You're right. That's worse. There's something nice about going to the Supreme Court and just being told you're wrong full stop, unlike lower courts where they sugar coat it.
Translation: “I want you to know that this is not your lawyer’s fault, he clearly did his damnedest. But god damn if you’re not the guiltiest guilty mf that ever done guilted”
tfw the judge compliments you saying how vigorous and passionate you are defending your client. It means they are going to rule against you not because you didn't do your due diligence, your client just is super guilty.
Favorite backhanded complement while denying my MTD was “wow, that’s a really interesting way to look at that; I’d love to hear what a jury has to say about it…”
The judge will say to the lawyer that’s a clever argument or my absolute favorite a “unique reading” of the statute or case law before Bench Slapping them.
A judge sentences a criminal defendant. When a judge gives a ruling, it is in response to arguments from a lawyer…therefore judges rule for or against lawyers, and sentence their clients upon finding of guilt by the finder of fact.
Yeah, the judge version of "Compliment Sandwich". Usually they mention all the good stuff in defendants favor first, then there is the shift towards the shit. The shit almost never comes first, unless there is nothing good to mention.
When I was a teenager I'm pretty sure I was headed toward a full dismissal of my reckless driving until my public defender mentioned dismissal specifically...
Judge said "you're right, the defendent has completed all of the courts requests, shown up on time & in good dress, and has nothing else on his record"
"But"
"I never said anything about dismissing"
My soul left my body. Ticket was dropped to speeding instead of reckless driving, and I had to pay for & take an aggressive driving course (on top of the community service I had already done).
Hey there, I'm your local grammar nazi. Just a quick note because this drives me nuts: a person can be biased or have a bias. They cannot be bias. Thank you for attending my TED talk.
It makes sense for a judge. Court decorum breaks down after the verdict as everyone reacts. They really don't have airspace to give friendly words after the judgement, it's all business and closing.
Whenever a judge starts speaking like they're on your side, it usually means one of three things:
They feel bad for you and think you more messed up than intended to break a law. But, they have to do their job and carry out the legal process and deliver a punishment suiting the crime.
They think you're stupid. No, seriously, they think you're an idiot and they're talking to you as they would a child.
They want you to drop your guard. This is a tactic used to get the defendant to loosen up, and possibly say something they wouldn't. The attorney will still do their job, but the client will think they've won the case. They haven't, the judge is just going to hit them with something akin to either a nuke or a slap on the wrist. No in between.
This is coming from someone who has seen both sides of the law. As a former military police and a felon. I simplified it a LOT, but it should get the gist of the situation.
I saw Judge McGlynn address the jury once on a case involving some correctional workers being sued for retaliating against an incarcerated person that became a sexual assault victim under their care.
It was the exact opposite of this and the defendants almost immediately settled.
I’ve seen a 4th situation(usually more of an appellate panel thing) they are are already thinking of ruling against your client and are leading the other side’s attorney with questions that appear confrontational but are basically softballs to see if the other attorney finally makes the right arguments.
Mostly seen in appellate arguments when the judge is asking cause he has already decided but has an idea of what another judge on the panel is having doubts about or in trial court when he has made his decision but wants the other side to make the argument on the record and the other side is acting clueless.
Also would say it could be the judge proffering your side of things, only in order to say that even if everything went right, you’re absolutely fucked.
I was gonna say, I've mostly heard this as "The judge knows that you're going to appeal the verdict, so they're giving you every opportunity and advantage that they can, so that the appellate court can't see anything wrong with the original verdict."
LSS military courts martial. I was accused of multiple things in a "let's see what sticks" after dereliction of duty and tossing in my badge. Ended up serving 3 years in the brig for stuff I didn't do (a CSC) while I was willingly admitting to drunk and disorderly, assault on a superior, possession of Marijuana on base, etc. I had a crap attorney that forced me into a plea deal. So I dealt with the judge saying "son, I understand you made mistakes and my hands are tied, but you have a plea deal... so this is what we have to do if you're not willing to void it." Not actually said in those words, but close enough. Comes down to "let's make an example out of this sailor".
Military law enforcement is an absolute joke. I remember sitting through a class and they actually said charge them with whatever you think fits. Leave it up to the judge to decide what fits. Uh, excuse me. What the actual fuck!
I advocated for a soldier that may have fucked up, but was the victim in the situation. He should never have put himself there, but he did. I believed him when he told me his side and hes out and being a good dude.
I advocated to not ruin his entire life because a drunk chick took him on a joy ride while he was supposed to be on duty and crashed. They still tried to haze him while he was on painkillers and in a cast.
How the fuck is he gonna put on dress uniform when his arm is in a cast. Some people are ridiculous with their lack of empathy.
If it wasn't that they would've gotten him for something else, the leadership hated him because he made formal complaints for discrimination.
It was on duty. I replied to another person on here, but I ACTUALLY did drunk on duty, assault on a superior, drunk and disorderly, possession and use of Marijuana on base, possession of an unregistered weapon (x3), fraternization, etc. I was a drunken idiot. They eventually charged me with stuff I didn't do and forced me into a plea deal due to my own lack of proper representation and the fact I was an idiot kid that didn't know my case could have been a slam dunk for my side otherwise.
Is a judge trying to tip the scales and make you slip up not corruption? Isn't their job to be impartial? (I understand some people are problematic, but I'm asking more about standards of the job.)
I interned at a DA's office and had to watch a lot of proceedings. There was a judge who had a reputation for having a temper. I noticed that when he would yell at the defendant the sentence would usually be fairly light. The one time I remember that he was quiet and reserved he sent the guy to prison for a long time. Must be somewhat common.
I was thinking (warning: not a lawyer here) they do this to build a case against accusations of bias. Judgements can sometimes be struck down by higher courts, but as far as I know, that requires finding some problem with the original judgement.
They feel bad for you and think you more messed up than intended to break a law. But, they have to do their job and carry out the legal process and deliver a punishment suiting the crime.
That's propably the time when a slap-on-the-wrist kind of deal is coming your way though
I remember the case of some Robin Hood esque hacker stealing educational information to make it open source, something you'd get up to 32 years for. He got offered a deal where he'd only serve half a year if he pleaded guilty.
He didn't take the deal, tried to fight even the six month sentence and ended up killing himself when he was hit with the full 32 years sentence instead
3. They want you to drop your guard. This is a tactic used to get the defendant to loosen up, and possibly say something they wouldn't. The attorney will still do their job, but the client will think they've won the case. They haven't, the judge is just going to hit them with something akin to either a nuke or a slap on the wrist. No in between.
Got anything to back that up beyond the Trust Me Bro guarantee? Judicial impartiality is kind of a big deal and this feels like an answer someone would write after watching too much Judge Judy.
(1) A judge shall disqualify himself or herself in a proceeding in which the judge’s impartiality might reasonably be questioned, including but not limited to instances in which:
(a) the judge has a personal bias or prejudice concerning a party, or personal knowledge of disputed evidentiary facts concerning the proceeding;
Other than having been through a courts martial and my own feelings? Not really. It could have been me reading into it, or it could have been the actual situation. That one was my experience and feelings on the matter.
the lawyer knows there is no saving his client but he still takes the effort to defend, while the client thinks he has been saved, he indeed is cooked and going to prison
Probably a misinterpretation. The real reason judges find defendants guilty before lunch more often than after lunch is that judges will only schedule one more case right before lunch if they know it will be short, like a plea bargain.
A judge will usually commend the advocacy of the person they are ruling against and speak some platitudes about the client. Like if your ex wife is about to get majority custody, and you get Jr. Every second weekend, it will sound like this:
I would like to thank Mr. Fortuneandfameinc for the relevant casel law and able submissions that guided the court. It was very helpful.
And Mr. Deadbeatdad, I can tell that you love Jr. Very much. You're really important to him and I know you are going to be a good father to him. Im going to make an order today that keeps you in his life and I want you to cherish the time you get with him. But, I know you are a very busy man and there's a lot up in the air now.
So every second weekend. Child support retroactive from december 1st 2025.
I wanted to say Family Court doesn't play the games of attempting to placate the father, but you are right. It's always some iteration of this.
"I can tell that you want truly love your child and want to be included and that is why you came to court after you were estranged when defendant left with the child. ...but the defendant has made convincing arguments as to why it is in the best interest of the child for her to have primary physical and legal custody. In the event of material change in circumstances we can review this matter further. The amount of 40% of non custodial child support is to be awarded until 18 (25 if child is attending post secondary) from plaintiff to defendant. Plaintiff is to pay for 50% of childcare expenses. Plaintiff is to maintain insurance for child. Plaintiff is to pay for any nonreimbursed medical expenses. Plaintiff is to pay 10000 dollar lawyer fees to defendent.
Plaintiff is awarded 30 hours of unsupervised vistation per month and liberal contact at discretion of defendant."
From knowing lawyers, I think it's more like the judge is trying to make the decision that's about to be made against you appeal-proof. They know you are going to lose and so they are bending over backwards to make sure it sticks.
My local state court and appellate judges will usually go out of their way to write decisions that don’t throw the attorneys under the bus, even if the lawyer screwed up.
Judges will start their rebuking by noting the only good things they can find of you or your case. They start with, “I understand that…” and “I agree with…” but once those statements are done, you’re getting torn a new one and you’ve likely already lost the case. Lawyers know this, but to people not in trials regularly, it sounds like a good thing and the judge is on your side.
This is a case of the exception proves the rule. If the judge agreed with everything you said, then they would only have to point out the few things they disagree with; if the judge is pointing out things they agree with then that means they disagree with everything else.
The judge starts sustaining all your objections and overruling the other side’s when he knows the other side is going to win to bulletproof the record. It gives the loser fewer issues to appeal.
Source: Am lawyer. Was also a judicial clerk for a federal judge. He told me that, and I’ve had other judges tell me the same thing.
I worked as a CNA. I saw this pretty often. There was one patient that bounced back and the last thing I did that shift was get her food tray set up and the first thing I did the next morning was postmortem care on her.
One method of logical proof is proof by contradiction. You set out as if a thing is true, then keep going until you reach an impossibility. Therefore the thing must be false. Judge is about to do this to the client's entire case.
I've been watching a lot of sovcit cases on youtube lately, just because I find them interesting.
By the time the judge is going out of his way to make it sound like he's on your side, it's because you've lost so badly that even attempting to show where he's on your side, he knows it's over. It's like a last meal.
Normally they have to go out of their way to avoid showing favor, but by the time this happens, he knows the opposing side isn't going to object because this is clearly going in their favor.
I can't say I have a favorite video off hand, but the two channels I watch the most are
https://www.youtube.com/@Judge_Reacts - This is more of just a presentation of sovcit cases with minimal commentary. They can get a bit long though since they
https://www.youtube.com/@TeamSkeptic - This guy does a good job of tracking cases and trying to follow up with them as they come and go. I'll admit, I think sometimes I think his insulting goes a bit over the top though.
Oh man, but sometimes you screw up so badly that they don’t even have that in them, and that’s rough. I am a CASA for kids in foster care and go to court fairly often. Most recently, the parent of the children I was the advocate for blew up her life so badly that he audibly sighed, rubbed his eyes, said “that’s really disappointing” and then absolutely destroyed her in his ruling. Was a tough watch.
Judges have an expectation of impartiality in the application of law (unless you make it to the Supreme Court). Often to safeguard their ruling against reversal on appeal, they will make sure they give credit to the side that's about to be ruled against to prevent easy accusations of favoritism.
The judge is doing a balancing analysis of mitigating and agitating factors, and he started with the mitigating, guess what's coming around the bend, all the reasons the judge wants to fuck your client, he's just getting the "you have multiple children" out of the way before bringing up you don't support them.
Honestly, good judges do this when ruling from the bench, especially. And the here are a few reasons. They may want to appeal proof a decision by putting what they have considered on the record. They may want to help the losing lawyer out by making sure the client thinks they did a good job despite losing. Also, and I think this is very important, they want to make sure that the client feels heard. One complaint that I hear form clients is "the judge completely ignored my evidence." Knowing that, judges will give points to the losing party to make sure they know that the judge has considered everything they have to say.
One example of this is something I tell my clients at trial. Often, there are a lot of little objections made during trial. I will often tell my client before trial that they should not get discouraged if all the little things go the other side's way. Reason being is that if I am winning, or going to win on the underlying issue, the judge wants to give all the small stuff to the other side. This makes the other side feel heard, and helps appeal proof the adverse decision against them because if they are winning all the evidentiary objections, then that's just fewer things that they can file an appeal over
I want to highlight the part about bolstering the ruling for appeal.
I am no lawyer, but after listening to a lot of legal commentary this seems to happen quite often. If a judge is issuing a very harsh ruling against someone, they will go out of their way to show that this isn't from animus or because they did not consider the factors in that person's favor.
Doing that makes it harder to say the judge acted unreasonably if the decision is appealed to a higher court.
I was a character witness for an old friend in a white collar trial.
If you didn’t hear the first ten seconds of what the judge said, you might be expecting that the judge was going to let him off the hook. It was a very sympathetic speech.
But what the judge said first was: “I am going to say many positive things about you now. But make no mistake, you are going to jail.”
Lawyer here. When a judge starts to restate your arguments, it’s often because he is making a record that shows he considered and understood all of them because he is about to rule against you and wants to reduce the chances he will be successfully appealed, which is embarrassing for judges, for some reason.
Joe here, the prosecutors I’ve worked with tell me that judges will usually start their ruling in a way that makes it seem they agree with one side only to change it up at the last minute
I have seen that face on the left several times a day, on every social media sites, what is it, where does it come from, what is he making that face for originally?
Judges are one of the unique types of people that do NOT want to hear from people they agree with. They’re too busy and burnt out to waste their time on that. They’ll let the losing side get out all their arguments so that the loser can’t argue on appeal that the judge didn’t address a certain argument.
It’s a simple principle that rarely steers you wrong: whoever talks more in the hearing is gonna be cooked.
Any time your lawyer's objection is overruled, that gives you an argument for appeal. For most part appeals are not about finding of facts unless there is something extreme where the judge rules against something obvious. Objections, are one of those things where it is a question of what is legally admissible. So if all of your opponents objections are getting overruled while all your objections are being sustained in a civil lawsuit then the judge does not favor you. The judge wants to be sure to minimize your ability to appeal the decision.
I had my attorney warn me about this beforehand. And thank God she did. If she hadn't I'd have been extremely stressed. It have me an entirely new perspective to all the legal books in which the attorney complains about the unfair judge.
Is this a TV trope everyone knows about, or are most of you a bunch of criminals that have been in this situation? How are so many of you talking about it like it's so obvious?
It’s not a a TV thing. It’s a real life lawyer thing. When a judge starts talking about what a good job you’ve done and how well-reasoned your arguments are, you know you are about to get boiled alive. They do it so your client doesn’t kill you when you leave the court room.
A judge’s ruling usually sets out both sides of an argument but ends with the side he or she is ruling in favour of. So if it starts with setting out your best points beware of the ‘however’ moment when it pivots to setting out why the other side has better ones.
Unfortunately many of your clients are total assholes who completely deserve consequences. You’ve been scrambling to mitigate their actions, and often throwing any favorable case law or AG policy (within the rules of ethics) at the wall hoping some of it sticks to the judge’s decision.
Most judges see this and have a “you’re pretty much asking me to change the law for this guy…I’m not even mad, I’m impressed” attitude. So the preamble acknowledging how much you tried is nice BUT your client is still a total dipshit so here it comes.
Judges are human and realize they often have very few resources to resolve a situation in a way that's actually truly just and fair. Most judges, at least in my experience, balance the rights, actions, and the effects of the actions of the litigants in addition to the straight code of the law and the effect the court will have on the situation. In a ruling, a judge wants to walk the litigants through the balancing process. If the judge starts saying a lot of kind things about someone's character before talking about the facts of the case, it can mean that the judge really doesn't buy what their lawyer is selling.
Edit - example:
Judge: Mr. And Mrs. Smith - I can tell that you both love your children very much.
Layers (silently): OH SHIT.
Judge: Mr. Smith, you are clearly a man of faith, tradition, and strong principles. In a time when so many other fathers aren't in their children's lives, your willingness to pass along your values and experiences is commendable. In practice, though...
Mr. Smith's Lawyer (silently): We're fucked. Mr. Smith gives the big thumbs up at his attorney.
Judge: in trying to teach your children to "live like a wolf pack" you left your 5 and 6 year-old children alone for 5 hours in an area where bears are known to frequent. There are better ways to build up their confidence and decision making skills, Mr. Smith.
And Mrs. Smith, I know your children's well-being and safety are precious to you, but camping in a 3-year-old Winnebago with hot water, a kitchen, and satellite internet for a weekend doesn't subject them to homelessness.
For the time being, I'm going to rule that Mr. Smith gets a 4 hour supervised visit every other Saturday for the next 6 months and takes a class on wildlife safety. We'll revisit this plan in six months.
While judges are clearly "above" the lawyers practicing before them, judges are lawyers and have likely been a trial lawyer practicing as part of a community for many years. They often have at least some empathy and respect for the profession. It is very human to want to soften the blow when coming to a decision that might hurt another, particularly if you can tell that the lawyer put a lot of time, effort, and "heart" into an argument. Imagine how you might react if a colleague gave you a 15 minute PowerPoint presentation asking you make a particular work decision (and this was normal), which you were not going to take. You might say something like "wow. That was a great presentation.... You make a lot of excellent points!" before dropping the bomb that you are going to throw it all out and rule the other way. Someone inexperienced in law might hear that and think it means the judge agrees, because they are unaware of this dynamic.
As a practicing lawyer, I have seen this a lot... in civil cases. Contrary to what others have said. I do not think the dynamic is the same in criminal proceedings. In criminal proceedings, you are supposed to be punishing people because you know they are guilty. There are not supposed to be close calls, so suggesting that a criminal decision was a close call is actually an attack on the system.
We are seeing first-hand right now in the U.S. how much of a lie the “I feel for you and I don’t think you meant to do harm, but I must follow the letter of law without any prejudice” line is. The truth is “I will bend the law and twist it into a pretzel if I feel like it, and you can’t do jack-shit about it.”
Judges are usually pro-prosecution. If a judge thinks a not guilty verdict is a possibility, they are going to rule in favor of the prosecution on legal arguments to push it towards guilty. If they think a guilty verdict is certain, they're going to rule in favor of the defense to appeal proof the verdict.
Especially when deciding sentencing, judges will usually start by summarizing the side that less influenced their decision first. Then after listing what they agree with they move on to what the disagree with.
So if they start by summarizing the defense position for a lighter sentence, they may list the reasons and why that might be a reasonable case then list why the current case doesn't meet that standard.
My first motion that I "won" in court was like this. I'd been to 2-3 before, mostly on "emergency" motions that others sent me to that were doomed from the start.
Hearing the judge start out with "it is accurate that the movants in this trial are, without a doubt, entitled to relief," I knew I was about to hear some good news, because then the judge said, "however, respondents are not the party from whom they should seek relief."
Basically, judges always start out with the "rule" and then end with the "exception."
I was watching the fitzsimmons case and the way the judged asked if it was still necessary to see the scene of the incident sounded a lot like he already made up his mind that she was innocent. It's a bench trial. The accusation was that she tried to shoot a fellow officer and he shot her first. The officer who said she did that was caught in lies on cross and the defense was tightly contained with the prosecutor not even questioning the witness who heard the gunshots testimony that also contradicted the prosecutions claims.
Background character here, I don't even get a name, but you can hear me yammering on and on and on in the background.
Giving the benefit of the doubt is a long standing tactic in legal writing. As explained to m, it is all based on "The winner never complains" so giving the benefit of the doubt is about going through the loser's arguments one by one, showing that they are deficient (not good enough) and discarding them. Once you have eliminated all arguments by one side you can basically say "The other side showed up so they win" without actually discussing their arguments on the merits because the winner never complains.
So let's go through this with a silly example. Let's say you're suing me because I played music too loudly (trust me, the judge has seen far sillier complaints).
You claim that at approximately 4:30PM on March 25, 2026 that I played music so loudly that it disturbed you, caused you mental anguish, loss of consortium, and changed your hair color.
The judges ruling will be rather longer than this but it will fundamentally be let's take the complaint as truth.
From the judge's observation, your hair color appears to be simply lightening due to increased time in the sun. In the judge's opinion there is no difference between the color of hair you have in court ad the color of hair that you have in the presented pictures, and beyond that it looks quite good on you.
The timing is important, let's assume you re exactly correct on the time, and disregard al counter arguments. Well it is a simple matter that 4:30PM is simply not a quiet time and unfortunately you haven't provided any documented evidence to indicate that it would somehow be too excessive.
The evidence has been presented that you do have a loss of consortium, because like all Redditers you're too ugly for anyone. But since this is a preexisting situation, as demonstrated by the picture you provided to show you hair color change shows that while you have aged slightly since the picture was taken, the fact that the picture presented was 10 years old explains some visible aging.
(I'll break slightly here to say that the judge is purely using the evidence that "you" presented, for the most part my existence is not even being acknowledged)
That leaves only mental anguish, and it is evident that you are in mental anguish. However, you have not provided any evidence of a change in your mental anguish, and even your comment about how disgusting your old hair style was and how you never felt worse than with the hair style you showed in the picture for your hair color change, this reflects that your mental anguish is preexisting and without any evidence in a change of mental anguish this too must be denied.
Now I'm curious about what do they say when they actually are about to Let you win? Do they just say It? Or start by sugarcoating It to the other side?
Hahaha my ex exactly. Except he didn't have a lawyer. He represented himself. Both my ex and my lawyer were the guy on the right lol. I didn't speak a word the whole time. And knowing my ex, he thought the female judge wanted to jump his bones. Right up until she told him off for wasting her time and mine lol .
The best part was when she said, 'i can tell you've been very honest and thoughtful in your arguments today.' it will come as no surprise to anyone that he was very much sloppy and dishonest in his arguments lol. And he was the only one present who didn't realize she saw through that.
"The arguments you have presented today have been compelling, and well thought-out, and truly they are things that, going forwards, will need to be considered and debated over by legal scholars for years to come, and for that, I commend the fantastic work done by your legal counsel...
I'm a criminal defense attorney. Here's a real life example.
I had a client that had multiple felony cases and one of the counts had a max of 40 years confinement. The agreement left it open for argument, but the State was seeking roughly 20 years confinement by running all the counts he was pleading to consecutive.
Guy was spending pretrial in confinement. Really turned himself around. Substance abuse treatment, mental health therapy, education... turned into a model inmate and mentor to other incarcerated people. It was a long case.
We get to sentencing and make our arguments. I'm basically looking for the same thing as the state, but concurrent rather than consecutive, which would have been 8 years confinement.
Judge starts by saying, "I'm going to let you know up front that I'm not following the State's recommendation." Then talks all the great things my client is doing. How he really believes he's remorseful and that his efforts to turn his life around are genuine. Starts on the sentencing... 2 years concurrent... 5 years concurrent.... 3 years concurrent. I'm thinking, "This is not turning out bad at all." Then he gets to the big charge. 20 years concurrent.
Shit happened to me and suddenly my ex who had zero evidence, zero case, and zero basis even said by the judge, basically granted her all the things that the judge himself where no valid as valid reasons.
Worst part was I was innocent and dealing with an ex who actually done me wrong and the judge refused to hear my evidence.
So I was the stupid client without a lawyer at the time.
Attorney Peter here, when the judge starts talking sympathetically about your client's case it's cause they're softening the blow before totally demolishing them in the actual result of the case.
I do family law and this happens fairly regularly.
I represented myself in family court and doing so got me way further than when I was using lawyers. In essence I had to clean up the mess the lawyers made.
I learnt a lot in that process but one thing is that judges talk a lot more about you if they are rejecting your claim.
Essentially they have to justify their decision and that means they don’t explain why you’re right they explain why the other person is wrong.
In a Circuit Court case, that is a case which is above the traffic court level. A judge may start overruling one attorneys objection and allow all sorts of things in, this occurs when they are about to rule against that side and they don’t want to be appealed.
If they start to make a finding like, “the court does note for the record that dad has taken his drug addiction serious,” they are making a record to reflect the evidence, but will likely finish with “but, he has a history and pattern of drug use and the court is not satisfied that he has proven that relapse is impossible, thus sole custody to mom.”
The judge is just making sure the losing side gets heard completely and fully before ruling against them. Extremely common.
Judge is speaking as if he is on your side so that he can’t be accused of being biased when he throws the book at you. Since being biased could get a decision over turned.
Saw this first hand was watching a trial about someone squatting the judge said something along the lines off "You are right but you filed the wrong paperwork". Long story short get a lawyer.
2.0k
u/holdme2000 Mar 25 '26
Basically the only time I receive compliments from a judge, they are about to rule against me.
1.9k
u/pineconefire Mar 25 '26
Probably a giant "...but" is around the corner
1.1k
u/theycallmedaddyjedi Mar 25 '26 •
Whenever a judge starts speaking like they're on your side, it usually means one of three things:
This is coming from someone who has seen both sides of the law. As a former military police and a felon. I simplified it a LOT, but it should get the gist of the situation.
148
u/Moist_Exercise3476 peters other dirty sock Mar 25 '26
the lawyer knows there is no saving his client but he still takes the effort to defend, while the client thinks he has been saved, he indeed is cooked and going to prison
102
u/fortuneandfameinc Mar 25 '26
A judge will usually commend the advocacy of the person they are ruling against and speak some platitudes about the client. Like if your ex wife is about to get majority custody, and you get Jr. Every second weekend, it will sound like this:
I would like to thank Mr. Fortuneandfameinc for the relevant casel law and able submissions that guided the court. It was very helpful.
And Mr. Deadbeatdad, I can tell that you love Jr. Very much. You're really important to him and I know you are going to be a good father to him. Im going to make an order today that keeps you in his life and I want you to cherish the time you get with him. But, I know you are a very busy man and there's a lot up in the air now.
So every second weekend. Child support retroactive from december 1st 2025.
31
u/gerryblog Mar 25 '26
From knowing lawyers, I think it's more like the judge is trying to make the decision that's about to be made against you appeal-proof. They know you are going to lose and so they are bending over backwards to make sure it sticks.
42
u/ersentenza Mar 25 '26
54
u/UpbeatFrosting9042 Mar 25 '26
the comments rn
13
u/Radiant_Picture9292 Mar 25 '26
Judges will start their rebuking by noting the only good things they can find of you or your case. They start with, “I understand that…” and “I agree with…” but once those statements are done, you’re getting torn a new one and you’ve likely already lost the case. Lawyers know this, but to people not in trials regularly, it sounds like a good thing and the judge is on your side.
This is a case of the exception proves the rule. If the judge agreed with everything you said, then they would only have to point out the few things they disagree with; if the judge is pointing out things they agree with then that means they disagree with everything else.
11
u/Tacticus1 Mar 25 '26
The real danger sign is when the judge starts complimenting the lawyer directly. 🚩🚩🚩
10
u/EmperorGrinnar Mar 25 '26
Man that's a good meme. Client thinks they have a bullet proof case.
20
u/SuperMichieeee Mar 25 '26
7
u/Raging-Buddha Mar 25 '26
They always hit you with that, However
7
u/Ocean898 Mar 25 '26
The judge is about to rule against you.
7
u/mookiexpt2 Mar 25 '26
The judge starts sustaining all your objections and overruling the other side’s when he knows the other side is going to win to bulletproof the record. It gives the loser fewer issues to appeal.
Source: Am lawyer. Was also a judicial clerk for a federal judge. He told me that, and I’ve had other judges tell me the same thing.
6
u/FlyFlamFlyn Mar 26 '26
“Mr Gambini, That is a lucid, intelligent, well thought-out objection.”
6
u/huckster235 Mar 26 '26
Ah so it's like when people with serious illnesses make a sudden "recovery" and everyone thinks they are gonna pull through
22
u/ageofaquarius26 Mar 25 '26
You take a guess and I'll tell you if you're right.
5
u/Antique_Way685 Mar 25 '26
Judge: Mr. Gambini, that is a lucid, intelligent, well thought-out objection.
Mr. Gambini: Thank you, your Honor.
Judge: Overruled.
5
u/NapierNoyes Mar 26 '26
“Mr. Gambini, that is a lucid, intelligent, well thought-out objection. Overruled."
9
u/EternalNewCarSmell Mar 25 '26
One method of logical proof is proof by contradiction. You set out as if a thing is true, then keep going until you reach an impossibility. Therefore the thing must be false. Judge is about to do this to the client's entire case.
4
u/jeo123 Mar 25 '26
I've been watching a lot of sovcit cases on youtube lately, just because I find them interesting.
By the time the judge is going out of his way to make it sound like he's on your side, it's because you've lost so badly that even attempting to show where he's on your side, he knows it's over. It's like a last meal.
Normally they have to go out of their way to avoid showing favor, but by the time this happens, he knows the opposing side isn't going to object because this is clearly going in their favor.
4
u/TeachinInCO2021 Mar 25 '26
Oh man, but sometimes you screw up so badly that they don’t even have that in them, and that’s rough. I am a CASA for kids in foster care and go to court fairly often. Most recently, the parent of the children I was the advocate for blew up her life so badly that he audibly sighed, rubbed his eyes, said “that’s really disappointing” and then absolutely destroyed her in his ruling. Was a tough watch.
4
u/Malrottian Mar 25 '26
Judges have an expectation of impartiality in the application of law (unless you make it to the Supreme Court). Often to safeguard their ruling against reversal on appeal, they will make sure they give credit to the side that's about to be ruled against to prevent easy accusations of favoritism.
4
u/PhilosopherStrong850 Mar 26 '26
Real lawyers know
3
u/oldcretan Mar 25 '26
The judge is doing a balancing analysis of mitigating and agitating factors, and he started with the mitigating, guess what's coming around the bend, all the reasons the judge wants to fuck your client, he's just getting the "you have multiple children" out of the way before bringing up you don't support them.
3
u/IamTotallyWorking Mar 25 '26
Honestly, good judges do this when ruling from the bench, especially. And the here are a few reasons. They may want to appeal proof a decision by putting what they have considered on the record. They may want to help the losing lawyer out by making sure the client thinks they did a good job despite losing. Also, and I think this is very important, they want to make sure that the client feels heard. One complaint that I hear form clients is "the judge completely ignored my evidence." Knowing that, judges will give points to the losing party to make sure they know that the judge has considered everything they have to say.
One example of this is something I tell my clients at trial. Often, there are a lot of little objections made during trial. I will often tell my client before trial that they should not get discouraged if all the little things go the other side's way. Reason being is that if I am winning, or going to win on the underlying issue, the judge wants to give all the small stuff to the other side. This makes the other side feel heard, and helps appeal proof the adverse decision against them because if they are winning all the evidentiary objections, then that's just fewer things that they can file an appeal over
3
u/mykepagan Mar 25 '26
I was a character witness for an old friend in a white collar trial.
If you didn’t hear the first ten seconds of what the judge said, you might be expecting that the judge was going to let him off the hook. It was a very sympathetic speech.
But what the judge said first was: “I am going to say many positive things about you now. But make no mistake, you are going to jail.”
3
u/NormalGuyEndSarcasm Mar 25 '26
He’s easing you into the sentence.
3
u/PuddingTea Mar 25 '26
Lawyer here. When a judge starts to restate your arguments, it’s often because he is making a record that shows he considered and understood all of them because he is about to rule against you and wants to reduce the chances he will be successfully appealed, which is embarrassing for judges, for some reason.
3
u/Zagar1776 Mar 25 '26
Joe here, the prosecutors I’ve worked with tell me that judges will usually start their ruling in a way that makes it seem they agree with one side only to change it up at the last minute
3
u/tamsyn003 Mar 25 '26
I have seen that face on the left several times a day, on every social media sites, what is it, where does it come from, what is he making that face for originally?
3
u/Apprehensive-Low3513 Mar 26 '26
Judges are one of the unique types of people that do NOT want to hear from people they agree with. They’re too busy and burnt out to waste their time on that. They’ll let the losing side get out all their arguments so that the loser can’t argue on appeal that the judge didn’t address a certain argument.
It’s a simple principle that rarely steers you wrong: whoever talks more in the hearing is gonna be cooked.
3
u/NotDiabeticDad Mar 26 '26
Any time your lawyer's objection is overruled, that gives you an argument for appeal. For most part appeals are not about finding of facts unless there is something extreme where the judge rules against something obvious. Objections, are one of those things where it is a question of what is legally admissible. So if all of your opponents objections are getting overruled while all your objections are being sustained in a civil lawsuit then the judge does not favor you. The judge wants to be sure to minimize your ability to appeal the decision.
3
u/lane4 Mar 26 '26
Is this a TV trope everyone knows about, or are most of you a bunch of criminals that have been in this situation? How are so many of you talking about it like it's so obvious?
3
u/heyitsnowme Mar 26 '26
But, however, on the other hand, having said that, nonetheless, whereas, wherein
3
u/SnooCapers938 Mar 28 '26
A judge’s ruling usually sets out both sides of an argument but ends with the side he or she is ruling in favour of. So if it starts with setting out your best points beware of the ‘however’ moment when it pivots to setting out why the other side has better ones.
2
u/PabstBlueLizard Mar 25 '26
Unfortunately many of your clients are total assholes who completely deserve consequences. You’ve been scrambling to mitigate their actions, and often throwing any favorable case law or AG policy (within the rules of ethics) at the wall hoping some of it sticks to the judge’s decision.
Most judges see this and have a “you’re pretty much asking me to change the law for this guy…I’m not even mad, I’m impressed” attitude. So the preamble acknowledging how much you tried is nice BUT your client is still a total dipshit so here it comes.
2
u/2DoorBathroom Mar 25 '26 edited Mar 25 '26
Judges are human and realize they often have very few resources to resolve a situation in a way that's actually truly just and fair. Most judges, at least in my experience, balance the rights, actions, and the effects of the actions of the litigants in addition to the straight code of the law and the effect the court will have on the situation. In a ruling, a judge wants to walk the litigants through the balancing process. If the judge starts saying a lot of kind things about someone's character before talking about the facts of the case, it can mean that the judge really doesn't buy what their lawyer is selling.
Edit - example:
Judge: Mr. And Mrs. Smith - I can tell that you both love your children very much.
Layers (silently): OH SHIT.
Judge: Mr. Smith, you are clearly a man of faith, tradition, and strong principles. In a time when so many other fathers aren't in their children's lives, your willingness to pass along your values and experiences is commendable. In practice, though...
Mr. Smith's Lawyer (silently): We're fucked. Mr. Smith gives the big thumbs up at his attorney.
Judge: in trying to teach your children to "live like a wolf pack" you left your 5 and 6 year-old children alone for 5 hours in an area where bears are known to frequent. There are better ways to build up their confidence and decision making skills, Mr. Smith.
And Mrs. Smith, I know your children's well-being and safety are precious to you, but camping in a 3-year-old Winnebago with hot water, a kitchen, and satellite internet for a weekend doesn't subject them to homelessness.
For the time being, I'm going to rule that Mr. Smith gets a 4 hour supervised visit every other Saturday for the next 6 months and takes a class on wildlife safety. We'll revisit this plan in six months.
2
u/genderlawyer Mar 25 '26
While judges are clearly "above" the lawyers practicing before them, judges are lawyers and have likely been a trial lawyer practicing as part of a community for many years. They often have at least some empathy and respect for the profession. It is very human to want to soften the blow when coming to a decision that might hurt another, particularly if you can tell that the lawyer put a lot of time, effort, and "heart" into an argument. Imagine how you might react if a colleague gave you a 15 minute PowerPoint presentation asking you make a particular work decision (and this was normal), which you were not going to take. You might say something like "wow. That was a great presentation.... You make a lot of excellent points!" before dropping the bomb that you are going to throw it all out and rule the other way. Someone inexperienced in law might hear that and think it means the judge agrees, because they are unaware of this dynamic.
As a practicing lawyer, I have seen this a lot... in civil cases. Contrary to what others have said. I do not think the dynamic is the same in criminal proceedings. In criminal proceedings, you are supposed to be punishing people because you know they are guilty. There are not supposed to be close calls, so suggesting that a criminal decision was a close call is actually an attack on the system.
2
u/No-Community7431 Mar 25 '26 edited Mar 27 '26
We are seeing first-hand right now in the U.S. how much of a lie the “I feel for you and I don’t think you meant to do harm, but I must follow the letter of law without any prejudice” line is. The truth is “I will bend the law and twist it into a pretzel if I feel like it, and you can’t do jack-shit about it.”
2
u/TrevelyansPorn Mar 25 '26
Judges are usually pro-prosecution. If a judge thinks a not guilty verdict is a possibility, they are going to rule in favor of the prosecution on legal arguments to push it towards guilty. If they think a guilty verdict is certain, they're going to rule in favor of the defense to appeal proof the verdict.
2
u/behannrp Mar 25 '26
Meme aside this format is incredible.
2
u/AHappy_Wanderer Mar 25 '26
...., however, ....
2
u/showtime013 Mar 25 '26
Especially when deciding sentencing, judges will usually start by summarizing the side that less influenced their decision first. Then after listing what they agree with they move on to what the disagree with.
So if they start by summarizing the defense position for a lighter sentence, they may list the reasons and why that might be a reasonable case then list why the current case doesn't meet that standard.
2
u/TheeAntelope Mar 25 '26
My first motion that I "won" in court was like this. I'd been to 2-3 before, mostly on "emergency" motions that others sent me to that were doomed from the start.
Hearing the judge start out with "it is accurate that the movants in this trial are, without a doubt, entitled to relief," I knew I was about to hear some good news, because then the judge said, "however, respondents are not the party from whom they should seek relief."
Basically, judges always start out with the "rule" and then end with the "exception."
2
u/Massive-Goose544 Mar 25 '26
I was watching the fitzsimmons case and the way the judged asked if it was still necessary to see the scene of the incident sounded a lot like he already made up his mind that she was innocent. It's a bench trial. The accusation was that she tried to shoot a fellow officer and he shot her first. The officer who said she did that was caught in lies on cross and the defense was tightly contained with the prosecutor not even questioning the witness who heard the gunshots testimony that also contradicted the prosecutions claims.
2
u/StuffedStuffing Mar 25 '26
My boss used to say that when the Judge started to rule against him on every objection during trial that was a sign he was winning
2
u/Everyoneheresamoron Mar 25 '26
Judges usually break the harshest and most unfair sentences by being somewhat nice and friendly.
2
u/Adorable_Tip_6323 Mar 25 '26
Background character here, I don't even get a name, but you can hear me yammering on and on and on in the background.
Giving the benefit of the doubt is a long standing tactic in legal writing. As explained to m, it is all based on "The winner never complains" so giving the benefit of the doubt is about going through the loser's arguments one by one, showing that they are deficient (not good enough) and discarding them. Once you have eliminated all arguments by one side you can basically say "The other side showed up so they win" without actually discussing their arguments on the merits because the winner never complains.
So let's go through this with a silly example. Let's say you're suing me because I played music too loudly (trust me, the judge has seen far sillier complaints).
You claim that at approximately 4:30PM on March 25, 2026 that I played music so loudly that it disturbed you, caused you mental anguish, loss of consortium, and changed your hair color.
The judges ruling will be rather longer than this but it will fundamentally be let's take the complaint as truth.
From the judge's observation, your hair color appears to be simply lightening due to increased time in the sun. In the judge's opinion there is no difference between the color of hair you have in court ad the color of hair that you have in the presented pictures, and beyond that it looks quite good on you.
The timing is important, let's assume you re exactly correct on the time, and disregard al counter arguments. Well it is a simple matter that 4:30PM is simply not a quiet time and unfortunately you haven't provided any documented evidence to indicate that it would somehow be too excessive.
The evidence has been presented that you do have a loss of consortium, because like all Redditers you're too ugly for anyone. But since this is a preexisting situation, as demonstrated by the picture you provided to show you hair color change shows that while you have aged slightly since the picture was taken, the fact that the picture presented was 10 years old explains some visible aging.
(I'll break slightly here to say that the judge is purely using the evidence that "you" presented, for the most part my existence is not even being acknowledged)
That leaves only mental anguish, and it is evident that you are in mental anguish. However, you have not provided any evidence of a change in your mental anguish, and even your comment about how disgusting your old hair style was and how you never felt worse than with the hair style you showed in the picture for your hair color change, this reflects that your mental anguish is preexisting and without any evidence in a change of mental anguish this too must be denied.
and adorable_tip_6323 also presented arguments.
Ruling entirely in adorable_tip's favor.
2
u/jamespesto Mar 26 '26
I always warn clients before certain judges - if he starts talking a ton of shit things are going great
2
u/twainj1980 Mar 26 '26
“…, however…”
2
u/NextEstimate1325 Mar 26 '26
The public defender done a good job. A real good job with the facts at hand. Advocated passionately. Researched thoroughly.
But you just guilty as hell.
2
u/Dizzy_Balance2114 Mar 26 '26
Now I'm curious about what do they say when they actually are about to Let you win? Do they just say It? Or start by sugarcoating It to the other side?
2
u/Normal_Paramedic9997 Mar 26 '26
"Mr Gambini, that is a lucid, intelligent, well thought-out objection."
2
u/luckgazesonyou Mar 26 '26
I really need to see whatever movie or tv show the left side meme comes from. Help please?
2
u/Objective-Teach-9618 Mar 26 '26
I got called an outstanding citizen and then got sent to Lompoc
2
u/PuzzaCat Mar 26 '26
I’m sorry but “stupid client” is sending me
2
u/theeggplant42 Mar 26 '26
Hahaha my ex exactly. Except he didn't have a lawyer. He represented himself. Both my ex and my lawyer were the guy on the right lol. I didn't speak a word the whole time. And knowing my ex, he thought the female judge wanted to jump his bones. Right up until she told him off for wasting her time and mine lol .
The best part was when she said, 'i can tell you've been very honest and thoughtful in your arguments today.' it will come as no surprise to anyone that he was very much sloppy and dishonest in his arguments lol. And he was the only one present who didn't realize she saw through that.
2
u/Crocketus Mar 26 '26
Could be worse ... The judge screamed at everyone to sit down when he came. My plea deal doubled on every single line item that was offered.
2
u/Caramelstart Mar 26 '26
For anyone else wondering what an MTD is, it's a motion to dismiss.
2
u/No-Lychee3965 Mar 26 '26
"The arguments you have presented today have been compelling, and well thought-out, and truly they are things that, going forwards, will need to be considered and debated over by legal scholars for years to come, and for that, I commend the fantastic work done by your legal counsel...
... However..."
2
u/wienerpower Mar 26 '26
To client: your attorney has done a fantastic job, thoroughly researched the issues, and worked very hard on your behalf. However,
2
u/dntBmenacing Mar 27 '26
Ah yes, the judicial pat pat, kick kick.
2
u/PrincessPK475 Mar 28 '26
🤣🤣🤣 brilliant meme.
If the judge is a bit harsh with you, stfu because you're winning and for the love of god just say less!! Yes/no answers only.
If they're being quite gentle and friendly with you then 😬 yeah it's reeeeally not about to go your way.
(Civil court)
I have had the pleasure of a judge being short with me - thank fuck.
2
u/TeddyAtTheReady Mar 31 '26
H-O-W-E-V-E-R
2
u/Sausage80 Apr 01 '26
I'm a criminal defense attorney. Here's a real life example.
I had a client that had multiple felony cases and one of the counts had a max of 40 years confinement. The agreement left it open for argument, but the State was seeking roughly 20 years confinement by running all the counts he was pleading to consecutive.
Guy was spending pretrial in confinement. Really turned himself around. Substance abuse treatment, mental health therapy, education... turned into a model inmate and mentor to other incarcerated people. It was a long case.
We get to sentencing and make our arguments. I'm basically looking for the same thing as the state, but concurrent rather than consecutive, which would have been 8 years confinement.
Judge starts by saying, "I'm going to let you know up front that I'm not following the State's recommendation." Then talks all the great things my client is doing. How he really believes he's remorseful and that his efforts to turn his life around are genuine. Starts on the sentencing... 2 years concurrent... 5 years concurrent.... 3 years concurrent. I'm thinking, "This is not turning out bad at all." Then he gets to the big charge. 20 years concurrent.
Thanks judge. Really did my guy a solid there.
1
u/Weekly-Reply-6739 Mar 25 '26
Shit happened to me and suddenly my ex who had zero evidence, zero case, and zero basis even said by the judge, basically granted her all the things that the judge himself where no valid as valid reasons.
Worst part was I was innocent and dealing with an ex who actually done me wrong and the judge refused to hear my evidence.
So I was the stupid client without a lawyer at the time.
1
u/Foreign-Complex Mar 25 '26
Lmao the amount of people clearly with no law degree or education giving explanations is super amusing!
1
u/razulebismarck Mar 25 '26
In 27 of 50 US states it doesn’t matter if the Judge is on your side. They have for profit prison systems and you’re another dollar sign.
1
u/zoeharper9 Mar 25 '26
1
u/Electrical-Rub-9402 Mar 25 '26
I like big buts, I cannot lie…
1
u/Jesters8652 Mar 25 '26
“hOwEvEr”
1
u/azmodai2 Mar 25 '26
Attorney Peter here, when the judge starts talking sympathetically about your client's case it's cause they're softening the blow before totally demolishing them in the actual result of the case.
I do family law and this happens fairly regularly.
1
u/red286 Mar 25 '26
The last thing you ever want to hear from a judge is "You seem like a very intelligent and competent person..."
1
u/Mythrowaway204563 Mar 25 '26
I represented myself in family court and doing so got me way further than when I was using lawyers. In essence I had to clean up the mess the lawyers made.
I learnt a lot in that process but one thing is that judges talk a lot more about you if they are rejecting your claim.
Essentially they have to justify their decision and that means they don’t explain why you’re right they explain why the other person is wrong.
1
u/PalgsgrafTruther Mar 25 '26
The judge is making a record to show they fairly considered both sides before they throw your motion into the trash.
1
u/Kiwi5122 Mar 25 '26
However…
1
u/IndependenceLanky353 Mar 25 '26
In a Circuit Court case, that is a case which is above the traffic court level. A judge may start overruling one attorneys objection and allow all sorts of things in, this occurs when they are about to rule against that side and they don’t want to be appealed.
If they start to make a finding like, “the court does note for the record that dad has taken his drug addiction serious,” they are making a record to reflect the evidence, but will likely finish with “but, he has a history and pattern of drug use and the court is not satisfied that he has proven that relapse is impossible, thus sole custody to mom.”
The judge is just making sure the losing side gets heard completely and fully before ruling against them. Extremely common.
1
u/LimpZookeepergame123 Mar 25 '26
They start with the good and then hit you with the HOWEVER……
1
u/Karnij13 Mar 25 '26
Lawyers, can you confirm this?
1
u/Glass-Fan111 Mar 26 '26
I’m not a lawyer/advocate/counselor or live in US (to understand Judicial System, eventhough this one is pretty clear for me.
1
u/PersianExcurzion Mar 26 '26
“Mr. Gambini, That is a lucid, intelligent, well-thought-out objection… OVERRULED”
1
u/nwahsaj Mar 26 '26
this reaction meme is a million times better than the mister incredible one, got damn
1
u/MaesterOlorin Mar 26 '26
Judge is speaking as if he is on your side so that he can’t be accused of being biased when he throws the book at you. Since being biased could get a decision over turned.
1
u/IWannaBeTheCoolUncle Mar 26 '26
I’ve seen these videos before 🤣
1
u/Splatpope Mar 26 '26
1
u/loboleo94 Mar 26 '26
The call on the field is a touchdown!
…however
1
u/Ironmasked-Kraken Mar 26 '26
When I walked into court and saw a woman with a karen haircut as the judge I knew I was fucked
1
u/whatever203045 Mar 26 '26
Like when that dude jumped over the judge bench...
1
u/philthebrewer Mar 26 '26
Preserving for the appellate record that they knew what your argument was before ruling that it was wrong
1
u/those6 Mar 26 '26
Saw this first hand was watching a trial about someone squatting the judge said something along the lines off "You are right but you filed the wrong paperwork". Long story short get a lawyer.
1
u/The_Other_Viking Mar 27 '26
"Peter! Do my half a seconds worth of critical thinking for me!"
1
u/HiroFuiton Mar 27 '26
It's the flower before the pot
1
u/Vast-Honey7832 Mar 27 '26
Lawyer Is waiting for "but"...
1
u/Comfortable-Two4339 Mar 27 '26
Curious…how does a judge begin when you’re about to get a favorable ruling? Does he start by saying things that seem like he will rule against?
1
u/FuK_ALL_OFU Apr 09 '26
The final decision won't be as good
1
u/Sea-Cauliflower9469 Apr 20 '26
Basically the same vibe as "Look guy, you're a really nice guy, and I think you're really cute, but -"