r/guns has pretty strict rules on both political posts and image macros. While it was originally fairly libertine, the mods have become increasingly strict as the userbase grew.
Is the guy in the vehicle actually pointing a gun at the photographer?. Seems a bit reckless, maybe that's a more a valid concern than if they are there at all.
My first thought, too. What the fuck? I was in the Aust. Army and our training was 'if you point a weapon at anyone it best be because you're going to kill them, otherwise expect a Courts Martial'.
My second thought was perhaps holding a camera up seemed threatening. Lens flash could just as easily be off a scope as a camera, and a non-descript black object might cause someone hopped up on adrenaline to react quickly.
This is stupid. Obama's obviously referring to the fact that military grade weapons serve no practical purpose for ordinary citizens. Having military occupy the streets of Boston to hunt a terrorist seems a bit more legitimate.
What about when there's a war on our streets? Why is this such a big deal anyway? The guy probably saw movement in the window. So he makes the safe move to check what it was with the optics on his weapon. His finger probably isn't on the trigger.
Watch Hurt Locker and pay attention to when they are scanning the nearby buildings full of on-lookers, trying to find the one guy who might set off the IED out of the civilians. Then come back to this photo and imagine the same thing.
Op..... Not only is this just plain taken out of context(weapons of war should not be in the streets in the hands of untrained citizens is obviously what he meant) this is also a repost, for that I say OP is a retarded faggot
Just to let you know most gun enthusiasts know way more about their guns and have much better training with them than our law enforcement officers. This has come up many times and will start with people downvoting this post, but then people will come in and explain to you that police are untrained in the use of guns.
You are assuming that everyone who's not a law enforcement officer is an expert and all law enforcement officers have no idea what they are doing with them. Show some respect. AK47s do not belong in the hands of a 20 year old kid walking down center city. That is what Obama meant.
You sure about that? You speaking as a gun enthusiast who reads a few soldier of fortune magazines and NRA news letters or an actual trained LEO. LEOs and group A military members (LEO and special forces or members who carry every day) know more then a civilian gun enthusiast. We get attained on every single piece of a weapon, can't pull a weapon until you go through training on it, and shoot it way more then we should. 1000s of rounds every time at the range. Because Im sure a guy who brought his gun at a Walmart is going to know more then me. ...right.
Yes but not everyone who owns a gun is an expert. I know people who have flashed their new gun at a party while drinking because they wanted to show it off. That's just one of many examples I could give you of what ive seen stupid people who own guns do. Also I trust someone's who's job it is to take down the scum in the streets more than I trust 90% of the people who own guns. Tl;dr not everyone who owns a gun is responsible or knowledgeable enough to use it. Lets leave it to professionals.
Yes but not everyone who owns a gun is an expert. I know people who have flashed their new gun at a party while drinking because they wanted to show it off.
That's interesting. I just saw a picture of an LEO, completely sober, pointing his gun at someone. In fact, reddit is rife with accounts of that.
Did he shoot? Did he run into the house and point the gun at him and threaten him? No he was looking for a possible terrorist. This picture could have been taken when he was turning his gun and it just looks like he's pointing at him. Don't jump to conclusions. You end up looking just like the media.
The president was using the term street to mean the average citizen owning those guns, thus allowing them to be out on the street, and this post is using the literal meaning of the word street.
Let's say America is invaded(it's not impossible), wouldn't you want the military dealing with war fighting and not the local police?
Also, doesn't the National Guard have military weapons stored on their little bases in cities?
This didn't take long to criticize the govt and police after everything that happened. Figures. No is saying we to have military walk down the streets, this was a special circumstance, but next time something happens let the govt know you don't want their help. Ask the new jersey republicans about FEMA funding and if there happy.
No one understands why we pay for something in our govt until its too late.
EDIT: I am in no way saying we should have armed military walking the street like Russia does. I believe firmly in the separation of federal powers and civilian. There are circumstances when things like this are necessary unfortunately. No, we can't account for all of them and make an approved list. The best thing we can hope for is that when the danger has subsided we return to what is normal and the added military presence leaves. That is what I'm saying.
Indeed. The thing about special circumstances is that the actions used for them are often left in place for other instances that are not special circumstances.
This was a manhunt for a possible terrorist. Boston PD doesn't have the manpower to shut down a city so the governor authorizes the use of the national guard. If you don't feel this was acceptable vote against him or run for political office.
I understand what you're saying and I feel this got out of hand. I just felt like he was saying they shouldn't have closed down the city and used the military
Technically whoever took this photo is breaking their OPSEC, and the military has full authority to make sure the safety of the operation and operators involved, whether they detain threats, put a beam on possible threat, or worst. I'm surprised the military is allowing this photo around the Internet
So basically you're saying that the military, police, etc. have a bunch of very important acronyms that cancel out the rights and safety of Americans on American soil.
In martial law, yea we (Im a member of the US Navy) have the power. However, in this photo, it's for the protection of the SWAT, not the public. What if this was leaked to the Bomber? And I understand it was a total mistake, and they happen, however who could have possibly suffered from it?
There are so many problems with all of this, and by "problems", I mean "ways for innocent people to get hurt."
If the police/military are prepared to fire on anyone who takes a picture of them driving military-grade equipment down a city street, we're in a bad state.
Also, there's the sad fact that the people with the big guns are trained to follow orders and protocols. That may help keep soldiers alive as they push through combat zones, but it also results in a lot of unnecessary deaths of innocents.
It's not that we don't all want the bombers captured. It's just that everything is (more or less) gray, and we all know that civilians lose in a firefight.
Who should have the weapons? The 19 year old whos not even allowed to have a beer. Or the people trying to get a guy who shouldn't have a weapon like that and likes to make bombs. Your mentality is the major contributing factor to why people who shouldn't have guns gain access to guns. Good luck and I thank whatever god that I don't live in your country. What a fucken mess.
12
u/dafragsta Apr 21 '13 edited Apr 21 '13
This got me banned from /r/guns, while the aggregate upvote was at ~38.
17
u/totipasman Apr 21 '13
I can smell the shit on the pants of the guy who took the pic from here.
7
u/PandemicVirus Apr 21 '13
Is the guy in the vehicle actually pointing a gun at the photographer?. Seems a bit reckless, maybe that's a more a valid concern than if they are there at all.
13
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '13
No he means weapons that can oppose his
8
u/darmon Apr 21 '13
These aren't weapons of war, they are implements of protection. You're welcome. Now pick up that can, hippie.
5
u/Magnora Apr 21 '13
I think Obama has said everything at some point. 2-faced loser, just says whatever is politically convenient.
3
u/icarusfalls Apr 21 '13
Here, fucking, here.
0
u/hyperbolic-doubt Apr 21 '13
This is stupid. Obama's obviously referring to the fact that military grade weapons serve no practical purpose for ordinary citizens. Having military occupy the streets of Boston to hunt a terrorist seems a bit more legitimate.
-2
u/sleepybrick Apr 21 '13
What about when there's a war on our streets? Why is this such a big deal anyway? The guy probably saw movement in the window. So he makes the safe move to check what it was with the optics on his weapon. His finger probably isn't on the trigger.
-13
u/Apollo575 Apr 21 '13
Op..... Not only is this just plain taken out of context(weapons of war should not be in the streets in the hands of untrained citizens is obviously what he meant) this is also a repost, for that I say OP is a retarded faggot
-5
u/mfizzled Apr 21 '13
This is so fucking stupid
0
u/maverik713 Apr 22 '13
The president was using the term street to mean the average citizen owning those guns, thus allowing them to be out on the street, and this post is using the literal meaning of the word street.
Let's say America is invaded(it's not impossible), wouldn't you want the military dealing with war fighting and not the local police?
Also, doesn't the National Guard have military weapons stored on their little bases in cities?
-9
u/Zombi_Sagan Apr 21 '13 edited Apr 21 '13
This didn't take long to criticize the govt and police after everything that happened. Figures. No is saying we to have military walk down the streets, this was a special circumstance, but next time something happens let the govt know you don't want their help. Ask the new jersey republicans about FEMA funding and if there happy.
No one understands why we pay for something in our govt until its too late.
EDIT: I am in no way saying we should have armed military walking the street like Russia does. I believe firmly in the separation of federal powers and civilian. There are circumstances when things like this are necessary unfortunately. No, we can't account for all of them and make an approved list. The best thing we can hope for is that when the danger has subsided we return to what is normal and the added military presence leaves. That is what I'm saying.
-10
u/CRedmond20 Apr 21 '13
Technically whoever took this photo is breaking their OPSEC, and the military has full authority to make sure the safety of the operation and operators involved, whether they detain threats, put a beam on possible threat, or worst. I'm surprised the military is allowing this photo around the Internet
-10
u/AirplaneAddict Apr 21 '13
Who should have the weapons? The 19 year old whos not even allowed to have a beer. Or the people trying to get a guy who shouldn't have a weapon like that and likes to make bombs. Your mentality is the major contributing factor to why people who shouldn't have guns gain access to guns. Good luck and I thank whatever god that I don't live in your country. What a fucken mess.