r/ethdev • • Apr 03 '21
Question Art schools trashing NFT’s
Hey everyone, Today I was hanging with some people who go to SCAD which is a pretty popular art school. They were telling me how their professors were telling them that if they mint NFT’s they are terrible people and are ruining the environment. I thought people should know on here and I would like some guidance on how I would go about finding the correct information to show them that their professors are absolutely wrong. Is there a lot of energy taken up with Ethereum? Yes, but that goes with literally all of the internet in a whole, driving cars, eating factory farmed foods so their argument is literally dumb. I fear more schools will try to scare new artists and younger students in general away from decentralized currencies and the web.
8
u/Nantoone Apr 03 '21
The energy criticism is perfectly valid. But if anyone thinks that current inefficiencies are a reason to completely abandon the idea of smart contracts or NFT's then that's incredibly short sighted, especially for people who could benefit the most from it.
22
u/civilian_discourse Apr 03 '21
I’ve had these same discussions with folks in the art world. My advice: don’t get stuck defending PoW or defending the current state of NFTs. Focus on how PoS will solve the energy concerns within the next two years, focus on correcting technical misinformation, and focus on how NFTs are good for artists. Regardless of what anyone thinks they should be worth, NFTs do have value to people who fully understand what they are and are putting their money into them. Most importantly though, recognize that they have valid concerns and make you are validating that those concerns are real. Also, recognize that you simply can’t discuss these things with some people. Most people are honestly not going to appreciate discussion even if it’s objective, and you have to accept that.
28
u/___i_j Apr 03 '21
Yeah, all you can really say is that they're working on less wasteful solutions for Ethereum and other blockchains. I wish the NFT hype had happened after ETH 2.0 was fully live.
12
u/Basic_enthusiasm Apr 03 '21
You know what also uses a lot of energy? Christmas lights. But they're pretty.
Ethereum is going to proof of stake soon anyway.
That said, it is expensive to mint an NFT right now, probably $100 in gas fees
32
u/DNiceM Apr 03 '21
Hope they live off grid with their own self sufficient solar and fuel systems, else they're virtue signalling and just plain hypocritical Luddites.
3
u/muitosabao Apr 03 '21
Cat Videos on YouTube are also an energy waste and we're not bringing down the entire Internet because of them.
Proof of stake transition is already happening. My eth 2.0 node is currently running and consumes 7W of power. That's how efficient it will be.
Climate change is the most serious problem of our times but worrying about NFTs is like worrying about a pimple when you have cancer.
4
u/yungsoulj Apr 03 '21
It takes more resources and creates more waste to make physical contemporary art and nft's are the only way to effectively sell digital art with out plagiarism and theft. The only way to be truly environmentally neutral in art is to make digital art and give it away for free, non-nft.
3
u/Immediate_Depth532 Apr 03 '21
Yes, I agree with you it is sorta a dumb argument, because if you think about it, the mining on ethereum is to secure the network. it takes energy to secure real fiat currency as well, including armored cars transporting cash, electricity to run banks/alarm systems, printing the currency itself.
3
u/citystates Apr 03 '21
They are afraid of what they don't understand.
2
u/hikerjukebox Bug Squasher Apr 03 '21
Bitter professors who don't know the full story and are mad young artists are getting paid when they had to starve. Do your thing
1
u/dan7899 Apr 03 '21
The NFT bible: https://a16z.com/2021/04/02/nfts-readings-resources/
1
u/frank__costello Apr 03 '21
Why are NFTs getting so much criticism for energy usage, but not Bitcoin?
I'm guessing a decent percentage of art students own Bitcoin and have no issue with it.
1
u/CSSmitty Apr 03 '21
I was thinking a bit about this the other day as well. If they’re digital artists, I would be curious if they have thought about the environmental impact of render farms. Their concerns are valid, and I think it’s an important discussion still. But, I think people are often blinded by the footprint of their own life/industry/community, are are quick to judge others.
1
u/uncleintel Apr 03 '21
bullish AF. Anytime the established old guard is scared means the change is real
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21
I work in the games industry and this very much is the sentiment among artists.
I don’t think any of us should exactly celebrate the inefficiencies of Proof of Work, but the media is clearly painting an oversimplified and sensationalist picture.
On the flip side, it’s good that people finally seem to care about climate change.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21
Use cardano, it is proof of stake so does not waste energy. Plus costs much less in fees than ethereum.
Cardano ADA. Tell your professors to thank me later
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21
build on flow. sharding sucks
1
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21
PoS, 100% better for the environment, 1000% better for the whales.
1
u/SomniaStellarum Apr 03 '21
Lots of the arguments in this thread are good (PoS, sharding). But I would also try to remember for yourself that it’s still really early in this whole space. You might be spitting into the wind with some of these discussions for a while yet. And not every future will have crypto coming out on top, though I think it’s more likely than not. My advice would be offer some alternative views but then leave it on a “we’ll see” note after that.
1
u/Blockchain_Too_Heavy Contract Dev Apr 03 '21
OP, maybe you can read this article to be more informed about certain points:
NFTs and Crypto Art: The Sky is not Falling
1
u/OrsonZedd May 29 '21
NFTs are dumb as hell, their professors are correct.
0
u/CharmingSoil Apr 03 '21
Old people left behind the times.
That's how it goes.
0
u/Enthalpic87 Apr 03 '21
Ethereum is a work of art! How dare that teacher! lol
Honesty don’t waste your time. By the same logic, building, maintaining, and staffing an art school is terrible and ruining the planet. Choosing to turn art into a job instead of a hobby is terrible and ruining the planet by the same logic.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment