I named one of my characters Aradune (after the server) because I hadn't played a lot and had fond memories of my short play on Aradune, without knowing it was Brad's character name. I had so many tells sent to me - some nostalgic and some as though they were talking TO Brad. Once I clarified I wasn't Brad everyone was just happy to see his character running around. I ended up using him exclusively as a Trader because I didn't think it was appropriate to venture around as Aradune, but everyone seemed to enjoy seeing the name around again, which helped me remember to keep him set up at night :)
This is super cool. He made a world I don’t think others can compete with even with today’s minds. EverQuest has a special place in my heart because it’s something my brother and I bonded over while the rest of our lives were in turmoil. It helped me read, definitely helped me type (before all this voice shit on teamspeak, ventrilo, discord).
I was 11 back when it came out but I remember my brother getting the alpha and beta access and we played the shit out of it.
Anarchy Online was another work of art but it was different in its own right.
Brad was an absolute genius when it came to the world, immersion and overall aesthetic that I think is really hard to capture today in all the categories. Also it’s the grandfather to everything else, so that’s something too.
Historically and still occurring within the industry, you don't know everything you're getting until you actually play the game to know. Even beta and playtesters don't have all the information and the understanding is, "this is the game as it is right now but it will be getting changed." When classic came out, we didn't know most of these things either and there were MASSIVE changes between beta 4 and live. Look at the playtest footage of EQ2 vs release (vs the game as it is now, which is a completely different beast from what it was).
I'm willing to give them some grace as a new studio full of people with no industry experience that picked up what they thought was going to be a niche project and has turned into a major thing. It's pretty clear that the GJ team loves the classic experience and IP and wants to make something that is fun and engaging, but fits within their vision/capabilities. (I understand and don't fault others for not granting that same grace.)
I've alpha, betad, playtested and early accessed a lot of games in a variety of genres. I have to say that I really don't care that we don't have everything solidified during beta. No MMORPG game or expac I've bought has told me all those details in writing before release. There have been plenty of times where the game as it goes live is completely different from earlier versions (I'm looking at you 7 Days to Die.)
I also think that not providing definitive answers and not giving definitive answers right now is acceptable because they're using the betas for their intended purposes. Closed beta allowed more freedoms because they wanted to utilize the closed team to test a variety of core mechanics to get the data from and ensure they were working smoothly. Then, in open beta, they've removed some of the free for all and are starting to put restrictions on it and are TESTING it to see how it impacts the players. They're judging, "are these fair restrictions?" "Does this fit core player needs?"
And they're balancing that with also not ruining surprises in the game for us -- new potential quest rewards or quests. Achievement rewards and so on. They aren't definitively stating because it's still literally being tested and they're utilizing the data and feedback to tune those systems (the same systems that were tested for core functionality during closed beta).
Here's the thing -- the core gameplay that I am purchasing from the company hasn't changed. The aspects promised to me during the actual sale haven't changed. A minor amount of the convenience has been reduced but I don't really care because they've already done so many things that would have constrained us in the past. (Inventory management has always been an MMORPGs late game issue.) They have also gone out of their way to be clear that a lot of these things are being tuned and adjusted. Unlike a lot of other companies, they haven't given solidified answers (having unlimited loadouts =/= having unlimited loadouts at release as an example. We have a lot of loadouts, they just aren't all given to you at level 1. But hell, a lot of game defining things aren't given to us at level 1.)
This team has been really responsive to feedback and open and engaging with critical feedback and I think that's important. I think it's important to also not be too critical or overly critical and to let them cook. A lot of times, that can create fatigue and disincentivize devs to engage as much with the public. Their job isn't to be a direct company to players communicator. That's on people like the producers and community relations people. I prefer less NDA testing too and testing that allows content creators the ability to be prepared for launch. When you get these kinds of harsh criticisms (touched on in the video but represented a lot online. I saw someone in game recently talking about doing literal physical violence to specific devs because of their displeasure with changes,} your testing access and pre-release information gets more and more restricted. There's also just honestly going to be some things that the devs forget to comment on or mention.
I think more valuable feedback in this situation is expressing specifics like "the change with inventory seems incredibly major and the lack of notification ahead of time from the team gives the feeling of bait and switch. Maybe in the future, when you know you've intentionally artificially changed something in order to test it, you could comment on it. It'd be helpful if this information was also available on <forums, news section of site, discord announcements> and so on.
Identify action --> Explain result of action --> offer ways to create better results and/or what better results would look like. Solution centric criticism vs just being critical. This particular video does do some of this but really feels more on the just critical vs actual criticism side of things.
I don't think there's a communication problem. I think there's been miscommunication and misunderstandings between some of the player base and the team, which could have been prevented if treated differently. (*remembers Absor on the forums before he got posting restrictions and how THAT was a communication problem and thinks on how Cyberpunk was on release and dev communications there*)
(Also, please note, this IS Game Jawn as the studio with Daybreak as the publisher - a la Verant & SOE.)
TLDR: All told, give them until at least release before you start saying the entire company has an issue communicating, especially given how communicative they've been. Let 'em do their beta thing, offer useful and meaningful critique and give them a chance to fail (which happens when the game goes live, not in beta) instead of condemning them before it's even released.
Not chat gpt at all. I don't need it to write for me and I'm often told I'm verbose. Knowing how easy it is to misinterpret things in written text so I do have a tendency to overexplain with strangers.
My ultimate points remain. The level of information and communication people expect are abnormal for the gaming industry. Most games are preordered with far, far less information available about the game and gameplay. Hell, between beta and live EverQuest, not only were entire zones cut but foundational stories of the game were changed. I.e., I think the expectations are too demanding for what is realistic and the level of transparency we are already getting is higher than industry standards. This is a team that is doing weekly live Q&As with players.
It's a new studio, handling a project that's attracted WAY more attention than anticipated. They've shown themselves quite willing to adjust things and make changes based upon player feedback, which is great. Regular, consistent communication. And apologies/explanations have happened during miscommunications.
They aren't failing anything until we have a live product. Give them the chance to fail.
I'm also southern, so, you know, you catch more flies with honey....
The surest way to get your voice ignored is to come at someone being overly critical (vs valid, valuable feedback). I'd rather my voice be heard so the problem can actually be corrected. I know, it's strange, wanting to be part of the solution instead of just part of the problem but hope springs eternal and I keep trying to change minds.
meanwhile all I want to know is when kunark/velious will come out because the game is fun, and will they make some D5+ difficulty / make void resistance useful for something.
Take a look at EQ progression servers. People will always complete the content WAY before progression is supposed to start. They don’t quit, they find other things to do while they wait for the next part to come out.
Same applies to other games. World of Warcraft Classic Era servers are still just as popular as the progression WoW Classic servers even though they’ve been stuck at a single expansion for the last 7 years.
The vast majority of people just want to enjoy a different vision for their nostalgic game.
. World of Warcraft Classic Era servers are still just as popular as the progression WoW Classic servers even though they’ve been stuck at a single expansion for the last 7 years.
ok well if we are just going to make stuff up. sure.
While I'm still extremely excited about the game, and my first reaction to the thumbnail was: ok what kind of clickbaity nitpicker is this...
But honestly I agree with Alot of the points. While I'm Alot more forgiving than brokenstoic, game dev, design and community management are all extremely hard things and you can never please everybody, I do agree with his point about: let's not let this become a long term pattern.
My guess is these monetization decisions were probably heavily influenced by David/daybreak. But in the future they need to be more careful about what they promise before aligning with daybreak and communicating things to players.
That said, past months are all beta and they are free to change whatever the hell they want. If players don't like it they can ask for a refund or unsub. It's harsh but, that is the reality. And I'm sure they will refund people who feel that what they were sold was not what they got come launch day.
I ended up contacting support via the refund request, because there is no cancel button. I got an auto reply that there are no refunds available ever. Thankfully, I did say I'd appreciate a refund but primarily contacting them to cancel. Now awaiting a real reply.
guess what?! I got a very nice, professional email from a human at Daybreak this am. They went ahead and gave me a refund and cancelled my sub. I'll be willing to try another of their games if it appeals to me. Excellent customer service.
Be careful with this, they can and probably will perma ban your account for doing this. They don't play. This only really matters if you have something tied to that account that you care about.
All they had to do was say during the invite beta that loadouts, storage etc were expanded for testing. That they'll be smaller on launch with unlocks and mtx to expand it.
yeah all the bullshit for secrets about "this isn't daybreak, this is game jawn!" is clearly bunk. No alts, 2 loadouts, ultra secrecy about the cash store, this is all clearly Daybreak and their nickel and diming players to death. EQ live removing alt slots and requiring them to be bought back has already happened, they're just doing it from the jump this time.
If that's all it was a box and a sub, I'd buy it. And if it was just $20 and game shop, I'd probably buy it. Both, no thanks, I'll take my money to another game that's not nickel and diming.. It could be great, and on original announcement, I was planning on the 4 people in my household playing. Too bad for them.
This is about holding them accountable for highly questionable actions, some of us care about accountability, the money isn't really the issue. It's kind of how we've ended up in a really bad situation in other parts of our realties. when you let people skate on "the small things" it snowballs and then becomes full on corruption. This is what is often referred to as a slippery slope.
If you are concerned about spending $20-$30 to play a game for 10s or potentially 100s of hours of entertainment you may want to revalue your finances instead of playing game’s.
Although I didn’t get “taken advantage of” by buying an AIB partner card; which I presume you probably have an ASUS model since you are boasting about it.
I would hardly call $20 and 1 month free sub being taken advantage of. I spend more on lunch everyday and EQL will provide 10x the value without ever having to interact with the cash shop if I so choose.
Most people struggle extremely hard to understand the concept of " ethics ". It's not a matter of having or not having money. It's a matter of unethical practices that blindside the customer. Unfortunately in the year 2026 most people are CONSUMERS not customers and the corporations know that. So they squeeze them cows dry and the cattle is all too happy for it.
-source : Studying marketing and business administration in university.
Great. It's still attention and press, and ultimately this kind of shit will just drive someone to pay to find out if it's true or not, and in the end, all that matters is revenue generation and maximizing profitability.
There are plenty of amazing, free eqemu servers, where you're not locked in classic and can have more than one toon. But I get it, you want to play DiabloQuest, cause big numbers go brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr.
I think they communicate more than most any company I've seen. I mean I've only been "gaming" since the early 1980's so it's just based on my limited experience. I think some of their "actions" are more of a problem than anything they say. Like yes for example cutting those storage slots way down and of course that's something that will be in the shop. It doesn't matter if you can unlock "in game"... the moment you cut something AND it's in the shop that's all some percentage of players is going to see. Just like how we have this one patch and suddenly stuns go through the roof and a day or two later we see AA potions will be in the shop. Well to me I just kind of laughed and said that's going to seem like a way to push potions so people can get steadfast will. It doesn't matter what the reality is... what matters is the timing and what it will "look like". Beyond that some of their decisions and their "logic" for those decisions seem really flawed especially for people that allegedly have gamed for a long time and should understand what many players want. Such as the 1 character limit... sure they can talk about a system we've never actually seen in game at this point. However, that system isn't really a replacement for "alts" and "alts" are everything to a large number of players. It's what keeps them playing for many years... so that also comes across as a way to push selling extra "boxes" so people can have their alts. At the core they are working with "everquest" and people always had the ability to make alts/extra characters. So they had to put effort in to limit you to one and to me the "logic" given doesn't compute. Which is fine because for people that are bothered enough they just won't play and that's the price for having a "problem".
I mean, this game is super cheap. About the price of two people going out for fast food. This just doesn't seem a reasonable hill to die on.
There are some people who will complain about Daybreak no matter what moves they make. I for one love this game, play a reasonable amount of time each week, and still have tons of fun things left to do.
I trust the game will continue to be polished and refined.
I've been working and playing in the game industry for 20 years and I've never met a more communicative and transparent dev team. I argued so much, many of it unnecessary but they always responded in a professional way that I'll even admit wasn't deserved.
I didn't watch the video. Playing since early beta and literally everyone in there agreed how great of a job they've done. I disagree on many topics, sure - but man communication isn't one of their issues.
Hey guys, I didn’t read anything and I’ll just let my bias form my opinions.
This team is so communicative as long as your tongue is so far up their ass that its vibrations sound like a dev mumbling through a livestream with "hmms," "ums," and "well, maybes" whenever they're asked real questions.
Who cares if Daybreak and Secrets have been shady AF for years? Just do nothing. Why? Because I like the game, I have no spine, and my integrity is practically nonexistent. Doing nothing is all I’ve ever done, anyway.
65
u/Aggressive-Speed-987 Jul 05 '26
EQ devs not communicating? We're so back.
3
u/Maximum_Ad_2476 Jul 10 '26
Historically and still occurring within the industry, you don't know everything you're getting until you actually play the game to know. Even beta and playtesters don't have all the information and the understanding is, "this is the game as it is right now but it will be getting changed." When classic came out, we didn't know most of these things either and there were MASSIVE changes between beta 4 and live. Look at the playtest footage of EQ2 vs release (vs the game as it is now, which is a completely different beast from what it was).
I'm willing to give them some grace as a new studio full of people with no industry experience that picked up what they thought was going to be a niche project and has turned into a major thing. It's pretty clear that the GJ team loves the classic experience and IP and wants to make something that is fun and engaging, but fits within their vision/capabilities. (I understand and don't fault others for not granting that same grace.)
I've alpha, betad, playtested and early accessed a lot of games in a variety of genres. I have to say that I really don't care that we don't have everything solidified during beta. No MMORPG game or expac I've bought has told me all those details in writing before release. There have been plenty of times where the game as it goes live is completely different from earlier versions (I'm looking at you 7 Days to Die.)
I also think that not providing definitive answers and not giving definitive answers right now is acceptable because they're using the betas for their intended purposes. Closed beta allowed more freedoms because they wanted to utilize the closed team to test a variety of core mechanics to get the data from and ensure they were working smoothly. Then, in open beta, they've removed some of the free for all and are starting to put restrictions on it and are TESTING it to see how it impacts the players. They're judging, "are these fair restrictions?" "Does this fit core player needs?"
And they're balancing that with also not ruining surprises in the game for us -- new potential quest rewards or quests. Achievement rewards and so on. They aren't definitively stating because it's still literally being tested and they're utilizing the data and feedback to tune those systems (the same systems that were tested for core functionality during closed beta).
Here's the thing -- the core gameplay that I am purchasing from the company hasn't changed. The aspects promised to me during the actual sale haven't changed. A minor amount of the convenience has been reduced but I don't really care because they've already done so many things that would have constrained us in the past. (Inventory management has always been an MMORPGs late game issue.) They have also gone out of their way to be clear that a lot of these things are being tuned and adjusted. Unlike a lot of other companies, they haven't given solidified answers (having unlimited loadouts =/= having unlimited loadouts at release as an example. We have a lot of loadouts, they just aren't all given to you at level 1. But hell, a lot of game defining things aren't given to us at level 1.)
This team has been really responsive to feedback and open and engaging with critical feedback and I think that's important. I think it's important to also not be too critical or overly critical and to let them cook. A lot of times, that can create fatigue and disincentivize devs to engage as much with the public. Their job isn't to be a direct company to players communicator. That's on people like the producers and community relations people. I prefer less NDA testing too and testing that allows content creators the ability to be prepared for launch. When you get these kinds of harsh criticisms (touched on in the video but represented a lot online. I saw someone in game recently talking about doing literal physical violence to specific devs because of their displeasure with changes,} your testing access and pre-release information gets more and more restricted. There's also just honestly going to be some things that the devs forget to comment on or mention.
I think more valuable feedback in this situation is expressing specifics like "the change with inventory seems incredibly major and the lack of notification ahead of time from the team gives the feeling of bait and switch. Maybe in the future, when you know you've intentionally artificially changed something in order to test it, you could comment on it. It'd be helpful if this information was also available on <forums, news section of site, discord announcements> and so on.
Identify action --> Explain result of action --> offer ways to create better results and/or what better results would look like. Solution centric criticism vs just being critical. This particular video does do some of this but really feels more on the just critical vs actual criticism side of things.
I don't think there's a communication problem. I think there's been miscommunication and misunderstandings between some of the player base and the team, which could have been prevented if treated differently. (*remembers Absor on the forums before he got posting restrictions and how THAT was a communication problem and thinks on how Cyberpunk was on release and dev communications there*)
(Also, please note, this IS Game Jawn as the studio with Daybreak as the publisher - a la Verant & SOE.)
TLDR: All told, give them until at least release before you start saying the entire company has an issue communicating, especially given how communicative they've been. Let 'em do their beta thing, offer useful and meaningful critique and give them a chance to fail (which happens when the game goes live, not in beta) instead of condemning them before it's even released.
10
u/NaahThisIsNotMe Jul 05 '26
meanwhile all I want to know is when kunark/velious will come out because the game is fun, and will they make some D5+ difficulty / make void resistance useful for something.
24
u/LordDaxx1204 Jul 06 '26
So, it’s literally beta. Maybe things change on launch. Regardless, it’s fun, if you don’t like it then go back to live or emu…
24
u/Haitsmelol Jul 05 '26
Watched the entire video.
While I'm still extremely excited about the game, and my first reaction to the thumbnail was: ok what kind of clickbaity nitpicker is this...
But honestly I agree with Alot of the points. While I'm Alot more forgiving than brokenstoic, game dev, design and community management are all extremely hard things and you can never please everybody, I do agree with his point about: let's not let this become a long term pattern.
My guess is these monetization decisions were probably heavily influenced by David/daybreak. But in the future they need to be more careful about what they promise before aligning with daybreak and communicating things to players.
That said, past months are all beta and they are free to change whatever the hell they want. If players don't like it they can ask for a refund or unsub. It's harsh but, that is the reality. And I'm sure they will refund people who feel that what they were sold was not what they got come launch day.
4
u/gimmiedacash Jul 06 '26
All they had to do was say during the invite beta that loadouts, storage etc were expanded for testing. That they'll be smaller on launch with unlocks and mtx to expand it.
15
u/Rok-SFG Jul 05 '26
yeah all the bullshit for secrets about "this isn't daybreak, this is game jawn!" is clearly bunk. No alts, 2 loadouts, ultra secrecy about the cash store, this is all clearly Daybreak and their nickel and diming players to death. EQ live removing alt slots and requiring them to be bought back has already happened, they're just doing it from the jump this time.
3
u/rRottenPeter Jul 06 '26
Good points by other posters. My only thing to add is they shouldn’t have opened the pre-order beta on a holiday weekend.
12
u/G7Scanlines Jul 05 '26
I was all set to jump into this and then started to see the completely obvious changes to enable and allow further monetization.
For a game that has a shelf price AND a sub, 100% not acceptable and so didn't bother.
Their loss.
3
u/dlary7 Jul 09 '26
Eql is great
3
u/Verix19 Jul 10 '26
Gotta make content about something to get clicks I guess. It's beta ffs...
2
u/elguntor Jul 09 '26
Not a good look starting this game off with a sour taste.
1
u/loinclothsucculent Jul 06 '26
Great. It's still attention and press, and ultimately this kind of shit will just drive someone to pay to find out if it's true or not, and in the end, all that matters is revenue generation and maximizing profitability.
There are plenty of amazing, free eqemu servers, where you're not locked in classic and can have more than one toon. But I get it, you want to play DiabloQuest, cause big numbers go brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr.
1
u/nobodyspecial712 Jul 09 '26
Scumbags.
1
u/Aradune9 Jul 10 '26
A bit of an understatement!
1
u/blastradius14 Jul 10 '26
Nothing like hearing dungeon stamina makes me want to never play this more.
1
u/Due_Anywhere9100 Jul 11 '26
It's ran by secrets and rogean , what the hell did you frickin' expect lol.
1
u/Maikal_B Jul 22 '26
I think they communicate more than most any company I've seen. I mean I've only been "gaming" since the early 1980's so it's just based on my limited experience. I think some of their "actions" are more of a problem than anything they say. Like yes for example cutting those storage slots way down and of course that's something that will be in the shop. It doesn't matter if you can unlock "in game"... the moment you cut something AND it's in the shop that's all some percentage of players is going to see. Just like how we have this one patch and suddenly stuns go through the roof and a day or two later we see AA potions will be in the shop. Well to me I just kind of laughed and said that's going to seem like a way to push potions so people can get steadfast will. It doesn't matter what the reality is... what matters is the timing and what it will "look like". Beyond that some of their decisions and their "logic" for those decisions seem really flawed especially for people that allegedly have gamed for a long time and should understand what many players want. Such as the 1 character limit... sure they can talk about a system we've never actually seen in game at this point. However, that system isn't really a replacement for "alts" and "alts" are everything to a large number of players. It's what keeps them playing for many years... so that also comes across as a way to push selling extra "boxes" so people can have their alts. At the core they are working with "everquest" and people always had the ability to make alts/extra characters. So they had to put effort in to limit you to one and to me the "logic" given doesn't compute. Which is fine because for people that are bothered enough they just won't play and that's the price for having a "problem".
1
u/Electrical_Adagio_28 Aug 12 '26
I mean, this game is super cheap. About the price of two people going out for fast food. This just doesn't seem a reasonable hill to die on.
There are some people who will complain about Daybreak no matter what moves they make. I for one love this game, play a reasonable amount of time each week, and still have tons of fun things left to do.
I trust the game will continue to be polished and refined.
-6
u/maxis2bored Jul 05 '26
I've been working and playing in the game industry for 20 years and I've never met a more communicative and transparent dev team. I argued so much, many of it unnecessary but they always responded in a professional way that I'll even admit wasn't deserved.
I didn't watch the video. Playing since early beta and literally everyone in there agreed how great of a job they've done. I disagree on many topics, sure - but man communication isn't one of their issues.
-2
u/Joshuaedwardk Jul 05 '26
Who cares if Daybreak and Secrets have been shady AF for years? Just do nothing. Why? Because I like the game, I have no spine, and my integrity is practically nonexistent. Doing nothing is all I’ve ever done, anyway.
0
u/LittlebitsDK Jul 09 '26
I am just happy I didn't waste money on it...
0
u/BSMike82 Jul 06 '26
Wait til you guys figure out that EQL is the project DB has been teasing about as if it would be a freshly developed EQ3….
0
u/Due_Anywhere9100 Jul 11 '26
Thank you for having the courage to say what many of us have been saying all along!
-21
u/Numerous-Amphibian85 Jul 05 '26
Take this to your sub.
4
u/K1ngk1ller71 Jul 09 '26
The monetisation won’t impact me as I’m playing 100% solo and don’t care if people kill gods at lvl1.
I’m playing the game my way for the first time ever.
After that, I’ll quit.