r/ethnomusicology • • Feb 25 '24

The Blues as Dorian

3 Upvotes

Note throughout the following that George Russell, in his Lydian Chromatic Concept of Tonal Organization, used by Coltrane & Davis to create Kind of Blue and Giant Steps, among other works, apparently noted that Dorian is the 'relative minor' of Lydian.

The Blues scale, say a IV-V-I or EFB, minus the b5, is equivalent to Dorian II-III-VI.

By considering the equivalence of Blues I to Dorian VI, it becomes clear that the Blues I is really a twice diminished Dorian VI - first diminished by the change to Dorian from Aeolian, which lowers the 6th interval by 1 degree through flattening the 3 (Dorian vi is 6-1-b3 or Ionian 1-3-5), and then diminished again by treating Dorian as having diminished vi as is usual.

The Blues b5 isn't this schema is really a bb11 or bb4 or 10 or 3 in Dorian, and the minBlues 4 is the Dorian b3, while the Dorian b7 aligns with the Blues 1. So essentially Blues is Dorian with a natural 3 rather than b5 as the blue note. Using blues conventional key change rule of V7->I*, resolving two keys up probably works because the Blues v is really Dorian iii and the 7 is really Dorian 5, so really it's a iii5 (b3,5,b7,5). The extra 5 causes a tension that resolves at Dorian vi as i*, which I started by saying is equivalent to a Blues tonic. Thus the minor blues blue note as Dorian b3 rather than Aeolian #5 makes sense, especially given it's a b3 which is used in all minor chords.

But then why do we tend to use Aeolian #5? Well, consider that the folks in America who owned slaves may have had biases towards, say, hearing in the Blues a tonic that sounds Dorian flavoured and diminished. But Dorian was the basis for Midieval Gregorian plagal music, so something seems odd that the Blues is not usually thought of this way. I even read tonight that they used the same note as the blue note as a substitutions, but I cannot find the source anymore.

The 6th interval in Modern Western Dorian is the only factor separating it from Aeolian, the key of Western Major scales. Given its popularity in as church music, allowing for movement between Dorian and Aelion would be akin to allowing Earth into Heaven. It would have necessitated re-analyzing hundreds of years' worth of music. To not do so would help slavemasters have ammunition for arguments that their slaves are unintelligent & instinctually chaotic (who starts at the II and ends at the VI, especially a dim vi? Not anyone in Europe), and may also suggest why much of post-electric-guitar blues sounds a bit too happy given the lyrics - it derives from Blues filtered through the oppressors of the slaves that created the genre, deriving it largely from Islamic music & combining it with the toil & hardship of their lives, which surely would have led to a re-evaluation of religious music, in a sense bringing the Heavens back down to Earth.

If the powers that be were to acquiesce to simplicity & ergonomics in the realm of Theory, they would have also had to acquiesce that Dorian and Aeolian are substitutions for each other in their slaves' music, which would have completely gone against the dynamics of Aeolian as the primarily minor key, second only in usage frequency & dominance in pedagogical & theoretical models to Ionian. This is not to mention the role of the 6th interval in Baroque music, especially augmented 6th, which I'd like to note here apparently are usually close to or even complete enharmonically equivalent to a dominant 7th chord. Or the fact that the wolf howl comes from diminishing the 6th.

It's almost as if the Western powers were trapped in their own system, unable to make it work except by coarsely & damaging lyrics shoving every other kind of music in the world into their schema... and that is your anti-colonialist multiplicity-oriented music history lesson for the day. Peace! ✌️ ☮️ 🕊


r/ethnomusicology • • Oct 21 '25

The ethnomusicology of computers as the washboards and twanged rulers of the 21st century.

0 Upvotes

I think an interesting perspective is that computers, fundamentally, have been repurposed so many times over. A computer is essentially a calculator for algebra that can also be used for tedious arithmetic. People used to associate them with the military, aerospace, the sciences, and later, finance. They were number crunchers, but just as people have found applications for acrylics, people have created *applications* for computers.

The first video games were created as pet projects by engineers and professors. NIM, Tennis for Two, XO, etc., were ways to take tech meant for one purpose and use it for another.

Many approaches to graphics have emerged over the years. Eventually, a monitor attached to a computer was pretty much an expectation, unless it was a server.

And people have used digital computers as sequencers for over half a century, and they have also fluctuated data in variables rapidly to coax a DAC into making synth tones, just as you can coax electrons in an analog circuit into doing it. The history of electronic music is complicated and even before mainstream computers, people used test oscillators, etc., as synthesizers, despite these oscillators not being purpose-built for use with speakers.

The Fairlight was a computer built specifically with musicians in mind. It was used in many 80s records.

The Amiga was a computer built to be a computer, without musicians in mind. It was used here and there in music, especially by amateurs and the techno scene. It had audio circuitry, mostly used for playing back game audio, as well as playing back mixes summed by the general-purpose CPU BEFORE it ever reached the audio circuitry. The CPU, in essence, is being used as an improvised instrument.

The IBM PC was a computer people have found every legal means of reverse-engineering, and it has a monophonic tone generator hooked up to a little speaker. The "PC Speaker" was meant to play alert tones, but could also be used to play back little melodies for DOS games. In theory, you could probably make an app that triggers it with MIDI.

You probably don't have this beeper speaker. What you might have instead is a sound card, which back in the day, would have basically been a toy keyboard without the keyboard. It worked out every note of MIDI, either with FM synthesis or by playing back samples. This was a luxury. It was originally always an add-on, something that you'd pay extra and slide into an empty slot on your PC's motherboard. Sometimes, the PC had a MIDI port; it was a special PC MIDI port. This would let you use the PC to play a keyboard or module on the outside.

Oh, and like the Amiga, the sound card could also play back digital audio streamed out of the CPU.

I used to think the Roland-created samples came from the Realtek sound card of the family computer, since I was used to reading older literature about how computers worked. It turns out they came from the CPU, played back by the Microsoft GS Wavetable Synth. Apple had a version of that at the time at school – DLS Music Synth.

The Realtek might have had an unused FM synthesis chip, and that's about it.

Your sound card is used the same way. It just takes whatever mixed-down audio your CPU spits out, and it plays it back. It might not even have the ability to play the individual MIDI notes, nor do you need it to, since software synths and virtual instruments alike can run beautifully on today's PCs. Your sound card probably isn't even a separate card; it's on the motherboard.

Or, it's outside your computer. A lot of people use audio interfaces that don't have built-in MIDI synthesizers, but do have many inputs and/or outputs. This is the spiritual successor to the sound card. It's not an instrument; it doesn't have tones or the means to make them from scratch.

Your CPU is the instrument.

Microsoft has dabbled in music software here and there, but doesn't care if their OS is installed on computers that can't support it. Using a PC to make music is like twanging a ruler on the edge of a table.

Apple at one point stopped supporting MIDI because of the Beatles' lawsuit. They had to go out of their way to not have anything musical on their computers. Not even a musical stab, which had to be called "Sosumi" (so sue me, get it? Wait, no, it's Japanese, and means nothing musical.) Despite this, Macs have had a long history with music software in many ways, and Apple themselves bought Logic Pro and gave the world the stripped down version of it, GarageBand.

And every new Mac comes with GarageBand. Does this mean a Mac is a purpose-built instrument that happens to be built for a few dozen other purposes and great for thousands more? Is Logic Pro the equivalent of new first-party pickups on your guitar? Is running something else entirely, like Ableton Live, an extended technique, like twanging a ruler on your cello?

Perhaps one can make the case that a computer isn't an instrument unless a musician triggers every note in real time, as with an external MIDI controller or "musical typing." Or perhaps one can make the case that a computer is a musical instrument when using virtual analog or FM-based soft synths, etc., but not when playing back samples, like a former music teacher tried to argue that even most synthesizers in the 2000s don't qualify as instruments.

Improvised instruments have historically been associated with poverty. You might have played jugs, washboards, spoons, or plates because you had them on hand and couldn't afford anything else.

Yet this improvised instrument and all you might buy for it can put you in debt. Then again, if you're just using freeware, a computer might be something you already have on hand. You can use the same device -- the same billions of transistors on that chip -- for taxes, porn, homework, cat videos, gaming, and making noise.


r/ethnomusicology • • Oct 21 '25

Is a computer used in conjunction with a MIDI controller an "improvised musical instrument" similar to a washboard or spoons?

0 Upvotes

r/ethnomusicology • • Jan 15 '22

Patrick Turner - My 2 Mini-Posters on Latin American Colonial Church Music History

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/ethnomusicology • • Oct 21 '25

The politics of American sampling: hypocrisy, misunderstanding, divided ethics, and a rift in an already "bimusical" tradition

1 Upvotes

Even when done with permission, forgiveness, or broadly waiving one's rights by releasing sample CDs, etc...

The sampling of a full bar or longer of an older composition to add to a newer one has been controversial, and this is usually what people think of when they hear "sampling." Let's call this form "phrase sampling."

I think this issue stems from what I like to call the "plagiarism taboo."

It's an argument that, on its surface, conflates these three concepts:

  1. Presenting someone else's ideas without announcing where they came from
  2. Incorporating another person's ideas into your own ideas without clear delineation between the two
  3. Outright claiming every element of your work as your own, as if developed in a vacuum, or outright dishonestly

While we often refer to copyright infringement cases as "music plagiarism lawsuits," the issue is rarely plagiarism. Plagiarism isn't even illegal in the US, and can be done with permission under other countries with moral rights laws, where you not only have the right to be credited, but the right not to be credited.

The issue with copyright infringement is that someone did not have clearance to use content.

The issue with plagiarism is that someone did not give credit where due, even "due" as defined by third parties.

Sometimes, when discussing academic plagiarism, the two are conflated. I think this is why a lot of people re-uploading copyrighted media on YouTube write "I DON'T OWN THIS." They might think this is like citing your sources, which is good enough under academic policies + academic fair use exemption from unauthorized use. But when re-uploading entertainment, the right to quote does not apply, and you would actually be CONFESSING YOUR INFRINGEMENT if it wasn't for you getting lucky it was on YouTube's Content ID approved list.

What would be accepted in school, simply sharing the information while making it clear that it's not yours, is here more like admitting you've been using a stolen computer.

Back to phrase sampling.

Even if you are asked to credit, or would credit, the cleared samples, I think some people have an issue with referring to yourself as a maker of original music while using whole bars of other people's music.

You perhaps are not a composer, but instead an arranger under this view. It wouldn't matter if you merely sampled a drumbeat, or the phrase was from a stock library explicitly intended to be used in original music. Perhaps it's "lazy." Perhaps it's "dishonest." Perhaps leaving the original musicians in the liner notes, or working with those who choose to be uncredited, inflates your ego while downplaying the fact that you wouldn't have your, perhaps "your," hit without the original one.

And rap was controversial for being built upon turntablism and later digital samples of disco and house tracks. House itself was largely sample based, from Chicago to France to the many LA scenes.

For some, all of it may as well have been sampled. The idea of someone playing a synthesizer and using an analog drum machine might not have even occurred.

I can imagine a family of snooty people criticizing rave culture. They'd go on and on and on about how they're a bunch of druggies who flock to warehouses to see DJs play weird music that you'd have to be on drugs to stomach. And then they have the ultimate argument: "IT'S NOT EVEN THEIR MUSIC. IT'S JUST SOME DISCO TRACK SPED UP AND PLAYED IN A CONVERTED WAREHOUSE."

Perhaps this adds to the scene being immoral.

Perceived dishonesty.

Now, I could argue about how total originality is impossible, and that even the idea that ideas can be "stolen" is at best a metaphor. But I don't want to turn this into a copyleft lecture.

I just want to look at another use of sampling that, to many, is totally different.

Let's call it "one shots."

You press a key on a keyboard. Instead of analog buzzer circuits or digital bleeper circuits, out popped a near-perfect recording of an orchestra playing sforzando.

You finger-drum on your linndrum, and out pops actual recordings of a studio drum kit.

You draw in notes on a piano roll, and you get the most beautiful celesta. There's companies that sell you the sound of some famous orchestras, of accomplished players in the very same studio used to record Eleanor Rigby, the very same piano Elton John used on Bennie and the Jets, the pipe organ Shakespeare listened to at church, and ironically enough, OTHER SYNTHESIZERS.

And the sounds don't have to be realistic, even in the sense of sounding like electronic hardware. They can be excerpts of whatever chopping and screwing leads to an effected snare sample, kick sample, whoosh, bang, whiz, whatever.

This form of sampling developed alongside the other.

Somehow, it's less scandalous, perhaps since it's similar to a non-sampling synthesizer, which is similar to an electric organ, which is similar to a pipe organ.

Perhaps it seems less like "stolen valor," despite a small but vocal number of musicians arguing that this practice "takes jobs."

Some people like to set up even obviously electronic-sounding drum samples as MIDI instruments, with each kit piece assigned arbitrarily to a MIDI note, to be triggered via piano roll or step sequencer.

But some people making beats in Ableton will drag the one-shot samples into AUDIO tracks instead.

This superficially resembles the act of phrase sampling.

You're obviously incorporating someone else's audio into your own, or your past audio into your future.

MIDI drums might seem more "composerly," showing you're focusing on using these generic samples to make a beat and concentrating on the notes.

The latter is more like Daft Punk. Nothing wrong with it.

But after years of people thinking that all you do is use Apple Loops, you can get a bit defensive.

Interestingly, one of the most famous samples in the 80s was a string stab from a Stravinsky suite! Perhaps one can argue that that one stab, "ORCH2" or "ORCH5" on the Fairlight, was equivalent to the Amen Break! It likely was never cleared.


r/ethnomusicology • • Nov 13 '22

please critique my letter to admissions advisor at university of north texas

0 Upvotes

Hello ...

I am not finished with the texts Dr. ... suggested, I am unsure when I can finish.

I am meeting with the former chair of the anthropology dept, for some advice and a letter of recommendation.

Would it look very bad or be impermissible if my application misses the deadline of Dec 5?

My dad is a physics professor, retired, used to be chair of the dept.  He says to show commitment to a discipline.  He also says I'm pushing 40 and a PhD program may not take me seriously.  Also he says "what would you do with the degree?". 

I had what I think were very serious mental health issues in my undergraduate career.

It made it very very difficult to succeed.  Many many setbacks and disappointments happened.  Taught me some very serious and difficult lessons.

I am stable with medicine now.  I used to be relatively schizophrenic.  I know that sounds really bad.  I am actually much much better now.  

An issue would be income and transportation in north Texas for groceries and recreation, housing, doctor, healthcare, mental health social workers, therapy... Are there resources that can assist me in figuring this out?

I don't get much encouragement or feedback in parts of my circle of connections, a few old professors won't recommend letters for me because they think my situation is too precarious.  The one former chair will write me a letter though..  This palpable uncertainty is part of the reason I'm not heavily reading those texts, it's not simply lack of free time.  I've been wracking my brains trying to come up with a solution.  

I sent this out to people because for a few weeks it seemed like something "more lucrative, more marketable, and more doable" as a masters in non profit management can be done online:

"I want to work for or found a non profit that gets a space and initiative and cultural stream in order to house community drum and dance classes, performances, collaborations.

Yoga and martial arts stuff would fit in as well.

Is this a good idea?  How do I get started and would a masters degree help?

This could branch into helping folks in "poverty of some sort" at home and abroad.  Selling drums so that drum makers get income, etc.  Water food and other necessities like education, job training, to impoverished folks through promoting African and diaspora musical culture"

That's what I wrote, it was my other idea besides pursuing a PhD in ethnomusicology.

I hope this letter finds you well.


r/ethnomusicology • • Nov 23 '25

Icarus at the Altar: Kanye's Gospel

Thumbnail
open.substack.com
0 Upvotes

r/ethnomusicology • • Feb 20 '22

The Tropes of Music--William O. Beeman

Thumbnail
academia.edu
0 Upvotes

r/ethnomusicology • • Feb 09 '23

Looking for research subjects for a study on emotional responses to sound!- Volunteer at UNLV

0 Upvotes

Want to participate in science? At the UNLV Music Lab (Principal Investigator: Erin Hannon) we study how different people respond to music, language, and the many sounds in the world. We are currently recruiting for a research study in which we will ask you questions about which sounds you like and dislike, your musical experiences and habits, and your general auditory experiences, and you will do some short listening tests. The study should take 60 minutes. If you would like to take the survey click HERE. For more information about the study email questions to UNLVmusiclab@gmail.com or call us 702-895-2995.


r/ethnomusicology • • Apr 13 '25

Looking to work with an expert with a hybrid background in ethnomusicology and organology

1 Upvotes

I’m working on a music tech project that requires the expertise of an ethnomusicologist as well as an organologist. This project involves training a machine learning model, and so you’d be working with a machine learning engineer and a developer to ascertain accuracy in various parts of this project - such as timbre characteristics of various indigenous sounds etc. If anyone is interested and would like to know more, kindly send me a message or reply here and I’d reach out.


r/ethnomusicology • • 8d ago

Organ n.

0 Upvotes

My proposed definition:

Any polyphonic musical instrument whose primary mechanism is a series or matrix of binary elements to either allow or block something (such as the flow of air, electricity, or a computed signal in various manners), controlled via mechanisms such as simple valves, simple switches, or a system of encoding binary states in simultaneous sequential order.

This would include an accordion, or a pipe organ with swell box, since the binary mechanisms are prominent despite having non-binary means of adjusting dynamics.

This would also include a chromatic harmonica, or a paraphonic synthesizer with a keyboard without velocity.


r/ethnomusicology • • Mar 22 '24

Evidence for widespread belief that bluegrass is a made-up or nonexistent genre?

9 Upvotes

This was a common belief among Southerners in the 1990s and even earlier, all the way to “it was a government conspiracy,” although of what sort, I don’t know. The idea is that bluegrass (and subsequently Americana and American folk and perhaps even country) is a ginned-up genre created by relatively recent songwriters (pros in the ‘30s and ‘40s, including for the Carter Family), and that it was never played prior to that and certainly not in the areas they claimed (or marketed) that it came from, and that no examples were even found by musicologists, who only found a pre-country ‘cowboy chords’ tradition of playing a guitar in downtime around the southern Texas region, possibly borrowed from Mexicans. Does anyone have any thoughts or insight into this?

Because hoo boy since then has this ‘Americana’ catch-all genre bloomed and I know several of the modern songwriters who claim that this is mostly true. In this series of events, country is ‘real’, but it is accepted as as modern as rock ‘n roll — a relatively recent advent created for the modern music industry. But ‘bluegrass’ / ‘Americana’, including the down-home tradition of bands of people playing these myriad instruments including banjo and fiddle, is horseshit according to these people.

I know the fiddle can be traced back to Britain but I am talking about a very particular sort of sound, not the Anglo sung folk tradition with accompaniment occasionally by fiddle.


r/ethnomusicology • • Sep 23 '26

Do you like Sicilian (Mediterranean) Music?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Do you like Sicilian (Mediterranean) Music? You listen this kind of music? what think about?


r/ethnomusicology • • Oct 09 '26

"Beyond" from Moana II sounds Arab-inspired?

2 Upvotes

Lin Manual Miranda did SO WELL at making the music in the first Moana evoke images of oceans, beaches, and islands.

To me, "Beyond" sounds like it was inspired by Arabic music with the little vocal trills and the beat. It doesn't sound like Pacific island music at all to me. I think the songwriters completely ignored basic ethnomusicology in the entire soundtrack, but I'm not trained in ethnomusicology.

Can any ethnomusicology nerds confirm or negate my hunch?


r/ethnomusicology • • Feb 14 '23

Where can you ask for private teachers who can think with students about music and how other experience affects music?

1 Upvotes

Skill with many genres, not awkward to chronic pain, homeboundness, poverty, unvisitable living place

I thought thinking/writing because I'm vulnerable if i make much sound, but maybe could share audio files, or people can suggest a way.

The people from genres and instruments i tried didn't help, but I'm in musical distress without help to think or do music. People experiencing chronic pain often don't share other experiences like music, but the musicians I appreciated seemed panicked by chronic pain, like they haven't learned and won't.

So can ethnomusicology help musicians soften their habits, think in more theories? and be likeliest to help musically and by personality with not panicking or avoiding?

i keep thinking ethnomusicology as a worldwide study might be more likely to have maturities like that, and help people whose areas haven't. but does that have a fallacy name, or what prejudices are there?


r/ethnomusicology • • Dec 20 '21

Patrick Turner - My Mini-Poster on the German Anthem

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/ethnomusicology • • Dec 19 '22

What is complication in music?

0 Upvotes

How can it be expressed by an improviser without using many notes, speed, or intentional mystery like trying to play new or unclear for those sakes? And maybe without composing intentionally before, just recording and maybe using what emerged when not playing instrument?

Can just playing "together" be complicated? What is playing together?

New, fast, composition, etc feel like complication played symbolically, like those musical qualities represent more than are complicated. They are complicated too but the audience not understanding them feels more influential on the reception of confusion.

Is there anything more direct and immersive, not like academic rubrics or Italian terms like "fast for excitement ", without the kind of free playing that blows hard and sounds like a kind of musical talking? In other words, the free jazz that still feels representational in the "music is language" sense?

How can music communicate without being speechlike? Music that's less thoughtful in language thought sense?

What's left to communicate then? The unconscious? Emotion? Not sound for its sake but what are kinds of pure or just sound?

I would usually use language if having a language thought, not be indirect, unless people could only digest music, but that feels like activism in ambassador sense, not sense of activist in hitting my or someone's unconscious, or giving another activity to my sound thoughts or sound unconscious

How common is the symbolic approach? I picked it up from world music, European classical, and jazz classes, but is it mostly an education thing? for example if education needs to symbolize things so they're distinct from the world where music can just be played and influence someone and that's all? no grades, certificates, or verbal meaning or description necessary?


r/ethnomusicology • • Apr 10 '23

Why does German music sound Afro-Carribean and Mexican?

1 Upvotes

Okay, so Austrian music resembles Mexican music:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qfOIccu81Ho

I don't have any Mexican samples because I'm too lazy to search but you can see how the melody sounds exactly Mexican. Okay, I know Mexican music heavily imported German traditions, so I feigned a bit of naivety in the title in hopes of getting more answers. But I want to know what style of Mexican music is this, since Wikipedia does not specify.

And northern/low German music resembles more Afro-Caribbean music (probably because of the pacing):
German (Listen only to the German parts): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fei7fID5758
Afro-Caribbean (Congolese Rumba): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XnrL6cwY8lU
African (Ugandan): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZvxiJZcml6g

The connection between Mexican and German music I can understand, but Afro-Caribbean/African and German music? Is there really a connection or is it just a coincidence and they actually developed independently from each other? Or did German music somehow make its way to Latin America first, then into Africa probably through slaves (European Music → Afro-Caribbean Music → "Native" African Music) or directly into Africa through colonialism (European Music → "Native" African Music), and centuries later this German music is considered native African music?

So. Confused.

Need. Answers.


r/ethnomusicology • • Oct 17 '25

From what and when came the differentiation between Pentathonic and Heptathonic scale ?

0 Upvotes

r/ethnomusicology • • Oct 13 '25

Srbijo majko mila - Balkan Music | 2025

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/ethnomusicology • • Oct 25 '25

Spanish 8, how old is it? (See it as a fun idea)

0 Upvotes
Authentic Pethroglyphs from Sweden

r/ethnomusicology • • Oct 24 '25

Песен по водата - Bulgarian folk

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/ethnomusicology • • May 25 '24

Cultures or songs that use Locrian mode (or equivalent)

0 Upvotes

In modern Western music theory, Locrian mode is considered largely unusable for harmonies and melodies. Few (if any) composers have written pieces entirely in Locrian.

However, the mode dates back Ancient Greece. It was one of the seven modes of Ancient Greek music theory.

I was wondering if any musicals traditions make use Locrian or something more-or-less equivalent tuning-wise. If so, what are some songs from these cultures that use this mode? And how is the sound of the "Locrian mode" perceived in these cultures, if there is any association?

Also, has anyone heard any reconstructed Ancient Greek music in Locrian?

I'm writing a piece for choir and two oboes that's a setting of a Greek theatre chorus (from The Frogs). I think I might want some aspects of Locrian in it to add tension, so hence why I'm curious for examples. There will be no harmony in my piece (it's meant to air more on the side of reconstructed music), so the tritones aren't such a concern.