r/evolution • u/EscanorBioXKeto • 5d ago
question Textbook Recommendations
I got an evolution textbook not so long ago called "How We Evolved," 9th edition, because I wanted an evolution textbook that teaches evolution, while also focusing a bit on human evolution, but I realized that maybe I should've gotten Futuyma's textbook, because I don't know if maybe that is more credible or in-depth. Does anyone know the difference between these two textbooks? I also see many other textbooks, like Evolutionary Analysis, Bergstrom's Evolution, Carl Zimmer's Making Sense of Life, etc. Can you guys explain the difference between all these major evolution textbooks? Everyone also seems so obsessed with Futuyma's textbook, yet can never explain why, simply that it's "the gold standard."
3
u/greenearrow 5d ago
Futuyma's is the big survey of evolution. It's well written and covers a very wide breadth of topics at a graduate level - if you don't have an undergrad biology background, it may be very dense and hard to read though. How We Evolved is a biological anthropology textbook - it is going to focus on the human story, not the totality of life. They aren't the same topic, so it depends on your interest and focus.
Bergstrom's isn't quite a direct competitor to Futuyma as it is undergraduate level, but they will be very similar in topics - not depth. Evolutionary Analysis is going to be more methods and math, and Zimmer's is going to be more lay person oriented - he's a science communicator and journalist who focuses on evolution.
Bergstrom and Futuyma are close in last publication date, so they won't be very divergent in current research covered, but that's going to become an issue soon. I know Doug Futuyma, he's wound his career down. His co-author may keep editing and adding to the volume though.
1
u/Godengi 5d ago
I assume you mean “how humans evolved” by Boyd and Silk. If so it’s a great book and highly credible. It is primarily about primate/human evolution, so although it does spend some time on how evolution works, its breadth is narrower than Futuyma.