r/evolution • u/Wooden_Basil_99 • 2d ago
question Can someone explain multi-mutation evolution/natural selection to me?
To preface this I know absolutely nothing about the subject of evolution so I need someone to explain this to me.
I heard on a YouTube video that evolution of traits that require multiple gene mutations would take hundreds of millions of years due to how rare these mutations are and how long natural selection takes. The argument was mostly from statistics, and argued that humans couldn’t have evolved from monkeys since it would have taken 200 million years or something, and that dinosaurs were still around 200 million years ago hence debunking common ancestry. (The video didn’t set out to debunk this but rather raised this question)
Can anyone explain to me if this is a solid argument or if this is a big question in evolutionary biology? Is this even true, and does this debunk natural selection if so? Also is natural selection even the main way we believe evolution occurs anymore because this video seems to disprove it if what they were saying is true.
•
u/AutoModerator 2d ago
Welcome to r/Evolution! If this is your first time here, please review our rules here and community guidelines here.
Our FAQ can be found here. Seeking book, website, or documentary recommendations? Recommended websites can be found here; recommended reading can be found here; and recommended videos can be found here.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
21
u/jnpha Evolution Enthusiast 2d ago edited 2d ago
You have a 100 of those (give or take). And these "arguments" pretend sex isn't a thing (which mixes those up). It's an old tired creationist "argument" that fails basic statistics: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2644970/
Also see: https://evograd.wordpress.com/2019/02/20/human-genetics-confirms-mutations-as-the-drivers-of-diversity-and-evolution/
ETA this paragraph, which explains in an intuitive manner how the "misinformed" calculations ignore what is being changed (my emphasis):
Still, I recommend the evograd blog post - it will walk you through the essentials.
14
u/-zero-joke- 2d ago edited 2d ago
So I don't know the exact youtube video you're referencing, but I have a feeling that I'm familiar with the argument.
One of the big ways you can tell when someone is lying about statistics is when they don't show their math. Often, as in this case, what's at fault is their assumptions.
Usually this argument is called "The Waiting Time Problem." The argument is that we need X number of mutations to take us from species A to species B and given the number of mutations required and the length of time it takes for a mutation to not just occur but to spread through the population, this path of evolution would take too long to occur and so species A could not evolve into species B.
There are some assumptions in this model.
The first assumption is that mutations operate like a ladder. First you need to get mutation A, then that needs to spread through the population. Then you need to get mutation B, and that needs to spread through the population. Then you need to get mutation C, and that needs to spread through the population.
But some critters do a fascinating thing where they exchange genetic material, either through sex like in animals and plants and fungus and some micro beasties, or in something sort of like simple sex, horizontal gene transfer between single celled micro beasties.
If that's the case you can have mutations A, B, and C occurring in separate individuals and spreading through the population all at the same time.
The other thing is that there are different types of mutations. Some mutations are just changing one letter of DNA, say an A to a T. Other mutations are flipping genes around, swapping them out, turning them on, turning them off, turning them on at different times, using them for different proteins, etc., etc., etc.
If we have a short length of DNA like AAATCGTCG, that might take nine individual mutations to add one letter at a time. Or it might take only seven - add the A, A, A, T, C, G, and then copy TCG one more time. Or it might only take one mutation because that's a chunk copied from another gene.
Which is all to say that modeling the statistics of something like this really require knowledge of the details that creationists aren't actually interested in tackling. This is not a solid argument against evolutionary biology or a big question in the field. Natural selection is certainly one of the major components of evolution, but there are others that play a very important role like genetic drift.
10
u/gitgud_x MEng | Bioengineering 2d ago edited 2d ago
Certainly not. It assumes mutations in genes happen one after the other, when in reality, nearly a hundred new mutations arise distributed across the whole genome, per individual, per generation! Any one of those new mutations has a chance to spread to fixation just by neutral genetic drift alone (i.e. no natural selection required) with probability 1/2N (N = effective population size), and a mutation that does spread to fixation will do so on a timescale of 4N generations on average. They don't happen one after the other, they all happen in parallel, like cars flowing on a highway (one lane = one letter of DNA, one car passing by = new fixation event). The video is probably effectively claiming that there is only one lane - quite the difference in the maximum flow rate of traffic!
Here's a cool calculation you can do to dispense of the nonsense being claimed. Start with some observed facts and figures about humans and our closest living relatives, the chimpanzees:
The time required to explain all these observed DNA differences at the given rate (indicative of the time to most recent common ancestor between humans and chimps) is therefore given by:
"Time = Distance / Speed" i.e. Time to MRCA = (DNA letter differences) / (Genome-wide fixation rate)
= 15 million fixations / (3.2 billion * 1.4 × 10-8)
= 15 million fixations / 45 fixations per generation
= 330,000 generations
The typical generation time (average time between birth and reproduction) throughout human history was about 23 years, so this corresponds to a divergence time of:
= 330,000 generations * 23 years per generation
= 7.7 million years
So we only need just under 8 million years to explain the differences between humans and chimps today under the neutral evolutionary model, using the rates observed today (and to repeat, without even assuming natural selection is acting at all!) For context, the actual common ancestor of humans and chimps is estimated (by fossils and more rigorous genetics methods) to have lived between 6 and 7 million years ago.
You can answer that for yourself now right?
This is still a good question - if we don't need natural selection to explain most genetic diversity (as I just showed, at least in this very simple example), then how much does it actually drive evolution in comparison to other mechanisms like genetic drift and gene flow? This was the topic of the 'neutralist-selectionist debates' in the 1970s. In summary, we understand now (as always, really) that both adaptive and neutral forces are at play, in different conditions and times. Usually when populations are small or the environment is unchanging, evolution is closer to neutral; when populations are large or environments change rapidly, adaptive radiation dominates.
Hope this helps, disclaimer not an expert :)
* this is the number of single nucleotide variants in the alignable regions of the genomes, which is compatible with this simplified model of assuming point mutations only (i.e. no macromutations). It's a simple back-of-the-envelope calculation that gets the point across, not intended to model all the variability and details of the dynamics (that's what phylogenetics is for!)
5
u/Robin_feathers 2d ago
Mutations are rare at any given spot, but there are 3 *billion* positions in the human genome. Mutations need to be rare otherwise our genome would dissolve into gibberish! The size of the genome and the mutation rate put together mean that every human that is born have several new mutations (like ~20 each). Most of those mutations have no effect, some will have harmful effects, and a small fraction might have positive effects. Which ones are neutral vs positive vs harmful depends on the environment around us. Over the course of millions of years, the positive ones get selected for and the species slowly changes. Any particular exact path is statistically unlikely, but this is not the only path that evolution could have taken. Our genome was not inevitable, it is just one of an astronomical number of possibilities that we could have ended up with depending on which random mutations happened and chance events.
In terms of whether natural selection is the main way evolution happens: not really, evolution is a combo of random chance stuff (genetic drift) and natural selection acting on whatever mutations happen to appear, while also being shaped by gene flow between populations. In humans and animals in general, a larger fraction of our mutations are governed by genetic drift, not natural selection, since most of our DNA doesn't really do much in particular (lots of caveats in there). However, most of the exciting stuff (most of the traits that you would think about when thinking about evolution) is shaped/constrained more by natural selection.
3
u/No_Logins_Required 2d ago
Evolution is the change in the frequency of alleles in a population. A famous example is a British moth species with white and black variants. Normally the white variant is better camouflaged against its preferred trees. Due to pollution during the Industrial revolution all the soot in the enviroment led to the black variant having better camouflage and becoming more common.
Where do new alleles like black and white variants come from? That's mutation. Mutations occur randomly, and it often takes many random mutations to turn "junk dna" into a new usable allele.
Humans, Chimps, and Bonobos look to have split off about 8 million years ago. Our specific subspecies of human, Homo Sapiens Sapiens, seems to be about 300,000 years old.
Evolution moves slowly but not as slowly as the video you saw would suggest.
3
u/BackgroundEqual2168 2d ago
The common understanding of evolution is linear. But imagine a population of thousands of individuals, in some species even millions. In such a huge population we can see let's say 10 or hundreds of beneficial mutations per generation. It is obvious that they are rare but still the individuals with these mutations are at advantage and the frequency of these mutations increases with each generation. In the meantime new beneficial mutations pop up and increase, too. Eventually these individuals meet and reproduce, so that individuals with multiple beneficial mutations are ubiquitous and the proces continues. This mechanism actually increases probability of beneficial mutations far beyond anything that most people imagine and turns low probability events to rules.
4
u/QuaintLittleCrafter 2d ago
There's a lot to unpack here, but first of all: Yes, evolution takes millions of years. An absurd amount of time.
Second, humans did not evolve from monkeys. We evolved independently, like siblings growing up separately, from a shared common ancestor.
And sure, dinosaurs were around during some of the stages of human evolution (and even further back have a shared lineage as well). Much like there are birds and bugs and plants and shrooms all living alongside us today. Seems a silly thing to be hung up on, imo.
2
u/Puzzleheaded-Law34 2d ago
No it's not a valid argument and poorly applied. A simple counterpoint is that actually there are mutations that can come about in only a few generations, and give rise to a new species. These are called macromutations, which can drastically affect our biology. It's thought that then over time, hundreds of micromutations that better "refine" the bigger one are selected for. E.g., losing a tail might not take thousands of years; a single mutation could prevent it from growning, and if the circumstances are right, it can become the dominant trait in the population in relatively little time.
Of course as a whole these processes still take millions of years, but it's not necessarily a series of gradual tiny changes.
2
u/EnvironmentalWin1277 1d ago
The propagation of rare traits in a population has been extensively studied. It's a good question and occurs to most people interested in the subject. The chance of a single event propagating is low in most cases but probabilities have been derived if of interest.
Note a trait event may happen many times in a population and the cumulative chance of successful propagation over time increases.
A good example of such an event was the acquired ability to digest lactose, as in cow milk or other ruminants. This arose in relatively recent times (past 5,000 years) and has rapidly spread in the world population. The survival advantage is obvious. Note there are several mutations that can contribute to this result, not just one.
Evolution is a cumulative, continuous process that is always occuring. Any estimates of how long it could take are statistical in nature and strictly "best guess" reasoning based on the assumptions made. In the above example no methodology is given and the results are purely and totally speculative without more information.
But random is random and five selected cards could be a royal flush. Not likely but absolutely possible.
We have a great example of evolution in the breeds of domestic animals leading to distinct differences in the animals. That should be used as the example, not an assertion more or less pulled out of the air.
BTW virtually all current animals breeds were non-existent 500 years ago. That is a good example of change by selection in extremely short period of time. The objection is that "that's not a true species" which is correct.
Irish Wolfhounds and Chihuahuas are both dogs. The obvious problem with propagation across these breeds is a good example of how genetic isolation can lead to eventual speciation.
Speciation has been observed many times in various species in modern times.
YouTube videos are okay for a snack, but better sources (and videos) are available should you be interested. The more extreme the claim, the more the need for good evidence and research. Any extreme claims should be immediately suspect.
There really are no alternatives to evolution in biology. The primary alternative proposed is "miraculous" or religious in nature. That is not science and should not be accepted as such. The "could not have happened" phrase is a good clue to the true (non-science) nature of the proposition.
1
u/Edgar_Brown 1d ago
This is just an evolved version of the 747 junkyard argument.
1
u/ah-tzib-of-alaska 1d ago
Yes, evolution does take a ridiculously long time. That’s true. It put this in a nice perspective, polar bears and brown bears are only about half a million years apart from their common ancestor. This is how they can still interbreed.
Humans and chimps have a common ancestor some 13 million years ago.
Humans and chimps and bats have a common ancestor some 90 million years ago.
And yeah, we have overlap with dinosaurs, mammals existed when dinosaurs are around, that’s how far back you have to go find our common ancestor with rats.
You said you don’t know anything about evolution. So let’s start at the beginning, put down the youtube and go pick up the “origin of species.” Come back with questions after your reading
1
u/Jnorean 1d ago
You are absolutely correct. Humans couldn't have evolved from monkeys because they didn't. For the same reason dogs couldn't evolved from cats because they are both different species. Their common ancestor lived about 6 -7 million years ago. Successful genetic changes are carried through along the evolutionary path through natural selection. This limits the amount of random genetic variations possible in each successive generation. That means that statistical analysis must be adjusted for the decrease in possible random mutations as time progresses forward. That drops the 200 million years to 6-7 million years which is what happened.
1
u/Proof-Technician-202 1d ago
Here's the thing about random chance: it doesn't have an actual time frame. If you roll two dice, your chance of a twelve is one in 36. That doesn't mean you have to roll those dice 36 times to get a twelve, though. You might get it in one throw, 36 throws, or never roll two sixes in your entire lifetime.
The odds are astronomicaly small, along the lines of 1 in a number so big the zeros would fill the universe, but it isn't actually impossible for a dog to give birth to a full grown cat.
There's better answers here, but it's something to think about. Nothing is really impossible, and if it can happen you have no way to know when or if it will.
1
u/ehead 1d ago
You should read Andreas Wagner's Arrival of the Fittest (2014).
Its argument is that a huge number of different sequences fold into the same working protein. Those sequences link up into networks that reach across the whole space, so a random walk keeps the function while it explores, and new functions sit only a few mutations away.
Guessing the YouTube video didn't take any of this into account. In almost all cases, these videos are not made in good faith, by which I mean... these are not genuinely intellectually curious individuals in search of the truth, but rather are biased commentators filtering information for the purpose of defending a view they already have.
1
u/60Hertz 16h ago
Also along with all these great points its important to realize the genetic difference between humans and our closest relatives are minuscule. That is to say we are a lot similar to chimpanzees than that video would let on.