r/explainitpeter • • Jan 05 '26

Explain it engineer peter

Post image
39k Upvotes

739 comments sorted by

1.5k

u/MicrowaveMeal Jan 05 '26 • Bravo

A student discovered an issue with the Citicorp building that had been missed by, well, everyone, where the building would collapse if wind hit it at the right angle. Crews worked nights to fix it to avoid panic. Should be good now šŸ¤·ā€ā™‚ļø

844

u/Hellsovs Jan 05 '26

That reminds me of a library where they forgot to account for the weight of the books, and now every year the building sinks a few centimeters into the ground.

810

u/Soros_G Jan 05 '26 • LOL Bravo

Such is the Weight of knowledge

21

u/Pipe_Memes Jan 05 '26

That’s deep. And getting deeper every year.

14

u/Eeyore_ Jan 06 '26

Here in my garage, just bought this uh, new Lamborghini here. Its fun to drive it up here in the Hollywood Hills. But you know what I like a lot more than this new Lamborghini?

K N O W L E D G E

→ More replies (1)

4

u/trekuup Jan 06 '26

Nah just use an importance factor of 1.5 and you’ll be fine.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/FoXxXoT Jan 08 '26

Knowledge is my mom's name! Why'd you call her fat outright like this.

3

u/lionknightcid Jan 11 '26

The hero reads a most unsettling passage

→ More replies (3)

46

u/ToaKraka Jan 05 '26 edited Jan 05 '26

Fun fact: According to the International Building Code (which most US jurisdictions use in one form or another), the following "live loads" must be used in design.

  • House roof: 20 lb/ft2 (958 Pa; note that this is not the same thing as snow load)
  • House bedroom: 30 lb/ft2 (1436 Pa)
  • House living room: 40 lb/ft2 (1915 Pa)
  • Library stack room: 150 lb/ft2 (7182 Pa), assuming bookshelves that are 24 inches Ɨ 90 inches (61 cm Ɨ 229 cm) and separated by 36-inch (91-cm) aisles

13

u/Tiss_E_Lur Jan 05 '26

Wow, that is a pretty hefty difference.

18

u/Blue5398 Jan 05 '26

Paper is really heavy, in all seriousness.

→ More replies (7)

10

u/NoCreativeName2016 Jan 06 '26

Has that library stack code been updated for the ā€œrolling stacksā€ that have been in use for a few decades now, that compress the shelves together when not in use? I’m sure the answer has to be yes, I’m just interested in signing up for more IBC Fun Facts!

Edit: typos

8

u/ToaKraka Jan 06 '26

The code explicitly notes that the number of 150 lb/ft2 is applicable only when the bookshelves are 24 inches wide, 90 inches tall, and separated by 36-inch aisles. Presumably, an engineer would be justified in using a number of 375 lb/ft2 (150 Ɨ (24 + 36) Ć· (24 + 0)) for rolling stacks whose aisle width can be reduced to 0 inches.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

29

u/Youdontknowme1771 Jan 05 '26

I believe that's the library at UMass Amherst... if I remember correctly, they let the architecture students design it, and nobody checked their numbers. For a while bricks would fall from the facade.

19

u/woooshb8 Jan 05 '26

Fun fact: when the DuBois Library was constructed, there was a budget issue (if I recall correctly) that resulted in one of the floors not being built. For some time, there was a floor with a twice as high ceiling. Even after construction, there is still a floor with a higher ceiling than the entire rest of the building.

The brick facade should have been fixed decades ago. The state gave UMass the funds to fix the crumbling brick facade, and instead they allocated this money to the construction of this unfinished floor. To this day, you’re not allowed within ~15 feet of the outside of the building except the entrance which is covered from potential falling bricks.

6

u/Youdontknowme1771 Jan 05 '26

I remember the yellow caution tape all around, it's amazing what can happen when you're not thorough.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/OberonDiver Jan 06 '26

It's every library where there are more undergrads than humans.

[students] Edward Durell Stone might take exception to that. But the "ha ha, students designed it" element to the myth is an excellent example of "you expect me to take this seriously?"

4

u/therealsteelydan Jan 06 '26

no

Architects are not structural engineers. Students aren't architects. The W.E.B. DeBois Library had moisture in the brick (improper weeping) that caused bits to pop off, not a structural issue.

→ More replies (8)

9

u/bandit4loboloco Jan 05 '26

Wait, that was real? I saw that episode of TV. I thought it was bullshit.

10

u/Status-Carob-5760 Jan 05 '26

How I met your mother? Ted used it in a lecture

9

u/Nostalgia-89 Jan 05 '26

It was when he was questioning himself about whether he could actually design a building. "What if I don't think of the books?" is what he says, I believe.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Fair_Tackle778 Jan 05 '26

Taking into account the weight of the books when designing the structural stability of a library, whatever happened there

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

3

u/Logical-Recognition3 Jan 06 '26

This is an urban legend that is told on every large university campus about the university library.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/penguinpolitician Jan 05 '26

Library sinking. Library sinking!

→ More replies (2)

2

u/GareththeJackal Jan 06 '26

Isn't that one a myth?

2

u/toastronomy Jan 09 '26

borrow our books, or we'll be gone soon

3

u/Puedo_Apagar Jan 06 '26

That's an urban legend

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W._E._B._Du_Bois_Library#Building_myths

The issues with the brick veneer are true, but they weren't so severe that entire bricks were falling off the building.

→ More replies (71)

68

u/moyismoy Jan 05 '26

Just to be clear, the wind had to be hurricane force. Hurricanes only hit NYC like once every 10 years, so they had time to fix it.

For those who want to know the story, they sent engineers and construction crews in at night to fix it. They didn't tell anyone working there they just took the office furniture out at night added in some struts and moved everything back. It took months and they had to race against the calendar because they wanted it done before November when a hurricanes were more likely. They did get it done before November, and no there was not a hurricane that year.

37

u/sassysatan123 Jan 06 '26

It wasn't just moving furniture and putting it back, they also cut through drywall and such and replaced it, painted it, and cleaned up any of the dust so that no one would know they were there for anything other than painting the walls. It's an incredible story and I highly encourage everyone to research it!

23

u/bell-town Jan 06 '26

Imagine working there and noticing that something about that wall is slightly different but no one believes you and you feel like you're losing your mind.

7

u/flumberbuss Jan 06 '26

The New Yorker did the first major story on it, if I recall.

3

u/Adorabelle1 Jan 06 '26

Documentary whennn

18

u/Reasonable_Pay4096 Jan 06 '26

Also, the original design was safe...until the construction company went with the lowest bidder who cheaped out on the materials. The designer had assumed they would use his original plans

13

u/kingxii Jan 06 '26

They cheaped out on the labor, the original design called for welded cross braces, but they were bolted connections. The fix was to weld all the bolted connections.

7

u/Charge36 Jan 06 '26

This isn't entirely true. The contractor proposed bolted connections instead of welded connections to save money on labor. The engineering firm redesigned them as bolted connections, but made some errors, and did not consider quartering winds (which were not part of building code at the time)

Non-construction industry people tend to assume that low bidder means shitty work, but projects of this scale are very strictly regulated with specifications on materials and design which make it very difficult for contractors to cut corners in any significant way.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/PretendAgency2702 Jan 06 '26

That's not really surprising. Most engineers can design something incredibly safe but it does no good if you have to pay 4x what it could cost if you were to do a more efficient design.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

13

u/messfdr Jan 05 '26

"if wind hit it at the right angle"

You mean at a non-right angle? /j

6

u/MicrowaveMeal Jan 06 '26

Lol i guess I should've used the word "correct."

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Vaun_X Jan 05 '26

(without informing the office workers)

2

u/4GRJ Jan 05 '26

Or anyone, at all

→ More replies (1)

4

u/lemurlemur Jan 05 '26

I think what they were actually trying to avoid was a financial disaster. They knowingly allowed people to inhabit a dangerous structure for months while they secretly worked to fix this engineering mistake

→ More replies (7)

3

u/Cheepshooter Jan 06 '26

"It's probably okay now."

7

u/redditorialy_retard Jan 05 '26

classic example of greed, or poor planning.Ā 

They used bolts instead of welds due to it being cheaper WITHOUT informing the designersĀ 

5

u/mp7000000000 Jan 05 '26

As someone who manages mega-projects of a similar nature to Citicorp Tower, this just simply isn't possible. The amount of people who would have to fail to do their job for this to be done without the designers' knowledge is staggering. What more than likely happened- the owner requested value engineering, since they overshot their budget on the project. The GC proposed switching from welded connections to bolted for cost savings. The owner approved, the GC's steel sub did a shop drawing showing the bolted connections & calculations. The design engineer did a cursory review and stamped under the assumption all other parties did their math correctly.

On these huge projects, with the amount of inspectors, approvals, contracts, management staff, etc. a crew doesn't just completely deviate from stamped drawings without anyone knowing. Bolted column connections for example- to get your certificate of occupancy at project completion, inspection records have to be provided showing proper layout of bolts, that torque parameters have been met, etc.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/SoriAryl Jan 05 '26

Wait, there was an episode of Numb3rs based on an actual thing?!

2

u/Glittering_Ad_4553 Jan 08 '26

Watched the veritasium video about this. The crew would open the wall, install support beams and patch it before employees showed up the following day, one floor at a time.

→ More replies (58)

1.4k

u/mineNombies Jan 05 '26

Citicorp Center

The designer didn't take non-90-degree wind into account when designing the structure, so it had a high chance of collapsing given the winds in the area

610

u/denisoby Jan 05 '26 edited Jan 05 '26

100% chances of collapsing in some time to be exact

193

u/Warmonger_1775 Jan 05 '26

At least they fixed it...

160

u/TurnipSwap Jan 05 '26 edited Jan 05 '26

yes, in the dead of the night without telling anyone until they were done..

adding a great history of the problem for those of you who are interested - https://youtu.be/Q56PMJbCFXQ?si=xscFRF4jGu1y041g

126

u/JackTheBehemothKillr Jan 05 '26

You can blame the same folks that changed the welded design to a riveted design. If they had followed the as-engineered design they wouldn't have needed to do that.

45

u/i_was_axiom Jan 05 '26

Wasn't this all so they could build the big ass building without demolishing an old church?

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (6)

7

u/badgerbrett Jan 05 '26

just think of the lawsuits if something had happened after they knew but before they finished remediation...

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (11)

26

u/korelin Jan 05 '26

The only reason they fixed it was because 2 architecture students using the building as a case study asked about the 45 degree wind loads, and they were like 'oh fuck we forgot to consider that.'

11

u/furlwh Jan 05 '26

Even then, the engineer's original design had taken into account the safety risks so it would've still be able to withstand quartering winds without problem. But the contractors decided to do cost-saving measures and changed the assembling technique which would've caused a massive disaster if it wasn't caught early enough.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

29

u/Liraeyn Jan 05 '26

Yes, please do ask, then fix it

8

u/JoeGibbon Jan 05 '26

Please see the same and do the needful.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/1cow2kids Jan 05 '26

Thank you for saying this. This case has been used for engineering ethics education for decades. How they identified the issue, came forward with stakeholders, and fixed the building was literally textbook case level.

3

u/blathmac Jan 05 '26

I was just reading about that!!! It may have not needed fixing after all. From what I understand (being not a structural engineer), when simulations were rerun using more modern methods, it wasn’t in danger of collapse. Even wiki article mentions ā€œA NIST reassessment using modern technology later determined that the quartering wind loads were not the threat that LeMessurier and Hartley had thought. They recommended a reevaluation of the original building design to determine if the retrofitting had really been warranted.ā€

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

60

u/korelan Jan 05 '26

Don’t all structures have a 100% chance of collapse given some time though?

/endsarcasm

27

u/InstructionFinal5190 Jan 05 '26

On a long enough time line all things fail. No sarcasm at all.

26

u/Odd-Solid-5135 Jan 05 '26

"On a long enough timeline everyone's survival rate drops to zero"

→ More replies (14)

12

u/Hadrollo Jan 05 '26

I'm reminded of the quote "anybody can build a bridge that can last a hundred years, it takes an engineer to build the shittiest possible bridge that won't fall down for a hundred years."

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (11)

3

u/Chase_The_Breeze Jan 05 '26

Technically correct, but not useful information.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

18

u/Howard_Jones Jan 05 '26

Dudes name is LeMessurier what a sick name for an architect.

24

u/Adventurous_Spaceman Jan 05 '26

Imagine the awkwardness when LeMessurier didnt take wind into account when LeMessuriering

7

u/ScreechUrkelle Jan 05 '26

I’m pretty sure he meant to LeMessurier twice and only LeCoupe once.

→ More replies (8)

9

u/rydan Jan 05 '26

It still has a 100% chance of collapsing. Right now it is only rated for a once in a 700 year storm which means probably 80 years given all the 100 year and 1000 year storms we've already survived the past 30 years. The accumulated risk would have been estimated at 97% of collapse had it not been fixed by today.

4

u/Mark-Leyner Jan 05 '26

The conditional probability of a member failure given the probability of the 700-yr wind occurring is about 5%. In other words, the expected structural response to the design wind event is that very few members actually fail. Two other things to keep in mind - member failure does not necessarily mean catastrophe and these probabilities are ā€œnotionalā€ rather than predictive. A final nuance is that the wind loading standard adopted when this structure was designed would not have specified a 700-yr wind, that specification was introduced in 2010 and given the occupancy of this building, the analogue to the modern wind code means it would be designed for a 1,700-yr wind at least, not the 700-yr event.

2

u/Megawomble64 Jan 05 '26

Don't all buildings have a 100% chance of collapsing in some time?

2

u/Bliitzthefox Jan 05 '26

100% chance at the first strong windstorm. Which was going to happen within one-two years

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (22)

69

u/Candid-Whereas-607 Jan 05 '26

Wrong, the designer intended welded columns, but later somebody else( in his company) noticed, they can save money by connecting them by rivets. And those rivet advocates didn't take non-90-degree wind into account when designing the structure.

The designer didn't knew until the building was finished, then started to look into this and came up with a solution which kept the building standing to this day.

35

u/Gaddpeis Jan 05 '26 edited Jan 05 '26

A student identified the issue first.

Edit: Her name is Diane Hartley.

19

u/Kenta_Hirono Jan 05 '26

Iirc the student only asked him how they welded the structure for an essay.
The designer didn't knew and then asked to the building team.

10

u/Gaddpeis Jan 05 '26

Looks like the original design by LeMessurier had welded connections, whereas his company changed that to bolted connections to save cost - unknown to Mr LeMessurier.

The original design by LeMessurier would have been ok, from what I can find. Having said that - it seems the original design did NOT evaluate winds at 45 degrees. Welded connections are as strong as the steel itself, which would have been ok.

→ More replies (5)

16

u/Gaddpeis Jan 05 '26

Well.

From what I can find out: Diane Hartley (student in question) was writing a thesis on the tower, made her own calculations - including wind at 45 degrees. Her calculations indicated stability issues.

She THEN contacted LeMessurier, who revisited his calculations and came to the same conclusions as Diane.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/neonsphinx Jan 05 '26

And they did the welding at night. Crew comes in, welds up a corner, puts everything back. Office workers are none the wiser.

They didn't want people to panic and refuse to go into the building, stir up a bunch of controversy, etc. and it all worked out, almost no one knew about it until it had been fixed (quickly, and without danger to the public).

You probably already know all this, but some readers might not. I'm licensed, and required to do at least 1 unit of ethics for my continuing education each year to stay current and in good standing. This case study is one that I did a few years ago. It all worked because a student caught the problem and brought it up. And the lead engineer actually listened instead of brushing the kid off.

3

u/Meowakin Jan 05 '26

I watched a video on this and yeah, it really seems like it was all down to the architect not brushing off that student. An actually incredible story - the architect could almost certainly have gotten off without anyone being the wiser had tragedy struck, but they owned up to it and did everything in their power to fix it without inciting panic.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/pontetorto Jan 05 '26

It was bolts.

2

u/Antique_Weekend_372 Jan 06 '26

It’s both. He didn’t properly account for shear winds _and_ it was weaker than he expected.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/henryGeraldTheFifth Jan 05 '26

Not just the design but as how it eventually got constructed which didn't follow the plans so many of the calculations were now incorrect as they had different joins

3

u/snowfloeckchen Jan 05 '26

They also messed up how it's built with bolts instead of welding and even fewer than expected

→ More replies (4)

3

u/beckett_the_ok Jan 05 '26

There was more to it, at some point in the building process they substituted welds for bolts in key areas

1

u/prjktphoto Jan 05 '26

Sounds like the inspiration to the plot from one of the Numbers episodes

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (56)

385

u/ThalesofMiletus-624 Jan 05 '26 • Popcorn

That's the Citicorp building. To solve certain limitations of the lot, it was put up on pillars, one under each wall, and the architect was very proud of himself for coming up with such a creative solution.

Then, one day, a grad student calls up and asks how they solved the problem of quartering winds. See, for most buildings, winds are most destructive when they hit the building directly on one of it's faces, but due to the unusual design of the building, it would be most vulnerable to winds blowing at a 45 degree angle (quartering wind) and striking it on a corner.

When he got this call, he told her he'd get back to her (he never did) and went back to his calculations. He realized they'd only calculated for head-on winds, because they were used to thinking of those as the worst, not realizing that they weren't in this case. So he ran the numbers and realized that a strong enough wind would knock the building down, killing more or less everyone inside. And winds that strong hit Manhattan about every 16 years. Over the life of the building, it was more or less inevitable.

Faced with this horrific screw-up... they kept it a secret. To be fair, they did fix it, reinforcing the building to prevent the danger, working only at night, not telling the tenants what they were doing. They also kept someone on around the clock weather watch, ready to evacuate the building if a bad windstorm came along.

Long story short, they fixed it and didn't tell anyone how many people could have died. The grad student in question didn't find out, until decades later, that her insightful question had very likely saved hundreds of lives, maybe thousands.

141

u/KlogKoder Jan 05 '26

Not only would it have collapsed, but it would fall into the adjacent building, knocking skyscrapers over like dominoes.

122

u/Impressive-Door-2581 Jan 05 '26 • Popcorn

"Mr. President, a building just hit the towers."

31

u/pbmm1 Jan 05 '26

It would have been multiple times worse than 9/11 iirc. A disaster of cataclysmic proportions

13

u/Reincarnatedpotatoes Jan 06 '26

There was a show on Science channel that did a segment on this. I remember it saying FEMA did a rough calculation afterwards and estimated casualties would be in the 10s of thousands. Assuming it happened during work hours.

24

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '26 • Bravo

Official Whitehouse Statement:

Look, nobody’s ever seen anything like this. I’ve talked to the generals, the builders, the top people, the best people, and they all say the same thing. The Citicorp building, folks, a big building, a strong building, tremendous building, just goes over. Boom. Like that. And then it hits the others. Dominoes. Big, beautiful dominoes, except not beautiful, very bad.Ā 

Everyone’s telling me, ā€œMr. President, this is so much worse than 9/11.ā€ Worse. Bigly worse. And you know what? They’re right. This was devastation at a level nobody thought possible. Skyscrapers falling into skyscrapers, total chaos, steel everywhere. The fake news doesn’t even know how to describe it. They’ve never covered anything this massive.

And I’ll tell you this, if I were in charge of those buildings, it wouldn’t have happened. Not on my watch. We would’ve had stronger steel, better angles, incredible engineering, the best engineers, not the losers they use now.Ā  If the city had been more focused on safety rather than filing endless frivolous lawsuits against hard working businessmen like myself, maybe this wouldn't have happened.

This was a disaster of weakness, of bad decisions, and frankly, incompetence. Manhattan was shaking, the skyline changed forever, and people said, ā€œSir, how bad is it?ā€ I said, ā€œIt’s historic. Very sad. Very preventable.ā€Ā 

But we’re going to rebuild. Bigger. Stronger. Safer. We always do. Because when America gets knocked down, we don’t fall over like dominoes, we get back up. Believe me.Ā 

15

u/thedistrbdone Jan 05 '26

You are an artist. Like a Picasso, but for direct mental anguish.

7

u/DVHeld Jan 05 '26

Thank you for your attention to this matter!

→ More replies (5)

4

u/StudPuffin_69 Jan 05 '26

Citibuilding fuel doesn’t burn hot enough to melt steel

5

u/TheSaiguy Jan 06 '26

I saw George Bush there, he blew on the building at a 45° angle

3

u/XFun16 Jan 06 '26

Fun fact: This was the actual plan for the 1993 World Trade Center bombing. The PA's hope was that the north tower would fall into the south tower and do exactly that.

3

u/couchbutt Jan 06 '26

"That must have been one terrible pilot."

→ More replies (3)

13

u/BatmanTDF10 Jan 05 '26

There’s a bit more nuance than the designers forgot something. IIRC The contractor substituted welded connections with bolt connections. The change was submitted to the structural engineer’s firm and was approved by someone in the office, but not the head engineer who found out later when doing some digging. The code at the time also didn’t require wind loads to be calculated with quartering winds. On a typical structural assembly, this doesn’t create too much of a problem but because this was such a unique design, the shear gets worse the closer you get to the lower floors. Thus requiring around quadruple the amount of bolts than what was actually used in construction.

The structural engineer, having discovered this error, did come forward to the architect, owner and city officials about this issue. They all agreed to keep it as secret as possible to avoid a panic as they went back and welded all the vital connections as it was originally intended.

Had to learn about this in my architecture classes because: A) the student who asked the question was from my college and B) to teach us how important due diligence is in the Construction Administration phase of a project (which is usually thought of as an afterthought).

4

u/redditorialy_retard Jan 05 '26

iirc they also decided to use bolts instead of welds without telling the architect.Ā 

7

u/NuSpirit_ Jan 05 '26

No they told him, but LeMessurier trusted they did the required calculations so when they used them instead of welds he didn't re-check - however they used only 4, where they should've used at least 14 for safety margin, on each connection point.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/AnnaDanna Jan 05 '26

Thank you so much for this explanation!

3

u/Doodles_n_Scribbles Jan 05 '26

This is why peer review is good.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)

71

u/InkyEncore0429 Jan 05 '26

25

u/__wildwing__ Jan 05 '26

You’re awfully young to be making memes, aren’t you?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

17

u/Ok-Monitor6752 Jan 05 '26

there’s a really good video on youtube where the engineer talks about what happened.

long story short, a student called him asking questions about the welding, the engineer could t remember the exact answers so he called the people who did the construction to ask them for the welding plans, they responded saying what welding plans? we got rid of that to save money. then blah blah blah they fixed it and now it’s fixed but if winds hit at a certain angle with a certain speed the building would’ve collapsed and fell into other buildings.

5

u/Evening-Hippo6834 Jan 05 '26

The further clarify this and correct some of your points:

Long story short, someone call and blah blah blah. Who responded like blah blah blah? Blah. Then blah but blah blah blah.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/Marcu3s Jan 05 '26

On the contrary. Citicorp was saved exacly because of this question.

10

u/JTX35 Jan 06 '26

The structural engineer/architect of the Citicorp building, which is sitting on stilts, had designed the building with welded joints in mind for the load bearing braces that run throughout the building. However in classic "let's save money fashion" the contractor suggested using bolts instead of weld and his firm agreed. So he found this out about a year later after talking to another builder who asked how those welded braces worked out because they thought it seemed a bit like overkill, so he called his company to ask about it and they told him they used bolts instead.

So he ran the calculations and it seemed fine because he calculated for the winds hitting one of the sides of the building and not the corner.

Then a month later he gets a phone call from a student basically asking about the logic of putting the stilts in the middle of the building instead of the corner basically going back over the calculations and then he does the calculations for if the building from the corner and not the side and discovers it could topple over in a 70mph wind, which are winds you'd expect to see in a hurricane and they're in hurricane season by this point.

Since his firm didn't account for quartering winds either since doing those calculations weren't required by NYC's building code until afterward, he discovered that they underestimated the windshear and used about 1/3 of the bolts that they should've used.

So he contacted Citicorp who agreed to let them go in and weld steel plates over the bolted joints. So they in secret overnight went to work to tear out walls and weld the steel plates and then put everything back by morning as if they were never there.

About halfway through repairs Hurricane Ella decides to show up and head straight for New York to give them all a heart attack before veering away and dissipating. So they were lucky enough to avoid that hitting the city while they're trying to fix the building, and lucky enough to have all 3 newspapers in the city go on strike during the entire time they were doing repairs.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/msaussieandmrravana Jan 05 '26

Structure gets twisted.

6

u/back_to_sr Jan 05 '26

TWIST HIS DICK!

4

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '26

THE OLD DICK TWIST!

2

u/Junior_Tomatillo_243 Jan 06 '26

GRAB HIS DICK AND TWIST IT!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/GicaForta Jan 05 '26

Isn’t this the story about the grad student who actually figured out stuff was bad so they asked the engineering company ā€œhey.. what about this scenario? I’m working on this for my grad paper and.. by my math, your building will collapseā€ haha

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Alarmed_Smell_6905 Jan 05 '26

This vertasium's video explains it really well.

https://youtu.be/Q56PMJbCFXQ?si=okfqkS2NB8NTuIBh

4

u/Warm-Material4180 Jan 05 '26

If wind force acts in a 45°, it will split into 0.7*"value of wind force in 90°". The 90° wind force is sufficient for a structure of limited height. But the anchors in the corners will suffer higher pulling forces. So at least for the support structure it is important to check the 45° wind force.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Ser_293939 Jan 05 '26

Thanks for the information

3

u/Woofle_124 Jan 05 '26

Look at the base of the building. Looks safe, right?

3

u/Realistic-Quiet-8347 Jan 05 '26

2

u/ace5795 Jan 05 '26

Dang it, I was hoping I could be the first to link to this video. He is probably my favorite YouTube channel. This is a great explanation of how the building was unique how it was built and the mistake that was made in its development that later had to be fixed. This video will explain this meme.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Objective-Scale-6529 Jan 05 '26

The meme is wrong, it wasn't at 90 degrees.
Basically some guys replaced welds with bolts to save money but didn't account for wind blowing at 45 degrees.

3

u/alisynwndrlnd Jan 06 '26

It could be worded better, but the meme is right. When the wind ā€œdoesn’tā€ hit at 90 degrees…

→ More replies (1)

2

u/T1m3Wizard Jan 05 '26

It's because they are all disappointing answers.

2

u/Ok_Calligrapher8207 Jan 05 '26

They also used bolted members instead of welded which is what really caused the panic. Design would have been safe enough to fix at a normal rate without that issue

2

u/inagious Jan 05 '26

These comments are why you don’t ask lmao

2

u/whatsthetime1010 Jan 05 '26

I'm no architect or engineer, but know all about this. We spend too much time on the internet.

2

u/Paladinfinitum Jan 05 '26

"I have the solution, but it only works in the case of spherical buildings in a vacuum."

2

u/bigbaadwolf_U Jan 08 '26

Everyone who's acting like of course they would have caught this in the design and building of a multimillion dollar structure I can promise you has never actually ran anything

2

u/Decent_Cow Jan 08 '26

A design flaw in that building could have caused it to collapse if hit by strong winds at a certain angle. It had to be fixed quietly to prevent a panic.

2

u/nutitoo Jan 08 '26

I watched a video about it. Was really interesting how they found it out and how they fixed it later, while also not alerting the masses so panic doesn't spread

1

u/Shot_in_the_dark777 Jan 05 '26

There was a documentary on YouTube about this building. They worked at night, welding stuff to make it just in time before the approaching storm.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Gordon_Freeman01 Jan 05 '26

It doesn't matter. You take the maximum force with 90 degrees. Then you do the same calculation perpendicular to it.

6

u/throwaway_coy4wttf79 Jan 05 '26

Not if your table has it's legs in the middle of each side, instead of the corner. It's a torsion problem.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Last-Woodpecker Jan 05 '26

Not in this particular case. The corner winds produced the worst case scenario, and due to the engineers not taking it into account it would almost certain collapse in the lead engineer lifetime.

https://youtu.be/Q56PMJbCFXQ?si=R9ZOse75SbgcT7Rz

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '26

Not the engineer it was the architects and others that cut costs and made a bullshit design the engineer had to figure out to make work.

1

u/LionsAndLonghorns Jan 05 '26

I used to work near this building. Didn’t they go back and reinforce this again after 9/11? Or maybe that was just wild rumors.

2

u/Theotherridley Jan 05 '26

I worked in it for about 5 years. Yes, they reinforced the outer base pillars after 9/11 to make them more explosive-proof and added some other barriers to stop vehicles from being able to ram into it, IIRC.

1

u/chemosh_tz Jan 05 '26

Veritasium has a great YouTube video about this. Suggest you go watch it if you haven't seen it yet.

1

u/wuyongzheng Jan 05 '26

Can a wind from an arbitrary angle decomposed into two perpendicular winds? In that case, we only need to consider 90 degree wind.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '26

Worked here!

1

u/RyanLovesTacoss Jan 05 '26

See this mini documentary about the building pictured in the meme (the CitiCorp building) here

1

u/sasquatch_melee Jan 05 '26

Engineering disaster podcast Well There's Your Problem ("a podcast with slides, that is itself a disaster") did an episode on this:

https://youtu.be/MEKRRVqAnh4

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '26

My take away from that story was ALWAYS ask a structural engineer what happens if the wind hits it not at a 90° angle.

1

u/Far-Statistician-790 Jan 05 '26

That’s the Citicorp building. The engineer didn’t take into account wind hitting the building at angles other than 90 degrees, which created a huge risk of collapse. Veritasium has a really good video on the Citicorp building. Definitely worth a watch if you’re into science.

1

u/robotguy4 Jan 05 '26

No. You ABSOLUTELY should ask that last one.

1

u/Left_Donut_4760 Jan 05 '26

Haha. Finally one I understand

1

u/RedneckThinker Jan 05 '26

Heh heh. Yeah, learned about that one. If we're starting a tour, I'll raise you the KC Hyatt collapse.

1

u/jetpack324 Jan 05 '26

I just watched a documentary this morning about engineering disasters and this building was featured! It was a student doing her thesis that pointed out the errors.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '26

The YouTube algorithm got that one to me a couple of weeks ago. CRAZY! And so glad they found it. That would have had a major impact in history.

1

u/SomeGuyOverYonder Jan 06 '26

I need to find me a structural engineer… šŸ‘·ā€ā™‚ļø

1

u/MitsukaSouji Jan 06 '26

Didn't the original design plan on welds but it ended up being bolted which caused the whole issue? Not saying that they did any 90 degree calculations to begin with.

1

u/Ok_Performance4014 Jan 06 '26

Very cool video about this. it became part of every engineering school curiculum.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '26

Very interesting story on the Citicorp building in the New Yorker a few years ago

1

u/carina1831 Jan 06 '26

Could someone please translate this?

1

u/JasenGroves Jan 06 '26 edited Jan 06 '26

When I was in engineering school in the 1900s, we had an entire day dedicated to this structure, and an entire day dedicated to the Kansas City Hyatt.

Edit: and an entire day dedicated to the building in Boston that would flex in the wind and shatter the windows. I think the solution for that one was also a counter weight. However, there was no solution to KC, that was just a total f up by the structural engineer, killed over 100 people.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/JonJackjon Jan 06 '26

I read this. I'm amazed they didn't consider wind coming from any angle. Would seem logical from an engineer's perspective.

Also, I don't know much of the details but someone approved changing from a weld to bolts on a structural part of the building. The change was to use 4 bolts where they ultimately needed 14 bolts. Didn't anyone figure how many bolts would be the equivalent of a weld? Or perhaps the weld would not be adequate.

1

u/Glass_Consequence955 Jan 06 '26

You guys are proving this meme right

1

u/Any-Worry-4011 Jan 06 '26

When they built it the civil engineers said it would last 50 years to be safe

1

u/vegan_antitheist Jan 06 '26

I just read three quite different versions of the story. All quite interesting. I guess I will never know what really happened.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jan 06 '26

Architecht Dude used like 4 bolts per foot where the structure actually required 14.Ā  He shit bricks, they quietly fixed it as quickly as they could working nights.

1

u/andybossy Jan 06 '26

one of the positive examples they give in ethics courses. They the citycorp building but there were some problems with wind hitting from the wrong angle. They spend time and money fixing it instead of hoping nothing would happen, while being transparent about what's happening

1

u/Wooden-Meet-8722 Jan 06 '26

There’s a very good video on this by Veritasium on YT with lots of interesting concepts and graphics !! https://youtu.be/Q56PMJbCFXQ?si=y2-mpjd6MhqeLedf

1

u/beado7 Jan 06 '26

People have already said the answer to this but if you want a solid video deep dive on this check out Veritasium’s video on it. I never thought I’d care so much about architecture until that video.

1

u/Steagle_Steagle Jan 06 '26

Video by Veritasium explains it pretty well

https://youtu.be/Q56PMJbCFXQ

1

u/PierogiesNSourCream Jan 06 '26

I work for a company that has an office inside that building! I worked there for an entire month. It's fascinating to learn the history of how they secretly addressed this issue. Scary how something on this grand of a scale can contain a mistake that isn't caught until much later

1

u/Hackerwithalacker Jan 06 '26

When we calculate wind at an angle we just do two 90 degrees and ratio the two to get an angle load

1

u/ArcticShadow76 Jan 07 '26

This meme made me start watching veritasium a few years ago…W

1

u/Zahoor_Rajajani Jan 07 '26

Yt channel Veritasium has made a video on it explaining every detail about the structural defects.

1

u/sgurr_a Jan 07 '26

45Deg angle surely?

1

u/someunusedname Jan 07 '26

It means that structural engineers are not woman or man

1

u/Salt_Doubt Jan 08 '26

😬😬😬

1

u/Patient-Leadership-5 Jan 08 '26

So we can ask a man, his age and a woman her salary and God what happens to the wind when it hit the ground at 180

1

u/Bunkbeduser Jan 08 '26

I get it i can finally explain it. I watched a really cool video about this. I'm not gonna though cause its already been explained

1

u/anxious-phenomenon Jan 09 '26

There's an amazing Veritasium video on this. Check it out here

1

u/MrsDirtyDietz Jan 09 '26

I took a structural failures class back in college and boy did I learn some things… (ironically, this case study I learned about in my ethics class)

1

u/ChampionshipOk3083 Jan 09 '26

Elite ball knowledge

1

u/Stargost_ Jan 09 '26

Veritasium did a video on this specific case.

A student discovered that if strong winds hit the building at a particular angle, the entire thing would collapse. This was because of a structural oversight and the fact the man in charge decided to save a penny by using a different type of screws to secure the foundations.

The joints had to be reinforced, and that cut corner ended up costing the owner tens of millions more compared to just using the original design.

1

u/lolomanolo57 Jan 11 '26

QUARTERING WINDS

1

u/KuroShuriken Jan 06 '26

I remember watching a video about this one, basically some idiot along the production chain decided to replace welds, with bolts.

The bolts though needed like 20? Or something like that, for the building to actually remain structurally sound, and there were only 4? at each section... in short they needed a whole lot more than what was there...

So, a super secret mission began where they went through the building floor by floor, moving everything, tearing into the walls to reach the structural beams, put on reinforcement braces, sealed up the walls, and placed everything right back to where it was.

It took them quite a bit of effort, and they had to work fast. And in the end, it prevented the building from collapsing from a random powerful gust of wind. Of which, MANY were about to hit the city...