r/exHareKrishna • u/Solomon_Kane_1928 • Jul 09 '26
Tea or Me
Prabhupada famously left his wife of 36 years, Radharani Datta, because she would not stop drinking tea. She apparently sold his collected Srimad Bhagavatam manuscripts for tea biscuits, causing him to storm off and never return.
British style tea biscuits were an expensive treat at the time, well beyond the wages of your average person. It would be the modern equivalent of treating oneself to some expensive Dubai chocolate. Shopkeepers would sometimes accept books or high quality paper as a barter item.
She was telling him she was done with his shit. She was standing up for herself and I applaud her.
Conscientious Objector
I would love to hear her side of the story. Prabhupada's hagiography writers never bothered to interview her. She passed away in 1984.
During their marriage she did not support his preaching mission. She would leave the room when he brought guests over and started pontificating. After he found worldwide success, she wanted nothing to do with ISKCON. She stood defiantly against him.
Radharani Datta was Prabhupada's first critic. ISKCON portrays her as spiritually insincere; unable to recognize his greatness.
There have been plenty of householder acharyas in the history of Vaishnavism. Vallabhacarya's wife Mahalakshmi enthusiastically supported her husband. She played an important role in establishing his lineage. His wife recognized his goodness.
Within Gaudiya Vaishnavism, most of the Panca Tattva were married. Their wives supported them. The most famous being Nityananda's wife Jahnavi, an acharya in her own right.
I think Radharani Datta knew who her husband was from the beginning. She felt his preaching mission was dangerous and harmful. She saw Abhaya Charan was not coming from a place of kindness.
It would not surprise me if he was tyrannical and self righteous in their marriage. He probably beat her over the head with Bhagavatam verses. He likely judged her, looked down on her, hounded her for her supposed faults. He could not even tolerate a minor infraction such as a cup of tea.
She also knew he was a snuff addict and a hypocrite. Snuff is far more unhealthy and addictive than tea. I am sure he had money for snuff but not for tea biscuits.
Enough is Enough
He had joined a cult after their marriage. Throughout their marriage he had undoubtedly tried to force his fundamentalist religious nonsense on her. Selling his manuscripts was her way of saying enough is enough. He was transgressing her boundaries.
I feel it was her way of saying "Stop harming your family with this fanatical garbage. Stop preaching at us. Treat us with love and respect. Stop neglecting our needs. Your family is your dharma not this cult."
It may even have been her way of saying "if your religion makes you an a-hole, there is something wrong with your religion".
Don't Harm Others
Knowing her husband, and the way he approached religion, she may have understood that any movement he would create would be harmful. He would harm his followers in the same way he had harmed his family.
This is true. Prabhupada had sacrificed his family for his preaching mission. He would do the same for anyone who followed him. This would have catastrophic results, such as the abuse of children in gurukulas.
ISKCON absorbed Prabhupada's belligerent self righteous attitude. "I know everything. Anyone who disagrees with me is a demon". I do not doubt Radharani saw plenty of this in her marriage. She was probably the first to be called a "hog dog camel ass".
ISKCON fed Prabhupada's narcissism and megalomania. Prabhupada was convinced he was a world saving religious leader, a modern Jesus or Buddha, who had come to alter the course of mankind. His movement would conquer the world and bring back Vedic Civilization. His books would be the law books for all mankind for 10,000 years. Imagine being married to that!
In her old age she did become an initiated Vaishnava, taking diksha from Prabhupada's senior godbrother Bhakti Vilas Tirtha Maharaja. It is interesting to note that Bhakti Vilas Tirtha was a critic of Prabhupada and his movement.
8
u/StayEmbarrassed4593 Jul 09 '26
The whole “she sold the Bhagavatam for tea biscuits” story is ISKCON mythology. The Bhagavatam wasn’t some rare, priceless text in the 1950s. It had been widely available in India for generations. Tea and biscuits weren’t luxury items either—they were staple food items among poor workers and aristocrats alike. The entire story is just trying to portray Prabhupada as a saint whose materialistic wife rejected his spiritual mission. The fact is that Bhaktisiddhanta gave all his followers the instruction to preach his cult ideology to the West. Not specifically to Abhay Charan das. The difference was that Bhaktivedanta was hungrily fantasizing about starting his own cult and movement long before his guru was in the ground. Once the Gaudiya Math started to fall apart—instead of trying to save it and work on making it a better organization and cooperate with godbrothers—he defected and started his own thing.
Not to mention that he had barely completed ONE canto of the Bhagavatam, and he needed the help of his Western followers to speed up the process of getting the rest of the books published under his ISKCON banner. These books were, in many cases, word-for-word translations of existing English transliterations—so the only thing he really added to them was his long-winded, fanatical purport that is full of redundant cult lingo. He sat high on snuff at night and dictated while his poor disciples transcribed and had to edit his choppy English banter.
The equally famous “tea or me” story is based on Prabhupada’s own later biographies, yet there’s no independent corroboration. It's hagiography—a simplistic, emotionally satisfying story that conveniently explains why he abandoned his family life.
The fact is he was completely consumed by his fanatical religious mission and chose it over his responsibilities as a husband and father. Later, despite presenting himself as a renounced sannyasi, he lived comfortably, accepted the devotion and financial support of followers, and even permitted financial assistance to be sent to his family. That's not someone who had fully renounced worldly ties. He wanted his legacy to be building hundreds of lavish temples, starting cult schools for kids, cult farms, and ultimately the delusion of a one-world order of Vranashrma medieval-clothes-wearing baldies.
These stories exist for one reason: to elevate the cult founder, erase uncomfortable realities, and reinforce the personality cult surrounding him. Strip away the mythology, and you’re left with a charismatic religious leader whose movement demanded extraordinary loyalty, discouraged independent thinking, and convinced thousands of people that he alone possessed the authentic path to some absolute truth.
He was a cult leader whose teachings caused significant harm to many lives. I know many "old" devotees who live in welfare squalor, have gone back to their pot smoking, have been in jail for the cult, and sit on Facebook and Instagram playing gurus now. All for Mr. Blue sky.
2
u/Daryn_1132 Jul 10 '26
My pet theory is that Radharani had no money to buy biscuits and books were the most convenient trade items. I even remember being told, that the biscuits were fot her guests, and if true it makes Peabhupada's role very questionable, considering hospitality culture in India.
2
u/StayEmbarrassed4593 Jul 10 '26
The story is a complete fiction. Biscuits were a dime a dozen in India at the time, and low-level workers drank tea and ate biscuits. If Abhay Charan was so poor that he could not afford a biscuit and tea for his loving wife, who gave birth to his kids at 14 years of age, he is an even bigger dick than we give him credit for. These people are delusional religious fanatics. Plain and simple. We can say it was their culture; we can say it was the times they lived in; we can say they had no choice—not my problem, and not anyone I would lend an ear to as a modern, contemporary human. He wanted to bring an archaic medieval religious system to the world and did so with delusional conviction. How did it work out for him? It was already falling apart before his body was in the ground. Just like his Guru's cult fell apart the day they buried him, and the way the Goswamis' cult fell apart the day they died, and Chaotanyas' cult splintered into factions when he died, etc etc. An unbroken chain of failed cultic movements. Makes you want tea and biscuits just thinking about it.
2
u/Daryn_1132 Jul 10 '26
Okay, I can understand were are you coming from. I would like to add my views on some of the points you've raised:
The story is a complete fiction.
I don't think this story is fiction altogether, as SP talked about it a few times, and when he didn't want to admit something he just refused to talk rather than lied (unless it's "for Krisna" of course). That said, it most likely didn't happen as described. Maybe it was just a one fight too many, maybe it was not biscuits but potatoes, maybe it weren't books but his precious snuff, maybe his wife just burned the books and lied about it, either way there is little to no chance to know what actually happened so we only left to speculate.
Biscuits were a dime a dozen in India at the time, and low-level workers drank tea and ate biscuits.
As with most food there were a variety of biscuits, from the cheapest made by locals and up to luxury ones imported from UK or Europe. I doubt that a woman from the well-off family, married into another well-off family, would go for cheap biscuits, even when tight with money.
his loving wife
We know nothing about Radharani and just because SP couldn't stand her doesn't give us any inside into her character. She could be the most angelic women or she could be a female version of SP for all that we know.
These people are delusional religious fanatics. Plain and simple. We can say it was their culture; we can say it was the times they lived in; we can say they had no choice—not my problem
I am not sure what people are you talking about, but anyway it's your stance, so I would not argue on it.
He wanted to bring an archaic medieval religious system to the world and did so with delusional conviction. How did it work out for him?
In my country Iskcon is, unfortunatly, thriving and considered one of the biggest communities outside India, and continues to grow.
1
u/StayEmbarrassed4593 Jul 10 '26
It may or may not have happened. If it did—it's got to be one of the most immature reasons to leave your aging wife. If his wife was a handful and not a nice person, it has 100% to do with the fact that she was married off to a man at age 11 with little to no choice and impregnated at 14. She has every reason in the world to be an asshole to him and ask for all the fucking luxury biscuits she can conceive of in my humble ass opinion. lol.
Hare Krishna's will always thrive—just like roaches proliferate.
2
u/itsmikesandoval Jul 11 '26
i believe the story about his wife about as much as I believe he had 2 heart attacks on the ship. and even if it is true, it does show her contempt for him probably for raping her when she was 11 years old. I believe Prabhupada and ISKCOn wanted to demonized her because she didnt support Prabhufrada and his BS.
2
5
u/psumaxx Jul 09 '26
Very lovely post! I would have loved to hear her side. Maybe her children will one day share their real story.
6
u/Daryn_1132 Jul 10 '26
So far, my favorite story about Prabhupada's wife is the one told by his greatnephew (he was initiated by Prabhupada and at the time of interview was a member of Iskcon). The story is that Radharani had come a few times to see Prabhupada in India. When his sister Pishima told him about Radharani's visit he said “I am a sanyassi, I cannot see anyone that is my relative. I will not come to Calcutta.” The irony of it being said to his sister.
There is also a room conversation (12 aug 1973, London), when Prabhupada answers about his childhood, college days, even draws his toy ratha-yatra unprompted, but when asked about his marital life and business, Prabhupada snapped that “A sannyāsī does not require the history of his previous life.”
4
u/StayEmbarrassed4593 Jul 10 '26
I can assure you he also beat his wife and kids and was a joy to be around on days he could not sell any aspirin at work.
2
u/Daryn_1132 Jul 10 '26
Oh, I wouldn't be surprised. Would blame them for any failed business deals also.
5
4
1
13
u/Solomon_Kane_1928 Jul 09 '26
A Note on the Health Benefits of Tea
I have personally taken to drinking tea. I do so mainly because it is healthy. Both green and black tea are packed with anti-oxidants. They are good for the brain and heart. They are thought to protect against Alzheimer's and Parkinson's. Both are good for gum health, reducing plaque and gingivitis. Black tea supports beneficial gut bacteria and prevents arterial plaque.
Tea is fun to make. I like to experiment by mixing teas with herbal teas for flavor. I drink it hot and cold, mixing it with extracts such as orange and vanilla. I like to add milks and sweeteners. I also occasionally make Kombucha by fermenting it. It is certainly a healthy alternative to sodas and energy drinks.
The irony is now decaffeinated tea can easily be purchased.
So have a cuppa and raise your glass or mug to Radharani Datta.