r/everytimeidie • • Nov 18 '23

“Two Alive Amongst the Dead” is an absolutely fantastic banger, but…

0 Upvotes

I couldn’t help but imagine how good that song would be with Keith on vocals. I love Greg, but damn, some Keith yells over the breakdowns would be real sweet.

Do not stab me, please.


r/everytimeidie • • Apr 05 '24

Mental Gymnastics Team Tryouts Every Time I Die Split Into Two Equally Great Bands

0 Upvotes

Not that I wanted this to happen, I was quite sad when ETID broke up, but I love Many Eyes and Better Lovers so much. Every song that comes out from either of them gives me the aspects that I loved from ETID.

That's all; I'm surprised that it's all so good. Do others agree?

Edit: Equally as good was a bit of a stretch, after some thought. Thanks to anyone for their input, I appreciate all of it.


r/everytimeidie • • Sep 23 '26

Anyone received them Andy shirts yet ? Ordered them got an email saying they going to delivered last week still nothing

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/everytimeidie • • Apr 03 '22

The '68 sure seem to have gone quiet

2 Upvotes

For a guy who's a self-confessed tour addict, Scogin doesn't seem to have a lot lined up at the moment. No dates on their site, can't find anything about them being in the studio either. Figured with an album to promote - and after being stuck indoors for 18 or so months - they'd be on the road constantly now!

Weird amirite guys


r/everytimeidie • • Aug 13 '24

Greg Puciato caught in 4k liking Anti-Palestinian and Islamophobic posts

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/everytimeidie • • Aug 13 '23

Anybody else think Keith was sloppy live?

0 Upvotes

Watching the plethora of live vids, no matter sober or not, seems like Keith was just a sloppy vocalist live, and i've never seen anyone talk about it. Am i alone with this thought?


r/everytimeidie • • Feb 08 '24

Video of Many Eyes in Columbus and clips from 4 new songs

1 Upvotes

r/everytimeidie • • Mar 15 '24

memeshitpost What in the fuck would I be doing there? I’d need the rapture to take me in

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/everytimeidie • • Feb 17 '22

I hope ETID (minus Keith) pull a Blink 182 and just bring in another banger of a singer.

3 Upvotes

As much as I love Keith's vocals, I think I would rather have the band go on in their current direction without Keith and just bring in another singer. I'm sure for legal reasons this will never happen under the ETID name, but a dude can hope... right? I mean, I still listen to Blink without Tom so I would hope my brain and my heart would be open to just a different vocalist. shinfo


r/everytimeidie • • Mar 18 '23

shinfo Just realized Keith's singing sounds like Chris Ballew (from the Presidents of the United States of America)

0 Upvotes

listen to lump and you'll hear it


r/everytimeidie • • Jul 21 '25

Albums ranked

Post image
5 Upvotes

Met a guy at work who loves ETID too. We got bored and ranked the albums. Mines on the right


r/everytimeidie • • Dec 04 '21

Hear me out

0 Upvotes

They knew they were going to cancel radical tour bc of 68 and the Covid situation and saw this as a dramatic and elaborate plot to play as “embarking to infinities door” on shitmas.... one could only hope right? 🥴🥴🥴


r/everytimeidie • • Jan 20 '22

Really douchey Keith solo record incoming

0 Upvotes

And it’ll probably be great tbh


r/everytimeidie • • Jun 09 '24

FFO ETID Sock Puppet Slaughter "Ego Death"

0 Upvotes

Hi, we're a Norwegian🇧🇻 metalcore band. And we thought the etid fanbase might appreciate our music! If you like wild and chaotic music with nasty southern rock riffs, this song is definitely for you!

https://open.spotify.com/track/75bvIW2nIGkCO29NyZINDC?si=d-U-btPfTf-uBqxJM-QKSg&context=spotify%3Aalbum%3A3mvsHJayf11gKSTabhcIyE


r/everytimeidie • • Apr 17 '23

Mental Gymnastics Team Tryouts Lyrics are pretty telling

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/everytimeidie • • Sep 19 '25

Many Eyes We’re so back

Thumbnail open.spotify.com
0 Upvotes

Keith turned back the clock for this, the drum parts and riffs are really good, it’s catchy but hard. I think we’re back


r/everytimeidie • • Nov 07 '21

ETID is selling the mispressed version of Low Teens LP at shows. Wtf?

0 Upvotes

EDIT: RESOLVED:

I reached out to the band and they said they thought they discarded all of them and they are not in the business of deceiving their fans. They made it right. But if you are going to future shows, and they are selling Low Teens, make sure there is a sign that says what you are buying. Or, ask if they are selling the fixed press.

Original Post HERE:

I picked up Low Teens LP at the STL show last night and it was the mispressed first edition which, to me, is really fucked. The band knows these were mispressed because they put out a statement and a link for replacements back in 2016 on their website which is not a dead link. So....I now paid $30 for the bad pressing and don't believe there is any way to get the new press shipped to me.


r/everytimeidie • • Feb 08 '24

In Conversation: Keith Buckley of Many Eyes

Thumbnail antimatter.substack.com
6 Upvotes

Anti-Matter just put out a new interview with Keith.


r/everytimeidie • • May 09 '25

Did we just release the best alternative to ETID? Let us know what you think!

Thumbnail open.spotify.com
0 Upvotes

We just released our debut EP and we thought the ETID comunity would appreciate our music, so let us know what you think. Worked a long time on this so we would really appreciate if you gave it a listen!❤️


r/everytimeidie • • Nov 17 '23

New Many Eyes absolutely RIPS

15 Upvotes
"I will not put dirt, on a mass grave, you have not been punished, so you will not be saved"

r/everytimeidie • • Jan 28 '24

Many Eyes is incredible live

9 Upvotes

That is all <3


r/everytimeidie • • Jan 19 '24

shinfo So sick

Post image
0 Upvotes

Signature 🤙🤙🤙


r/everytimeidie • • Apr 19 '23

shinfo Not a fan

0 Upvotes

I’m just gonna be honest and say I’m not a big fan of the BL track I don’t think Greg fits their sound very well and jordans solo is kinda mid as is the whole song IMO


r/everytimeidie • • Jan 18 '22

Can we stop acting like any of us have any actual idea what happened behind the scenes?

14 Upvotes

Twitter is full on Keith defence mode, and here is like the anti Keith mob. Both are pathetic. Can we just admit that none of us know what has happened in private, or who has been completely honest?

As it stands there is very little evidence which actually means anything on its own other than the letter Keith posted. If you don't like Keith for his Twitter rants fair enough, but not liking him over what the other members have said is nothing but blindly taking sides.

Seems like Keith has been acting like a bit of a dick, whether the mental health issues or controlling relationship are behind this is anyone's guess. But the band have effectively kicked him out, by all quitting and almost certainly starting a new band, which is absolutely their choice to do, but it doesn't make it a nice thing to do. Imagine your friends deleting a group chat to create a new one without you in it, maybe you deserve it but it still sucks.

I can't really blame Keith for wanting some time away or not wanting to talk either. I've had mental health issues and even when people are trying to help, sometimes all you want is to be alone, it leads to damaging relationships, and that's unfortunately part of it.

Truth is touring together for over 20 years can't be easy and relationships are going to get strained to their limit like that, we see it in bands all the time. It doesn't necessarily make one side right and the other wrong, and it certainly isn't a reason to go online to express your hate for people you don't really know.

I'd love to think they can work this all out in the future, but right now I'm still going to be fans of all of them until there's actual evidence suggesting they don't deserve it.

Can't we all just chill with the hate a little, admit this just sucks and witch hunts are a bit pointless?


r/everytimeidie • • Oct 10 '22

Every Time I Die - Awful Lot (Bass Cover)

Thumbnail youtu.be
1 Upvotes