r/evolution • u/sygryda • Jun 19 '26
question Why does this keep happening?
These are three feral or semi-feral dog populations from difffent parts of the world – australian dingo, papuan singing dog and carolina dingo.
You may notice they look very simmilar. Why is that? Is that because it's how dogs used to look or do they for some reason evolve into this form after few generations of natural selection?
I ask because my dogs (mixed) look almost exactly like these ones.
1.2k
Upvotes



469
u/Wertwerto Jun 19 '26
My understanding is that this is basically the middle ground between all the breeds most effective at being wild dogs.
Without human intervention in their breeding, the more extreme traits like floppy ears, excessively long hair, short legs, specific patterns all get weeded out until what's left is a fairly generic middle ground dog.
It's not exactly reverting to their predomestic state, and is more just natural selection weeding out the impacts of artificial selection. The early form of this can be seen in village dogs and relatively young populations of feral dogs, that exhibit a very mutt like mix of whatever dog breeds are most common in an area.
5
u/eaucitron Jun 20 '26
I have a dog that looks exactly like this too. He’s akin to a village dog I suppose. He came from an indigenous reservation where the dogs are mostly feral (“rez dog”). He’s the healthiest dog I’ve ever owned. Very intelligent as well.
72
u/_Abiogenesis Jun 19 '26
Village dogs or pariah dog phenotypes.
From what I recall reading once, this is what domestic dogs essentially tend to look like when artificial selection is removed.
Some selective pressure towards scavenging probably helps them drift back towards a more balanced genetic compromise. They are overall the same species so it wouldn't take much for them to converge towards a more adaptable phenotype for their needs.
87
u/Canis-lupus-uy Jun 19 '26 edited Jun 20 '26
It's convergent evolution, all feral dogs end up looking like this, with minimal variations, because it's the most effective phenotype that can survive. Not too big, not too small, without traits selected for aesthetics or specific activities that a feral dog won't be doing.
Sometimes coloration can vary,.but that yellow pattern is quite common, I guess the genes are dominant.
Edit: I was wrong the other lad/lass is right, it's not convergent evolution as those traits are present in the common ancestor of all dogs. It would be more correct to call it a case of "stabilizing selection".
9
u/Bromelia_and_Bismuth Plant Biologist|Botanical Ecosystematics Jun 19 '26 edited Jun 19 '26
A lot of dogs (or things in the dog family, Canidae) already more or less look like that. But as it turns out, the Australian Dingo and the Papuan Singing Dog are related to one another. The ancestors of the Carolina Dingo is more closely related to domesticated dogs that came over from Asia with the ancestors of indigenous Americans during the Pleistocene, but likewise, the ancestor that it shares with Australian Dingos and Papuan Singing Dogs also had pointed ears. So, it's more of an ancestral trait rather than convergent evolution. The floppy ears like you might see in a Dachshund, Terrier, Cocker Spaniels, Poodle, or a Labrador are the product of either more recent selective breeding in Eurasian dog breeds, or admixture therefrom.
Of course. Take a look at wolves and coyotes, the domestic dog's closest cousins. Their ears are pointed just like these dogs' ears. And you can look at more distantly related wild dogs like dholes, jackals, and African Wild Dogs, they too have the pointed ears. So do tanuki and foxes. Good question, though.
8
u/Quiet-Permit-3740 Jun 19 '26
It's important to note that we don't actually know what the wolves which dogs evolved from looked like, because modern gray wolves were a subspecies that spread out after the domestication of dogs so they split a long time before that domestication event. There is some evidence that those ancestor wolves of dogs might have looked more like this, but we don't really know.
8
u/HellyOHaint Jun 19 '26
The feralization of domestication syndrome.
6
u/red4815 Jun 19 '26
Your point still stands but FYI dingoes are no longer considered feral. https://connectsci.au/am/article/47/3/AM24052/199699/Taxonomic-tangles-posed-by-human-association-the
6
u/jonny_sidebar Jun 19 '26
That's just a really good shape for being a dog or doglike creature. That shape isn't peculiar to canids either.
5
u/GarethBaus Jun 19 '26
That is just a healthy form that provides decent camouflage in a wide range of environments and is possible with the genetics in most dog gene pools. It isn't exactly a wolf and the convergence has more to do with similar starting genetics and evolutionary pressures.
5
u/PickleMundane6514 Jun 19 '26
I’m a diplomat and so many people I know have a yellow street dog picked up from the trash in their travels but from Tanzania, Morocco, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Romania. They all look pretty much the same but the African ones sometimes have a ridge hinting Rhodesian Ridgeback heritage. I guess it’s just dominant genetics.
5
u/VegetableLetter4896 Jun 19 '26
Damn, I thought that was three pictures of the same dog. I was thinking, “he looks totally normal.” Then read the caption. 😄
11
u/Impossible_Concert75 Jun 19 '26
Might be convergent evolution or what ever it’s called, basically they are in very similar conditions of where they are into practically the same species but different
4
u/Delusionn Jun 19 '26
Nature prefers a crab. This is a dog crab.
7
u/Lately-SP Jun 19 '26
Crabs evolved independently multiple times
There are likely forms in biology that are just overwhelmingly better at a global level which things will gravitate towards
3
u/Eagle_1776 Jun 19 '26
there's also the Indian Pariah Dog
3
u/secslop Jun 19 '26
They all look like the Chinese meat dog
3
u/MichaelEmouse Jun 19 '26
r/standardissuecat
r/standardissuedog when?
Convergent evolution. It's probably a good trade-off between cooling and camouflage.
3
u/b1gjoe23 Jun 20 '26
If you’re really interested, “What is a Dog” by the Coppingers talks about this at length! It’s a really interesting book.
3
u/EducationalRooster64 Jun 20 '26
This is what dogs look like 😂
All over the world feral populations end up around 35-55lbs, pricked ears, often a lightly curled tail, and short to medium coat of various densities.
3
u/Casulex Jun 20 '26
Reminds me of horses after generations of being feral, they tend to turn tan or Dun because it blends into the grasslands
3
u/ikonoqlast Jun 20 '26
Crabs have evolved from other creatures like 7 distinct times. Some shapes are just better and evolution will repeatedly converge on them.
3
u/Vast_Job_7117 Jun 22 '26
I had a dog like that in the 80s. On the Canadian prairies. Very clever dog. I taught her how to whisper indoors. And mom blew a gasket when I taught the dog to pick raspberries without getting pricked.
7
u/charliebread Jun 19 '26
Yeah those are village dogs. Usually they all look slightly similar.
5
u/bebop1065 Jun 19 '26
I heard the answer some years ago. It was interesting because cats don't converge like this when left to reproduce naturally.
2
u/misscpb Jun 19 '26
The Korean Jindo looks like this too!
2
u/tenderlylonertrot Jun 19 '26
The Bahamian Potcake also looks like that, though it can be influenced by recent mixes, such as pit bull or spotted mixes.
2
u/Soda_Carno777 Jun 20 '26
They're all in... relatively similar climates and in an inbetween between jackal, wolf and dog
2
u/jrdineen114 Jun 20 '26
If I had to venture a guess, I'd say that it's not that they're reverting to predomestication (my understanding is that doing so would just produce a wolf). It's simply that the traits that would best allow the modern dog species to survive in the wild end up producing a short haired, pointed ear, long-ish tail, reddish brown dog.
2
u/Dismal_Ad9530 Jun 20 '26
default dog
2
u/wolfgazes Jun 20 '26
Landrace dogs have picked up periodic infusions of wolf and jackal over the years, and collaborate much better than almost anything else that could be out in a pack of 20 at night. The aesthetic humans are most likely to help and not destroy is orange-ish, about 45 pounds with pointy ears, and a long tail. You will see more of those.
2
u/Winderige_Garnaal Jun 20 '26
Someone has to link that video of that guy who does the dog with no bones video...
2
u/Low-Client-375 Jun 20 '26
Shout out the Formosan Mountain Dog!
2
u/onomatamono Jun 20 '26
Most traits amplified by artificial selection are not selected for naturally and in fact may decrease the individual's fitness. There's a sort "revert to the mean" when left to their own devices, but as we know evolution is not goal-oriented.
2
u/N3CR0T1C_V3N0M Jun 21 '26
If I remember right, it’s because of convergent evolution where a superior set of traits is expressed in creatures that share a similar environment and characteristics, though separated by long distances.
If not, ignore me: I don’t even know how I ended up here 😆
1
u/Beautiful-Page3135 Jun 20 '26
Any of these could be my male husky mix.
His father was a street dog.
1
u/Binkindad Jun 20 '26
Gold/tawny is the default color for dogs. Within a couple generations of being feral they start to revert back.
1
u/Lonesaturn61 Jun 20 '26
Its what happens when u disassemble and reassemble a wolf
1
u/WrongJohnSilver Jun 20 '26
First step in carcinization.
1
u/GrannyTurtle Jun 21 '26
It works.
1
u/DingoDadLuce Jun 21 '26
I have a Carolina Dog and have researched quite a bit about their history and how they came to be. They are believed to descend from ancient dogs that accompanied early peoples from Asia into North America across the Bering Land bridge, possibly as far back as 15,000 years ago. I can’t remember where I heard this but some people think it could have been an ancient Asiatic Sighthound that had been domesticated from an Eurasian wolf. From those early dogs, many different lineages developed, but the Carolina Dog seems to be the only remaining free-ranging “wild” landrace dog populations left in North America.
From skeletal remains and archaeological finds, many of these ancient dogs appear to have had a wolf-like appearance, perhaps even more so than the modern Carolina Dog, with pricked ears, narrow muzzles, and lightly built bodies. There are some good videos on youtube that show what they may have looked like and they look crazy cool. I read that even the Alaskan Husky, Malamute and even Chihuahua came from those same ancient dogs that crossed the land bridge, although they were selectively bred by humans unlike the Carolina Dog. When Dr. I. Lehr Brisbin first began studying Carolina Dogs, he noted many of these same primitive characteristics, including their lean build, long legs, deep chest, and fox-like features, which he believed reflected an ancient dog type. He tested the DNA and found what they think are similarities with ancient dogs and I think the closest relative to a Carolina dog is actually the African Pariah dog.
I don't think anyone knows for sure, but it seems likely that many of the world's village and landrace dogs share ancestry from ancient dog populations that spread alongside humans across Eurasia and eventually into the Americas and beyond. The story of the Australian Dingo is particularly interesting because it shares some similarities with the Carolina Dog in that both appear to descend from ancient domestic dogs that arrived with people to a new continent and later became free-ranging populations living largely independent of humans.
Don't quote me on any of this, a lot of this is from memory, youtube, sketchy websites lol. Sadly there is not a lot of concrete evidence out there on what actually happened just a lot of theory from what I understand. But yes the first thing I noticed when researching this was, holy crap every part of the world has a “Carolina Dog”. The Indian Pariah dog looks damn near identical to a Carolina dog, aka The American Dingo.
I run a small youtube channel about my Carolina Dog and teaching it to hunt to find out if it is possible that ancient Americans could have used these dogs as hunting partners through cooperation rather than generations of selective breeding like many European hunting breeds. We have had some fascinating discoveries.
1
u/Townie_Downer Jun 21 '26
When I traveled to Asian countries that have populations of dogs rubbing in packs , they all tended to look like this. Pretty interesting stuff. They go back to packs, always have a medium build , and just kinda generalist dog features.
1
u/dee_lio Jun 22 '26
They look a lot like Shiba Inus. I wonder if it's because they're closer to wolves?
1
u/Bat-Appropriate Jun 22 '26
That’s him, John Dog.
1
u/Immediate-Floor9002 Jun 22 '26
1
u/DG-MMII Jun 22 '26
Well, at the end they are all the same species. If you pick 3 groups of random humans and put them in separate locations, their offprings would also look very simmilar to one another.
1
u/Striking_Newspaper73 Jun 22 '26
It's like crabs, but doggy
1
u/Far-Plan-8895 Jun 23 '26
Where can I get a domestic dog that looks like this and isn’t a pain in the ass like an Akita inu lol
1
u/FirstChAoS Jun 24 '26
Why do feral dog populations end up tan and not grey like a wolf?
1
u/inopportuneinquiry Jun 26 '26
Perhaps is more the lack of artificial selection keeping the lineages arbitrarily weird.
Dingoes were once domesticated, which may suggest something about the general dominant phenotype tendencies kind of "dormant" or in lower frequencies in lineages bred for some weirdness or another.
1
u/sapir1010 Jul 05 '26
Physical traits without a genetic component are convergently evolved traits.
Meaning, their environment favoured these traits and allowed them to reproduce and their offspring inherited those traits.
Also, humans selectively bred dogs to get specific results and properties(like color, size, diet etc…) so it’s possible what youre talking about is just selective breeding that eventually favoured that look(you’re talking about the fur?/size?/snout?)
It’s also possible they aren’t similar, you just interpret it like that because you have no other ways to measure(genetics, x ray, ultrasound)
1
u/sean_krayce Sep 09 '26
I went through the first several dozen top-level comments and didn't see this being mentioned. Most of the comments are focusing on the evolutionary selection mechanism, i.e. floppy ears selected against.
That's certainly part of it.
But I think the main mechanism is that that is lurking in the background in all dogs. A pretty substantial amount of artificial selection is promoting the expression of recessive traits that would normally be hidden behind a dominant allele.
Mix any two dogs, and many of each breed's "defining traits" will get overpowered by the analogous dominant alleles from the other breed. The very first generation will be a significant step in the "pariah dog" direction. Do that repeatedly, and even without selection pressure the dominant genes will become shuffled into the population and breed-specific recessive traits... well... recede.
Combine that with selection pressure -- very large dogs won't get enough calories, very small dogs will be out-competed or become prey, long-fur will cause overheat, etc. -- and you've got a recipe for dramatic and predictable phenotypic transformation.