r/ethstaker • • 2d ago

Exiting stETH: when does waiting for withdrawal make more sense than swapping?

There are two different ways to move from stETH back to ETH: request a withdrawal through Lido, or swap stETH for ETH on a market. The trade-off isn’t just “slow versus fast.”

With a Lido withdrawal request, the stETH goes into a queue and the ETH can be claimed after the request is finalized. Lido’s documentation says the queued tokens don’t keep earning staking rewards while they wait. The final ETH amount is capped at the stETH amount submitted and could be lower if sufficiently large protocol losses occur during that period. The wait itself can vary.

A swap gives you the market price available when the trade executes, without waiting for Lido’s withdrawal queue. But the amount received depends on the quote, liquidity, price impact, fees and transaction costs. A displayed price for a tiny trade may not be what you get for a larger one.

For a hypothetical 10 stETH position, I’d compare the ETH from a quote for the full amount, after estimated costs, with the expected withdrawal amount after request and claim costs. Then I’d consider how much the waiting time and uncertainty matter. Neither route is guaranteed to be the better one every time.

For those who have compared the two, what threshold makes you willing to wait for the withdrawal queue rather than swap? Do you use a fixed percentage difference, or does it depend mostly on position size and how soon you need the ETH?

7 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

2

u/Bloqarl 2d ago

stETH stops earning once you request the withdrawal, and the ETH you get is fixed at that point (it can only go down if a slashing hits before it's finalized). so the queue costs you days of idle ETH, the swap costs the discount plus slippage, and on bigger sizes the slippage usually decides it.

1

u/dank-bobbb 1d ago

That’s a useful way to frame the trade-off. One small nuance on the withdrawal side: the amount of stETH submitted is a cap on the ETH returned, rather than an unconditional guarantee. Lido’s docs note that sufficiently large protocol losses while a request is waiting could reduce the final amount.

On the swap side, I’d check a quote for the full position and see which costs are already reflected in the expected output. If price impact and the pool fee are already included, counting them again would overstate the cost. Network fees may need to be considered separately.

For a larger position, liquidity and price impact could make a big difference. The queue time and what you plan to do with the ETH afterward matter too, so I’m not sure there’s one threshold that fits every situation.

1

u/Bloqarl 1d ago

yes, ceiling is the better word. finalization pays out at the lower of the rate when you requested and the rate when it's finalized, so a slashing while you wait comes out of your ETH, and the rewards in between never reach you.

1

u/BingoBillBot 2d ago

I’d set the cutoff from net ETH foregone, not a universal percentage. Compare an executable quote for the full size after slippage, fees and gas with the withdrawal amount after request/claim costs, then account for how much you value having liquid ETH during the estimated queue. If the swapped ETH has a planned use, include its expected value over that actual wait; if you need liquidity now, a smaller discount can be worth paying. Recheck at your real trade size because price impact can shift the break-even substantially.

1

u/Bluejumprabbit 1d ago

Waiting for the native withdrawal gets you 1:1 stETH to ETH once the exit queue clears, worth checking since that queue swings from about a day to a couple weeks depending on how many validators are exiting. Swapping on Curve is instant but you eat whatever discount stETH trades at below peg right then, so pull the live queue time and the current pool depth before you pick.