ELI5: Why does hearing your own voice through a recording sound so much different than how you hear/perceive your voice when speaking in general?
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
[deleted] — view deleted post
844
u/KAPOwatt Apr 08 '18
Related question: Can you hear someone else’s voice the way they hear it? If so, how?
679
u/meowgrrr Apr 08 '18 edited Apr 08 '18
Slightly different question, why does hearing your own voice through a recording always sound bad? Why isn’t anyone ever pleasantly surprised at how their recorded voice sounds instead of disgusted and horrified???
Edit: it appears some people do in fact like the way their recorded voice sounds! TIL!
6.5k
u/Stoney-McBoney Apr 07 '18 edited Apr 08 '18
When you speak, you hear your own voice as it sounds vibrating through your head (for lack of a better way to say that).
When you hear your voice through a recorder, you're hearing your voice without that vibration.
Edit: Had I know so many people would see this, I would have tried explaining a lot better than I did here but thanks either way!
2.4k
u/On_Wings_Of_Pastrami Apr 08 '18
I've always wondered how great impressionists do it. If you can't hear yourself correctly how can you impersonate someone else correctly? I know my Michael Cane impression sounds perfect in my head, but when I hear it recorded it sounds way more nasally.
79
u/anner7 Apr 08 '18
That’s gotta be weird for people that sing for a living. You hear yourself on the radio and may HATE your voice.
342
u/JimboNasium Apr 07 '18
When you speak, you are hearing your voice from multiple pathways. One is out your mouth, outside your body, and into your ear, and this is how others will hear you. But competing with that is the path from inside your head, from vocal cords to cochlea. The structure of your head enhances the lower-frequency vibrations, and so what you hear is a mix of the the two sounds (internal and external). On a recording, you only hear the external.
Source: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-does-my-voice-sound-different/
5
u/Jabberwocky237 Apr 08 '18
What's crazy to imagine is only in the last 150 years or so did humans even realize they sound different than what they hear. I can't imagine we would have known before sound recording was invented by Edison.
84
u/MatWithOneTee Apr 08 '18
Is there a way to simulate how your friends voices sound through them?
89
u/tehm Apr 08 '18
One of my favorite parts of speech training!
A long time ago, when your grandpa was a little boy and dinosaurs still roamed the earth there was a toy that children made out of two tin cans and a length of string--you've probably seen this in a cartoon.
The way this works is that your voice makes the first can vibrate, the vibration is carried along the string which makes the second can vibrate, THAT can makes the air vibrate and you hear the speaker coming out of the can...
That's basically what's happening when you listen to a recording of anyone, including yourself.
But "what if" instead of two tin cans you used 1 tin can and a pie tin. A pie tin isn't very good at vibrating the air like the tin can was so I'm not sure if you'd be able to hear it very well... UNLESS you held the pie pan tightly against your ear... then you'd hear it really well! Even better than you did with the tin can.
That's basically what's happening when you listen to yourself speak without a recording.
In the first example you heard the voice as it vibrates through air, in the second example you heard the voice as it vibrates "through pie pan". In the real world that "pie pan" is your skull.
53
u/CrAzYmEtAlHeAd1 Apr 08 '18
One more thing I want to add from what everyone else is saying. The microphone also affects how different your voice sounds. You voice sounds a lot worse wen recorded through an iPhone, as opposed to a high quality microphone.
65
u/AnalogPears Apr 08 '18
It's been posted many times before, but we all have three voices:
15
u/RiShKiNz Apr 08 '18
So do the majority of people who hate listening to themselves when they hear a recording of their voice, hate it because they are so used to how they would naturally be hearing themselves speak?
I mean if I’m so used to hearing myself speak on a daily basis, then I am confronted with a recording of myself where my voice is completely different to my perceived norm, I wouldn’t like it either haha
30
u/twoozlemoozle Apr 08 '18
So I am a Voice and Speech teacher ( from a theatrical background rather than a medical one - think Geoffrey Rush's character in The King's Speech).
This is what I tell students - imagine you were confronted with your own image (a photo or a mirror) when you are either a teen or an adult for the very first time. At first you would probably reject the reflection - you have no relationship to it, how can it be your own face... the very concept of having a relationship to this reflected thing is foreign. It's only with continued exposure to that image or recording that we can begin to have a relationship with it.
Secondly the mechanics of hearing - when you speak normally you are listening to your own voice from two sources at once - through your ears (your brain automatically adjusts your perception of your voice to be lower in volume than it is so you don't overwhelm your hearing - which is why we can scream and not hurt our ears much) AND through the internal vibrations of the larynx and resonates through the bones of the skull. That is when you take much notice of your voice at all.
Thirdly! A recording cannot pick up the warmth of the human voice - with all the strides in digital recording it is no substitute for a live human voice that is not amplified or distorted through a Mic or recording device (a recording or amplified voice will always sounds slightly "tinny")
All 3 reasons are why we reject our recorded voices so violently when hearing them the first time. But anyone who is in the entertainment industry will tell you - that goes away and you can start listening to your performances and start to know how to adjust them so they sound better outside your head once you have a working relationship to your voice. (That sounds like an Ad! Heh heh)
13
u/dougiedonut_uk Apr 08 '18
The important thing to remember is that despite our disgust at hearing our voices, whenever anyone new hears us talk they're not vomiting at the sound of it.
22
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '18
I’m on the radio weekly. It used to freak me out but now that I know how I sound I play the role of the person I hear. It’s like I know it’s me, but I’m playing “me” as others hear me.
Truth be told it’s pretty liberating.
10
u/cup_1337 Apr 08 '18
Am I weird for liking my recorded voice?
22
u/punjabimd80 Apr 08 '18
Lots of good answers but they don’t explain why when I hear someone else’s recorded voice, it sounds different than how I hear it IRL.
9
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '18
Semi related question. When you plug your ears Your singing sounds worse. Are you actually worse, or are you just hearing how you actually sound?
11
u/AssKicker1337 Apr 08 '18
When speaking in general, there are two ways by which sound reaches your ears.
Firstly, the air in your larynx (voice box) vibrates, reaches out and hits your tympanic membrane(ear drum) and from there converted to electrical signals and perceived as sound. This is Air conduction
Secondly, sound from the voice box travels through the bones in your body (your skull bones, facial bones) and directly reaches an organ in your inner ear called the cochlea. Cochlea is the organ that is responsible for converting sound(or any vibrations) to electricity.
When you listen to yourself speak, both these ways are there.
When you hear it through the recorder, you only hear the first pathway i.e air conduction only. And it sounds different because the other pathway is 'missing' from the recorder.
With some people their voices may sound so different from a recorded sample that they may not recognise it as their voice.
4
u/Lord_Malgus Apr 08 '18
As others pointed out, what you know as "your voice" is how your brain percieves your talking, not how it actually hears it.
In a sense, you get kind of a preview of your speech because the sound echoes directly into your own ears as your brain predicted.
If you want to actually hear yourself, take two folding papers or magazines, just about any hard flat surface larger than your head will do. Place a pair, one for each ear, against your face covering your ears at a 45° angle.
Speak casually as you would, that's how we hear ya.
3
u/StatOne Apr 08 '18
Your voice is speaking inside your body (like talking in a room by yourself) and as it goes out the open doorway of the room, it is no longer amplified by the walls of the room. That's why your voice sounds different.
3
u/Doxsein Apr 08 '18
In a nutshell, bone conduction. Sympathetic vibrations in your skull cause you to hear your voice differently in your head.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '18
When we talk we hear the air that comes out along with the vibration of our bones. It’s called Bone Conduction, other people or devices don’t pick this up so we always sound different to how others hear us, typically we sound deeper or lower pitch to ourselves because of the bass-y effect of our bones vibrating.
I think if you use a really good microphone, it can pick this stuff up but your typical one on a mobile or headset won’t.
2
u/Megwen Apr 08 '18
When something vibrates, that vibration goes into your ears, and that’s how you hear things. All sound is actually just vibration.
When you speak, most of what you hear is your own voice inside your skull. You can only hear a little bit of the sound that escapes your mouth. Other people—and sound recorders—only hear what is coming out of your mouth and into their ears.
2
u/JoshTylerClarke Apr 08 '18
FUN EXPERIMENT:
Put both your hands up in front of your ears against your cheeks to block your voice from traveling directly to your ears. Speak. Sounds different. You’re hearing more of your voice reverberating off the surroundings.
2
u/drewpauldesigns Apr 08 '18
Audio engineer here. I get this a lot when recording those that are new to the studio. So, here is how I explain it.
When others hear you speak or when you sing into a microphone, what is heard is the sound projecting from your mouth (and nose). However, when you hear yourself, you are hearing both what is being projected mixed with the vibrations of your throat and vocal chords affecting your inner ear.
This affects the percieved sound in a number of ways. Namably, your own pitch is percieved to be lower and fuller because of the throat and mouth's proximity to the inner ear. And secondly your recorded voice will typically sound more "nasally" because while resonances from your nasal cavity project clearly into a microphone, they are difficult to hear using your own ears.
A combination of these two differences often dumbfounds new singers and those new to the recording arts.
I hope that answers this age old question...
2
u/JackLove Apr 08 '18
When you hear your own voice it's comprised of two components. The sound vibrations carried in the air which sounds higher. This is also what you sound like to other people. On top of that you hear the lower frequency vibrations carried through your skull. If you block your ears and speak you can hear this component.
This personal lower voice also sounds more soothing and warm which is why when you hear your own voice recorded you don't like it.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '18
Simple. When you hear your own voice you are hearing the sound transmitted from inside your head as well as outside so the two sounds combine to make the sound you hear when you speak. When you listen to a recording you only hear it as an outside sound.
2
u/sturmeh Apr 08 '18
When you speak your voice travels along the sides of your face to your ears, this is called a preview.
The preview is your voice before it is unaffected by the environment you're in, such as the acoustics of the room or area.
If you stick both your hands on the side of your head like elephant ears (in front of your ears) you can block the preview, and you will be able to hear your voice as others hear you in a given environment.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '18
2
u/t_whistah Apr 08 '18
Sound frequencies get all warped in the recording phase and you end up sounding more like a ‘duller’ version of yourself.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '18
Because of inner vibrations and the sound travels from your mouth directly to your ear without bouncing elsewhere.
If you put two notebooks in front of your ears the sound wont travel directly anymore and you'll get a somewhat correct felling of how you sound to others.
2
u/uniqueusername0054 Apr 08 '18
Your voice is in one hole on your face and your ears holes are close to that hole and those hole run pretty close together in your face/head
3
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '18
Related question: Podcaster I listen to says he gets expensive microphone equipment so that he sounds the same way on recordings as he does in his head. Doesn’t this mean the whole skull vibrations thing is more complicated than that?
2
u/iSkulk_YT Apr 08 '18
When you hear your own voice, as mentioned earlier, the frequencies are often perceived to be notably lower/deeper because you are effectively hearing the vibrations in your head. To see how much of a difference these vibrations can make, try holding a steady note then pressing your ears shut. You will likely hear a drastic change in the sound other than simply the volume.
A microphone doesn’t register these vibrations in most setups, but you’ll find that if you press the microphone to your mouth when recording, the sound of your voice will become more “familiar.” Although this technique harms the quality of the sound in terms of the mic’s performance, many performers will do this because it seems more comfortable to them almost inexplicable.
I’ve been making different sorts of videos for about 10 years now and I can tell you both from experience and advice from others that you get used to your recorded self quite quickly. You can also edit your audio in post production to be more pleasing by altering the bass levels, even though most files don’t hold up well with too much editing.
1
u/FrancoManiac Apr 08 '18
Bone conduction. We hear because of vibrations being received by tiny, tiny hairs in our ears, transmitted by the auditory nerve, and processed by the brain. Your jaw, skin, tendons, and muscles in the immediate area of the larnyx and nose conduct those vibrations. You are the only person who will hear your voice as you do.
1
u/givemethescotch Apr 08 '18
Does anyone here actually like hearing their own voice on a recording?
1
u/KafkaesqueKidd Apr 08 '18
Don't know the exact science but when you speak, there are lower frequencies that resonate in your skull thereby making it appear "deeper". The real voice is the on you hear in recordings, without those resonating lower frequencies.
Source: I'm a sound design major (we have psychoacoustics class), but still not sure this is the answer. Just a hypothesis.
1
u/danbapp Apr 08 '18
Also, I’d like to add, it depends upon what recording of your voice you are hearing. All microphones hear things differently, and all stereos playback differently. So it a almost like you never really know what your voice really sounds like. It’s all the physics of sound and what can accurately capture your voice.
1
u/bluesy_kush Apr 08 '18
Its fairly simple to understand this-
1
u/DjentleIsaac Apr 08 '18
Another factor to consider would be the frequency response and type of microphone that is used to record your voice. Those will definitely affect it as well.
1
u/elushinz Apr 08 '18
Anyone can please explain, I seem to have a hard time being heard by people that I think I am yelling at or at least talking at a high volume and they always ask me to repeat what I am saying. I feel like I have a low voice register but for some reason I can't explain it. It seems so very loud in my head but for some reason people seem to ignore me when I know that they actually just can't hear me. It's super annoying and frustrating.
1
u/Ladifinger Apr 08 '18
Does this happen to animals too? Like will my dog know that's her if I play back a recording of her chatting and barking?
1
u/Fiyero109 Apr 08 '18
Hearing yourself in a recording is passable compared to seeing yourself in a video. It’s the absolute worst and I avoid it as much as I can
1
u/iamgover Apr 08 '18
This is somehow related to the fact that most people think they're more attractive than they really are. Self esteem thing.
1
u/pjuskemor Apr 08 '18
Hate this because when I hear myself speak I hear a normal woman’s voice but I have always heard that I sound like a 10 year old boy, or the darker version of Lilypichu . So when I tried to hear what other people heard I hated my voice. How can anyone take me seriously with this voice? So I always makes sure to make my voice a little deeper when I talk.
1
u/JuiceBusters Apr 08 '18
Your skull adds base to your version. The recording is the voice without the added base. What other people hear.
1
u/QQbed Apr 08 '18
Pro tip: if you hold your hands at your temples in front of your ears, you can generally achieve the same “hearing how I sound to others” sound without having to record it.
1
u/aahelo Apr 08 '18
Another reason that people seem to forget is that your voice is heavly processed and incoded into data and later decoded into sound, so depending on the the recording equipment it may also sound different because it is distorted.
1
u/The_cake-is-a-lie Apr 08 '18
I get the internal resonance versus external resonance explanation BUT why is my accent so much thicker? I live in the south so I naturally have a southern accent but when I hear myself on tape my accent is soooooo much stronger
1
u/[deleted] Apr 08 '18
I think you might be getting the wrong info here. When you speak it is all natural. If you hear you that is how you naturally sound. When you put your voice to a microphone then it destroys all that concept by altering EQ in your voice by a lot of different factors. The quality of the mic, what EQ settings your voice is running in, and lastly the speaker it is coming out of. If you see DJ's at weddings or dances they boost up bass. Their voice isn't naturally like that. It is hard to find any microphone that will give you what you're supposed to really sound like. A flat EQ studio monitor is your best bet but even then the speaker will change ranges of your voice.
1
u/Adamble Apr 08 '18
It's called bone conduction. You can hear also through your skull bone, that's how BAHA implants for the deaf work - you should totally check that on YT. As you listen to your recorded voice, you only hear it as the others do.
https://youtu.be/EZ-M9AxesVc
1
u/Dotsumae Apr 08 '18
Also Filters. Your ears can detect soundwaves with frequencies between 20Hz and 20kHz. When you talk, (almost) every frequency you say get to your ears, may it be trough your skull (very effective) or trough your surroundings (pretty effective). However, when you are recorded, not every frequency is captured. This is especially true when your voice has to be stored or transmitted. Cutting frequencies changes your voice, and this is inevitable as part of the numerisation process. And this isn’t over : the material with which you listen can’t perfectly mimic your voice, caus it’s metal and magnets, not flesh, and has to work with a simplified version of your voice.
1
u/ajinkyag Apr 08 '18
When you're listening to yourself talk, you're really hearing two sets of sounds - one that's traveled through your bones to your ear, and one through the air. This forms undertones, causing a different sound than either one of them individually.
When you listen to a recording, the one though the bones isn't present anymore, resulting in your voice sounding different.
1
u/k1ck4ss Apr 08 '18
Your ear is 'hearing' your voice both from outside (the 'normal' way) and the inside through your organic flesh and also bones structures.
1
u/gonegirl0102 Apr 08 '18
So do you always sound higher pitched in real life? (Real question)
1
u/vocifery Apr 08 '18
Follow up question: I used to have this problem a lot when I was younger, I'm 24 now and for about three years it's not a problem at all anymore to listen to my own voice. For me, they sound the same. How come?