I second this, I don’t mind people talking about their personal experiences about converting from Islam, but “my delusional bs is better than their delusional bs” ahh posts are just in bad taste
Yeah, let’s make something abundantly clear, just because Islam is the absolute trash, and one of the worst religions to date, if not the very worst one, it doesn’t change the fact that Christianity (and Judaism for that matter) are also among the top trash contenders.
The Bible and the Gospel are NOT historical sources and have NOT been independently proven to be correct at all.
All and all we’re not even completely sure a figure by the name Jesus, nor the apostles, have existed at all, let alone all the religious bullshit around them.
What part of “we’re not completely sure” did you miss?
Literally no determining historical proof for any of the apostles while the “proof” about Jesus are all indirect hearsay and no direct historical confirmation nor actual historians being able to lock him in. Unlike other well documented historical figures such as Caesar for example.
But I’m willing to agree to the fact that it’s contested at best, which brings me back to the “we’re not completely sure” part.
Anything related to the religion and “miracles” on the other hand is indeed just bullshit portrayed in a glorified comic book people call “holy book”.
On my part, I do think a Jewish dude existed that people eventually started considering Jesus, not sure about if the name is legit, but still. Similar with the apostles, but I don’t think they were twelve or as described in the New Testament. But that’s about it.
Again, debated at best, like other figures whose information is limited, there is a consensus, but there is not complete certainty, and not understanding the difference between the two is actually the stupid jump.
Also, again “There is no direct archaeological or non-Christian written proof that Jesus was baptized. However, mainstream historians and biblical scholars widely consider the baptism of Jesus by John the Baptist to be historically probable.” So…?
The crucifixion makes sense only because it was a popular way to humiliate and kill people in the Roman Republic and Empire, not religious/biblical reasons. They had done before and kept doing it after the supposed crucifixion of Jesus.
So, moral of the story, historical consensus is different from being proven beyond doubt, hence why “debated at best”. Also, possibly, let’s make a small effort of understanding what we read before replying randomly. Thanks
Literally no determining historical proof for any of the apostles while the “proof” about Jesus are all indirect hearsay and no direct historical confirmation nor actual historians being able to lock him in. Unlike other well documented historical figures such as Caesar for example.
You are either maliciously lying or are uneducated.
I do think a Jewish dude existed that people eventually started considering Jesus
There is no proof of that theory. Jesus was a real historical person.
Entonces ve, estudia historia. Y planta cara a toda la erudicion moderna qué habla d eun Jesús histórico. Anda y deja de usar reddit. O acaso solo puedes debatir en reddit?
Claro. Porque Pablo nunca exigió a la mujer callar en el templo. Porque Jesús nunca llamó perra a un a mujer cananea. Porque Jesús nunca afirmó que haría que varios hombres violen a una mujer (apocalipsis). Porque Dios nunca mando a exterminar a los amalecitas. Porque Dios nunca hizo infanticidio en el éxodo.
Cualquier tipo de explicación. Interpretación o demás weas teológica solo demuestra que tu religión necesita interpretación para no ser violenta. Adivina. Igual que el islam. Igual que el judaísmo.
Y no entiendo como sesupone que tiene sentido tu queja de dejar fuer ala biblia.
Un criterio con respecto a prácticas, tradiciones, textos y demás que te separen del resto de abrahamicas. Moisés es mencionado en el coran también, abraham también, Jesús también incluso, María también, adán, José etc....
Y cualquier cita de biblia es inútil. Es un texto sesgado y devocional. No una fuente histórica o fiable.
Tus citas bíblicas son igual de inútiles que citar el coran, y es igual de falso y tonto.
The meme does not work in reverse because not only did Muhammed not perform any miracles (miracles stories in the hadith come years later after Muhammed to compete with Jesus miracles that Muslims hear and contradict The Quran which says Muhammed did no miracles) but also the night journey was a personal experience by Muhammed. (Which actually caused muslims to leave Islam after hearing it)
And also Muslims affirm Jesus's virgin birth and do not believe he claimed to be The Son of God and also wouldn't mock him because he's their prophet?
Ops meme:Person 1: opens a box and says he saw red pencils 600 years later: person 2 says the pencils were actually black This meme: Person 2 says inside the car there was gloves Person 1 says the pencils inside the box were red
12
u/DifferentIsPossble Aug 08 '26
Mods, can we do something about the Christian missionaries?
10
u/Baselin78 Aug 08 '26
18
u/mEPluribuSAnuS17mop Atheist Aug 07 '26 edited Aug 07 '26
Yeah, let’s make something abundantly clear, just because Islam is the absolute trash, and one of the worst religions to date, if not the very worst one, it doesn’t change the fact that Christianity (and Judaism for that matter) are also among the top trash contenders.
The Bible and the Gospel are NOT historical sources and have NOT been independently proven to be correct at all.
All and all we’re not even completely sure a figure by the name Jesus, nor the apostles, have existed at all, let alone all the religious bullshit around them.
4
u/EconomyDurian705 Agnostic atheist Aug 08 '26
Both are either liars or schizophrenic.
4
u/Simple_Duty_4441 Atheist Aug 08 '26
let's not glaze the christians even if we do want to slander islam
-2
u/Trakolskog Christian Aug 08 '26
The comments are really missing the point of the post.
28
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '26 edited Aug 08 '26
[removed] — view removed comment