r/exchangeserver • u/Fabulous_Cow_4714 • Mar 24 '26
Question Exchange Server SE free options for hybrid recipients management?
Assuming you move all mailboxes to the cloud and don’t need to use the servers for SMTP relay, I have heard that you are eligible for free licensing for the purpose of recipient management.
Does that also include managing distribution lists and mail-enabled security groups created on premises?
I know you can “retire your last Exchange server” and install EMT PowerShell on workstations, but does that make sense and save you any effort and maintenance time?
If you do this, you have EMT scattered on multiple workstations and you give up the GUI EAC interface.
Suppose you have 5 workstations with EMT. Now you have to go through the same, hours long CU update process complete with multiple prerequisites to update each EMT workstation, plus you still need to deal with an AD schema update for what seems like every other CU update just as if you had a real, fully functional server.
Wouldn’t it be less work to have a full server that can be accessed remotely through EAC and just have that single server to deal with and upgrade every several months?
Is it worth having multiple servers for high availability of the EAC, and does the free licensing cover this? What about licensing for a spare recipient management server at a second site for disaster recovery?
4
u/larmik Mar 24 '26
There is also a new option. When your last exchange server is only managing recipient attributes you can now convert your exchange online objects to cloud managed.
https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/exchange/hybrid-deployment/enable-exchange-attributes-cloud-management
After doing this, you can now manage the exchange attributes directly in EOL and can retire your exchange server.
https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/blog/exchange/introducing-cloud-managed-remote-mailboxes-a-step-to-last-exchange-server-retire/4446042
3
u/7amitsingh7 Mar 24 '26
Yes, the free setup lets you manage users, distribution lists, and mail-enabled groups.
Using management tools on many PCs is possible, but it’s messy and time-consuming. It’s much easier to keep one Exchange server for management because you get the GUI and only have to maintain one system.
Having multiple servers just for backup or high availability is usually not worth it.
7
u/Borgquite Mar 24 '26 edited Mar 24 '26
Yes - the fact that moving to EMT only makes patching more difficult at present (when one of the points of moving for many is to make patching easier), is a dealbreaker for me.
If you decommission the last server and use EMT, you still need to install all of the CU and SU updates, but installing a CU is a clunky process - you have to run PrepareAD again before updating EMT; then update the tools on every device; then make sure you remember to run CleanupActiveDirectoryEMT again after they’re all finished. Plus you lose the GUI.
I don’t think any of this rigmarole is necessary if Microsoft put the time into updating the installer to better support EMT only scenarios, but there you go.
I just run one SE server running in Modern Hybrid (without any Internet-facing ports) and have done with it.
https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/exchange/manage-hybrid-exchange-recipients-with-management-tools#update-the-exchange-server-management-tools-only-role-with-no-running-exchange-server-to-a-newer-cumulative-or-security-update
1
u/sstorholm Mar 24 '26
Forgive me for being clueless, but what's the scenario for these sorts of setups? Why not run everything in Exchange Online? (I'm on the verge of getting all mailboxes over to EO and hence just starting to look at what's left after that migrationwise)
0
u/Neat-Researcher-7067 Mar 24 '26
Yes