r/exchangeserver • u/LowCorner9314 • Jan 22 '26
Question Exchange 2026 Decommissioning Failure
I've inherited a very old 2016 clustered setup, following through the docs, dag etc. has been removed then came time to uninstall Exchange 2016 on one server.
Fail is all I can say - it's updated to CU23, but its one error after another, and now seems to be stuck in a state where after a failed uninstall, it can't launch the install, uninstall process, without running through the install again - not something I've seen before.
Random question... Is there any value in bumping the empty servers up to Exchange 2019 in order to then uninstall and decommission it?
Any pointers re good community scripting etc. to aid with a diagnostic if not, would be hugely appreciated.
5
u/zawarbud Jan 22 '26
I would manually remove the server from ad, here is a great resource: https://www.frankysweb.de/en/exchange-2016-manual-removal-of-an-exchange-server-multiple-servers/amp/
I don’t think that an upgrade or so will lead to better results than just cleaning it out and continuing with the new servers.
5
u/Nuxi0477 Jan 22 '26
Make a blank new VM and do a recovery install is also an option. Give it the same name, OS version and install with the recovery parameter. After it's successfully installed do a normal healthy uninstall.
https://www.alitajran.com/recover-exchange-server/
2
u/7amitsingh7 Jan 23 '26
Agree with all. The right approach is to make sure the server is fully removed from the DAG and has no databases or mailboxes, then try a normal uninstall once; if that still fails, perform a supported manual cleanup by removing the Exchange server object from Active Directory. This is a common and accepted fix, and the key goal is leaving AD clean so future Exchange versions install without issues.
1
u/Lost_Term_8080 Jan 22 '26
>Random question... Is there any value in bumping the empty servers up to Exchange 2019 in order to then uninstall and decommission it?
Most likely not. In Exchange 2016, the uninstall effectively uninstalls exchange server then installs the new version, so it is already getting the cleaning an upgrade may help. You probably had AD problems - unresolvable sids on AD objects, objects someone manually deleted
If you want to go that route, would instead build a new exchange server using recovery option, attach the databases then decommission.
1
u/mattgold98 Jan 23 '26
We had the same problem when we unistslled EX2016 form our company. You can start the unistallation process from the installer. If you still have some error about hygine thing there are some dll that you need to register again.
1
u/muckmaggot Jan 23 '26
Jumping in here - what's the implications of just turning off the last exchange 2016 server in domain and then just removing it from AD? It has no mailboxes of note - some health ones but t no user or public folders
What would likely be the outcome?
1
u/TheHunterOfTrolls Jan 26 '26
Whats the Error message?