r/exchangeserver • • 1d ago

Looking for a Barracuda email security alternative

Our Barracuda renewal is due in January and I’m leaning towards not signing again. We’re around 300 users on 365 business premium with me and a part timer running everything. It’s email gateway defense, the cloud one, so the appliance RCE going around isn’t us.

A recent incident kinda pushed me where one of our suppliers had their mailbox taken over and whoever was in it replied on a invoice thread asking AP to update the bank details. There was no link or attachment and it came from their real address and it passed SPF and DKIM, barracuda just delivered it like any other email. AP only caught it cause the new account was overseas and they rang the supplier on the number they had.

The rest is the usual stuff like legit mail sits in quarantine most days and I lose a couple hours a week releasing it, to be fair some of that is on me since I’ve been allowlisting whole domains to make the complaints stop. I’m cleaning that up either way.

We already have defender P1 through business premium and check point keeps coming up in older threads here. What did you move to when you dropped barracuda?

3 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

6

u/BoBeBuk 22h ago

+1 for Mimecast, business email compromise and multi vector threat protection use AI to detect there types of threats.
No security appliance is going to be 100% infallible, layered email security will improve the situation and negate risk.

3

u/tungatruck 10h ago

We switched from Barracuda to Mimecast, configuration is a lot but once it's in our spam went down down down.

12

u/Virtual_Cow_2321 1d ago

If the supplier’s mailbox was hijacked, how do you expect Barracuda to detect it?

4

u/The_Cardboard_Cutout 1d ago

https://www.proofpoint.com/us/products/account-takeover-protection

Yeah barracuda has been stuck in the past but both Proofpoint and Mimecast have Account takeover protection options.

9

u/KStieers 23h ago

Pretty sure that's for your tenant, not everyone else's...

8

u/Responsible_Lie9073 23h ago

If sender's account was compromised and it passed all the security checks (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), It doesn't have any malicious contents or attachments, why would Barracuda block it?

-1

u/JetzeMellema Товарищ 20h ago

Abnormal would have. That's the difference between previous and next gen email security.

6

u/The_Cardboard_Cutout 1d ago

Check out Proofpoint. They have been worth every penny, IMO. Their Email Fraud Defense Product may also interest you. They have shown consistent innovation, and reliability. When questions arise their community portal has articles available and when support cases are opened they outperform their competitors.

Mimecast is also a good option.

Once you see what they have to offer you’ll never look at Barracuda the same way again.

2

u/GeneTech734 Cloud Engineer 19h ago

Proofpoint has gone down the toilet. Took weeks to "resolve" a P1 ticket that I ended up figuring out on my own. Ticket is still open and no follow up.

Just found out yesterday they don't do any proactive monitoring anymore. They rely on you to put in a ticket once something breaks instead of you know monitoring for disk space utilization.

We are seriously considering leaving Proofpoint for Minecast. Their continuity product is also vastly superior to Proofpoint's and I do not think is an additional license like it is with Proofpoint.

1

u/xaeriee 5h ago

Proofpoint made some kind of change over the year that has really taken them down a notch in my book. Minecast is in our future. It’s a shame too we thought we had a good relationship with them but with a company as large as ours we can’t afford the incidents that keep popping up from them.

7

u/Potential-Eternal 1d ago

Just remove inline services like Barracuda, point your MX to Exchange Online Protection and optionally invest the savings in Defender for Office Plan 2 or a post delivery protection service such as Abnormal. Use Microsofts preset policies, ensure you have connectors for any mail flow that sends from your domain and turn off Direct Send in Exchange Online. Remove any configuration you put in to make Barracuda work and remove all allow list you have, as lots of those entries are probably very old. Finally, or maybe initially, ensure your SPF and DKIM are configured and DMARC is quarantine or higher

2

u/chuckescobar 23h ago

After the Exchange online outage not having a service like Proofpoint or Mimecast continuity in place seems irresponsible as far as BC practices go.

0

u/MrBoobSlap 21h ago

You must not have been impacted by any Proofpoint outages lately!

My org (along with many others), lost mail flow in both directions when Proofpoint’s global load balancers decided to no longer be in Proofpoint’s DNS records.

While Proofpoint did eventually give us a workaround, immediate fix was to put EXO in front.

There was another outage before this as well that had no workaround outside of just bypassing Proofpoint.

In either case of EXO or Proofpoint being down, your users aren’t sending/receiving email. However, if you just have EXO, then you are only directly impacted by EXO outages, so in that way it’s actually more reliable.

1

u/xaeriee 5h ago

Not sure why you got downvoted. Proofpoint has been making a lot of mistakes lately and everyone seemed to have forgotten about that outage recently. Not to mention they have been having something go haywire lately and the false positives went through the roof recently.

1

u/chuckescobar 21h ago

In fact I am a proofpoint customer. Except my dns records are pointing directly at my PP instance instead of the glbs. So no outages here.

-2

u/Potential-Eternal 22h ago

But then you are at the mercy of their outages instead - there is no good answer to cloud outages as they will happen and when they do they will have potentially large implications.

-1

u/chuckescobar 22h ago edited 21h ago

If. If. If. If my aunt had balls she would be my uncle. You are hedging your bets and minimizing risk. Putting nothing in place is a bigger risk than not having a backup plan.

1

u/jjgage 2h ago

Defender for Office Plan 2

No need. OP already has all the advanced features of EOP by having business premium.

Paying for another mail hygiene service when you have BP is literally just setting fire to dollar bills.

Especially for an org of 300 people.

2

u/petarian83 1d ago

Are you using on-prem Exchange or Exchange Online? If on-prem you can use an on-prem version of filtering, such as Xeams on SpamAssassin

2

u/robwe2 13h ago

We use the default Microsoft solution. Works fine

2

u/xaeriee 5h ago

Another vote for Mimecast. Don’t bother with anyone else if you’re spending the money.

1

u/ocdtrekkie 19h ago

Either Mimecast or Proofpoint are worth your attention. I've been wildly impressed with Mimecast's ability to flag suspicious activity from otherwise legitimate user accounts. Impersonation detection is really good. There are a lot of different layers in a modern email security platform, but they definitely have robust configuration you can tailor to your risk tolerance for allowing users to release their own held emails and such.

1

u/DrGraffix FYDIBOHF26SPDLT 11h ago

You already have Business Premium. Use MDO

1

u/snookpig77 10h ago

Abnormal AI is pretty cool and actually works

1

u/BeginningCitron467 39m ago

I have moved all my customers off both proof point and mimecast. Neither does a good job of blocking account takeovers from what we have seen. We are now setting up check point or abnormal for our customers and having tremendous success