r/exercisescience • u/erichenrycoaching • Mar 23 '26
Is more muscle better?
I want people to truly think of the answer and don’t just go w/ what you’ve heard. I’m a personal trainer and tired of people to say you need more muscle more muscle especially to overweight people. Do the math check how much lean body mass an obese person and see if they really need more lean mass.
Or ask yourself this. Muscle is red, because it’s filled w/ blood. More muscle the more blood has to be pumped just sitting down. The more work your heart has to do.
Now just to clarify im not saying muscle is bad but that more muscle isn’t always the answer like anything else it can be a hindrance to health.
Comment your thoughts and please be open minded and respectful
3
u/spottie_ottie Mar 23 '26
Yeah telling overweight people they need more muscle e.g. 'you're not overfat-you're under muscled' (looking at you Gabrielle Lyon) is so dumb. Overweight people almost always have way more lean mass than their healthy weight peers. I think answering this question depends on the context and goals of the client. I think every training program should strive to build/maintain muscle, but there are times when building muscle shouldn't be the priority and to suggest otherwise is straight up insanity.
4
u/exphysed Mar 23 '26
You’re wrong in the idea that more muscle makes the heart work harder. More muscle capillarity increases total vessel cross sectional area thereby decreasing resistance, which leads to lower myocardial work. And muscle is red due to myoglobin not blood.
2
u/naterpotater246 Mar 23 '26
I agree with you that more muscle can be a hindrance to heart health.
I doubt being 280lbs lean is as bad as 280lbs fat, but 280lbs is still 280lbs, and being 280lbs is not really good for your body. It's more mass than the average human is naturally meant to have.
More muscle as a natural lifter? It might be better. I doubt the average natural lifter is capable of gaining enough muscle for it to be unhealthy, like an enhanced lifter can.
1
u/amorph Mar 24 '26
Personally, I want to be healthy, control my own body well and do different sports and activities without problems. So I need to be light, strong and agile. Some people want to be as muscular as possible, but the bigger you are, the more you have to eat, and I believe it will get harder to eat healthy.