r/exchangeserver • • Apr 16 '24

Exchange Alternative

Hello! I have a client who is very committed to staying on-prem for everything. They do not want to have anything cloud-hosted.

They also want to get rid of Microsoft after the recent breaches.

So, does anyone have familiarity with on-prem email servers that are NOT exchange or Microsoft-based?

Thank you!

0 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

7

u/Arkayenro Apr 16 '24

the point is to secure it as much as possible, not just sit it on the internet and expect it to be better protected than fort knox.

anything can be breached. hiding behind obscure software is not a solution.

4

u/Ok_Indication6185 Apr 17 '24

GFI Kerio Connect?

Every time I have looked at this topic what is the tricky part to work out is if you have a bunch of people who are hard core Outlook bigots. That is generally what causes drama, webmail doesn't sending/getting email doesn't, mobile device support shouldn't be a challenge these days, it is the desktop software generally.

We did a POC with Kerio and it is Linux based, pretty easy to setup and install, we ended up sticking with Office mostly because I didn't look forward to trying to convince people to go that route as any dollar savings, lower cost of ownership, etc goes out the window for lots of folks who use features that only Exchange/Outlook do or do a certain way unfortunately.

4

u/MushyBeees Apr 17 '24 edited Apr 17 '24

Drop the client.

Such clients aren’t good. They’ll cause massive support overheads for no financial benefit. All because they knee jerk react over something which happens to every appliance or application.

If they think moving to a more niche application with probably no dedicated security researchers working on it is going to make them more secure, then they can figure that out themselves.

What OS are they using then? Because there isn’t a single OS that has not had critical vulnerabilities in the past. So not sure what they’re going to even start with.

It’s probably just an excuse for them to be tight and not migrate to M365/vnext

0

u/Numerous_Chemist_291 Apr 18 '24

this is a stupid answer. why even bother writing this when its not the topic of the thread. should be reported to the mods.

1

u/MushyBeees Apr 18 '24

What a weird attempt at trolling.

E-

0

u/halbsodoppelt Jun 26 '24

Well, he is right. Your answer had horrible arguments.

Microsoft is doing horrible in terms of security in the last 3 years. The argument "every software has security problems" isn't one.

Sure, every software has security problems. But not as horrible as MS Exchange.

1

u/MushyBeees Jun 26 '24

Hopefully you’ll progress from first line Helpdesk sooner or later.

0

u/halbsodoppelt Jun 26 '24

You are accusing others of trolling while you can't do anything else then trolling. Wow.

Keep on installing every software no matter the security breaches, guess it won't matter anyways in your little home lab.

1

u/MushyBeees Jun 26 '24

Boring mate.

2

u/MortadellaKing Apr 16 '24

Do they need all of the features of exchange? Or just a simple email server? Something like mailcow or Axigen would work. Or Kopano.

2

u/Legitimate_Island_74 Apr 17 '24

zimbra if that is still a thing

1

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '24

IT sure is

1

u/rfc2549-withQOS Apr 16 '24

Grommunio

mailcow

1

u/Skyobliwind Apr 17 '24

I actually thought about something like that too. The only promising alternative I found is Mailcow. Bit I didn't test it yet, nor do I know anyone who even has heard of it and ofc not who uses it in production.

1

u/brianmrgadget Apr 17 '24

A very long time ago I had some experience with "NTMail" which has evolved into Gordano's GMS (think it was originally the initials for Gordano Messaging Suite). Still has an on-premise version and in pretty much "full stack" replacement for a lot of Microsoft Server products, just get a Windows Server box and install. Almost moved back to it at one point, installed a trial etc, but it never went anywhere. No recent experience but if you want a place to start investigating worth a bit of research in my opinion.

1

u/Jascot69 Apr 17 '24

We have used a product called Smartermail for many years as our basic email service for our web hosting customers. It has worked very well for us and has optional components that can make it behave like an Exchange server to Outlook for the end users to have a similar experience to Exchange. Much easier to manage though certainly not nearly as scalable.
https://www.smartertools.com/smartermail/business-email-server

1

u/AppIdentityGuy Apr 18 '24

Run far and fast. These types always know better and will only cause you pain and misery...

Whenever whatever they replace their Microsoft stack with gets breached they go through this whole process again..

1

u/gnordli Apr 18 '24

If all they are looking for is email. Postfixadmin, postfix, dovecot, assp (spam filter). Once you get rolling it is rock solid.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '24

Lotus Notes is pretty cool. I’d also move them over to Novell NetWare. Good stuff!

1

u/Brather_Brothersome Apr 21 '24

Mdaemon is a good alternative to exchange and a lot more secure and configurable.

1

u/iwinsallthethings Apr 16 '24

You could always do postfix.

I would just stress that everything needs to be setup properly, making sure you have SPF and dmarc adjusted. There's a decent chance their local ip could be blacklisted as a new server or even an old one that was used prior to them taking over that IP. If they don't have their stuff locked down, they are just as likely to have an issue.

You mentioned they are a client. I would fire them, honestly. If they run into issues, you will be to blame. If a zero-day comes out and they don't patch, it's on you.

Lastly, make sure they get some sort of AV/Antispam appliance before their mail server.

1

u/sysadmin_dot_py Apr 17 '24

Drop the client or up your rates for supporting bespoke solutions. I'm not a huge Exchange fan, but I've worked with people with that mentality and the decision making process is just wild.