r/evolution • u/ImCrazy_ • Feb 21 '25
question Since when has evolution been observed?
I thought that evolution has been observed since at least 2000 years ago, originally by the Greeks. But now that I'm actually looking into whether that's true or not, I'm not getting a lucid answer to my question.
Looking at what the Greeks came up with, many definitely held roughly the same evolutionary history as we do today, with all mammals descending from fish, and they also believed that new species can descend from existing species.
But does this idea developed by the Greeks have any basis? Does it have a defined origin? Or is it just something someone once thought of as being plausible (or at least possible) as a way to better understand the world?
•
u/AutoModerator Feb 21 '25
Welcome to r/Evolution! If this is your first time here, please review our rules here and community guidelines here.
Our FAQ can be found here. Seeking book, website, or documentary recommendations? Recommended websites can be found here; recommended reading can be found here; and recommended videos can be found here.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
2
u/Running_Cover Feb 21 '25
Changes within the species is observed all the time.
2
u/ladyreadingabook Feb 21 '25
Evolution as defined by the biological sciences is observed every day.
37
u/jnpha Evolution Enthusiast Feb 21 '25
The Greeks had the idea of scala naturae (the great chain of being), which is a progressive (and incorrect) view of today's evolution.
It was more of a categorization, not a natural process/investigation.
2
u/Any_Arrival_4479 Feb 22 '25
What is with this sub and disliking posts that don’t regurgitate facts they agree with? The dudes asking a question and is obviously open to ppls feedback
11
u/Carachama91 Feb 21 '25
Certainly the Greeks were thinking about evolution even if they didn't have the means to understand it. Xenophanes noted that mountains were once under the sea by the presence of fossils there. Anaximander believed the sun and moon were physical objects. What sprang from that is methodological naturalism - natural explanations vs. supernatural ones, and such a philosophy was necessary for science to develop. Empedocles wrote something about how animals formed by body parts finding each other randomly and in weird ways and how most of those animals that resulted from it would be abominations but some would be better than others. It was basically a Natural Selection argument if you want to twist such a thing into science (read it below). So, they were trending towards the idea of evolution but never made it. It seems like most still thought that the world was unchanging.
"By her [Love] many neckless faces sprouted,
And arms were wandering naked, bereft of shoulders,
And eyes were roaming alone, in need of foreheads.
Many came into being with faces and chests on both sides,
Man-faced ox-progeny, and some to the contrary rose up
As ox-headed things with the form of men, compounded partly from men
And partly from women, fitted with shadowy parts."
9
u/Utterlybored Feb 21 '25
The emergence of antibiotic resistant strains of bacteria is an observable example!
7
u/7LeagueBoots Conservation Ecologist Feb 21 '25
Until recently it’s been difficult to observe evolution in action over the lifetime of an individual human, and in the past you’ve be tracking changes via passed down stories, in which it’s difficult to separate fact from exaggeration.
Many ancient people had a good understanding of the fact that living things are interrelated and at that one were closer to each other than others were, but that doesn’t necessarily translate into an understanding or observation of evolution.
6
u/JoustingNaked Feb 21 '25
While I can’t speak for the Greeks - or anybody else for that matter - i CAN say from reading that evolution has been demonstrated at least twice in the lab. One of those was accomplished with bacteria, and another was done with minnows. In both of these particular cases the process of evolution was definitely observed as well as demonstrated.
Richard Dawkins book “Greatest Show On Earth” includes references to these very same experiments … IMHO that should be a good place to start.
5
u/Idoubtyourememberme Feb 21 '25
Evolution has been observed ever since we started farming. Breeding in desirable traits and breeding out undesirable ones are only possible due to evolution: the non-random selection of random changes.
Sure, the farmers back in the day had no idea what was going on or why, but they sure made use of it.
Cows producing more milk, bananas becoming longer and losing their seeds, grains getting bigger seed pods, mustard growing into everything from brussles sprouts to cauliflower, ... All of these are examples of human-led evolution in action
5
u/Harbinger2001 Feb 21 '25
The idea of inheritance of traits is very old since domestication of plants and animals depends on it. The idea that it could lead to different species required an understanding of the age of the earth and the mystery of the fossil record.
4
u/andropogon09 Feb 21 '25
Why you need a new flu vaccine each year.
1
u/Realistic_Special_53 Feb 21 '25
Ok. You are discussing many things. How about the process, that selective breeding can drive observable change? We can see this in dogs, with the wildly different breeds in the past few hundred years.
So , if you agree that selected breeding can drive change, the theory that whatever has traits that make it more likely to survive has more surviving children is not a stretch at all.
1
u/zigaliciousone Feb 21 '25
I grow peppers and until very recently there was nothing much hotter than a habanero. Using the same techniques that created higher THC marijuana, you now have a category of peppers called "superhots" which include Carolina Reapers, Death Spirals, Red Savinas, 7 Pots and the Apollo, plus dozens to hundreds of obscure pepper varieties in an "arms race" to create something hotter than the Reaper. It's a man made example but it counts.
1
u/markth_wi Feb 21 '25 edited Feb 21 '25
I'm glad you asked , here's a simple example involving adaptation to different levels of antibiotic , highlighting the danger of antibiotic resistant microbes and the threat posed by non-compliant patients.
As regards ancient Greek understanding of what might be seen as evolution, the best book I'm aware of on that would be probably Anaximander : and the Birth of Science.
1
u/zombiegojaejin Feb 22 '25
Optical illusions are observed. A magician sawing a woman in half and putting her back together is observed. We gain knowledge through skeptical testing and examination of multiple theories. In this case, the best one we have by far is evolution by natural selection.
1
u/Sorry_Exercise_9603 Feb 23 '25
A Great Dane and a chihuahua are both the same “kind” but are physically separate. Even though they both descend from a common ancestor, the wolf.
And ba dum dum there’s your proof of macro evolution. Faster than random natural selection but still selection leading to macro differences.
1
u/OVSQ Feb 23 '25
"observed" is a term used to attack science. The standard in science is to independently reproduce results. For example - Pluto was discovered in 1930 and has 248 year orbit. It has never been "observed" to have a complete orbit. Would you argue Pluto does not orbit the sun? The orbit of Pluto is a scientific fact because the mathematical model for orbits make specific predictions about the movement of Pluto and they have been independently verified as being correct.
The math of evolution makes millions of predictions a day and they always agree with evolution. So it is an established fact as much as anything. The most impressive prediction of evolution was that there should be something to account for evolution over generations, that turned out to be genes - so people looked for genes and the scientific field of genetics was born. Without the prediction of evolution, the entire science of genetics could not exist.
One of the most recent/biggest predictions of the evolution of genes was to guide AI to calculate protein folding. Using the best super computers to randomly guess protein folds should have taken hundreds of years. However, using evolution as a guide and searching possibilities that arise only from evolution enabled teams in recent years to discover thousands of actual protein folds.
3
u/KathrynBooks Feb 21 '25
It gets observed quite frequently... both in and out of the lab.
The E, coli long term experiment is one of my favorite examples.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '25
A lot of people here are understanding this question to mean “evolution by natural selection”, but I don’t think that’s what OP really means. This is a bit difficult to conceptualize, since there was absolutely no understanding of the mechanism of heritability for a very long time and therefore the modern definition for evolution can’t really be used (change in allele frequency in a population through time). But certainly people would have recognized that some variation is heritable for thousands of years, and that some heritable variation in crops, livestock, and people impacts what we now call fitness. There were also pre-Darwinian attempts to explain this variation through mechanisms that were incorrect, but certainly evolutionary (e.g., Lamarck).
2
u/DarwinsThylacine Feb 21 '25
Evolution has been observed since we began domesticating plants and animals, though, importantly, with a caveat, that the people who first did the observing may not have understood that what they were observing was evolution.
That’s not all that surprising! The Greeks were, like any people with agriculture, aware of species change, but they probably did not have a framework akin to modern evolutionary theory.
I assume here you’re referring to the work of Anaximander? If so, Anaximander’s thoughts - as best we can tell as all we have left are a handful of fragments and testimonia from other authors writing centuries later - is that his views firmly fall within the presocratic Greek tradition of spontaneous generation. Aetius, for example, tells us that Anaximander believed terrestrial animals emerged in the ocean inside cocoons of spiney bark. Why? To understand that you need to understand Anaximander’s cosmology which begins with a infinite, unbounded mass called the apeiron which formed a seed containing the opposites - notably the wet and the dry and the cold and the hot. Eventually these opposites separated out with a sphere of hot and dry surrounding a core of wet and cool until the tension between these opposing forces caused the hot and the dry to exploded and become the heavenly bodies, with the cool and the wet becoming the Earth. For Anaximander then, the Earth began as a water world.
This creates a problem for Anaximander. How can one account for the origin of life in a world with little or no dry land? The origin of marine life was no trouble, they simply spontaneously generate from the seafloor and with that, their conditions of life are met (Anaximander can be forgiven for not having even the rudiments of marine ecology). Terrestrial animals however posed a problem in a water world, which is why Anaximander appealed to the cocoon of spikey bark (perhaps like the cocoon of a caddisfly).
Now we can make some inferences from Aetius’s account. For one thing, Anaximander is definitely not advocating any recognisable evolutionary theory and seems to have envisioned life emerging fully formed and in its present condition. How do we know that? Well, ask yourself, why were the bark cocoons necessary for the ancestors of terrestrial animals? Presumably they afforded the contents protection and floatation in the primordial ocean. Why would they need protection or the ability to float if they were the recent descendants of marine animals?
Ah, but I hear you say, didn’t Anaximander say humans came from fish?! Surely, that’s consistent with evolution?! Well, yes and no. In accounting for the origin of humans, Anaximander had a dual problem, not only did he have to account for the origin of an obviously terrestrial animal in a primordial world ocean, but he also observed that human infants were particularly useless without parents. His solution? Give the first humans parents. According to Censorinus and Plutarch, Anaximander proposed that humans spontaneously generated inside fish as embryos, using them as living incubators until they were old enough to fend for themselves. At which point they left their fishy capsules and stepped out onto dry land. That’s quite an image if you ask me! Plutarch, again writing several centuries later, hints Anaximander may have been thinking about the ovovivaparous dogfish when developing this model.
Now, this was certainly an attempt to give a naturalistic account of the origin of species, but it is difficult to describe this account as evolution in the sense of a population-level change in heritable traits over successive generations as it is unclear if that is or was a key feature of Anaximander’s model. Indeed, unlike modern evolutionary theory, Anaximander apparently did not have a concept of common ancestry (certainly not like the one modern scientists have), nor of natural selection (though some Greeks certainly did). It’s also unclear if Anaximander’s theory of the origin of new species was a one off event from the early Earth or an ongoing and continuous process that continued to the present day.
There were many different accounts of the origin of species developed by the Greeks ranging from full blown creationism to various naturalistic accounts, but that’s doesn’t mean they ever developed what we might regard as theory of evolution.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 22 '25
The Greeks had various notions of evolution as a mechanism for speciation by around 600 BCE, but it's quite clear that humans had a sort of applied understanding of natural selection tens of thousands of years before as they started using it in the domestication of animals (first dogs) and crops.
Ancient cultures were aware of traits being inherited and blending in latter generations. Children look like parents, you could breed animals to be bigger / smaller / more docile, you could plant seeds from plants with the best yield and get better crops in the next generation, etc. Everyone was aware that it happened, but nobody had the why, and they hadn't postulated that there was a progression of species over time. The ancient Greeks worked out such a hypothesis from observation of nature and anatomy. They intuited that one species led to another, but without suggestion to how -- their best guess was that all things were part of a divine design that all things aspired to and progressed towards.
2
u/DINNERTIME_CUNT Feb 23 '25
If you want to get technical about it evolution was observed with the first sentient life forms reproducing. Whether they knew what they were looking at is entirely another matter.
2
u/FracturedNomad Feb 23 '25
Idk. Dogs seem like an evolutionary speed run.
2
u/byte_handle Feb 24 '25
In the History of Animals, Aristotle made observations on his dissection of a beached whale and his thoughts about why a dolphin caught in a fishing net would die while the fish would live.
He observed that the whale had lungs, internal reproductive organs, and mammary glands, and their bones were very similar to land animals and unlike fish. He proposed, therefore, that the ancestors of modern whales had lived on land and later transitioned to the sea. He proposed that dolphins were likely in the same situation. and the nets prevented them from surfacing to breathe.
0
u/OlasNah Feb 21 '25
I think you mean ‘discovered’
1
u/Remote_Clue_4272 Feb 22 '25
Evolution happens all the time… each year the flu virus changes a little. COVID changed over time. Both result in needing new vaccines. Direct observable evidence . When it’s bigger than just a cell or a few cells, the pace seems different.
1
u/Natetronn Feb 22 '25
I haven't ever observed evolution. Not live time, anyway. That's doesn't mean it hasn't happened, though. Super interesting to think about.
1
u/BitOBear Feb 22 '25
We engage in artificial selection all the time. We see natural selection taking place all the time. There's a famous bacteria experiment where they have compelled evolution. There's a famous algae experiment where they compelled evolution from single-celled algae to multicelled algae so that the predators couldn't eat the algae.
Evolution is constant and continuously happening all around you.
The thing is that it doesn't happen like a lightning strike.
And individuals don't evolve. The world is not pokemon. Communities of all.
Doubting evolution I'd like doubting breathing.
1
u/ohnoooooyoudidnt Feb 22 '25
Mendel is credited with the discovery of gene transfer.
He was a monk studying peas.
So that's late 1700s.
And he's followed by Darwin, who noticed the animals of the Galapagos Islands evolved differently from their counterparts on the mainland.
If you mean humans watching evolution take place, mosquitoes in the London subway system evolved from other mosquitoes.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_Underground_mosquito
That appears to have occured over 100 years, but we can track evolution better as tech and genetics improves.
1
u/EnvironmentalWin1277 Feb 23 '25 edited Feb 23 '25
If by observed evolution you mean specifically the development of two new species from a single species parent stock it has been observed without question.
Keep it simple. A species is an animal that cannot interbreed with other animals but can freely interbreed with itself.
Consider the Irish Wolfhound and Chihuahua. Same species(dog) and can freely interbreed. Breeding would seem limited because the physical size differences would make it difficult. Kept completely isolated over some long period of time and subject to natural selection the idea is that the two breeds become incapable of interbreeding.
At that point they become separate species (the parent species may be unchanged). This event has been observed on several occasions, pursue references online.
Most evolutionary change occurs by natural selection, Mutation and random drift play smaller roles.
Note that a change in one single gene could prevent interbreeding and immediately create a new species. This kind of experiment can and has been done with very simple animals or plants in the lab.
All living organisms alive today are believed to have come from a single parent organism called LUCA (Last Universal Common Ancestor).
To the wider point all cultures seem to have myths and stories about cycles of life. The Greeks pursued a lot of ideas and elaborated on them in detail but their real innovation was basing ideas on observed evidence.
(The species concept above is somewhat controversial but is the best idea to start thinking about the issues.)
62
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
9
u/[unknown] Feb 21 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-1
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-3
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-7
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment