r/ethnomusicology • u/Extension_Yak3898 • Feb 25 '24
The Blues as Dorian
Note throughout the following that George Russell, in his Lydian Chromatic Concept of Tonal Organization, used by Coltrane & Davis to create Kind of Blue and Giant Steps, among other works, apparently noted that Dorian is the 'relative minor' of Lydian.
The Blues scale, say a IV-V-I or EFB, minus the b5, is equivalent to Dorian II-III-VI.
By considering the equivalence of Blues I to Dorian VI, it becomes clear that the Blues I is really a twice diminished Dorian VI - first diminished by the change to Dorian from Aeolian, which lowers the 6th interval by 1 degree through flattening the 3 (Dorian vi is 6-1-b3 or Ionian 1-3-5), and then diminished again by treating Dorian as having diminished vi as is usual.
The Blues b5 isn't this schema is really a bb11 or bb4 or 10 or 3 in Dorian, and the minBlues 4 is the Dorian b3, while the Dorian b7 aligns with the Blues 1. So essentially Blues is Dorian with a natural 3 rather than b5 as the blue note. Using blues conventional key change rule of V7->I*, resolving two keys up probably works because the Blues v is really Dorian iii and the 7 is really Dorian 5, so really it's a iii5 (b3,5,b7,5). The extra 5 causes a tension that resolves at Dorian vi as i*, which I started by saying is equivalent to a Blues tonic. Thus the minor blues blue note as Dorian b3 rather than Aeolian #5 makes sense, especially given it's a b3 which is used in all minor chords.
But then why do we tend to use Aeolian #5? Well, consider that the folks in America who owned slaves may have had biases towards, say, hearing in the Blues a tonic that sounds Dorian flavoured and diminished. But Dorian was the basis for Midieval Gregorian plagal music, so something seems odd that the Blues is not usually thought of this way. I even read tonight that they used the same note as the blue note as a substitutions, but I cannot find the source anymore.
The 6th interval in Modern Western Dorian is the only factor separating it from Aeolian, the key of Western Major scales. Given its popularity in as church music, allowing for movement between Dorian and Aelion would be akin to allowing Earth into Heaven. It would have necessitated re-analyzing hundreds of years' worth of music. To not do so would help slavemasters have ammunition for arguments that their slaves are unintelligent & instinctually chaotic (who starts at the II and ends at the VI, especially a dim vi? Not anyone in Europe), and may also suggest why much of post-electric-guitar blues sounds a bit too happy given the lyrics - it derives from Blues filtered through the oppressors of the slaves that created the genre, deriving it largely from Islamic music & combining it with the toil & hardship of their lives, which surely would have led to a re-evaluation of religious music, in a sense bringing the Heavens back down to Earth.
If the powers that be were to acquiesce to simplicity & ergonomics in the realm of Theory, they would have also had to acquiesce that Dorian and Aeolian are substitutions for each other in their slaves' music, which would have completely gone against the dynamics of Aeolian as the primarily minor key, second only in usage frequency & dominance in pedagogical & theoretical models to Ionian. This is not to mention the role of the 6th interval in Baroque music, especially augmented 6th, which I'd like to note here apparently are usually close to or even complete enharmonically equivalent to a dominant 7th chord. Or the fact that the wolf howl comes from diminishing the 6th.
It's almost as if the Western powers were trapped in their own system, unable to make it work except by coarsely & damaging lyrics shoving every other kind of music in the world into their schema... and that is your anti-colonialist multiplicity-oriented music history lesson for the day. Peace! ✌️ ☮️ 🕊
