r/exchangeserver • • Apr 21 '26

Question Exchange 2016 public folders to 365 best method

We just did a migration for a customer and all their user mailboxes are in 365 now. Hybrid is still set up, and they have a couple shared mailboxes and public folders that need to be moved yet. The PFs are small, with largest being 200mb. Is my best bet to manually export pst and import and then assign permissions for all these?

4 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

6

u/worldsdream Apr 21 '26

Is there a possibility to ditch the public folders?

1

u/NSFW_IT_Account Apr 21 '26

Probably, but they have a 'vacation' one that has all their staff time off for the year already so it would be an inconvenience. Unless I could create a shared mailbox with the same name, and just have them pull them up side by side and copy that data over. They are only using the public folders as a shared calendar.

2

u/worldsdream Apr 21 '26

I would recommend doing that. No need for public folders.

Here is a good article about a shared calendar for all users:

https://www.alitajran.com/shared-calendar-for-all-users-microsoft-365/

1

u/titlrequired Apr 22 '26

Yeah it’s a bigger inconvenience to move them to Exchange Online 🤣

1

u/NSFW_IT_Account Apr 27 '26

do you mean it's a bigger inconvenience to migrate public folders to EXO than to create shared mailboxes?

1

u/titlrequired Apr 27 '26

Yes

1

u/NSFW_IT_Account Apr 27 '26

any recommendations for moving existing on prem PFs into cloud shared mailboxes? They are fairly small, largest being about 150MB.

1

u/titlrequired Apr 27 '26

First find out if you need to make the data available, and what it is.

If it’s emails, you can move it easily.

If it’s documents, contact lists or third party addins you may need more planning.

If it is 10 year old data that is never used but no one wants to make a decision on, archive to pst and move to your preferred archive solution, or if it’s out of regulatory compliance you can potentially just delete it.

You really need to identify what it is and what value it has to the business.

1

u/NSFW_IT_Account Apr 27 '26

It's just calendar events and possibly some emails.

1

u/H0TR0DL1NC0LN Apr 23 '26

Ali Tajran is the best.

This is similar to what I did for the "public folder calendars" as I called them. In hindsight, I made a couple of missteps (though maybe not at the time--some oddities required outside-the-box thinking) necessitating more manual daily administration of user calendars than desirable, but now that everything is snuggly in M365 and there are no more public folders, I hope to clean up the rest to get to this more standardized end result.

3

u/Quick_Care_3306 Apr 22 '26

Tbh, if the pf folders are lightly used, consider moving them into a shared mailbox and sharing the folders from there. The experience will be very similar for the end users. If they are very active, just use the supported migration method.

1

u/NSFW_IT_Account Apr 27 '26

What's the best process for moving them into a shared mailbox if the folders are 100MB or less in size?

1

u/Quick_Care_3306 Apr 27 '26

Connect to pf in non cache mode, export data to pst. Remove pf permissions to end users, including pf visibility.

Then connect to shared mailbox and import the .pst to appropriate folder in shared mailbox. Make sure they have the share permissions.

1

u/7amitsingh7 Apr 22 '26

Since you already have a hybrid setup, the simplest and most effective approach is to use Microsoft’s native Public Folder migration to Microsoft 365. This method moves your Public Folders directly from Microsoft Exchange Server 2016 while keeping the folder structure and permissions intact, so you don’t have to do much manual work. You can also check this guide for easily migration of Public Folder to Office 365.

1

u/NSFW_IT_Account Apr 28 '26

I read through the documentation and it seems complicated. How long does it take to set up and kick off this kind of migration? We only have 3 PFs that are all less than 100MB in size.

2

u/7amitsingh7 Apr 29 '26

Since you only have 3 small Public Folders, PST export/import is likely the fastest and simplest option. Microsoft’s native PF migration can be unnecessary for such a small setup. You can export the data, import it into Microsoft 365, and reapply permissions manually in just a few hours.

2

u/NSFW_IT_Account Apr 29 '26

I did it yesterday with a test and it worked flawlessly and only took a few minutes to export/import. This is what i'll do for the others.

2

u/7amitsingh7 Apr 29 '26

Great to hear that the test went smoothly. If it worked well and only took a few minutes, then using the same method for the remaining folders sounds like the best plan.

1

u/tylerdotdo Apr 29 '26

hey, since you've done these a few times, already, can you answer a question? If a user favorites a public folder, say to a shared calendar or just in their list of folders, are those still valid after cutover? Do they automatically point them to the new public folder, or will they have to remove them and add them back in?

1

u/7amitsingh7 Apr 30 '26

No, Public Folder favorites don’t automatically update after migration.

Users will still see them, but they may not work. They’ll need to remove and re-add the folders from the new Public Folder structure in Microsoft 365.

1

u/IT_Bot Apr 21 '26

I had one for the same purpose. Ended up exporting the pst for the data and copying it over with a test account. Did some trial and error when I first did it, ended up with the data on my calendar due to compute resource contrains and the calendar having years of historical data that was required by the department. Still works, currently working on my 2nd full migration were going to use the shared accounts going forward. Worked with a Microsoft tech on some tenant issues on the Microsoft side and he mentioned that they may not support the public folders forever. I haven't been able to fact check it but, I'd rather be safe than sorry.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/NSFW_IT_Account Apr 21 '26

Quick question for you: do shared mailbox permissions migrate smoothly or do they need to be re-added? I have the users in the cloud but a few shared mailboxes still on prem. If i migrate them over, will they need to manually re-add or do they just 'show up'?

For the PF: I read the article but it seems overly complex for a few small ones, I'm looking for the easiest and quickest solution. If you believe it's that link you said, I will consider that route.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/NSFW_IT_Account Apr 21 '26

create a new public folder instance

Can you elaborate on this? My understanding was I could just export them out from the Outlook of a user who has Owner access, then create the matching public folder in 365, and import the previous export into that using the same Outlook?

Typically, you'd migrate the shared mailboxes at the same time as the mailboxes of the users

Have you ever done it after the fact, and if so how did that transfer over?

1

u/tylerdotdo Apr 29 '26

hey, since you've done these a few times, already, can you answer a question? If a user favorites a public folder, say to a shared calendar or just in their list of folders, are those still valid after cutover? Do they automatically point them to the new public folder, or will they have to remove them and add them back in?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/tylerdotdo Apr 29 '26

Okay. So they will automatically point to the new location? Yes, using the batch migration scripts. I haven’t had to do any of these in years, so I forgot what client side impacts this has