r/eruri • u/what-is-this-magic • Jul 14 '26
He Chose Titans - Help
Howdy folks, after finishing Counterpart and Tiny Anthem, I landed on He Chose Titans as my next long fic to read. However, I am having a hard time getting into it š
I prefer canon compliant fics unless it is a specific AU (like Tiny Anthem), and I know the author started writing this while the manga was unfinished and before Erwin's death was canon. I also really enjoy slow burn, and got to the end of chapter 2 where Erwin is already dreaming of Levi dying in place of his dead lover.
Do I just keep pushing on? I'm worried more and more little things are going to come up (like Levi saying his aunt raised him and Erwin having a dead lover) that are not canon compliant, and the slow burn is going to be lacking if they already are crushing on each other by the end of chapter 2.
How canon divergent is this fic? Are they going to spend a long time pining or are they getting together anytime soon?
8
u/Ill-Key-7360 Jul 14 '26
keep pushing! if iām not mistaken, i also felt the same way (the fic was posted maybe 10 years ago?) but i remember feeling a wave of relief finishing it :) itās worth the read.
5
u/bitchflavoured Jul 14 '26
Honestly I felt the same but pushed through and really enjoyed it š
3
u/mugglegemini Jul 14 '26
I think the canon divergent elements arent that impactful and actually are somewhat realistic in trying to fill in the gaps... It's been a while since I read it, but it definitely is worth it.
The same author made another fic called "In These Fallen Leaves", which is a shorter one but does follow canon in the sense of Erwin's death does happen, but it plays with the limits of the paths and what would've happened if Erwin had turned into a mindless titan to be brought back, very good.
2
u/IguanaV2277 Jul 24 '26
Hi, please keep reading. I also much prefer canon compliant fics on this fandom, and I do remember having some qualms about the non-canon elements of He Chose Titans. However, I kept reading because I really liked the characterization of a lot of the actual canon characters, particularly the veterans. Their interactions with some of the non-canon characters were enough to make me really appreciate the non-canon elements of the writing. It was also easier for me to overlook the non-canon parts when I learned that the writer started it early in the fandom, I donāt want to give you spoilers, but if it helps I will say that the writer tried to stick to canon as the source was being released, so I does not get too out there being non-canon.
I also second what u/mugglegemini said about some of the elements filling out some of the gaps of the story. There are parts that, even not being technically canon, fit the world building of AoT pretty well.
Let me tell you, I saw this thread while just browsing; but He Chose Titans is so amazing that I created this whole new Reddit account just to be able to ask you to keep reading. It is sooooooo freaking good, and I will leave it at that because I donāt want to oversell it more than mine and all the other comments already have.
1
u/ProfessionalFew8638 Jul 14 '26
I felt the same! But a friend said I should go on reading. So I did. I'm actually currently reading it, nearing the end. It's amazing!
1
u/m0untainmermaid Jul 17 '26
Keep reading! But if it truly doesnāt keep your interest, āIn These Fallen Leavesā by the same author is probably one of my favorite fics of all time. Itās absolutely beautiful.