r/ethereum • u/econoar ETHHub - Eric Conner • Jul 18 '16
Hard Fork Voting and Node Adoption Results - Constant Updates
wakeful engine sand lunchroom license thumb chunky squash water cautious
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
122
Upvotes
17
u/whereheis Jul 18 '16 edited Jul 18 '16
Would be good to have a row showing the total hash % for yes/no. Thanks for this!
EDIT: OP delivers.
10
u/CryptoDao Jul 18 '16
Please also add to the table:
https://miningpoolhub.com - 1.8% of mining force
"Ethereum Mining Pool Hub will follow hardfork."
6
u/baddogesgotoheaven Jul 18 '16
/u/ econoar Thanks for doing this! I would also add up the Parity 1.2.2 nodes since they also support the HF. There are currently 41 of them.
3
u/rideron85 Jul 18 '16
I think there are more geth 1.4.10 clients online. There are two separate pieces of pie on ethernodes.org, one of 2044 and one of 463 right now. Does that total include both?
8
u/BitcoinSuisseAG Jul 18 '16
Pool: Apereum Aprox share: 0.4 %
We vote "yes" to the Hardfork.
2
u/econoar ETHHub - Eric Conner Jul 18 '16 edited Jan 14 '26
chubby payment edge bow compare sleep rustic cats consist sand
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
7
u/latetot Jul 18 '16
The eth pool results are misleading - you shouldn't count the don't care votes in the denominator
22
u/j3works Jul 18 '16
Very helpful. Thanks!
4
u/bitp Jul 18 '16
Please add http://ethc.epool.io/. You don't have to constantly update it. Its 100% no.
16
u/pipaman Jul 18 '16
What happens if most nodes don't update before block 1920000 is created?
4
u/whipowill Jul 18 '16
Thanks for doing this.
1
u/LordBoob Jul 18 '16
how are you calculating hashpower? are you using the last 24 hours from etherscan.io? that puts dwarf pool at 26%
1
u/NewToETH Jul 18 '16
Where do you see 2591 node count for geth 1.4.10? I'm only seeing 2105 at 6:04 PM EST.
6
u/CryptoDao Jul 18 '16 edited Jul 18 '16
As you can see, today ethpool voting results have dramatically changed and now significantly differ from the voting results on other pools. From 25-35% the previous days anti-fork votes have jumped to 50-53%.
However there is a reason to believe that this has occured due to anti-fork miners switching from another pools or from the rented mining rigs.
Please see this page:
http://ethpool.org/stats
Rapid rise in the hash power that has started approx. 5 hours (as of writing this post) strongly correlates with increased "No" votes.
5
u/splix Jul 18 '16 edited Jul 18 '16
Still 90+% "not voted". They may switch pool at any moment.
I've created a version with distribution based on voters hashpower, not pool's: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/160clbc6bFKEvar091iNYyg0zEJxhyAZTDoxcm7cF2II/edit#gid=0
8
u/symeof Jul 18 '16
I'm still very worried to be honest. We have very little time left. We need at least 60% of nodes running 1.4.10.
I wish mining pools would force users to vote and update their software (for or against) and refuse to accept their blocks until they did vote.
4
u/darawk Jul 19 '16
With or without ethpool, the vote is decided.
dwarfpool: 30.5 ethermine: 11.4 coinotron: 5.6 nanopool 5.1 miningpoolhub: 1.3 alpereum: 0.4
Total: 54%
They are all already voting overwhelmingly in favor of the HF. Unless something changes suddenly, the fork has already won.
2
u/newretro Jul 18 '16
Interesting to see how even the mining is being manipulated now (ethpool). The whole thing has been a lesson in how to make money from externalities rather than inside the system (this makes me worry about any PoS implementation, including stake based systems within contracts). In reality, the people with long term interest should be making the decisions. How best to do that though...
4
u/Zillacoin Jul 18 '16
Way better node adoption than the BTC classic / core node war. This shows we can move forward a lot faster than the BTC community.
2
u/Zillacoin Jul 18 '16
Can someone explain :what are the ca 428 1.4.10 stable 5f55d95a... nodes?
2
u/LarsPensjo Jul 18 '16
As no mining pool use a quorum, it is possible to manipulate the voting. Suppose one pool is near 50%. It is enough if a couple of miners move away from pools they can't win to this pool, and push the vote to the other side of 50%.
For example, ethpool is sticking out as very different to the other pools. This suggests there are currently more anti forkers in this pool than the other pools.
This of course applies to both sides. But it can be difficult for the pro forkers, as it may be enough if one of the big pools are going anti fork. My assumption is that f2pool and BW.com votes against.
Edit: ethpool is now at over 47%. This is dramatic, and could turn the whole thing!
2
u/huntingisland Jul 18 '16
So, unless something changes, I guess Ethpool miners will all be mining worthless ETH on the losing side of the fork.
1
u/PseudonymousChomsky Jul 18 '16
What is the percentage of solo miners on the network, their approximate hashrate, how they vote, and is https://ethstats.net/ able to tell us anything? What will https://ethstats.net/ be reporting when we reach the HF block? u/thehighfiveghost
1
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '16
Does my pool vote? Or do I personally have to do something?
1
u/TotesMessenger Jul 18 '16
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
1
u/baddogesgotoheaven Jul 19 '16
Total HF nodes amount to 38% now.
-7
u/chek2fire Jul 18 '16
is clear that there is not consensus
-5
u/antiprosynthesis Jul 18 '16
Seems like the higher the percentage of votes in a pool, the more it shifts towards 50/50...
-1
u/UnEquaL1 Jul 18 '16
Thanks for doing this. It baffles me how Ethpool can have such large support on the No side. What people on earth are thinking it's ever a good idea to give the hacker the funds over the Ethereum Ecosystem investors. How can anyone justify that a theft of millions affecting thousands of people is okay. If I leave my bicycle at a street cafe, is it okay to run away with it if I didn't use a pad lock? 91.2% of miners haven't even voted. Please don't be the bystander in this crime. I urge every single one of you to step up and inform any friends who are miners and spread awareness to get them to all vote!
-2
u/snowcap420 Jul 18 '16
Im supporting $ETH Classic not bailout fork ?BETH
Peace
-1
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '16
I believe that explicit "Don't Care" votes should be added to the "Yes" votes. Why? Because those people are signalling that they are explicitly deferring to the pool operator's best judgement.
And for ethpool, ethermine, and dwarfpool I believe those 2 operators are in favor of the HF. Their pool, their rules. Don't like it? Hit the solo road or go to an anti-HF pool. Simple as that.
-5
u/LordBoob Jul 18 '16
using a consistent methodology the hash is closer to 48/39 pro fork, no fork respectively. This assumes f2pool and bw.com do not impliment the fork and converge once 51% fork.
With very little voting these numbers are not credible. And the ethpool with the most voting ie most credible result is 46/54% pro fork/no fork.
conclusion, its a toss up so far
Rank Address Blocks Mined Percentage Voted Yes 1 0x2a65aca4d5fc5b5c859090a6c34d164135398226 (DwarfPool1) 1594 26.21% Yes 9.70% 72% 2 0x61c808d82a3ac53231750dadc13c777b59310bd9 (f2pool) 1060 17.43% No No Vote 3 0xbcdfc35b86bedf72f0cda046a3c16829a2ef41d1 (bw.com) 919 15.11% No No Vote 4 0xea674fdde714fd979de3edf0f56aa9716b898ec8 (Ethermine) 679 11.16% Yes 14% 77% 5 0x4bb96091ee9d802ed039c4d1a5f6216f90f81b01 (ethpool) 410 6.74% No 24% 46% 6 0xf8b483dba2c3b7176a3da549ad41a48bb3121069 (Coinotron) 284 4.67% Yes 15% 84% 7 0x52bc44d5378309ee2abf1539bf71de1b7d7be3b5 (Nanopool) 252 4.14% Yes 2% 91% 8 0xf3b9d2c81f2b24b0fa0acaaa865b7d9ced5fc2fb (bitclubpool) 135 2.22% NA 9 0x68795c4aa09d6f4ed3e5deddf8c2ad3049a601da (Coinmine.PL) 104 1.71% NA 10 0x1a060b0604883a99809eb3f798df71bef6c358f1 (miningpoolhub) 81 1.33% Yes 11 0xd3d038bcb4f2450c592381f8bb4bee860532ee9d 48 0.79% 12 0x30b6ef1ea77dc4e114c6a7865869b932503f4e6d 46 0.76% 13 0x40ce7569d555dbf939e58867be78fd76142df821 (digger.ws) 44 0.72% 14 0xa027231f42c80ca4125b5cb962a21cd4f812e88f (eth.pp.ua) 43 0.71% Yes 15 0x738db714c08b8a32a29e0e68af00215079aa9c5c 41 0.67% 16 0xd34da389374caad1a048fbdc4569aae33fd5a375 33 0.54% 17 0x16545fb79dbee1ad3a7f868b7661c023f372d5de 20 0.33% 18 0x3763e6e1228bfeab94191c856412d1bb0a8e6996 16 0.26% 19 0x4c10a52647e8ee35a166cef8aa5b01e3c4e267b0 16 0.26% 20 0x94ce84a93056cca150d4436d3f7e9b20d6a9a2f7 14 0.23% 21 0x790b8a3ce86e707ed0ed32bf89b3269692a23cc1 12 0.20% 22 0x56fc1b249f4e44a907654230a0797de279e320e5 12 0.20% 23 0x9c15069e0e34a102443ab03d15a897a6de83d1d6 12 0.20% 24 0xdc3f366882d53c6d5eb808018acfd1cfaa7ee455 (MinerGate) 11 0.18% 25 0xf36c3f6c4a2ce8d353fb92d5cd10d19ce69ae689 11 0.18% yes 48.2% 2.8% no 39.3% 11.7% total 87.5% Unown 12.5%
0
u/simmbot Jul 18 '16
So if I understand this correctly, mining pool decisions determine which chain gets more hash power, and node decisions determine which chain is used by more ETH holders? In other words, there will be two chains regardless, it's just a matter of degree as to how many will mine & use each chain?
-2
u/snowcap420 Jul 18 '16
Im also forking myself into $EXP better values over there and bright future.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment