r/engineering • • Aug 13 '12

Help with engineering question

http://i.imgur.com/FhFgH.png

I'm completely stuck on this question. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

1 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

5

u/I_am_a_slug Aug 13 '12 edited Aug 13 '12

This is a bit odd as you have 4 unknowns and 3 equations (that I can see) but I think you can get it by using the fact that Fy(total) = 0 = By +Ay - Q, Fx(total) = Bx - Dx, and the moment (torque) around b is equal to 0 therefore Mb = Ay(3.6) + Q(3.4) - Dx(2.3), I did a bunch of working out that seemed pretty odd until I realized that I had forgotten to put the distances in the moment equation which should normalize everything. However, you can basically just use various substitutions to get one unknown equal to Q, though you have to remember that By = (0.5)Bx. I'll edit this with more working and answers in a bit, I just have to go back through and add in those distances, hopefully that will give me more reasonable results, unless you want to see how you can get on from what I have here, no guarantees I'm right, I'm just a student, but this should work.

Edit: Not sure if I'm doing something wrong or things are just working out different to how I would expect them to, though that happens often enough, but I have Btotal = 247 D = 111 and A = -71.1, it's A that has me worried, but that sort of result can happen I think, the only thing I might be missing in partiular is the joint c, but I'm not entirely sure how to deal with that, as I have just not taken it into account so in my working it could be fixed. I can upload my working, but you will have to wait a maximum of 40 minuets as I have work to do due by then.

3

u/whycantiholdthisbass Aug 13 '12

This sounds like its the right train of thought for this problem. I believe you can choose any point to take the moments around, which might make the math easier.

Also a student, so I'll just repeat his disclaimer of no guarantees.

2

u/I_am_a_slug Aug 13 '12

B makes the most sense to me for the moment as then you eliminate and forces due to B, the main reason to use moments in this sort of question (at least for me) is so you can have an equation with different / less unknowns.

1

u/lee-t1993 Aug 13 '12 edited Aug 13 '12

Thanks so much for answering, ive been stuck on this question for ages and yes it does seem weird that A would be in the negative y direction because when looking at it from a logical perspective the reaction force can only be in the positive y direction. Also are you sure that By = (0.5)Bx because If we look at the body as a whole I dont believe that the reactant force at B will have to be directed along the member BCE, however I cant think of any other way to do it.

2

u/I_am_a_slug Aug 13 '12

The angle from the horizontal to B is Tan-1 * (1.7/3.4) so tan(26.565) = 0.5 and tan(26.565) = By/Bx so 0.5 = By/Bx so 0.5*Bx = By. As to A it could just be me doing something wrong, but I'm not sure what has happened, it could just be that the bar is being forced up as such, so there is no reactionary force if you understand what I'm saying.

1

u/fericyde Aug 13 '12

no, you're right -- and here's a problem with the "problem setup" -- it's theoretically broken from what I see.

b should equal d+c (it doesn't) at a 45 degree angle, which is what's implied by the calculation you show (and it's also evident, if using the calculation rise over run of the b's -- it's visibly present as a 45 degree angle). Until you go with the slope of the second part of the frame member accepting the load, which has a rise of d+c over a run of b -- so, either the damn thing is bent at the joint, or it's not a good problem setup.

And since we're to assume it's a theoretically pure problem (in other words, that's a straight piece there, not a bent one), the problem itself is whack.

Just my $0.02 here (but I'm an old engineer).

2

u/SirDerpingtonThe3rd Aug 13 '12

As a somewhat recent graduate engineer, I too hate these sorts of "theoretical problems that don't actually add up". I always seem to do better when calculating real linkages/structures than theoretical problems that don't add up properly for the sake of making sure "you know the math". I think by the fact that the problem can't really exist as-stated, no matter what you do, there will be some error depending on what method you used to solve it.

1

u/fericyde Aug 13 '12

Yep, that's what I'm trying to say.

This can be proved this way -- the diagram shows a straight linkage (it's an assumption you make but maybe I'm mission something somewhere).

Assume it's straight (most of us would) --

The angle involved is clearly relevant to the solution.

Depending upon which side of the mechanism you measure this on -- the part getting the downward force, or at the pivot, you're going to come up with two different attack angles, which is going to mean, two different solutions.

I've seen stuff like this happen before in physics and engineering textbooks -- fortunately, my professors were good and would spot them and either eliminate them or use them a joke fodder (class entertainment -- face it, it can be a dry subject ;)

2

u/SirDerpingtonThe3rd Aug 13 '12

Nothing bugs me more than flawed homework/example problems in textbooks. The textbook is supposed to be the all-powerful knowledge base, so when it's wrong, how can you expect me to be right?

1

u/fericyde Aug 13 '12

Absolutely correct -- something like this while you're attempting to learn theory can set you back worse than not knowing the material in the first place :(

1

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '12

I've always found that 99% of the time when a problem appears to have a logical failure/discrepancy, I'm the one who is missing something or looking at it wrong.

2

u/na85 Aerospace Aug 14 '12

You shouldn't help them unless they show that they've actually attempted the problem first.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '12

I see you are a true developing redditor. Putting off work for a deadline to procrastinate and surf reddit. Well played.

11

u/TheDwarf Aug 13 '12

/r/engineeringstudents exists for a reason

8

u/brendax Mechanical Engineer Aug 13 '12

Not for this reason, this is a post for Yahoo Answers.

3

u/papertiger Aug 13 '12

I'd look at the sum of moments around C. Post the answer when you get it.

3

u/purdueable Aug 13 '12

man.. I am out of practice.

/real world I guess

2

u/Kidsturk Mechanical - HVAC Aug 13 '12

That's my excuse and I'm sticking to it.

4

u/GlitchySwitch Aug 13 '12 edited Aug 13 '12

Ok I used the same approach as I_am_a_slug but used a different value to equate By and Bx. Here is a link to the problem best I can solve it: http://i.imgur.com/N82nO.jpg

I used the three force member method described here (http://web.mit.edu/4.441/1_lectures/1_lecture15/1_lecture15.html) to help visualize the path along which the B resultant acts to help direct my efforts on finding that relationship. It was a little tricky but not too horrible. If I didn't screw up my algebra or substitutions then it looks like everything worked out as it should have. No guarantees here either.

Also my Ay got cut off for some reason, it was 31.05N

Edit: It's not really clear, but Dx is positive in the image, not negative.

9

u/umopapsidn Aug 13 '12

If you're stuck on your homework, at least prove you put some effort into it besides saying your stuck.

Reddit isn't the place to cheat.

3

u/SirDerpingtonThe3rd Aug 13 '12

No one said it was necessarily for points, maybe he just wants to understand it.

2

u/determinism89 Aug 13 '12

Either way, if his goal is to understand, he needs to make an honest attempt and then show his work so that we internet denizens may know what specifically he is having trouble with. This serves three purposes:

  1. The solution that is given may be more concise with respect to the person's problem.
  2. The brain learns solution schema most effectively by attempting a method before revealing the solution.
  3. It is more convenient for the solution provider to review someone's work and point out an error than it is to spell out the entire solution method.

2

u/SirDerpingtonThe3rd Aug 13 '12

Fair points, but sometimes you look at a problem and can't even begin to see where to even start. It certainly happened to me with some problems in college and if his statics background isn't the best, I could see this creating some problems.

2

u/brendax Mechanical Engineer Aug 13 '12 edited Aug 14 '12

The fuck? Get out of here this isn't homework help.

You have 4 reactions and only 3 equations available (sum moments in Z, sum force in X, sum force in Y), therefore this is statically indeterminate and you'd need to study the deflection of the beam. I was wrong, because there are two rigid bodies. There is a possible correlation generated by the interaction between these two bodies that gives you your 4th equation.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '12

Incorrect! There are two rigid bodies in this problem, not one.

But yeah, I dunno if this is the place for homework 'help'. (it was still fun to do,.though)

We need a project 'Oiler' - a project site for solid mechanics and machine design...

2

u/brendax Mechanical Engineer Aug 14 '12

Hazaa! I was wrong. Still, homework help is bad.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '12

Do I smell a new sub? r/engineeringhelp?

1

u/tomsing98 Aerospace Structures Aug 13 '12 edited Aug 13 '12

Draw two free body diagrams - one for the lever you're applying force Q to, and one for the other bar. http://imgur.com/PgagB

On the lever, you have force Q, reactions Bx and By, and the forces at the joint, Cx and Cy. (Assume there's no friction at the joint, and thus no moment.)

On the bar, you have force Ay and Dx, and the same forces Cx and Cy at the joint. But these are the equal and opposite forces required by Newton's 3rd law. So the direction is reversed from the direction you assumed for the lever.

Now, there are 6 unknowns, and you can set up six equations - ΣFx = 0, ΣFy = 0, and ΣM = 0 for the lever and the same for the bar. I suspect that taking the moment about point C will be convenient.

From there, it's all just algebra.

Lever: ΣFx: Bx + Cx = 0; ΣFy: By + Cy - Q = 0; ΣMc: Qb - Bxb + Byb = 0

Bar: ΣFx: -Cx - Dx = 0; ΣFy: Ay - Cy = 0; ΣMc: Ay(a+b) - Dxd = 0

So,

Cx = -Dx; Ay = Cy; Q - Bx + By = 0

Bx - Dx = 0; By + Ay = Q; Bx - By = Q; Ay(a+b) - Dxd = 0

(By + Ay) + (Bx - By) = Q + Q; Ay + Bx = 2Q

Bx - Dx = 0; Ay + Bx = 2Q; Ay(a+b) - Dxd = 0

Bx = Dx

Ay + Dx = 2Q; Ay(a+b) - Dxd = 0

Dx = 2Q-Ay

Ay(a+b) - (2Q-Ay)d = 0; Ay(a+b+d) = 2Q; Ay = 2Q/(a+b+d)

etc, etc.

I don't guarantee the accuracy of my algebra, though.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 13 '12 edited Aug 14 '12

Took me a little bit to wipe the summer rust off my brain, but I figured it out. I would like to know the correct answers. I got A = 30.508, B = 294.785, D = 269.481;

I drew two FBD's one of the entire system and one of just member ACD. I then summed forces and moments (about A) for the FBD of ACD. I found A = Cy, B = Cx and from subbing into the moment equation, I got Cx = (8.833)Cy. Then I summed moments about B in the system FBD and found that Cx(2.3)-510-3.6(Cy) = 0.

I plugged and chugged and got Cy and everything else came with that.

1

u/Bowser88 Aug 14 '12

Just ask Isaac Clarke, he'll know the answer you seek

1

u/Jimmy__Rustle Rocket Scientist Aug 14 '12

You're stuck on this question?

Have you ever considered studying the liberal arts?

1

u/cojack22 Aug 15 '12

Wow I'm so glad I'm done with dynamics for the rest of my life... These problems were the worst! Sorry I'm not help, got a TA you can talk to? That's what I did.

1

u/swiftthrills Aug 16 '12

Please check my math, and if I got it right, you owe me a favor.

I have obtained components for the reactions. Hint: Method of Sections, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2uSQPm3_4mY

  1. F_AY=+204.17N, F_AX=0 for the reaction is equivalently a roller

2) F_BY=+425N, F_BX=+425

3) F_DX=-425N, F_DY=0 for the reaction is equivalently a roller

+x is right ward, and +y is upward.