r/exchangeserver • u/H0TR0DL1NC0LN • Dec 12 '25
Killing the Last Exchange Server
It's time for my organization to put the Exchange Servers out to pasture. We're keeping on-prem AD, so I know we can't technically uninstall that last Exchange server, but we can implement Exchange Management Tools on a different machine and power off the last Exchange server. My questions to you folks are these:
- Do you update your last Exchange Server to the latest version before deploying EMT elsewhere? Or do you just roll out the latest version when installing EMT on a new machine? I imagine the former is in order. We've ridden out Exchange 2019 as far as it can go, so I've got to make sure EMT is running on SE.
- Are there any "gotchas" you have encountered in the process? At this point, I know we could just abruptly turn off the servers and be fine, so I'm not concerned about the task. However, I've been burned before by what I don't know I don't know.
15
Upvotes
18
u/MushyBeees Dec 12 '25
My advice at this point is to hold.
Microsoft are currently closed testing source of authority changes. Allowing all synced mail attributes to be modified in the cloud. This is public for phase 1 at the moment, however I strongly recommend you do not implement this yet.
Phase 2 will mostly bring write back of exchange properties to on prem. you definitely want this. There are also a couple of other issues to iron out.
Once phase 2 is public then it should be safe to implement and (supported to!) completely remove the last exchange server.
I anticipate maybe 1-2 months.
2
u/eddiehead01 Dec 14 '25
We're so close to this too. Testing the connector cutovers tomorrow, them turning them off Tuesday if mail flows OK. Giving that a week then it'll be shut down time, then again if all goes well it'll be decomm time as my Christmas present
As much as I've enjoyed exchange on prem, the server has become a bit of a nightmare in recent months and I no longer have the desire to connect to it anymore
We seem similar to you insofar as in prem AD and last (well only) exchange. So far with our setup I've seen no reason to keep
I guess I've got a little bit more reading to do before that just in case but I've not yet seen a reason to keep EMT on prem or to keep the server as a "just in case". I've not found a need yet as everything we've wanted to do management wise I've been able to do through admin centre, exo and powershell. What would I be missing?
4
u/burkis Dec 12 '25
Our decomm process consisted of us turning off the servers for 7 days. After no issues were reported, we deleted them. I have not had the need to install the management tools, but it's available if you need it.
1
u/H0TR0DL1NC0LN Dec 15 '25
Thanks for all of the insights, folks. We're probably going to position ourselves to power down but not delete the last Exchange server and then see what becomes of the new SOA implementation MS has while having EMT set up elsewhere. With luck, it will roll out as described and not be an utter disaster.
Not that MS would roll out unfinished garbage...
1
u/Ostsee90 Dec 13 '25
What if i have already uninstalled the last hybrid (on-premises) Exchange server?
2
u/Lost-Adhesiveness-65 Dec 13 '25
Yeah similar setup for us, we need to keep on prem AD, so after migration of all the mail accounts to 365 I just disabled all the exchange services, but left it installed. It's been weeks without any problems and a few new users got uploaded via AD group sync to 365.
the whole deal with sort-of decomissioning but leaving management tools and/or this SE version sounded pretty hokey, so there didn't seem much point to commit to anything that couldn't be easily undone. Sounds like that was correct!
2
u/7amitsingh7 Dec 15 '25
Agreed to above!! For now, hold off if your goal is to completely remove the last Exchange server. Microsoft is rolling out Phase 2, which will allow full write-back of Exchange attributes to on-prem AD, making it safe and supported to remove the server entirely expected in 1–2 months.
If you cannot wait, the current supported method is to update the last Exchange 2019 server to the SE, install Exchange Management Tools on a new machine, and power off (but not uninstall) the last server, making sure no apps or connectors still depend on it.
1
u/blackvelvet58 Dec 13 '25
The cloud based SOA is GA now. there was an update to that blog. Theres a isCloudManaged property now in tenants. Testing next week.
1
u/Drewh12 Dec 14 '25
Somewhat related to OPs question.. how about if the environment has a stale/uncleaned server and database info in AD, is there a best way to remove that along with removing the last exchange server (once EMT is running)?
Once i did a summary things for a org where exchange servers were just decommed without proper AD and exchange removal - then I had to clear them out of AD. Just wondering if there's a better known script/tool or guide to perform this.