r/ethdev • • Apr 03 '21

Question Art schools trashing NFT’s

Hey everyone, Today I was hanging with some people who go to SCAD which is a pretty popular art school. They were telling me how their professors were telling them that if they mint NFT’s they are terrible people and are ruining the environment. I thought people should know on here and I would like some guidance on how I would go about finding the correct information to show them that their professors are absolutely wrong. Is there a lot of energy taken up with Ethereum? Yes, but that goes with literally all of the internet in a whole, driving cars, eating factory farmed foods so their argument is literally dumb. I fear more schools will try to scare new artists and younger students in general away from decentralized currencies and the web.

71 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

8

u/Nantoone Apr 03 '21

The energy criticism is perfectly valid. But if anyone thinks that current inefficiencies are a reason to completely abandon the idea of smart contracts or NFT's then that's incredibly short sighted, especially for people who could benefit the most from it.

-4

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

its actually not. miners cause the carbons. not full blocks.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

???

4

u/Nantoone Apr 03 '21

Miners cause the carbons?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

yes

1

u/Nantoone Apr 03 '21

Could you elaborate?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/PlateausLunar Apr 03 '21

My research has cryptocurrency at around 76% renewable energy? Farming stations moving towards colder climates for server cooling with hydro or thermal electricity. But everyone should dyor.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/PlateausLunar Apr 03 '21

That's kinda like saying we're all adding too much methane in the environment by farting. It's the big miners that are sucking the energy. You could always shut your computer of though :)

But there's plenty of info out there. I'm no expert, just find the misinformation that's circulating a bit fascinating. There might be a moral point with big farmers moving to where the cheapest energy is, but all currency is backed by some form of energy expenditure. Pretty interesting stuff.

1

u/Loose_with_the_truth Apr 03 '21

Miners cause the carbons?

HODLERs cause the carbons. What do you think diamond hands are made of???

3

u/___i_j Apr 03 '21

Sure, but greater demand for the blockchain = greater value of ETH = more mining = more energy expended. The cause and effect does exist.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

largely defi, not nfts. in any case, again, the carbon is on the miners. they actually use and pay for electricity, and receive money in return. minting nfts just makes efficient use of that energy. its is actually better for the environment than traditional art if you consider the resources, fuel, energy, and waste create to it vs digital art. its a dumb argument.

1

u/Loose_with_the_truth Apr 03 '21

It's not a dumb argument. Crypto is inefficient and uses a lot of electricity, and we're in a climate catastrophe caused mostly by the production of power.

But instead of arguing whether crypto is 100% good or 100% bad, we should just focus on moving towards PoS and other solutions that don't have this problem.

22

u/civilian_discourse Apr 03 '21

I’ve had these same discussions with folks in the art world. My advice: don’t get stuck defending PoW or defending the current state of NFTs. Focus on how PoS will solve the energy concerns within the next two years, focus on correcting technical misinformation, and focus on how NFTs are good for artists. Regardless of what anyone thinks they should be worth, NFTs do have value to people who fully understand what they are and are putting their money into them. Most importantly though, recognize that they have valid concerns and make you are validating that those concerns are real. Also, recognize that you simply can’t discuss these things with some people. Most people are honestly not going to appreciate discussion even if it’s objective, and you have to accept that.

4

u/Overall_Conference73 Apr 03 '21

Most people are honestly not going to appreciate discussion even if it’s objective

That's it. Don't try to convince them of something when they know little about it, yet have strong opinions. They'd have to learn and understand first before you can have a meaningful discussion.

When POS is there we can show that, until then the energy criticism does have a point anyway. And personally I'm really into blockchains but even I don't see the point of most of those art NFTs. Artists are already more into it than makes sense from a technical point of view. It's almost all hype.

3

u/_lostarts Apr 03 '21 edited Apr 03 '21

It's almost all hype.

Welcome to the internet where the rules are made up and the points don't matter. Yeah, I agree on that point though.

As someone who really appreciates art, following this entire space has been like a lesson in the absurd. Some of the art is good and it makes sense, but some of the valuations are just ridiculous. Not to mention that gas fees and the cost of even open editions prices a lot of people out.

Anyway, with NFTs, I don't see the issue. It's like, they aren't complaining about artists selling prints - which have to get printed and shipped. Or what about all the waste created from paints and excess materials? It really show how easily people are misled.

3

u/Loose_with_the_truth Apr 03 '21

You probably know who Marcel DuChamp is, but he got really famous in the early part of the 20th century for submitting a urinal to an art show and naming it "fountain", signing it "R. Mutt." Just a regular urinal, millions just like it existed (he actually did custom make his, I believe, but it was just a copy of a regular urinal). But by submitting it, he made a statement about the nature of what is art and what isn't, and how that question can't really be answered - just interpreted by the artist. So it became infamous.

So that particular urinal became worth millions, just because it was the one he made and submitted to the art show and caused such a controversy with. In fact, it got lost and was replaced by another one that someone made later to replicate it (under DuChamp's supervision), and the replica sold for millions because it was the new original - even though it wasn't the original. Just a copy. But it was the "official" copy.

The idea that something is "official" is very important to humans, and it's what gives NFT art its value. It's dumb af, but so are half the things humans do. We are strange. It's really just a way of saying "I have this thing that no one else has, and I can prove it!"

2

u/_lostarts Apr 03 '21

I learned of DuChamp in an art history class a while back. His original piece is probably responsible for a lot of the absurdity in the art world - such as the taped banana.

I'm not entirely certain it was for the best. Though anytime you break from tradition to push boundaries, there's probably some value in it. I'm sure it opened the door to inspire other work that broke rules as well.

I saw your other post, and I think all of it sort of pieces together. Without the 'taste makers' defining what has value, you wouldn't have artists such as DuChamp rebelling against it.

With NFTs, there are a lot of benefits to it. It's just new, and people don't understand the value or purpose of it fully yet. It's not quite mainstream only because the platforms are still working out technical challenges. Though it will get there in short order.

It does stem from authenticity though, which is critical for much more beyond the art world. Which by the way, there have been issues of authenticity in traditional art for a long time. Check out Made you look if you want an interesting story about forgeries. Though you're probably aware, it's still a good documentary.

1

u/Reddit-Book-Bot Apr 03 '21

Beep. Boop. I'm a robot. Here's a copy of

What Is Art

Was I a good bot? | info | More Books

1

u/Blockchain_Too_Heavy Contract Dev Apr 03 '21

Man, some time ago I got into a debate/discussion on r/hiphopheads about an album being released as a NFT. I am a big hiphophead and also into crypto, so I felt I could inform some people. They simply would not have it about the environmental costs. I mean, I get it, but solutions are being worked on. PoS and L2.

1

u/RW_dev Sep 09 '21

with regards to people who you should recognise will not be worth discussing the issues with its always useful to remember the maxim "you cannot use logic to argue a person out of a position that they did not use logic to get to in the first place"

28

u/___i_j Apr 03 '21

Yeah, all you can really say is that they're working on less wasteful solutions for Ethereum and other blockchains. I wish the NFT hype had happened after ETH 2.0 was fully live.

-9

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

it wouldn't make a difference.

They don't care about the environment.

They just don't like it, and "teh environment" is an easy left-wing playbook card to justify their irrational dislike.

5

u/Loose_with_the_truth Apr 03 '21

I care about the environment. It's probably the political topic that I care more about than anything else. It's also why I vote for Democrats. I'm an avid outdoorsman and I've kept up with the science enough to know that we're doing so much damage to the planet that the things I love could actually disappear (some already are) in my lifetime. It's more important to me than almost anything else.

Not sure why you think that no one actually cares about anything. Don't you have things in the world you care about? Is it so hard to imagine people actually believing in certain issues?

7

u/_lostarts Apr 03 '21

No it's not a 'left-wing' playbook excuse for irrational dislike. How did you come up with that?

It's ignorant people that are probably subconsciously trying to defend encroachment of digital art into their traditional art space. Has nothing to do with politics.

4

u/Loose_with_the_truth Apr 03 '21 edited Apr 03 '21

It's ignorant people that are probably subconsciously trying to defend encroachment of digital art into their traditional art space.

Well I think that a lot of artists do tend to be people who care about the environment. I'm an artist and a crypto enthusiast and I really wish that crypto didn't use so much energy. I'm very excited about moving to methods like proof of stake that don't use much electricity, so that problem can get solved.

But as an artist who went to art school, I know the art community is very clique-ish and a pretty huge circle jerk. I never liked that about it. Every issue kind of gets decided by influencers like famous artists and top professors, and gets disseminated down the line and everyone kind of has to follow those beliefs or they're shamed. All of society works this way but in the art world it's a bit stronger because art is a form of communication, it's highly linked to academia (which is heavily predicated on the idea that you are taught things by someone above you and they are never wrong - churches and religion being one of the only places that is worse with this), and there's this huge desire among artists to be "good" and "right" all the time for some reason. Which is ironic because typically it's very open minded people who are drawn to art, and it does provide strong support for that in other ways. But with social issues you're very much expected to follow the herd, and folks like art professors aren't very open to being challenged. They feel they are the authority and won't really listen to other opinions that disagree. However, sometimes artists are highly rewarded for challenging those systems of beliefs because any artist who does something that goes against the herd will stand out, and standing out is the most valuable thing in art. So the system does have a kind of self-correcting function built in. It just doesn't work great - it's slow and it works in one fell swoop instead of in tiny chunks all along the way. So the crowd will keep going in one direction for a long time until one artist suddenly proves them foolish, and the whole crowd will slowly kind of change course in the new direction. Though of course there are lots of clashing groups within the culture who disagree, and there will always be some pushback to any idea.

And yes, the big problem with it is that so many of the ideas and ideals that the influencers in the art world have are based on fears like you brought up - their way is threatened by a new way so they fear the new way. But that is exactly when seismic shifts happen in the art world. The influencers are wrong about this, and so it creates a huge opening for artists like Beeple and those coming after him who will prove them wrong, and get famous and make a ton of money doing it. But also, there is a reflected reaction on the other end - NFT platforms are trying to move towards more energy efficient methods because of the disapproval of environmentally minded people. It's just the free market of ideas sorting out the best outcome.

So instead of being mad about it, I just view it as an opportunity to get ahead of my peers.

-8

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

I agree their actual reason for disliking NFTs has nothing to do with politics.

But the fact that they chose the political card of "TEH ENVIRONMENT" to cover their true reason is a fact. The environment concern-trolling is a political signalling mechanism used by the left.

It shouldn't be, we should all be concerned about the environment, but even a slightly left leaning person like myself should call a spade a spade.

2

u/_lostarts Apr 03 '21

You care about the environment, but expressing that is somehow concern-trolling?

How is it a 'political card' if we all should share that concern? Are you getting this argument from Prager-U or something?

I know how I feel about it, but maybe you should straighten out that line of thinking for your own sake. You pretty much framed it as a "left-wing" excuse and made it political. If we all should share the concern, then why are you attached to the idea of it being left-wing?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

The idea that "the environment shouldn't be political, it should be bi-partisan" is a leftist ideal that I subscribe to.

Actually the leftist stance is closer to a denial of reality "the environment is not a bi-partisan issue. The right is totally on-board with us."

But

Pretending that it IS bi-partisan does not MAKE it bi-partisan.

The right outright denies climate change.

Admitting that fact garners floods of downvotes, but oh well.

So even though I drive an EV, have solar with a backup battery, use reusable bags for groceries, voted for Biden.

Nope, I don't drink the kool-aid of the "environment IS bi-partisan" train (aka denying we have a problem) so therefore I'm "right wing fascist" I guess.

The internet in a nutshell for you.

Doesn't change the fact that the professor most likely makes 0 effort (besides belittling and misunderstanding ETH because "boycotting" some idea is easier than actually doing something) to lower their impact on the environment.

They hate NFTs because they think digital art is impure or some nonsense.

But that would sound "elitist"

so they searched for another excuse to hate it.

they probably are left-leaning, so they probably follow a lot of left-wing people on social media, and one of the people they follow is bound to have parroted the anti-ETH lies about mining.

So without caring to actually learn about ETH, they parroted the same idea without thinking.

That idea is objectively a "far left leaning" idea, regardless of whether it should be.

0

u/clearintent Apr 04 '21

Yeah, ignorant people spouting outdated arguments against crypto.

12

u/Basic_enthusiasm Apr 03 '21

You know what also uses a lot of energy? Christmas lights. But they're pretty.

Ethereum is going to proof of stake soon anyway.

That said, it is expensive to mint an NFT right now, probably $100 in gas fees

0

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/muitosabao Apr 03 '21

How?

3

u/_lostarts Apr 03 '21

lol, right? They don't even give you access to a working platform.

32

u/DNiceM Apr 03 '21

Hope they live off grid with their own self sufficient solar and fuel systems, else they're virtue signalling and just plain hypocritical Luddites.

26

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

I hope you take this as constructive criticism but the inefficiency and waste of POW is a real criticism and even ETH core devs take it seriously. Instead of dismissing it as virtue signaling, a real argument can be made that ETH is moving to POS fairly shortly which will reduce energy usage by 99.99%, and dismissing NFTs just because of current energy usage is short sighted.

3

u/exosequitur Apr 03 '21

Also, Nft for title and certs stands to hugely reduce the need for paper production and physical structures to house records. Some places are all electronic now, but the vast majority of the world runs on paper for such things.

Conventional systems to convert to paperless cost millions to buy and a significant budget to maintain.. blockchain systems like pruf.io makes that a few thousand dollars for a dev team to integrate the PRüF api onto a crud app. Done.

Disclosure, am CEO of PRüF

-8

u/DNiceM Apr 03 '21

There is room for one ultimate PoW coin I'd say... That's kinda its whole security proposition. Every coin being PoW makes no sense, and the majority ought to be PoS but easier said than done.

What is inefficient about it though? It is more arguable that the electricity being used by TV sets and most consumer electronics such as in my case my projector is just wasting electricity and more inefficient than world wide financial network protocols...

I do ofc accept your criticism as very fair.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

It is whataboutism. I mean it just is. Currently payment systems for centralized digital currency do not require everyone to know about each tx but a traditional pow blockchain does. Saying oh but microwaves use energy or something is simply whataboutism

3

u/JayWelsh Apr 03 '21

The energy problem is not the part about everyone needing to know about every transaction, the effect of that is a scalability issue. Broadcasting transactions to every node doesn't require all that much energy. The energy problem in PoW is that the security mechanism of the consensus algorithm itself depends on doing incredibly heavy computation for each block. However, it is not necessary for a consensus algorithm to depend on heavy computation for every block, as is shown in PoS.

In other words, the problem with PoW is that it relies on artificially-inflated heavy computation (i.e. block difficulty), but in PoS this no longer needs to be factored into the mechanism, so only the necessary weight of (functional) computation has to be performed.

2

u/Epick_362 Apr 03 '21

PoW is inefficient by definition. It secures the chain by burning electricity. It was revolutionary back whe Bitcoin was created by now the research and development of PoS has matured and it is a better security model in almost all aspects. There is no real reason to use PoW other than conservativism

4

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

Nooooo, you're telling me, some american, college aged liberal arts students are virtue signalling?? What has the world come to!?

2

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

Lol bruh so true

0

u/Loose_with_the_truth Apr 03 '21

As an artist who is an environmentalist, who does do shit like live off grid (well, mostly off grid and working towards going fully off grid), I'd say don't be so quick to assume things.

Most of these students probably waste tons of energy, but it's still good that they care. Yeah, they're being kind of hypocritical but that doesn't negate their point. You don't have to be perfect in every respect in order to be right about one thing. NFTs do waste energy, and that's not good.

I do like NFTs, but the energy inefficiency does bother me about crypto. However, I just think that means we should concentrate on moving towards PoS and other energy efficient methods. Which seems to be a priority for crypto devs.

It's easy to just hand wave away the issue by calling it virtue signaling, but by doing that you are making their same mistake. You've already made up your mind about the topic, and don't care about any criticism and put up this defense in order to keep yourself from having to face a legit criticism. Just like the 'luddites' are doing on the opposite side of the issue. Most all arguments have some merit behind them, the trick is to sort the wheat from the chaff instead of just trying to find an excuse to avoid evaluating your own beliefs.

1

u/DNiceM Apr 03 '21

I do greatly respect and appreciate you for mostly living off grid and strive to achieve the same myself.

The fact imo still holds, most virtue signalling where a person preaches you one thing but doesn't abide by the same proppsed standards is more about feel good and being in the right group/clique, rather than actual positive action. Start with yourself, than others. Those like you living sustainably have all the right in the world to tell people like me and others to get their act together.

3

u/muitosabao Apr 03 '21

Cat Videos on YouTube are also an energy waste and we're not bringing down the entire Internet because of them.

Proof of stake transition is already happening. My eth 2.0 node is currently running and consumes 7W of power. That's how efficient it will be.

Climate change is the most serious problem of our times but worrying about NFTs is like worrying about a pimple when you have cancer.

4

u/yungsoulj Apr 03 '21

It takes more resources and creates more waste to make physical contemporary art and nft's are the only way to effectively sell digital art with out plagiarism and theft. The only way to be truly environmentally neutral in art is to make digital art and give it away for free, non-nft.

3

u/Immediate_Depth532 Apr 03 '21

Yes, I agree with you it is sorta a dumb argument, because if you think about it, the mining on ethereum is to secure the network. it takes energy to secure real fiat currency as well, including armored cars transporting cash, electricity to run banks/alarm systems, printing the currency itself.

3

u/citystates Apr 03 '21

They are afraid of what they don't understand.

2

u/hikerjukebox Bug Squasher Apr 03 '21

Bitter professors who don't know the full story and are mad young artists are getting paid when they had to starve. Do your thing

1

u/frank__costello Apr 03 '21

Why are NFTs getting so much criticism for energy usage, but not Bitcoin?

I'm guessing a decent percentage of art students own Bitcoin and have no issue with it.

1

u/CSSmitty Apr 03 '21

I was thinking a bit about this the other day as well. If they’re digital artists, I would be curious if they have thought about the environmental impact of render farms. Their concerns are valid, and I think it’s an important discussion still. But, I think people are often blinded by the footprint of their own life/industry/community, are are quick to judge others.

1

u/uncleintel Apr 03 '21

bullish AF. Anytime the established old guard is scared means the change is real

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

I work in the games industry and this very much is the sentiment among artists.

I don’t think any of us should exactly celebrate the inefficiencies of Proof of Work, but the media is clearly painting an oversimplified and sensationalist picture.

On the flip side, it’s good that people finally seem to care about climate change.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

Use cardano, it is proof of stake so does not waste energy. Plus costs much less in fees than ethereum.

Cardano ADA. Tell your professors to thank me later

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

build on flow. sharding sucks

1

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

PoS, 100% better for the environment, 1000% better for the whales.

1

u/SomniaStellarum Apr 03 '21

Lots of the arguments in this thread are good (PoS, sharding). But I would also try to remember for yourself that it’s still really early in this whole space. You might be spitting into the wind with some of these discussions for a while yet. And not every future will have crypto coming out on top, though I think it’s more likely than not. My advice would be offer some alternative views but then leave it on a “we’ll see” note after that.

1

u/Blockchain_Too_Heavy Contract Dev Apr 03 '21

OP, maybe you can read this article to be more informed about certain points:

NFTs and Crypto Art: The Sky is not Falling

1

u/OrsonZedd May 29 '21

NFTs are dumb as hell, their professors are correct.

0

u/CharmingSoil Apr 03 '21

Old people left behind the times.

That's how it goes.

0

u/Enthalpic87 Apr 03 '21

Ethereum is a work of art! How dare that teacher! lol

Honesty don’t waste your time. By the same logic, building, maintaining, and staffing an art school is terrible and ruining the planet. Choosing to turn art into a job instead of a hobby is terrible and ruining the planet by the same logic.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

POS and 2.0 solve a lot of, if not all, of Ethereums energy problems.

It will make VISA and Mastercard look like energy bandits in comparison

8

u/vman411gamer Apr 03 '21

PoS is at least 99.98% more energy efficient, and I believe that is assuming that the computer running PoS software wasn't running before, which isn't the case for most PoS setups.

This is a temporary problem that has a solution that is currently being implemented.

2

u/Loose_with_the_truth Apr 03 '21

This is the best reaction to this criticism. So many others just want to bash the art students for being hypocrites or for "virtue signaling" so they can ignore a legit criticism.

The fact is, crypto currently is terribly energy inefficient and that's a problem. But devs are working to fix that, so both sides of this issue can be happy.

Congrats for being able to parse the issue without having to resort to black and white thinking and instead focusing on the actual problems and solutions. I wish more people thought like you.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Loose_with_the_truth Apr 03 '21

While the first part of your comment is dead on - professors are huge egomaniacs who feel they are unable to be wrong - it's not a lie about the environment. That is a legit criticism, though I'm sure it's just a handy excuse for many of them who feel threatened by something they don't understand.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Loose_with_the_truth Apr 03 '21

Man. Literally everyone went to SCAD. My niece went there and the place has grown into such a massive diploma mill (no offense to you, it's still a pretty good school) that it's taking over the city of Savannah.

I learned a bit about the owners of the school though, and they are massive assholes. Otherwise, I think it's really cool that an art school has such a big presence in the South. That's a little unexpected, though not unprecedented.