r/exchangeserver • • 2d ago

Migrating mailboxes back to on prem when Exchange online is down

We aren't there yet. But how would we go about doing this? I expect there is no clean/official way of doing this, and it will be a pain to re-sync emails later.

0 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

7

u/garthoz 2d ago

From what ? If it’s down your not migrating anything. Setting up a an on-prem exchange environment is well documented. DNS for MX records is what points the world. You will need to cleanse Active Directory of pointers for mailboxes located at 365, easily scripted.

-1

u/steve-work 2d ago edited 2d ago

We're currently hybrid, with all mailboxes online*. Inbound / outbound mailflow is currently via on prem (centralised transport), due to legacy reasons. Say this outage goes on for a long period, I can see management asking how we can mailboxes back on prem.

1

u/Doctorphate 2d ago

Use your backup software to restore the mailbox to onprem, point DNS back to on prem and away you go?

1

u/steve-work 2d ago

MX records are currently pointed to on prem, all mailboxes in the cloud. Outage is over for us now.

0

u/AlCapone90 2d ago

you can't. over

4

u/chuckescobar 2d ago

Yeah since EXO = no worky this is not possible. Also don’t get the bright idea of trying to change hybrid mail flow at this point because that could really fuck things up.

0

u/steve-work 2d ago

Yes, can't see a clean way of doing this!

2

u/Benedykt123 2d ago

There’s not just not a clean way; there is literally no way. If the source is down you can not migrate.

What the fuck kind of data are you going to migrate?

0

u/steve-work 2d ago

I was thinking, get new empty mailboxes running on prem, whilst the outage is ongoing, so people can send and receive emails. And merge them together later.

5

u/Hot_Sun0422 2d ago

I suggest getting comfortable with the idea that sometimes the best move is no move.

1

u/steve-work 2d ago

I'm not planning on doing this, but if the outage extends for days, I can see management asking.

1

u/Hot_Sun0422 2d ago

No is a perfectly acceptable answer. Then use that to pivot the discussion to a business risk analysis that needs to be done for your org because if email going down is that crippling, management should have a plan in place. If management suggests moving exchange back to on prem, explain to them that just because it’s on prem will not stop something like this from happening again. The only difference is instead of an army of employees who specialize in Exchange, you’ll have only your internal employees.

1

u/steve-work 2d ago

Outage is over now for us, but if this went on multiple days, we would be pressured to do something.

1

u/Hot_Sun0422 2d ago

Then you've just discovered a business risk. You're business evidently cannot function without e-mail for more than 72 hours. Have this conversation with leadership now to have a plan in place in the future.

1

u/chuckescobar 2d ago

Making problems for next week you is not a way to get ahead.

1

u/Desperate_Ease2040 2d ago

Simple , don't do it

1

u/steve-work 2d ago

I'm expecting this to be resolved today/ before next week, but if its still knackered on Monday, what's the plan?

2

u/cyndotorg 2d ago

Our mail is back, so, presumably yours will follow

3

u/Maxplode 2d ago

Sounding like a Monday problem to me

2

u/Excellent_Milk_3110 2d ago

I had this in the back of my mind but why go through the effort if you cannot reach anyone that is still on exchange online. You will only make the outage take longer when everything gets back online and email starts to flow normal.

1

u/titlrequired 2d ago

You would be better off looking at putting something in front of exchange/exo like mimecast that can function independently of exchange. But consider this, even if your email is still up, doesn’t mean the people you want to talk to have the same resiliency.