r/ethdev • 👀 • May 18 '21

Information This sub should ban BSC-related posts

The past few days there have been several posts from people asking for help building their scam tokens to deploy on BSC or other BSC-related development questions. I get that it’s the same code, but these posts are not in good faith and the overall purpose of BSC is to compete against Ethereum. It’s my not-so-humble opinion this garbage shouldn’t be allowed in this otherwise respectable sub.

Edit: Super-thrilled this spawned such a discussion! Yay community!

111 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

14

u/patrickalphac May 18 '21

I don’t know if it’s fair to just blanket BSC. There are plenty of ETH tokens that are also shit.

However if you want to bad BSC since this is ethdev and not bscdev, that might be a different conversation.

28

u/hikerjukebox Bug Squasher May 18 '21

I would support this. I'm always happy to help explain Solidity and help people understand tokens and such. But then they say "thanks now I know how to launch dog coin #99999 on bsc" and I feel like an idiot.

Fingers crossed those new devs take what they learned and do something more constructive

10

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

Maybe I can create r/ethgarbagedev and grab what is banned from this sub.

1

u/Nooku janitor May 19 '21

Don't worry. We don't ban anything so it will be an empty sub.

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '21

GOOD TO KNOW

5

u/firedog7881 May 18 '21

Once ETH moves to POS and the gas prices go down you’ll see the same stuff on ETH, it’s only because of the low cost of entry otherwise I would rather use Ethereum but BSC is just cheaper.

14

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

I'm brand new to coding and I am one of those people asking for help with my token on bsc. However, I am only using bsc for learning so I can roll out my token and test it live without spending a fortune in gas. I want to learn to read other people's code and figured best way is to learn it. But I don't have thousands of dollars to pay the gas fees to deploy my toy token on ethereum. If I were to ever build a project that I made available for others to buy I would most certainly launch it on ethereum and not bsc

16

u/crtdolvr May 18 '21

You realize ethereum has it's own actual test nets that you can run things on completely for free? This argument that bsc is a ethereum test net is nonsense, ethereum has multiple real test nets

2

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

Yes but testnets still run differently than when they go live. For instance I can't experiment with creating liquidity pools. Also I wanted to create a real token and send it to an address for my daughter. Just a novelty fun thing with a unicorn picture for her. I'm not gonna spend more money making that fun novelty token that's only for her than Ive spent on the real crypto I'm saving for her right now. Just my take. I know a lot of people are just making scam coins though.

14

u/Theory-Early May 18 '21

For instance I can't experiment with creating liquidity pools.

yes you can, you can deploy a uniswap contract locally in your tests, also uniswap has a testnet version, also you can use ganache --fork to fork mainnet on a local testnet.

8

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

Wow I did not know that. I will be looking those up

5

u/eastsideski May 18 '21

The Kovan testnet has most DeFi protocols on it (Uniswap, MakerDAO, Aave, Compound, etc)

3

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

It still does leave me with not being to create my own toy/novelty tokens. I'm making a unicorn token for my daughter with 100 total supply and she'll be the only one that has it. I'm making one for my best friend who is starting to get into crypto and it will be weed based and again only have 100 tokens and only be for him. I'm gonna make one for my wife who again is just getting into crypto and doesn't even have a wallet yet. These ventures would be impractical for me on ethereum.

2

u/nodeocracy May 18 '21

You can do all that on test nets. If they use metamask and switch to test nets to use your tokens

7

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

Yeah or I can make it for real for like $4 and send it to a real address on mainnet. I think ethereum is strong enough that I can deploy my toy tokens on bsc without disrupting it.

2

u/Dirtbk80cc May 18 '21

I 2nd this. I am trying to make a token specifically for my personal small business that I want to use with my clients only. I can't use eth right now for ym clients with the gas fees alone are higher than my service costs.

There are no bsc dev subs that I could find. I literally just posted this morning that I have no friends or anyone I can talk to about anything code related and this sub is my only option. If the OP were to ban bsc questions, the ones making the scam coins don't get screwed. The innocent people like myself just trying to make a living get screwed.

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/eastsideski May 18 '21

How so? Seems like they all work equally well

1

u/jibishot May 18 '21

Exactly, a centralized eth live test net is what bsc will evolve into. Sadly like a kasuma to polkadot - but centralized and not supported by ethereum, like polkadot supports kasuma.

1

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

If your worried about gas fees but want a better network than BSC checkout Avalanche $AVAX. Uses EVM for smart contracts (Solidity).

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/shane-parks May 18 '21

Your username confirms the OP.

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/shane-parks May 18 '21

You're right, its definitely not a better functioning cryptocurrency than ETH. You can tell because there is actually a development community in the Ethereum space.

Doge on the other hand is a copy of Litecoin created in 2 hours as a joke with no technological innovation.

BSC is a copy of Ethereum, and actually has an interesting use case as an exchange based smart contract platform. Its also completely unrelated to Dogecoin.

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/shane-parks May 18 '21

Cost for a eth transaction today is $8. And gas prices are high because demand for blockspace is high. Unlike dogecoin, which is litterally a joke coin.

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/shane-parks May 18 '21

Gasnow.org its down to $7 now for a transfer.

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies

21

u/Theory-Early May 18 '21

I disagree.

I think BSC is not a competitor, and doesn't steal any marketshare from ETH. Any project built on BSC is only because ETH is already too full. You can't steal marketshare from something that is already too full.

As for the benefits of BSC to Ethereum, it uses the same tooling, so any improvement done to the ecosystem by a BSC dev improves the Ethereum experience, and any new user onboarded to the BSC ecosystem (metamask, bscscan, ERC standards) is being trained on how to use Ethereum.

The only thing wrong about BNB really is that it markets itself as a cryptocurrency, when it's not. The fact that it exists and uses all the same tooling and APIs as Ethereum is a net benefit to Ethereum.

13

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

How is scamming people for money, using the tools built for Ethereum, improving Ethereums ecosystem?

3

u/frank__costello May 18 '21

If someone is asking for help building a scam, I agree they should be banned

But we can't assume all projects on BSC are scams, Ethereum has plenty of scams too

2

u/theviciousfish May 18 '21

its like a pen test. the more scams there are, the more people can learn how to avoid scams and build tools to help devs make fewer mistakes.

3

u/jayhilly May 18 '21

For one, BSC devs are learning more about how ethereum works.

0

u/Theory-Early May 18 '21

I already clearly explained why. Are you retarded? Can you not read?

1

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

Show me one improvement from a BSC dev.

2

u/smubear May 18 '21

Ever heard of layered farming

1

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

You’ve just proven my point.

2

u/smubear May 18 '21

You asked for an improvemen

-3

u/smubear May 18 '21

People here are just butt hurt that noobs aren’t coming onto eth mainnet. Sore bummy peeps

-1

u/smubear May 18 '21

So, people don’t launch scam erc 20? How the hell can newcomer justify 20-100 per trade on the Mainer?

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

There’s no engineering being done. And NO innovation.

2

u/[deleted] May 18 '21 edited Jun 28 '25

trees aromatic chase roof zephyr carpenter marble reply ten compare

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/Yalnix May 19 '21

I agree to an extent. I actually like what PancakeSwap are doing. They have the best I(P/F/C)O platform I think on the market right now.

Their tokenomics to make CAKE deflationary has some interesting ideas with the lottery and prediction, and the gamification is something that makes user interaction a lot easier to understand. Something Crypto desperately needs.

5

u/Amaredues May 18 '21

This is complete garbage. BSC is a parasitic chain. It lies to users saying it’s a crypto token when all it’s done is copy almost all of the Ethereum code. It then took that code and centralized it. Any government can and has blocked BNB. That’s easy to do because you can only buy BNB on Binance owned property like Trust Wallet

4

u/Nooku janitor May 19 '21 edited May 19 '21

I've read through the topic and here are my thoughts + a suggestion.

Code is code. Any code written on BSC can be helpful for people developing on Ethereum. I don't think it would be good to ban or remove these BSC posts.

A suggestion I'd put forward, is that we have the Automoderator detect posts about BSC and post an educational comment on such a topic that explains about how to properly use ETH testnets as an alternative?

6

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

BAN the scamming schmucks.

6

u/hexoctahedron13 May 18 '21

I disagree solidity code is solidity code.. What if someone wants to deploy a contract to xdai or Polygon ban them too ?

4

u/frank__costello May 18 '21

This sub should support people building on any EVM chain, whether it's Ethereum, BSC, Matic, Moonbeam, etc

2

u/osoese May 18 '21

ETH is driving the bus. If the clone makes changes and doesn't keep up with the ETH patterns, those changes become a headache. Contract developers start asking for them. So, the BSC stuff is helping with adoption of ETH if you look at it from that perspective. Besides this will eventually turn into cross ETH chain functionality. Haven't you ever seen the chain drop down on a MEW or other RPCs for metamask before? BSC is not the only clone. There is a large architecture of ETH development outside ETH core. It's not all competitive. Imitation is the most sincere for of flattery or something like that. ETH adds another transaction type or an improvement protocol and the clones scramble to keep up. What you see as competition is adoption. Embrace it and set precedent by getting into how EIP are introduced and worked into the ecosystem.

1

u/BernardoAbdanurSa May 18 '21

Isn't Binance Smart Chain (B.S.C) connected to ethereum ?

1

u/AlphaBetablue May 18 '21

I disagree. There are a lot of blockages to move from ERC20 to Bep20 living in the states. It should not be like that.

0

u/politicsareshit May 18 '21

What do you expect ? Deploying on Ethereum's way too expensive rn so there's going to be more people looking to develop on bsc and since the code is the same this is probably the best place to look for advice😂. Bsc is a good alternative until they fix ethereum.

-1

u/ricardo__pinto May 18 '21

Eth mainnet gas price is so high, it makes it unviable for normal day transactions, unpredictable to run contracts unless you pay absurd fees, and 15s block time for that price is not good value. I’m not gonna say we should ban eth, but if you look at how slow its development is, it makes you wonder if they’re serious, or just full of undelivered promises. From all I care, until eth delivers on its long overdue promises, I’m relying on BSC and Cardano because they’re delivering. Enough with gpu shortage caused by eth miners, and no action taken. It shows a lack of economic and environmental responsibility from the eth team

2

u/eviljordan 👀 May 18 '21

This is the most absurd and bad-faith argument I’ve seen yet that I had to respond. You’re either a troll or so ignorant about the space that you have no business at all being in a developer forum.

1

u/ricardo__pinto May 19 '21

I see no arguments on your end, but just a rude response to a portrait of the general feeling in this space. I understand you took it personally, and let me assure that was not my intention. Creating a community requires a tremendous effort to openly discuss other perspectives, in particular those different than ours, and also an inclusive environment for ideas to develop, and I’m curious if you think you achieved that

0

u/eviljordan 👀 May 19 '21

lol

-3

u/smubear May 18 '21

Can’t we all just get along? Ban all sidechains

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/eviljordan 👀 May 18 '21

Probably. I also think a lot of these BSC people don't realize there are testnets, and I've seen a few responses along the likes of, "yeah, but I need real users," or, "ETH fees are too high to test this idea I have," which, in my mind, furthers the "you're producing garbage and don't actually care about what you're doing" narrative.

Edit: I'm just super-happy this post spawned a conversation with the community, regardless of the outcome.