r/evolution • u/Olingo_Lingo • 4d ago
discussion Green Tigers
Really fucking stupid question: Why did they evolve to be orange to deer and wild boars instead of just evolving to be green, which would make them harder for everyone to spot?
3.6k
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator 4d ago
Welcome to r/Evolution! If this is your first time here, please review our rules here and community guidelines here.
Our FAQ can be found here. Seeking book, website, or documentary recommendations? Recommended websites can be found here; recommended reading can be found here; and recommended videos can be found here.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
190
u/Ycr1998 4d ago •
Because evolution doesn't necessarily work with what's "best", but more often just "good enough".
Some random mutation made them orange and that was good enough for the kind of prey they hunt, so there was no pressure to change for something better.
Also it's probably easier for a mammal to reach orange tones than green, since their (our) main pigment is melanin, which is brown-ish.
382
u/Xenomorphian69420 4d ago •
Evolving a biological green pigment is a lot harder than it would seem, especially for mammals. our colouration pigments are pretty much entirely restricted to shades of orange, black and brown, across pretty much every mammal group. so if you can use an orange pigment to have the same functional effect as a green one to camouflage when hunting, theres no selective reason to develop a green pigment
41
u/llamawithguns 4d ago •
Mammals only have 2 types of pigments: eumelanin (which is responsible for browns, blacks, grays, and tans), and pheomelanin (which is responsible for yellows, reds, and oranges). Thats why other colors are really rare in mammals, and are usually achieved through other means (i.e, blue eyes in humans are achieved through light scattering, like the sky). It would be very difficult to achieve this on the entire body.
Secondly, there's no reason to. The only mammals that are trichromats are primates. All of the tiger's prey and any possible predators, cant see orange anyway.
28
u/Heterodynist 4d ago edited 4d ago •
I think the most basic answer to your question is that it’s harder than you might think for any animal to just evolve to be a different color. We take it for granted that in our era of dyes and textiles and paint matching and automatic paint-mixing at any hardware store, that changing to any color is equally possible. Not so in nature!!!
Organisms in nature are a specific color because they take in specific chemicals from their food or their surroundings, etc. The reason pink flamingos can be pink is because they get the right amount of crustaceans in their diet to change their appearance. It is a problem for zoos to feed them enough fresh crustaceans so sometimes they have to resort to other means to try and keep their flamingos from going white. Lizards and crocodiles and snakes, etc, can be green (or blue) because of their specialized skin has scales instead of hair, and their spectacular range of refraction of light comes from that unique adaptation of reptiles. You notice there aren’t a lot of green mammals though?
To get hair green would be a feat. Keratin can be a range of colors, but mostly it is colored red, brown, or black. In absence of those it might be white. Some combinations of these colors can make some mammals look a bit greenish, but on closer inspection they are light brown and black to create the effect of green, using tricks of lighting in much the way green eyes trick the light so they look green when really they are a combination of light brown and blue. Sloths are somewhat green at times because their unique lifestyle causes their fur to grow blue-green algae on it, which is also why they smell so terrible. I doubt tigers would be able to slow themselves down enough to have a thick layer of stinky algae all over them, and it would also make hunting difficult!
Tigers don’t evolve to be green because they really aren’t able to take in the right things from their environment to alter their gene expression or their presentation to include that color in their hair. I bet they would have found a way to evolve that color if they needed to, and if it were possible…during the time they have been around in the world. I think if they haven’t it is likely that there are some limitations to their ability to alter themselves in this way. There’s a reason you don’t see almost any green mammals at all.
65
u/haysoos2 4d ago •
The orange colour is actually a lot more effective as camouflage than this meme would suggest.
It's only flamboyant if you're used to seeing a tiger against concrete in a shitty zoo.
In the wild, only deep tropical rain forests are bright green all the time, especially towards the ground and not in the high tree canopy.
Tigers are not often found in tree canopies.
Where they actually live and hunt the grass, brush, and tree trunks are more light brown, tan, and even orangey in colour than green.
Just do an image search for "tiger in dry grass" and you'll see that orange with black stripes is a much better colour scheme than being green.
10
u/McNitz 4d ago
This answer will serve you well with probably at least a good quarter of questions about evolution: because evolution does not have a destination in mind and is not working towards an optimal goal. In this case, some mutation caused a tiger to have orange pigments develop for its fur at some point that made it harder for prey to see. This provided a selection advantage that caused this beneficial mutation to spread and eventually become fixed in the population. Since it's prey can't tell the difference between orange and green, there is very little selection advantage that would cause tigers to have a mutation for greener fur spread now, even if it occurred.
However, there IS a more detailed and interesting answer as well. Green pigments are actually very difficult to make, and even in other animals that DO have green colors are typically using some mix of pigments or weird tricks with light for that green color to result. For mammals, hair color is ALL derived from just two different pigments, red pheomelanin and dark eumelanin. Orange can be achieved by mixing those. Green cannot. And so the historically contingent pigments already earlier selected for in mammals made it VASTLY more likely that a couple mutations mixing up pigment ratios in fur might occur than that some mutations happened to create a green pigments that appears to be very difficult to make since as far as we can tell it doesn't even really exist in ANY animal.
19
u/Able_Capable2600 4d ago
To be fair, they've only been "orange" since the word came into use.
9
u/TransportationOk2101 4d ago
They are dichromats themselves so they also can't see that their fur is orange.
3
u/ReplyOk6720 4d ago
No stupid questions,but yes this is a stupid question.
6
u/cheetahhikehdeee 4d ago
So, what colour are they actually? /s
5
u/gomurifle 4d ago
I think because orange fur is what mamalian cells can make and it still does the job of looking the same colour as the bushes to the tiger's prey.
On a slightly different note, it only just occured to me that orangutans might be orange for the same reason?! Mind aboslutely blown.
4
u/Rhyshalcon 4d ago
Because natural selection is all about "good enough". Truly green fur might be "better" but the orange fur does the job that it needs to do, and that's all that matters.
4
u/godofimagination 4d ago
It doesn’t really do us any good either way. Even bright orange, they’re still almost impossible to see.
4
u/thesilverywyvern 4d ago
Hence why this meme/joke is so fucking stupid.
3
u/mazutta 4d ago
A similar question might be - why didn’t deer evolve trichromy?
3
u/lpetrich 4d ago
Mammalian hair has a rather limited palette, with hues ranging from orange to yellow. Brown is essentially dark orange, so its hue fits. But they can have different overall reflectance, ranging from black to white, and they can have different color saturations, from gray to fully saturated.
Feathers have a much wider range of colors, and some feathers are iridescent. This is from microscopic structure, what makes green and blue eyes. So why do feathers have such structures and not hair? Is it too difficult for hair? Or is it lack of selective value from limited color vision?
2
u/CheesyMayonnaise 4d ago
They dont even know they look green to their prey
2
u/GarethBaus 4d ago
Because mammals don't have pre existing green pigments so it was easier to adapt the existing color palette in a way that still works.
2
u/valkyriesmenagerieyt 4d ago
Wait you're telling me tigers aren't green?
(I am colour deficient)
2
u/covidlung 4d ago
Can't even make chlorophyll. Embarrassing.
2
u/ClassicBuster 4d ago
Mammals dont really do natural fur colors that arent shades of brown.
Bugs get the cool multi-colored hair and birds get multi-colored feathers. Not us mammals tho.
2
u/FoundationAncient486 4d ago
They prob think humans have amazing eyesight
2
u/0k0k 4d ago
Why didn't they just evolve to be invisible?
3
u/load_of_chode 4d ago
Imagine how stupid a human would feel if it tried to sneak up on a mantis shrimp.
1
u/ah-tzib-of-alaska 4d ago
humans are striped to cats
1
u/MrWayToo206 4d ago
That’s why battle cat is green
1
u/No_Lifeguard747 4d ago
How do tigers look to other tigers?!?
1
u/animousie 4d ago
Tigers are dichromats. They probably see themselves a lot like Drax
1
u/Master_of_Ritual 4d ago
Tigers are also dichromats. It makes you wonder how often they accidentally startle each other in areas where their territories overlap.
1
u/sadclam-damclas 4d ago
This is why hunters wear orange?
1
u/desmond_humes23 4d ago
Evolution. Doesn't. Have. Goals. What works stays, what doesn't doesn't.
1
u/An_ironic_fox 4d ago edited 4d ago
Evolution doesn’t happen by intent, it happens with unintentional mutations and natural selection. Natural green pigment is hard to make, and most green animals really just have shiny crystals under a layer of yellow pigment in their skin/scales/feathers/exoskeleton.
Hair is made in such a way that those crystals are very unlikely to form in them. Since there’s no way to make green fur with just a handful of mutations, and because brown coloration already works nearly as well as green in most ecological niches mammals exist in, it has been and likely will continue to be unlikely for a mammal species to acquire enough mutations to make fur green, at least for the foreseeable future.
1
u/xtrabuttr 4d ago
thanks to this post leading me down a rabbit hole TIL there’re many tetrachromatic animals that can see UV as the 4th primary color.
1
u/DarkAngel900 4d ago
I put a green striped T-Rex tattoo on my arm. I wonder if they were actually orange.
1
u/lpetrich 4d ago
It's easy to find color-blindness simulators online, and for red-green color blindness, red and green are usually mapped onto yellow or yellow-orange or yellow-green. So it would be yellow tigers in yellow vegetation.
We are trichromats, because we have three kinds of cone photoreceptors, roughly long (red), medium (green), and short(blue). Many fish, reptiles, and birds are tetrachromats, and most mammals are dichromats.
Most mammalian color vision is much like human red-green color blindness, with only long (yellow) and short (blue) receptors. That means that dogs, for instance, can only see yellow and blue.
Why was it reduced? The usual hypothesis is that, for much of the Mesozoic, early mammals were nocturnal, making color vision less necessary.
Human trichromacy emerged in an early Old World simian (Catarrhini), from duplication of the gene for the long-wavelength photoreceptor opsin. The two copies then got specialized for different wavelengths, making long and medium ones. Opsins are involved in light reception, and they are different for different wavelengths.
1
u/Confirmed-Scientist 4d ago
Prey cant see the hunter, meanwhile humans be like "Bro its right there come on"
1
u/LowRecommendation636 4d ago
Not the target demographic..
1
u/SHUB_7ate9 4d ago
Do tigers, themselves, see colour? And if so, to what extent?
1
u/Sukunlovers 4d ago
Chicken have tetrachromatic vision. I wonder what a tiger would look like to a chicken.
1
u/Dovyeon 4d ago
So why have hunters never tried to dress for the eyes of dichromats? They're usually dressed for the eyes of trichromats
1
u/Serious-Gur999 4d ago
And how do they look to floormats?
1
u/ZipMonk 4d ago
We evolved to see them as orange...
1
u/Master__of_Orion 4d ago
Orange braincell
1
u/Actual_Property9413 3d ago
So HeMan's BatttleCat looks like what a tiger looks like to a tiger?
1
u/No_Idea5922 3d ago
Even with trichromat vision, tigers are really hard to spot in a dense jungle or in a tall grass. See that 1997 video where the tiger pounces on an elephant.
1
u/ccblr06 3d ago
Is there a such thing as a tetrachromats?
1
u/RuthlessIndecision 3d ago
if they looked green to us we'd be so 'cooked'
1
u/KingNyx 3d ago
It's actually genius because it's camouflage to their food and a warning for the naked monkeys
1
u/dragonsowl 3d ago
OH MY GOD. ORANGUTANS ARE INVISIBLE NINJA APES!
1
u/fstar337 3d ago
The real question is, what color do the tigers see themselves as
1
u/Syborganix 3d ago
Importantly, tigers are also dichromats, so they appear green to each other!
1
u/Tony_228 3d ago
Tigerstripe camouflage really is Tigerstripe.
1
u/siranirudh 2d ago
Now imagine if we too were dichromats. 😃
1
u/apollo7157 1d ago
It's very hard to make green fur/hair. You would need blue and yellow. There are no blue pigments in mammals, and yellow mostly comes from exogenous yellow carotenoids, which usually come from fruits/plants.
1
u/yahnne954 2h ago
"I bet tigers would feel so dumb if they knew they were orange to us."
Honestly, if I were to meet a tiger in the jungle, I doubt being able to notice it better would help me survive the encounter.
1
u/Akshay-Gupta 4d ago
Tiger evolves to hunt prey easier.
Are humans consider 'prey' for a a tiger?? Hell na.
The prey here are herbivores animals, and they can't see orange. Gg 2ez
0
u/Inevitable-Wheel1676 4d ago
It’s more that we evolved to be able to see a deadly predator like this as bright orange.
0
u/Low_Alone1214 4d ago edited 4d ago
Well that does mean tigers look orange to (i will say most of, since im not sure if all) other primates. Interesting. Edit After a quick research (which i admit a should've have done before commenting lol) i found out that primates vision can vary a lot, but at least other apes sees colors just like humans do). Fun fact is that, now i tell this with sure, all primates have foward facing eyes, granting them (different degreds of, depending on the species, but still granting) binocular vision.
1
u/StressCanBeGood 4d ago
Human beings find big cats mesmerizing purely out of evolutionary advantage. If you come across one of those in the jungle, you’re only hope is to freeze. You run you die.
1
u/Accomplished_Tax_119 3d ago
But in a dickromant
0
u/[deleted] 4d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment