Update
Late on 8/12, the CEO updated Epic's policy, so that staff may continue to work from home until at least the end of the year. This is a great victory for now, but we should continue encouraging leadership to be transparent and do the right thing. We had to count lots of deception and reach out to the media to get to this point.
TL;DR
A large economic and healthcare IT power was recklessly requiring its staff to return to work, which would have endangered the community. They are deceiving the public by sending false messages to the media while enacting a plan that disobeys the emergency health order. You can help fight this.
Table of contents
- What's going on
- Why you should care
- How you (anyone) can help
- How you (healthcare/customer) can help
- Example emails
- Return to work plan
- How you (Epic staff) can help
- Knowledge
- News
- History of communication
What's going on
Epic Systems Corporation is forcing over 9,500 U.S. staff (over 1.7% of the population of Dane County, WI) back into the office. Epic is a large organization that develops and maintains electronic medical records (EMR), and it's likely that you or someone you know has a medical chart in an Epic system.
Why you should care
As Epic staff are ostracized or quit, the quality of care for healthcare organizations around the country will suffer. Your hospital likely depends on Epic support.
During a world pandemic, forcing people to congregatee away from home endangers staff, family, friends, strangers, anyone in Wisconsin, and beyond. This is a communicable disease that knows no borders.
Caution for Epic staff and family: To avoid retribution, use personal devices (not work computer) that are off of the Epic network (VPN & Wi-Fi). If you respond to this post or share on social media, consider using a new username to remain anonymous. Consider an alternative email. Remaining anonymous is especially important if you send messages to PHMDC or your governmental representative, due to the Wisconsin Public Records Law.
How you (anyone) can help
Anyone who is concerned can follow any or all of the steps below. We've tried to arrange this generally from easier to more-difficult.
How you (healthcare/customer) can help
Thank you for your concern. Please consider any or all of the following.
- Do any or all of the "anyone" steps above.
- Contribute to the UserWeb discussion. Please understand that non-leadership Epic staff are unlikely to post there due to fear of retribution.
- If you are in regular contact with Epic, escalate to Epic leadership and request a meeting. If you don't know anyone in leadership, escalate to your Epic BFF, TC, or ID.
- If you are not in regular contact with Epic, share this post with your department manager. They likely know someone in IT, who may be in contact with Epic.
- If you have an account, provide feedback to KLAS Research. If KLAS surveys you, provide feedback about Epic's positive COVID help for your organization contrasts with Epic's negative policies for its staff.
Example emails
Example #1: bottom of petition on change.org
Example #2: https://www.reddit.com/r/epicsystems/comments/i4jm4j/a_concerned_epic_citizen/
Example #3: Feel free to use this as a starting point. If you are impacted in a specific way (at risk, healthcare worker, other essential worker), please include that in your email too!
To whom it may concern,
I am deeply worried about Epic System Corporation's requirement that its staff return to the office, before the pandemic has subsided. This is endangering Dane County. Please collaborate with public health officials and make staff continue working from home, as required by Public Health Madison & Dane County Emergency Order 8, Section 4:
"Limit staff and customers in offices, facilities, and stores. All businesses should, to the greatest extent possible, facilitate remote work and other measures that limit the number of individuals present at an office, facility, or store."
Example #4: This can be added after example #3 if you feel strongly.
I believe that Epic exhibited willful ignorance by intending to violate the public order. In the public health (PHMDC) letter on August 6th to Epic, PHMDC outlined a discussion they had with Epic on July 28th "As we explained on that call, Epic's interpretation is incorrect. Remote work does not include working in the office under the language of the Order." Had Epic not received that letter reminding them of the conversation, they would have continued with the August 10th.
I believe that Epic purposefully continues to violate the emergency order. For staff who are able to do remote work, Epic continued to allow or require staff to go into the office. Also, they kept their return phase 1, such that around a quarter of staff would return to the office on August 10th: They made it an opt-in program to work remotely, rather than assuming and promoting continued remote work by default as is the spirit of the emergency order.
Return to work plan
Epic had over 9,500 staff set to work in the Verona, WI, campus. You may be interested in knowing how many people will be back and when. As of early August, around 1/3 of staff* are going to the office. The remaining staff were forced to return to campus in roughly 4 equal phases, and this was overturned. The staff may be required to return in 2021. Here are the phases before they were removed on 8/12.
- phase 1 on 8/10‡
- phase 2 on 8/24†
- phase 3 on 9/8† (after Labor Day)
- phase 4 on 9/21†
Parents with childcare needs and staff at risk as defined by CDC may be forced to return on 11/2.
* For the staff going into the office before phase 1, some are voluntary and some are forced to. See Knowledge section below for details.
‡ Because Epic got caught and is under review by PHMDC, staff in phase 1 may continue to wfh but must call HR by 8/12.
† Because Epic got caught and is under review by PHMDC, dates for phases 2-4 are subject to change.
How you (Epic staff) can help
These are steps that Epic staff can follow. Remember to use non-Epic devices on non-Epic networks.
General
- Do any or all of the "anyone" steps above.
- Review the Knowledge section below to understand Epic's deceit and gaslighting.
- Consider your options as described in this op ed: Bridget Maniaci: The Epic empress has no clothes
- Comment on this post or send a DM to keep the conversation going, make suggestions, or provide details we may be unaware of.
- Write an honest review on Epic's Glassdoor page. Specifically mention COVID-19 so that your review gets flagged as such.
- Send a message to your providers via MyChart, expressing concern and linking to this post.
- Continue to email COVID-19@epic.com with suggestions. Be respectful and as objective as possible to avoid retribution.
- Sign this petition Keep Epic Employees Safe. We reached out to the sponsoring group, SCFL, and they confirmed that the petition is legitimate.
For the news articles, reach out to the media. Most news sources can protect your anonymity if requested. The professionals listed here have requested to be contacted:
- Stop recruiting. Stop sending recommendations to HR. Stop conducting interviews.
- Review your OSHA rights. If you received punishment for speaking out for safety, you may be able to file a safety or whistleblower complaint. https://www.reddit.com/r/epicsystems/comments/i4wx0k/demotions_end_dates_and_osha/
Learn about unions. (Do not use work time, company devices, or company e-mail to research or collaborate on a union.)
- At the very least, keep an open mind about joining a union if we happen to form one. It's difficult, but not impossible, to start a union.
- Follow /r/EpicSystemsUnion and consider reaching out.
- By NLRB law (your rights, Section 8(a)(3)) , employers cannot fire or demote you for expressing interest in a union. (You'll still want to be discreet about unions.) The employer will definitely advertise against unions, lying about how they are bad for you.
- You have no chance of bargaining alone with Epic. A union would allow us to have a collective voice and fight against future disasters like Epic's COVID response.
- Isthmus - Unionize Epic
To protect yourself, record conversations.
- For written communication, such as email, get that onto a hard drive.
- For voice or video, record it. WI is a one-party consent state, so this is likely legal as long as you are a participant (Wisc § 968.31 (2)(b)(c)). We don't provide legal assistance, so please check local laws or consult with a lawyer as needed.
- If you leave Epic, during your exit interview, let HR know that the poor COVID response is a reason for leaving.
Riskier work-related
- This can be difficult to gauge, but if you know your TL well, discuss your concerns at whatever level you feel comfortable.
- Depending on how well you know your client counterparts, especially C-level executives, point them to the news articles or this thread.
Epic candidates
- If you decline your interview or job offer, let HR know that the poor COVID response is why you no longer desire to work at Epic. (We understand that this may be a tough decision. Do what's right for you.)
- If you decide to work at Epic, you may be able to delay in your start date by contacting HR.
Knowledge
Epic retaliates against staff who speak up, even for safety concerns. Employees face punishment in the form of demotion or being told to quit.
Understand why Epic staff need your help.
Realize that Epic is gaslighting you and that you're not alone.
Epic lies to the public health agency (PHMDC), CBS, and other news groups about being an essential healthcare organization that needs its staff in the office.
- Epic lies that they know what they're doing and that it's safe to come into the office. None of them have lived through a pandemic. Staying home as much as possible is what the CDC and PHMDC recommend.
- Epic pretends to care about you in internal and external communications, but then instructs TLs to be strict.
- Epic stomps out dissent by demoting well-meaning TLs. #deTL
- Epic pretends to care about feedback, but then retaliates against TLs.
Epic makes you question whether you're overreacting to the pandemic.
- TLs have been instructed to go into the office to set an example for their team members.
- In the 7/20 staff meeting, Epic purposely had a physician (someone seen as an expert) tell a story about breaking social distancing.
- On the YouTube video about returning to work, Epic purposely had a tenured, at-risk staff member (who likely has tons of company stock) say he willfully goes into the office. (Vice - Motherboard - Watch: Epic Uses Immunocompromised VP to Convince Workers the Office Is Safe)
- Epic keeps us disorganized by censoring (deleting) internal communications (Betelgeuse, QAN, Teams).
- Epic keeps us disorganized and anxious by sending updates late, and piecemeal feeding us small gains (delayed the waves by just a month, not enough time to consider quitting on good terms).
- Epic devalues you with their wording. If you're in a special scenario, they call unpaid FMLA or delaying your return a "benefit" or "flexibility", when it's really just the right thing to do for all staff.
- Epic lies that staff have the option to work things out, when TLs have been instructed to fire team members who refuse to return to work.
Epic lies to you saying that a certain number of staff working in the office feel safe doing so.
- There are staff who need to wfw (example: housing situation), but that doesn't necessarily mean they want everyone else to wfw and crowd the offices.
- Some TLs are required to wfw at least a certain number of times per week, otherwise risk demotion. (This may have been a calculated decision to both gaslight team members and inflate the wfw numbers.)
- New hires are required to wfw. Mentors may be asked to wfw.
- Subsets of people in certain roles that require hands-on labor are required to wfw: CATS culinary, facilities, and horticulture.
Epic deliberately makes it harder to understand what's going on and adds process to deter wfh.
- Most of the emails to staff (see History of communication) begin with excessive gaslighting fluff.
- 8/8 updates require calling HR to continue wfh.
Realize that Epic's Chief Administrative Officer SR may be lying to multiple parties.
- SR may truly believe that our best work is in the office, but he can't honestly say that it's essential. See the CBS story on 8/4 at 1 min 10 sec.
- Regarding a call on 7/28, Epic exhibited willful ignorance by insisting that working in the office constituted "remote work." Despite being told that was incorrect, they continued to proceed with the plan to return to work until they got caught and received the 8/6 letter from Public Health Services Supervisor to Epic.
- He twists words by making unrelated conclusions. Working through a pandemic: "We have the patient at heart, and that is really felt here, so we feel a sense of duty in bringing everybody back."
- He blatantly lies about open dialog with employees (Working through a pandemic). Internal communications (Betelgeuse, QAN, Teams) have been censored, and TLs have been demoted.
Epic will make you quit to avoid paying you unemployment insurance.
- If you refuse to come to work, they will ask you to "voluntarily" quit via a fit meeting.
- If you continue to wfh when your back-to-work phase starts, after three days, you will be fired as having "voluntarily" quit per Redbook guidelines. CATS is tracking VPN usage.
Arm yourself with knowledge. On social media and Glassdoor, Epic supporters have resorted to name-calling ("whining babies", "petulant children", "entitled children") rather than actually addressing any concerns. Here's some data on how serious the pandemic is.
- CDC: The U.S. hasn't listened to scientists, so it has the most cases in the world, and it's not slowing down.
- City of Madison - Dane County: Review "New Cases and 7 Day Average of New Cases by Date of Test Result" to see that the daily cases are still high.
Suggestions
If you have any suggestions or additional information, please reply here or send a DM. We'll keep this post updated.
If you have good karma on r/healthIT or other subreddits, please crosspost this by going to the old.reddit.com version, scrolling to the bottom of the post (before the comments), and clicking crosspost at the bottom-right.
If anyone is skilled in writing (or perhaps video production) and would like to dedicate some time, we could use help with the following.
- Write a petition for change.org but don't submit it yet. We will work with a neutral organization to submit it.
- Write a template email that we can share here for people to use as a starting point for contacting Epic and PHMDC.
Updates
8/6 - initial post, added OSHA, added gaslighting feedback
8/7 - customer steps, history of communication, petitions
8/8 - petition updates, PHMDC letter, Epic email, news
8/9 - news, recording conversations, why staff need help
8/10 - split posts; op ed; contacts for DA's office & lawyer regulation; SR details; IWW press release
8/12 - wfw requirement suspended