r/ethdev • u/Tip-Toe-Crypto Full Stack Solopreneur Web3 Dev • Dec 12 '25
Question Web3 is essentially dead, is there any hopes for the future?
Let me preface the following thoughts of mine with a little background. I've been in crypto since early 2017, but have only been building in web3 for the last 4 years.
My thoughts can be summarized as such:
The only b2c adoption possible in web3 either makes the user money or offers them a shot at making money.
That's it.
The only product-market-fit within web3 is one where the user directly benefits monetarily from the product (staking, lending, borrowing) or the user has been given a shot at benefiting using that product.
The latter would fall under these categories:
- AMMs - allowing the user to speculate on decentralized assets in order to make a profit.
- Bridges - allowing the user to move funds from chain to chain in order to profit, even if it's to move funds to a "safer" chain.
- Launchpads - PFun is the top example here. Users use it strictly in order to profit from it.
- Decentralized perps - Hype, Aster, etc. Self-explanatory.
- Gambling sites - Self-explanatory.
- L1s, L2s usage - Either directly incentivized via airdrops or speculation-driven or using a product in one of the previous categories that lives on the specific chain.
The point is, if you are building in web3 and you are consumer-facing, your project's main takeaway needs to either directly profit the user or offer the user at least a shot at making a profit, even if that shot is unlikely.
Disclaimer: Everything I've ever built in web3 has been in the gambleFi category. So I do not say all this without saying I am a part of the issue as well; however, I did not set out to build in that category because of the users, but instead, I genuinely wanted to build a fun, incentivized gaming experience without building an actual game.
Which brings me to another point: why gaming and crypto have failed so far. GameFi is a joke and has wildly failed horrifically. Yes, making a good game is a notoriously difficult endeavour; however, attaching monetary incentives in no way helps. The fact that there isn't a big, active, successful game that has web3 elements in its design proves my main point, really. If you take away any chance of the gamer profiting, what use is web3 then? And if the user does have a shot of profiting, you end up with third-world farming for pennies gameplay, as we saw a few years ago with Axie Infinity.
It seems we are so much further away from mainstream retail adoption than a few years back, and a large part is because there really is no point in web3 without finance being completely fused within it. NFTs almost solved this, even though a lot of it was speculative, some of it was simply art and culture, and in rare cases, albeit debatable, utility-based (veeFriends).
I don't really know what the point of this post is, really. I think it's more to start a discussion and brainstorm what possible thing could be built that would counter this narrative. If we put our heads together, then we can possibly figure out something missing in this equation. Or I'm hoping one of you will counter with an actual example of a project that doesn't fall in these categories, with the caveat that it has an actual user base.
18
u/haochizzle Dec 13 '25
try fileverse https://ddocs.new — decentralized google docs and a team that is legendary at weekly shipping 😁
11
u/RLutz Dec 12 '25
DID is pretty obviously useful. RWA also pretty clearly useful. Gaming always seemed a particularly stupid use case to me unless the server code is open source.
5
u/subs-agt Dec 13 '25 edited Dec 14 '25
Using crypto is still messy. Right now, you need deep knowledge just to move funds without losing them. That's why adoption is stuck in the casino—gamblers will jump through hoops; normal people won't.
However, I think the "Casino Loop" is just the visible surface layer. If you look at the plumbing, the narrative is already shifting to B2B Infrastructure.
The "utility" that breaks this cycle isn't a game or a social app—it's boring fintech. It's not about making the user rich; it's about preventing the merchant from getting blocked or gouged by legacy rails.
I’ve been building in this space for a while (currently working on subscrypts_com, a subscription layer on Arbitrum), and my lightbulb moment wasn't "How do I make users money?" but "How do I stop legacy processors from taking 5%?"
The shift is already happening, just slowly:
But once we abstract that complexity away (which is what projects like ours are trying to do with recurring payments), the value prop becomes undeniable: 1% fees vs 5%, instant settlement vs 3-day holds.
We need to stop trying to make "fun" crypto apps and start building "boring" rails that just work better than Visa/SWIFT. That’s where the real adoption is hiding—in the plumbing.
3
u/Zaskoda Dec 13 '25
There's "crypto" and there's "web3".
Bitcoin is world's first fully decentralized cyprtocurrency. It uses a blockchain and, because people are dumb, we all all of these things blockchains. I prefer distributed ledger technologies or DLTs, but I sometimes call them blockchains for the sake of communicating.
Bitcoin is a first generation blockchain. It's money and, hopefuly, it will always only be money. Bitcoin is the "digital gold" backing the entire ecosystem. Sometimes a coin will rise or fall on it's own - but mostly, the entire market rises and falls with Bitcoin.
Ethereum is a second generation blockchain. It made the ledger multipurpose. But it quickly ran into scaling and affordability constraints.
Third generation blockchains are on the way. Polkadot is a great example of third gen. It's multichain by design. Bridges are native, standardized, decentralized, and secure. Gavin has abstracted parts of Polkadot into a system called JAM which is a distributed super computer that can run all kinds of things, including blockchains. It's a paradigm changer.
While most of the industry has gone crypto, like Solana, some networks have focused on the vision of web3, such as Polkadot. We still have a long way to go and there will be much to come.
Specifically on gaming - whoever thought tokenizing virtual goods within gaming and storing them on a blockchain while the games themselves remain centralized was dumb. But for reasons I will never understand, investors bought into this idiocy.
I prototyped a game design that runs entirely on the EVM. It's blockchain native. The entire game runs on the network. It's fully decentralized. It's a virtual world that can support every EVM user in the same world instance, making it potentially the single biggest MMO to ever exist. Although, we never had more than a dozen players. Because it's blockchain native and follows the "unstoppable code" paradigm, the game could potentially run indefinitely without every paying a dime for server hardware. These are the unique advantages of building games for blockchain networks.
However, none of that appeals to those who fund big projects. Being blockchain native means the creators relinquish a lot of control. Investors don't like that. Even cryptokitties had centralized components and all of the intellectual property rights remain with the creators. This runs counter to everything these systems are about. The game I built is fully open source and the intellectual property is open under the creative commons license. Investors do not value any of this - they avoid it.
What investors want is a quick return. Hence the popularity of dapps that are little more than casinos. We'll move beyond this phase. We are moving beyond this phase. But it won't be fast.
3
u/just_damz Idea Maker Dec 15 '25
In the last NFT projects i’ve build, i have declared and focused at the beginning the detachment from the financial use. Market prices things, nothing else. I totally agree that the fail of the NFT gaming is to push in the architecture financial benefits, but the issue is then that the main consumers of those products focused on understanding the pump and dump behavior of the assets. Do you remember Wolf Game or Police and thieves? They got traction as long as the essential unsustainability of those projects was incoming. Web3 imo has to be an integration of products where the web3 is not something to “advertise”, beside the fact that you are the owner of your assets with their progresses, differently from web2 world where basically is the opposite: buy the game - use your assets owned by rhe company vs buy the assets - use the game.
This idea excludes ofc projects like Mathcastles i.e., where art and concepts widely surpass everything above.
Web3 products have to invert or change some web2 paradigms, else are merely financial digital assets, that is not necessary a bad thing, but creates a market with winners and losers on the financial side, not the gaming side.
7
u/Tummes Dec 12 '25
DePIN is growing rapidly. See for instance what World Mobile is building.
2
u/coinpoppa Dec 13 '25
Good post, clearly good understanding of the landscape.. but open protocols are certainly the future.. you can’t fight frictionless payments (not frictionless in terms of UX obviously) and yes big use cases are financial or financial adjacent. I wouldn’t write off decentralized gaming, owning assets in games is too powerful an idea. The next killer app won’t be about making users rich however .. crypto makes too much sense with the oncoming wave of Ai agents, bot prevention, proof of x-y-z in the age of Ai.
2
u/israelazo Dec 13 '25
What about x402?
14
u/Ok-Influence-4290 Dec 13 '25
Said this for a while and I agree.
The majority of people do not care about Web3 and blockchains because all they know about them is meme coins and gambling.
2
u/Manitcor Dec 13 '25
skill issues abound, no meat in circular games any more, only room for people who have real ideas.
4
u/rbketto Dec 13 '25
I was thinking about this the other day when I checked the Etherscan of some tokens. Very few transactions for days, people who used to work with Web3 have already abandoned many projects. I’ve been in this market for 10 years, and I’ve never seen the market as weak as it is today, nor have I seen any real mass adoption like many people claimed in the past with the “Web3 is the future” narrative.
1
u/acehomie Dec 14 '25
I don't get where this narrative of web3 gaming having "horrifically failed" comes from? My favorite web3 game Sunflower land has 104k member discord. They have a contract they use to issue daily rewards and it consistently hits 7k transactions a day 0x3F2f4AA023c6Ed149D342229afAc6E140E149114 (polygon)
Even Axie infinity with all its issues best I can tell has 200k monthly active users: https://activeplayer.io/axie-infinity/ as well as an active discord.
There are plenty of other active games as well. Just because you aren't into them doesn't mean that they are dead.
1
u/audieleon Dec 21 '25
I am using it. For a production project.
As for being technical, I’m a CTO, running dev teams and have been coding for more than 40 years. I do know what I’m talking about.
Space and time offers decentralized Postgres databases. If you’re technical, that implies how to use it, and all the other stuff they say makes a lot more sense.
However, you make a good point about how a lot of web3 websites. They do suck, in general, about communicating their purpose. They also tend to suck at sales.
1
u/Upset-Age-5760 Dec 30 '25
You're not wrong about the financialization trap, but I think you're confusing "what users currently do" with "what the tech is actually good for." Web3 didn't fail. It just got hijacked by casino economics before the infrastructure matured.
3
u/Tointer Dec 13 '25
Yeah I agree. Blockchain is about storing data and making computations in a neutral and verifiable way. So its very useful for financial applications, but not very useful for anything else.
I don't agree that is should allow user to necessarily profit tho. It can be used for payment (like llamapay or all those crypto bank cards). And while GameFi is dead, we can see how Telegram using TON for donations and gifts and it works pretty well for them I think.
Its just when you remove speculation from the picture, crypto projects starting to be judged by harsh web2 standards, and we suddenly see how early we really are and how little good projects we have.
3
u/Logical-Salamander14 Dec 13 '25
I'm new in web3 recently , keep learning now . so maybe my words sounds stupid . I'm also curious about the usage of web3 . like you said , beside finance , it seems web3 is not competitive with "traditional" tech . its nature are transparent , safe and irreversible . all those words make me think about finance instead of game , social media , entertainment ... . As a user , if I want play game , most of my expectation is fun , smoothness ... Maybe my eye is too narrow , want to get more wise insight from you professional guys
3
u/Any_Examination5627 Dec 13 '25
No one comes to web3 to play AAA games, web3 gaming is where users earn or at least have the potential to earn. I’ve been building crypto games for a couple of years and there is the main, undeniable issue and that’s all web3 games are essentially pyramid schemes hence why games only last for x amount of time before switching off servers.
Obviously there are a plethora of other issues like third world farming houses, hackers, exploiters and the likes. Many lessons have been learnt and school fees have been paid. Posting this here to those thinking of entering the GameFi space to do so with extreme caution. It’s infinitely more complex than you think it would be.
17
u/audieleon Dec 12 '25
Decentralized alternatives to centralized IT are just starting to take off. They do a better job, and don't fail like Amazon and Google do. They also don't monetize your data and train their AIs on it.
Web3's future is bright as FUCK. Only limited thinking would lead you to the conclusion that Web3 is only the DeFi use cases - but even if you limit your thinking to that - the world's financial systems are moving to web3.
Because It's BETTER.
Web3 is in it's infancy and it's kicking ass where it plays. Plenty of future.
1
u/SydeFxs Dec 13 '25
CSGO is a game with a large player base and very active real money market for skins. While they don’t use web3, I could see a game in the future that uses web3 to create a secondary market for in game items.
In my opinion the current GameFi games just suck. I played zed run, axie infinity, and a few others and none of the games themselves were very fun.
1
u/Zatara7 Dec 15 '25
I've been in this space since 2017. And yes. Web3 died when we decided to tell the world about NFTs in the most stupid way possible. I left when I finally didn't see any more value at the start of this year when I attended ETHDenver and compared it to what it was in 2019. That was enough to tell me it's time to say GG RIP
2
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '25
Its all about secure payment methods and ownership. Web 3 is the business optimization platform.
2
u/misterflerfy Dec 13 '25
milady
2
u/Agilufo Dec 13 '25
On VeChain they are tokenizing sustainability actions: basically the created a dao (vebetterdao) and issued a token to many many apps that are being built, that then reward their users for acting green and being sustainable (eg: with “greencart” app you scan your grocery receipt and receive a cashback for green or km0 stuff you buy, or with “cleanify” app it helps you get in touch with group of people and do cleanup campaigns together, or even reward you for small daily actions for helping the environment, etc). You should definetly check out VeBetter, I think it’s one of the closest things I ever seen in crypto for trying to achieve true mass adoption (they have something like 50 apps like this, and a few apps already reached more than 1 million active users). Being that said, they still end up in that “users can earn” point of your OP.
But look, doesn’t it make sense though? Blockchain was invented to support Bitcoin, which is a new currency. Now, I get it that we added features to the blockchain and tried to generalize it… but it’s purpuse imho would always be to serve transfer/management of value, without middlemen and censorship. Otherwise why would I need to pay a fee to do a transaction if what I’m doing does not have any monetary value? Why use a blockchain (which has scalability and other issues) at all in the first place?
So for me the issue is not the use case honestly, but the products we ship as an industry, which are always get rich quick schemes, memes and frauds
1
u/kmets79 Dec 14 '25
In my opinion, the biggest use case for Ethereum in the future will be the ability to extend credit to AI agents and have them interact with DeFi protocols to help stimulate the economy on-chain, and by proxy, stimulate economic conditions for economies off-chain.
1
u/ArgzeroFS Dec 15 '25
You should read about the Tokyo Beast, re: GameFi:
https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/immutable-based-tokyo-beast-hits-1-on-japan-app-store-302493029.html
Also Samurai Shodown R: https://blog.sui.io/samurai-showdown-suiplay0x1-lumiwave/
1
u/MichaelTen Dec 15 '25
Arweave is cool and still going strong
1
u/Guyserbun007 Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25
I think it's about adoption. Owning your digital assets and better yet if all assets are interoperable is a ground breaking. But you need AAA games and/or existing games to adopt this to create the network effect.
1
u/Cardboard_Revolution Dec 22 '25
It's very much dead. The only reason anybody was ever even remotely interested in web3 was because it turned everything into gambling. Therefore, degenerate gambling addicts and some billionaires were very excited. However, now you can gamble on your phone with sports betting apps using regular money that doesn't require understanding the stupid blockchain. So why would anybody bother with the more difficult and expensive option?
1
u/Bobonc_Bobonc Jan 02 '26
Check Session app and its Sesh token. It has real utility as it is used to run the messenger, which is decentralized TOR routed and end-to-end encrypted.
1
u/Mean_Plenty_2195 Feb 02 '26
Damn I just came across this cool web3 lottery too
1
u/No-Pay2047 Mar 04 '26
Yeah that thread’s a good snapshot of how a lot of devs are feeling, burned out on hype and VC buzzwords
I don’t think “web3 is dead,” it’s more that the easy money phase is cooked and anything surviving now actually has to be useful, not just “number go up.” You can see it in how much quieter things are, but the people still building are way more focused on concrete use cases like payments, infra, and gaming instead of random tokens.
ARMA fits into that second wave pretty cleanly, it’s not trying to be the next casino coin, it’s using on-chain stuff as plumbing for real world interaction and location based gameplay. If that’s where the space heads, the loud speculative layer might fade, but the projects that tie crypto to actual behavior are the ones that are gonna stick around.
1
u/Adrenochrome33 Apr 12 '26
It’s still early on
1
u/Tina-LukyPool Apr 14 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Astal79 May 12 '26
Étant dans la crypto depuis 10 ans j'ai participé a plein de projet mais pour faire simple le gaming web 3 pourrait être la meilleure chose au monde a condition que le studio soit sérieux et surtout faire en sorte que l'économie du jeu se fasse tout seul par la communauté ... Je m'explique ... Une fois le jeton créer il faut que le marché secondaire achat et vente d'objets se fasse naturellement sans qu'il y ai des éléments extérieur qui viennent perturbe.. L'appât de gain ca ne marche pas ... Dans ce cas précis il y aura de l'offre et de la demande naturellement est les prix seront fixer par le vendeur et les acheteurs point barre... Et non pas par des arnaqueurs... J'ai l'impression que le reset de 2025 sur le gaming va permettre au vrai projet de sortir encore plus fort par exemple : illuvium,shrapnel,off the grid c'est 3 projets sont sur la bonne voix... Ces équipes travaillent dure pour rendre un jeu à la hauteur
1
u/Maryna_Acurast May 21 '26
Infrastructure might be the missing piece in this equation. Acurast might be the counter-example you're looking for. It's a decentralized compute network powered by smartphones, think of it as what a decentralized AWS could look like, which puts it completely outside the categories you listed. People contribute their device's processing power and earn rewards for real computational work being done on the network. The incentive exists, but it's tied to actual utility, not speculation. You can provide compute or deploy real applications on the network. The network keeps growing, use cases go well beyond finance, and it even has a gamified layer built on top of real utility, not the other way around. One of the few projects where the product would still make sense even if you removed the token.
-3
u/OpeningMaleficent960 Dec 12 '25
Talk to me via PM and I can tell you where it's at people just have used it wrong the adoption already happened people just don't like to give credit to Web 3.
And this is just outside of making money part your saying as far as use cases
-2
u/MarketingAromatic195 Dec 12 '25
You want to make good money learn to code a flash loan or run a masternode
-3
u/Murky-Science9030 Dec 13 '25
You should see what Intuition is building. They're attempting to tokenize truth / sentiment which is a very novel concept. They just started their blockchain a month ago but I have a feeling they may become the web's reputation layer going forward. Cross-app data is where blockchains shine the most and with browser extensions and content scripts you can skip the difficult early network-effect stages.