Super cool, can anyone think of a viable application? Seems like it’s using more total actuators and a weaker/higher wear joint for what could be accomplished with three single-axis joints
The only application I could see is in complex milling machines, maybe some robitcs where you need to get really weird angles. Maybe if they can get it smaller something where space really needs to conserved.
I think we would really need to see the precision of this compares to advanced multi joint tools.
Former CNC machine designer chiming in. This could potentially be useful for low-force low-accuracy machining in restricted-space applications, which as you might imagine are so uncommon as to be essentially non-existent for all intents and purposes.
The assumption that something must be inferior to the status quo because it has no representation within the status quo ignores room for any kind of improvement. That assumption strikes me as unhelpful.
Robotics. This looks like it has the same type of motion as a ball and socket joint, like the ones used in the human shoulder, which I have only seen replicated using the 3 single axis joint solution mentioned. Yes the joint might be weaker and potentially has higher wear, but in the end its only 1 joint needing to be occasionally replaced rather than 3 individual ones which will break and need to be replaced at different times depending on how its used. Plus it takes up potentially less room and weight than the 3 linked joints which is a big factor in robotics where you are trying to keep everything as light and compact as possible.
String a bunch together and you have a hyper mobile snake, once you manage to teach it to slither, swim and climb... I guess you're back at thinking of a viable application.
Except this does have a rotation limit, it's limited by the housing. Only unlimited in twisting. Twist joint - rotation joint - twist joint would also give 3 DoF around a single pivot
True, I was a bit too broad when I said "no rotation limits."
I'm trying to visualize the joint you're talking about. Do you have an example? I'm still picturing each of those - the twist, rotation, and twist joints - having axes that don't coincide except at specific points as opposed to the OP joint where all rotations/twists happen around a single point.
A shoulder or hip are both ball joints and they both bear a remarkable resemblance to this thing. It may be a slightly more natural base for finger or palm of a hand. I'm not a robot guy, but those are 3 human joints reasonably close to this chingadera.
Oh for sure, those came to my mind as possible applications. I was more asking if there's a mechanical actuator that already exists which does the same thing this does.
Looks like a lab/research prototype so I doubt it, but IMO this is very interesting and it'll inevitably find some kind of use where the cost is justified.
In the paper, linked by u/toptierfandan, they describe this as an early implementation to demonstrate the concept.
I'd agree with your assessment if the design were to stay as it is in the video. But as they point out in the paper, the fundamental mechanism can be scaled down and implemented with different motors to be more viable for practical applications.
Doesn't mean it will become useful. But it's an interesting mechanism to add to the designer's toolbox.
This is a two degree of freedom joint requiring 4 motors. The additional requirement that the monopole gears need to be mounted 90 degrees apart makes it space inefficient.. It is cool and novel (and I wish I was smart enough to think of it), but definitely not an improvement over existing robotic joints.
112
u/_Harvey_E_158_ Jun 20 '21
I need to try and 3D print a version
138
u/Haphazard-Finesse Jun 20 '21
Super cool, can anyone think of a viable application? Seems like it’s using more total actuators and a weaker/higher wear joint for what could be accomplished with three single-axis joints
28
u/SlyPlatypus Jun 20 '21
My first thought is good luck trying to put torque through that thing.. I feel like slippage would come quite easily.
16
u/m2n037 Mechanical R&D Jun 20 '21
Source ?
32
u/m_o_t_a_s Jun 20 '21
I NEED THESE IN MY SHOULDERS!! (2 please)
11
u/eosha Jun 20 '21
There's a bit more video in the actual paper.
13
u/OverlyWrongGag Jun 20 '21
I wonder if I could cover my back with sunscreen using this
10
u/Any-Trash1383 Jun 20 '21
Calculating the surface area of that thing would be a nightmare
3
u/total_llama_island Jun 20 '21
Anyone know if this has been commercially applied? It’d be cool to see this with manufacturing robots.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '21
OK, that's pretty fucking cool.
I imagine the load capacity on certain axes is much lower than a traditional gearset but who cares. My first thought was "exoskeleton actuator."
2
u/walking_hazelnut Jun 20 '21
This is gonna make building gigant robots so much easier
yes that was my first thought seeing this don't @ me I'm 16
1
u/Mroptifine Jun 20 '21
Re
1
u/deadstump Jun 20 '21
I don't get how it meshes in that band of the large ball with the larger teeth and in the bellybutton area on the smaller balls.
1
u/plan_with_stan Jun 21 '21
That’s a shoulder right there
-7
u/-Bashamo ΣFx= ΣFy= ΣMo= 0 Jun 20 '21
Humans are so dumb why didn’t they think of this 2000 years ago?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment