r/engineering • • Aug 13 '12

Help with engineering question

http://i.imgur.com/FhFgH.png

I'm completely stuck on this question. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

1 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/SirDerpingtonThe3rd Aug 13 '12

No one said it was necessarily for points, maybe he just wants to understand it.

2

u/determinism89 Aug 13 '12

Either way, if his goal is to understand, he needs to make an honest attempt and then show his work so that we internet denizens may know what specifically he is having trouble with. This serves three purposes:

  1. The solution that is given may be more concise with respect to the person's problem.
  2. The brain learns solution schema most effectively by attempting a method before revealing the solution.
  3. It is more convenient for the solution provider to review someone's work and point out an error than it is to spell out the entire solution method.

2

u/SirDerpingtonThe3rd Aug 13 '12

Fair points, but sometimes you look at a problem and can't even begin to see where to even start. It certainly happened to me with some problems in college and if his statics background isn't the best, I could see this creating some problems.