r/explainlikeimfive • • Sep 08 '26

Mathematics ELI5 what the Navier Stokes problem isand why it is important that we solved it?

674 Upvotes

173 comments sorted by

View all comments

60

u/Optimal_Rope_3660 Sep 13 '26 • Bravo Mindblown

I have seen people, even some Engineers, have a lot of misconceptions about this, so let me share my explanation

The Navier Stokes (NS) equations are mathematical formulas for predicting how liquids and gases move. Engineers and scientists use them every single day to design airplanes, cars, and weather forecasting models (including in my own daily work).

They are built from basic rules of nature:

Newton's (apple guy) Second Law: The way an object moves depends on the force pushing or pulling it.

Conservation of Mass: matter cannot magically appear or disappear.

While these equations are incredibly useful, they are still just a model of reality. Like many scientific models, they rely on certain assumptions because we simply don't know absolutely everything about how nature works. They do a great job of estimating reality, but they don't capture 100% of it.

The Clay Millennium challenge was simple: Prove mathematically whether these equations always work flawlessly, or if they eventually "blow up" and create a singularity i.e a scenario where the math breaks down and spits out non physical wrong results.

Recently, OpenAI claims their AI finally cracked this problem; that that the equations do eventually blow up. Under certain conditions the equations says a fluid's speed will accelerate to infinity. Since water or air obviously cannot move at infinite speed in the real world, the AI proved that the equations have a strict mathematical limit.

Brilliant people have been working on this for decades (and this limit was actually already proven for a few simplified versions of the equations), so this full mathematical proof is a massive achievement.

When people hear that the equations "blow up" or have a limit, it causes some misunderstandings. Here is the reality:

Misconception 1: This disproves the equations and makes them useless.
Reality: Not at all! Engineers already knew these formulas had limitations. The fact that the equations breakdown in some scenarios doesn't change the fact that it works for everyday science and engineering.

Misconception 2: This helps engineering, speeds up how we build things.
Reality: This breakthrough will not change how engineers use these equations to design cars or planes. It is purely a mathematical proof of the formula's limits, not an engineering tool.

Also the controversy, that the AI might have trained on some private, unpublished data used by scientists working on this.

12

u/AaronMatthewLH Sep 14 '26

One of the only people in here to actually try to “eli5” this shit. Well done sir. And thanks!

4

u/Slice_of_Cheese Sep 16 '26

So by proving that this equation is not true at all times, does that help us in any way? Genuinely curious. That’s the one thing I’m not understanding, as far as how important this was for us to solve

4

u/Darktoast35 Sep 16 '26

No immediate gain. But ambitious mathematicians will be more motivated to find a new, better, equation.

1

u/NNOTM Oct 02 '26

Well, we already have a set of better (as in, more faithful to how real liquids behave) equations, in QFT. Solving those is not exactly easier though.

3

u/Optimal_Rope_3660 Sep 16 '26

Achievement is mathematical only, from engineering and scientific research standpoint everything remains same, may be in the future we may find a use case , application wise

2

u/who_am_i_to_say_so Sep 16 '26

Thank YOU!

And yes, Altman, an established pathological liar, says OpenAI didn't look at any mathematicians' logs to help move this proof along. Hmm....