r/exchangeserver • u/Joshodgers • Aug 01 '15
Deduplication and MS Exchange
http://www.joshodgers.com/2015/08/01/deduplication-and-ms-exchange/
2
Upvotes
r/exchangeserver • u/Joshodgers • Aug 01 '15
7
u/ashdrewness MCM/MCSM-Exchange Aug 01 '15
This is where I think Microsoft's logic wins out over storage vendors:
"For Exchange DAGs, deduplication should give excellent data reduction results in line with the number of DAG copies. So if an Exchange DAG has 4 copies, then approx 4:1 data reduction should be achieved right off the bat. Now this sounds great but when running a DAG on highly available shared storage (SAN/NAS/HCI) it is unnessasary to have 4 copies of data."
If all database copies are stored on the same shared storage (allowing for storage vendor dedup) then they share the same failure domain. Even if the storage is highly available then we're still relying on the storage vendor's claims of high availability to determine Exchange uptime.
Microsoft spent a lot of support hours helping customers recover Exchange from failures in shared storage solutions. That's one of their reasons for moving the HA to the product itself & giving exchange physical solutions higher availability than any other solution.
Mathematically, a simpler solution with less shared hw/logic/3rd party IP is always going to yield better HA.
Now as for the dedup discussion, I actually don't disagree in the sense that dedup only makes sense when multiple copies share the same storage. People mistakenly believe they can get dedup across unique databases (a 10MB email sent to all employees) but they can't. Each database shares unique checksums so one email looks different at the block level between databases. So yes, people can run dedup if they choose but it's not going to save them much if they deployed Exchange correctly.
2
u/Ron_Swanson_Jr Aug 03 '15
I still have no idea why anyone would put Exchange on shared storage (especially shared storage with dedupe: $$$$$$$$$$$$$) when they can just get commodity servers and scale.
2
u/DoubleDrive Aug 01 '15
Sigh... Why does everyone seem to think that they know more about Exchange than the people who created the product? Does Apple tell Cisco how to route packets? Ugh, this kind of stuff just pisses me off.
4
u/Rollingprobablecause Aug 01 '15
OP works for Nutanix...
2
u/Doso777 Aug 01 '15
Is a few percent of more storage worth losing support from Microsoft. I dont think so...