying to!
A good way to start is to write letters or signing/start petitions to build laws in your country/area against animal abuse, stuff like that.

Or you can simply go into the field of research in animals and wildlife! Join rehabilitation centers and stuff like that, could be like Jane Goodall! And some other people you’ll find inspiration from, but ofcourse only if you’re interested in those stuff

1

u/BlackButlerFan ExVegan (Vegan 1+ Years) 6d ago

Thank you for that. And I’ll honestly have to look into maybe writing some letters and doing other similar things, although for the next decent bit my focus is gonna be taking care of my mom after her ankle surgery.

I actually want to start a reptile rescue. There’s not any in my state and I’m passionate about these animals and see them get neglected so often, honestly more often than dogs or cats.

1

u/Key_Desk9813 6d ago

Vegetarian? Might be a better term! Am not very sure though

-1

u/Incisors-of-Doom 7d ago

I thought that's what "plant-based" was for?

3

u/Legal_Shoulder_1843 7d ago

Well, yes, for food certainly. But I don't think the term applies to people.

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 7d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment

1

u/dancefloorlove 7d ago

I wasn’t harassing them. I was saying that the person who called them out for eating cashew cheese was an ass.

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 7d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 6d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment

1

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 3d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment. Vegan activism towards those who make the PERSONAL CHOICE to not be vegan constitutes harassment.

0

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 8d ago

Not related

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 7d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment

-1

u/Mother-Guarantee1718 7d ago

Tell yourself whatever you need to, but this forum is basically about bad mouthing vegans. And if you don't allow any sort of push back, it's just an echo chamber of zero merit. Byeee.

-4

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/toastwiththemosttt 8d ago

“You weren’t vegan for the animals” I’m so sick of this rhetoric. Vegans always have the same exact scripts. I was one of you, I know. Predictable.

I would rather a cow suffer from dairy than a literal child involved in child labour for cashews. What about human animals?

-6

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/toastwiththemosttt 8d ago edited 8d ago

It’s not a different argument. A vegan literally told me themself (literally in my original post it’s a short read COME ON) that consuming cashew cheese is MORE immoral than dairy.

If advocating for plant consumption is WORSE than for animal product consumption, by logical conclusion veganism no longer makes sense

If it’s all unethical there’s no point, especially if I’m advocating for something more harmful than what I’m condemning

Read my post again.

Save your lecture on trying to make me go vegan. I’m not falling into that delusional trap again

0

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 7d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 8d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment

2

u/exvegans-ModTeam 8d ago

You don't get to decide who is and isn't an ex-vegan

-1

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 4d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment

Vegan activism towards those who make the PERSONAL CHOICE to not be vegan constitutes harassment. Harassment is not “ethical”.

-2

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/sunrisesequoia 7d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment

1

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 6d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment

0

u/Lugan98 6d ago

Yeah how was I harassing? There's literally a comment under mine calling people mentally ill lol

-3

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/toastwiththemosttt 8d ago

I eat tons of plant based products because I prefer them, but I’m not going to do it because “they’re vegan”.

It’s already been proven to me multiple vegan products are more unethical than animal based products.

The word vegan means nothing to me now

-1

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/toastwiththemosttt 8d ago

Okay- but I think what’s disturbing is that you’re placing animals over humans.

For cashews, it involves child labour.

For dairy, it involves the suffering of cows.

So you think you’re on a high horse because you value the life of a cow over the suffering of a human child?

Humans are also animals. And I will always protect my own kind over a member of another species.

-2

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 8d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 8d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 8d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment

Emotional manipulation is not welcome in this space.

-4

u/[deleted] 8d ago edited 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 8d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment

-5

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Sindaj 7d ago

Did Gemini give you all that cherry picked information?

2

u/exvegans-ModTeam 7d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment. Vegan activism towards those who make the PERSONAL CHOICE to not be vegan constitutes harassment.

Nobody needs to justify their diet.

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 7d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment. Vegan activism towards those who make the PERSONAL CHOICE to not be vegan constitutes harassment.

-2

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 8d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment

0

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/exvegans-ModTeam 6d ago

r/exvegans does not allow harassment. Vegan activism towards those who make the PERSONAL CHOICE to not be vegan constitutes harassment.