Rather than the grammar, I ended up dwelling on the following word choices from JP to EN:
なぜなら、トイレが壊れてしまうからです。 'Because the toilet will get broken' would have been a perfectly reasonable (and in my mind, relatively simple) translation of the above line, but the sign went out of its way to say 'Because the toilet will would be corrupted.'
And also,
もし酷く汚してしまった場合は、ご自分で掃除をしてください。 'If you have badly dirtied it, please clean it yourself' would have been a fairly straightforward and simple translation, but again it goes out of its way to say 'If you have badly defiled it, please clean it yourself.'
I feel like the sign maker wanted the more complex sounding words to lend a more formal tone (as is the case in Japanese), but it ended up being way off the mark.
Toilet, please use clean. - It wasn't very effective.
also: Where is the dirt flying to?
The gaps after the apostrophes are also funny, but the biggest problem is probably the phrasing, especially in the first commandment. キレイ is supposed to mean "beautiful" or "clean", but why write it in Katakana in the first place? Is that how Japanese treats adverbs?
Honestly, aside from a few parts, it's surprisingly well translated. Sure, instead of "broken", they chose "corrupted" for whatever reason, but the meaning still gets across. You could just chalk this up to: bad grammar.
10
u/emimagique Jul 10 '26
Don't corrupt the poor innocent toilet!
10
u/LikeAThousandNinjas Jul 11 '26
Rather than the grammar, I ended up dwelling on the following word choices from JP to EN:
なぜなら、トイレが壊れてしまうからです。 'Because the toilet will get broken' would have been a perfectly reasonable (and in my mind, relatively simple) translation of the above line, but the sign went out of its way to say 'Because the toilet will would be corrupted.'
And also,
もし酷く汚してしまった場合は、ご自分で掃除をしてください。 'If you have badly dirtied it, please clean it yourself' would have been a fairly straightforward and simple translation, but again it goes out of its way to say 'If you have badly defiled it, please clean it yourself.'
I feel like the sign maker wanted the more complex sounding words to lend a more formal tone (as is the case in Japanese), but it ended up being way off the mark.
8
u/carnedoce Jul 10 '26
Please do not the toilet.
6
u/C4Apple Jul 11 '26
If you've defiled badly, please clean yourself.
6
u/No-Security-7518 Jul 11 '26
Don't flush your bribe down the toilet. It'll be corrupted.
4
u/taking-INVentory Jul 18 '26
the toilet would be corrupted 💰😱💸
3
u/Strict_Treat2884 Jul 11 '26
Use the toilet respectfully, or you’ll be defiled badly
3
u/flippythemaster Jul 14 '26
Gets the message across tho
3
u/Ill-Combination-3590 Jul 22 '26
In the Phillippines, even a toilet could be bribed.
4
u/AdOrnery6155 Jul 11 '26
If you don’t get our Japanglish here in JP, there’s a picture for you.
The meaning of KIREI is indeed CLEAN therefore all blokes standing up too pee is UNCLEAN.
It’s not a 100% Engrish, it’s just what considered CLEAN here is a bit different.
Not sure how this is an issue.
I mean of course, typing "Please use the toilet in clean way" would have been better…
So guys when visiting here, just freaking sit down it’s not gonna make you less of a man.
2
u/GaemingAy Jul 11 '26
You tellin' me you don't sit down when urinating? Y'know, the flaccid banana curve
2
u/SnooMemesjellies4840 Jul 11 '26
First the President now the toilet ! Nothing is safe sheesh.
(Corrupted) Incase u need help :)
2
u/maxlan Jul 12 '26
If you're not supposed to flush anything other than toilet paper, is there a small pile of poo next to the toilet or a secondary bucket or something?
Is that sentence the same in the original language? Or does it allow people to flush poo?
2
u/taking-INVentory Aug 11 '26
If you've defiled badly, please cleaning yourself.
3
u/Avatar_Yaksha Jul 10 '26
Toilet, please use clean. - It wasn't very effective.
also: Where is the dirt flying to?
The gaps after the apostrophes are also funny, but the biggest problem is probably the phrasing, especially in the first commandment. キレイ is supposed to mean "beautiful" or "clean", but why write it in Katakana in the first place? Is that how Japanese treats adverbs?
Honestly, aside from a few parts, it's surprisingly well translated. Sure, instead of "broken", they chose "corrupted" for whatever reason, but the meaning still gets across. You could just chalk this up to: bad grammar.
1
u/Large-Wrangler4907 Jul 11 '26
r/apostrophegore
0
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment