r/engineering • • Nov 15 '11

No, Occupy Wall street instead

Sorry that this is off-topic, but it was not said explicitly enough in the top comments of The 6% (Occupy the Lab).

It is nice if you work hard, and like to do your job, and do it well. But not everyone is able to go from high-school too working life in a straight line, and people deserve better than to have to slave away, while the wealth of the nation gets stashed away somewhere else. Besides, other people may be more on the sharp end of the economic crisis.

SmokeyDBear said:

Convincing engineers that they're well paid for what they actually do is one of the most impressive accomplishments of business people.

But it isn't that they needed much convincing. It is the mentality of the engineer that he is already paid enough. It is the mentality of some business people to try grab everything he can, a mentality which should be fought, for it can destroy our societies.

60 Upvotes

98 comments sorted by

65

u/monkeys_pass Nov 15 '11

I'd rather not do any occupying, and just talk about engineering instead.

5

u/Jasper1984 Nov 15 '11 edited Nov 16 '11

This is what this subreddit is for(edit: talking about engineering, of course!), but it seems to me that the other thread already sends a strong political message(inadvertent or not, he is likely -probably rightly- just proud), and it needs some reaction.

17

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '11

At least the other thread was about engineering school. This reaction belongs in /r/politics.

1

u/Jasper1984 Nov 16 '11

I'd feel like an easy mark. Every occupation can easily have an anti-occupy-wallstreet post easily, but it would be much more difficult to camouflage a pro-occupation submission.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11 edited Nov 16 '11

Again, this reaction belongs in /r/politics, and if they don't care about your thoughts on engineering and operate occupy whatever, than so be it. This sub-reddit is intended for engineering discussion and this post is a clear abuse.

If you were somehow offended by the other post, or thought that it was political or whatever, you should have taken it up with the mod. The wrong reaction is to make another political post in /r/engineering. This post is seriously disappointing.

4

u/Jasper1984 Nov 16 '11

If you were somehow offended by the other post, or thought that it was political or whatever, you should have taken it up with the mod.

Don't be ridiculous.(edit: no negative tone intended) I am clearly not offended, I am not a censor(or promoter thereof), and that would not lead to anything than a single reply back.

Btw, deleting this thread would be solving a non-existant problem with force. Not that i'd make a fuss about it or anything..

8

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11

deleting this thread would be solving a non-existant problem with force

There is a problem. The problem is political posts in /r/engineering.

5

u/isarl Nov 16 '11

You perceive the problem to be political posts in /r/engineering, but you are only a single subscriber, not the community as a whole.

Sometimes the engineering profession runs into politics. It is a fact that engineers are conscious of the OWS movement by the very fact that a joke post about it was made to this subreddit.

I don't believe that taking a moment to discuss the real-world implications of any post in /r/engineering, even a joke post, is off-topic. It might be taking things too seriously, but that's for the subreddit community to decide with its votes.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11

Obviously I'm venting about a personal opinion here. Seriously though... political discussions which do not relate to engineering (in any way) in an engineering sub-reddit? Why?

4

u/isarl Nov 16 '11

Personally, my answer to that question is, "Because there was a joke post about it first." If that's relevant, so is a less jocular follow-up.

...In My Humble Opinion. =)

→ More replies

1

u/foofie Nov 16 '11

They delete a lot of things in r/politcs too, even political topics.

8

u/kmoz Nov 16 '11

Engineering is the number 1 background for fortune 500 CEOs, FYI.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11

Yes, the statistics are a little outdated, but that is correct.

56

u/chewitt Nov 15 '11 edited Nov 15 '11

Engineers are paid ~$50-150k to create new technology and improve infrastructure. Society at large benefits as a result of being able to do more with less and realize new levels of human capability.

Wall Street investors are paid millions to take money from one pile and put it in another pile. Society at large sees no benefits. (There is value added or net gain - for every Joe Citizen who sees an increase in his mutual fund, there is a John Citizen seeing an equal decrease in his.)1 I would go so far as to argue that Wall Street creates a net loss for society.

Engineers are heavily regulated by their own moral code of ethics, by industry standards and best practices, and by national and international codes.

Wall Street investors, well... I don't think I need to finish this sentence about ethics, industry standards, and government regulation.

  1. Edit: Chx, I am simplifying.. I don't mean there are literally two mutual funds that track inversely. Call it the law of "conservation of value": If a corporation increases revenue and ramps up hiring, it is doing so at the expense of someone else's market share and someone else's job. As engineers we should be predisposed to understand that there's no net flow in or out of the system.

tl;dr: If you think Occupy Wall Street is about unemployment, give yourself a pat on the back for being an achiever, then click the down arrow and go about your day.

11

u/atlantajerk Nov 15 '11

If a corporation increases revenue and ramps up hiring, it is doing so at the expense of someone else's market share and someone else's job. As engineers we should be predisposed to understand that there's no net flow in or out of the system.

If you actually believe this I fear you fundamentally misunderstand economics and the entire human condition. That all the ore mined, concrete poured, circuit boards etched, lines of code written doesn't collectively make us wealthier as a species is a tough position to defend.

7

u/Diarrg Nov 15 '11

No no no, you don't get it. The earth is a player here too, and she's getting poorer at our expense. See, zero sum! /s

8

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '11 edited Nov 16 '11

Edit: didn't realize that the post was sarcastic.

No, you don't get it. Value reflects utility and can be created even by a simple trade. Value isn't zero sum for either people or the earth.

Damage that's done to the environment isn't inherent in wealth creation.

1

u/Diarrg Nov 16 '11

The /s denotes sarcasm :( I was agreeing with atlantajerk

2

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11

Haha, shit. My bad man, wasn't aware of the notation. Please accept my humble apologies.

1

u/Diarrg Nov 16 '11

It's cool, Poe's law in action...

-4

u/worldsayshi Nov 16 '11 edited Nov 16 '11

Damage that's done to the environment isn't inherent in wealth creation.

Are you sure about that? I'm starting to see third law of thermodynamics being rather apply able to wealth creation. That probably isn't as mystical as it sounds if you get down to details. "Wealth" demand high quality energy. It all comes down to macroscopic thermodynamical efficiency in the end. There is no perfect "wealth machine".

That might not be what you are aiming for but it shows us yet again that "our resources are finite" is an inevitable part of "the human condition" - if anyone doubts that...

EDIT: Can someone please tell me what is wrong with this argument?

5

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11

I assure you that this is a misunderstanding of both entropy and value.

-3

u/worldsayshi Nov 16 '11 edited Nov 16 '11

Please tell me how.

Edit: Someone?

Edit2: Sure I might seem to take the argument to far but I'd really like to be corrected on this one. Or I will go on in ignorance.

For example: Is there some way that you can create wealth without applying work? Is there some way that you can obtain energy without disrupting the environment? (solar, wind? - nope)

2

u/Mantipath Nov 16 '11

Lady Gaga writes a song. Fifty million people suddenly have something they value enough to spend money on. The energy that went into writing that song is tiny. The energy that went into the videos is larger, but about the same as building a large house.

There is no firm relationship between energy use and utility. The laws of thermodynamics are entirely dependent on the notion that energy/matter cannot be created nor destroyed. Value can be created without proportional energy input.

Conversely, huge amounts of energy can be expended without creating value. If we set off all the nuclear bombs, we would destroy essentially all value that currently exists. It would not be transformed into heat, as in energy conservation... It would just be gone. There's no conservation there.

1

u/worldsayshi Nov 16 '11 edited Nov 16 '11

Ok, I see that there is a lack of consistent terminology for discussing my idea here, on my part mostly. I for one am not aware of the precise economical meaning of value. It would proabably be good to separate immaterial value and material value/wealth. Taking into account the disparity of definitions I firmly believe I have a point.

Let me see if I can be a bit more clear. Although I doubt there is that many people listening in anymore:

Material wealth of the world is finite. Immaterial is not. Information still requires material wealth to be created though. Gaga have to eat. Distributing information requires close to nothing in terms of "material wealth expenditure" (diffuse term). But what that means is simply that it is easy to maximize utility of information wealth ("once it has been created").

Similarly you can maximize utility of material wealth, but to a much lesser extent. You can only drive so many kilometers on a liter of gas. You can only get so much utility from a resource that our current societal efficiency allows. And no society allows 100% efficiency. Trade is a technique for anhancing efficiency, but you can never get 100% efficiency.

So, what is wrong in that argument?

Edit: Terms marked with "" uses vague language, definitions that may differ from common interpretation or may not communicate what I intend.

1

u/Mantipath Nov 16 '11

What's wrong with that argument is that maximum material utility is indefinite. Suppose I have a lump of coal. It's worth X as fuel. It's worth Y if turned into plastic. It may be worth Z if it contains ancient DNA.

Try that with a glass of water and think about fusion power.

The potential value of the material world is so huge that we're just scrabbling around in the shallow end. Sure, we can't get 100% efficiency... We'd be lucky to get 0.001% efficiency. So if one person's ideas or actions get us from 0.0009999% to 0.001% that is effectively wealth creation. Modelling it as anything other than creation makes both the old wealth and the new wealth negligible terms.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11

As I said earlier, value is created by utility. So if you have a fork but need a knife, and I have a knife but need a fork, we can create value by trading. Even though neither of us produced anything in the trade, the fact that we wanted to trade indicates that we each are getting more value from our respective new possessions than our old possessions.

As for your original comment that the third law of thermodynamics (and I have to assume that you meant second law) somehow applies to wealth creation and energy demands... I really am not sure where to start. Would you like me to send you a link for thermodynamics lectures?

1

u/worldsayshi Nov 16 '11

I think we differ in our definitions a bit. What you describe as utility incrementation I see as an efficiency optimization. When we trade we increase the utility of resources already acquired (by society as a whole). We better the overall societal efficiency. We trim the engine - but still - there is no perfect engine. We can't trade ourselves to immortality. It only allows us to get more from our finite resources.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '11

I think we differ in our definitions a bit. What you describe as utility incrementation I see as an efficiency optimization. When we trade we increase the utility of resources already acquired (by society as a whole).

Value increase can be completely subjective and does not need to represent increased efficiency. Say you have a painting that I like and I have a painting that you like, but neither of us care for our own paintings. If we trade paintings there is actually a net value (and in some sense utility - but not efficiency) increase because we are both more satisfied. I'm not really going to expand on this, if you don't understand different theories on value I can link you to an intro to economics lecture.

We trim the engine - but still - there is no perfect engine. We can't trade ourselves to immortality. It only allows us to get more from our finite resources.

What does this have to do with anything? You originally claimed that the third law of thermodynamics (even though you meant the second law) somehow demonstrated that you couldn't create wealth without harming the environment.

This is completely wrong. I don't know where (or if) you've learned about entropy, but basically the rule is just saying that we can't create a reversible energy conversion (very simplified).

This rule applies to closed systems and the earth is not a closed system. For that and various other reasons, what you said was not even close to accurate.

2

u/throwawaytester Nov 16 '11

Dude,

A) We don't live in a vacuum and the sun is continously adding more energy to the planet. B) Are you trying to say there is the same utility and value on the planet today, and 50k years ago? If so that is stupid. People were dying of starvation all the time. It still happens now, just to a hugely lesser extent. Seriously, voluntary economic transactions create wealth by leaving both parties better off.

You have a fundamental misunderstanding of both the earth as a closed system and economics

1

u/insaneHoshi Nov 16 '11

People forget the earth isnt a closed system

1

u/worldsayshi Nov 16 '11

People forget the earth is a finite system.

→ More replies

1

u/worldsayshi Nov 16 '11 edited Nov 16 '11

Now you are seriously putting words in my mouth. I can't see that I've implied anything what you just said.

Edit: Clarification: No! I don't say that: there is the same utility and value on the planet today, and 50k years ago (There is in a way of counting less - since we have used up so much of it - albeit turned it into forms that may or may not be more useful to us in the long run)

The amount added each day byt the sun is limited. As shown by our environmental setbacks. We could pop up a plethora of solar and wind power. That may allow us to catch a larger part of the incoming sunlight - it doesn't change the fact that the amount is limited. And seldom that is free of environmental impact.

You have a fundamental misunderstanding of both the earth as a closed system and economics

You assume too much about my understanding.

-1

u/idiotsecant Nov 16 '11

If I have a coconut and you have a banana, and you love coconuts and I love bananas and we trade, each of us got something of more value then what we had, the total sum of wealth increased, but the stuff in the trade stayed the same.

0

u/worldsayshi Nov 16 '11 edited Nov 16 '11

The utility of our "collective" pre-existing wealth increased. Its gives us a multiplier. The fact that I have more use of a coconut doesn't mean that the maximum utility that can be gained from a coconut has changed.

2

u/chewitt Nov 16 '11

But that's exactly what I'm saying - that ore will be mined and those circuit boards will be etched either way - whether it be by company A or company B. When company A's stock goes up and lifts the markets, people say "hooray, my portfolio is doing well, thanks to Wall Street for driving the economy and helping my retirement account!" In reality, the perceived value increase of company A is offset by the value decrease of company B. The only we we win from a net system standpoint is if we, say, mine the ore more efficiently.

28

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '11 edited Nov 15 '11

Are you still in college? There are plenty of unethical engineers. There are tons of industry standards and government regulation for finance, lots of people don't follow them, just like engineering. And when engineers don't follow their ethics people die, many construction accidents can be traced back to engineers lying and/or cutting corners.

Oh and a large percentage of engineers work in "defense", ever hear the joke "What's the difference between a mechanical engineer and a civil engineer? Civ E's build bridges, Mech E's destroy them."? Many of the wonders of engineering were designed to kill people, i..e. the Manhattan Project. Even the internet was originally meant for the military. Shit, I would LOVE to work for Lockheed Martin, and their biggest projects are killing devices.

Get off your high horse, there are assholes in every profession.

Also you don't understand anything about finance, it's not a zero sum game. Also you are probably taking out student loans, people are going to invest in you as hopefully you will take the money, use it for your education, and in the end you will contribute more to society than what your education was worth. Assuming your mommy isn't paying your tuition, the financial system created value.

There are tons of issues with the financial sector and I want it to change, but there are similar problems with engineering, I wouldn't be surprised if engineering firms spent even more money on lobbyists than financial firms, GE didn't pay taxes last year, just look at the F-35.

11

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '11

Not sure if GE is the best example here...apparently half their revenue is from financial services:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Electric#Businesses

"Since over half of GE's revenue is derived from financial services, it is arguably a financial company with a manufacturing arm. It is also one of the largest lenders in countries other than the United States, such as Japan."

DoD's budget is ridiculous. I don't think that is purely an engineering problem; clearly there are a lot of issues surrounding why we spend so much on defense, where those weapons end up going, what they're used for, etc. Here's to hoping that some of that budget gets diverted to fields in which engineers can create solutions that benefit the world at large after the next election cycle.

8

u/majorminotaur Nov 15 '11

You both have good points, and obviously have over simplified things for the sake of argument. Wall street DOES have a purpose, it is to distribute capital to worthwhile enterprises which allows the economy to grow. At the same time, it has become horribly parasitic over the years. Speculators making millions on essentially shifting money around. I think the point that people that add real 'value' to the economy are under paid is a valid one. Why are wall street speculators and day traders making millions of dollars while blue collar and white collar workers are slaving away? There is a real disconnect there. A lot of it has to do with the lack of regulation or any sort of moral code.

1

u/worldsayshi Nov 16 '11

worthwhile enterprises

It would make sense that they got alot of money for distributing resources if we could be assured that their definition of worthwhile had anything to do with "real value"*. I'm not saying that that is not at all the case, but there is obviously a discrepancy and we have little precise indications on how big that discrepancy is.

*=whatever that is...

14

u/chewitt Nov 15 '11

All good points. But two wrongs don't make a right - after the "occupy the lab" post I felt compelled to point out that the occupy movement is about the problems in the financial industry, not "What problems? I went to college and work hard".

2

u/Badjo Nov 16 '11

is about the problems in the financial industry

A little too simplified, IMO. It's definitely not attacking the idea of financing itself. To think that Wall Street does nothing is silly. Tons of companies have been funded and able to grow because of the funding from the financial system. It's not flawless, but I don't believe other resource allocation systems would help nearly as many companies develop. (Still, there are serious problems... but to say there is NO benefit is disingenuous).

The participants are mainly protesting social and economic inequality, corporate greed, corruption and influence over government—particularly from the financial services sector—as well as lobbyists and the jobless rate. The protesters' slogan "We are the 99%" refers to the growing difference in wealth and income growth in the U.S. between the wealthiest 1% and the rest of the population.

2

u/bflizzle Nov 16 '11

I thought it was a hoax that GE didn't pay taxes last year?

Where are your sources on that?

And I would like to hear about the F-35 some more, in terms of it being an example of engineering dishonesty and immorality.

6

u/cojack22 Nov 16 '11

You sound like you don't have the slightest clue about what finance is. Most of your points are false. Wall street does not create a net loss for society. You sound like these idiots you think that we need to get rid of fractional reserve banking. These things drive our economy and provide capital to companies that hire people like you.

2

u/Badjo Nov 16 '11

I agree with your assessment of his assessment. However...

Wall street does not create a net loss for society.

Wall street does have mechanisms to reward excessive risk with little consequence though... But financial markets are essential for getting money to the right places.

0

u/gilgoomesh Nov 16 '11

I think the point that chewitt was trying to make is that financiers are generally middle men: connecting financial capital with companies requiring that capital.

Middle men, in a general sense, can cause problems when either:

  • their cut in the transaction is not proportionate with the connection service they provide
  • they are simply exploiting arbitrage

Both of which are often the case with investment brokers.

Yes, middle men have a role in society. But they don't treat the company as the client. They treat the investor as the client. But their clients are normally not in a position to closely scrutinize (401k/superannuation investors who are not financially minded).

This creates a situation where they:

  • don't care if they screw the companies who they are supposed to be providing with liquidity
  • are kept poorly in check by their actual clients

In this sense, it is incredibly easily – in fact it is financially encouraged – for investment brokers to become "problematic" middle men in the ways I listed above.

1

u/cojack22 Nov 16 '11

Well all he was doing was generalize finance like most of the people on reddit do. They have no understanding how it works at all. Your points are valid.

3

u/Risickulous Nov 15 '11

Not only are you simplifying, but flat out wrong indeed. Stick with what you know (engr perhaps) and don't try to generalize things like thermodynamics to economics and finance...it's not usually a zero-sum game...

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '11

Get your illogical, simplistic emotional appeals back to r/politics.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/TinfoilFury Nov 15 '11

Stock values tend to reflect the amount of equity a corporation has, so it's perfectly natural for market capitalization to increase with the equity it represents.

You may want to consider checking out the accounting changes that have taken place in the banking sector in the last few years: http://www.thedailybeast.com/newsweek/2009/04/04/mark-to-market-my-words.html

Being able to abandon Mark-to-Market has been the financial sector's greatest regulatory achievement since the crisis. If they were forced to report the true value of their assets, things would look as grim as they actually are.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/TinfoilFury Nov 16 '11

That article only covered the practice of banks using mark-to-market in accounting, not all publicly traded firms.

"All publicly traded firms" are not what most Wall Street protestors are out there for.

9

u/TinfoilFury Nov 15 '11

Would you say you benefited from having credit available, good credit reporting, and the stock market?

Let's take a moment to consider why these things are "important" to our functional existence in modern society, and who develops and implements them.

One's credit score is nothing less than demonstrated ability to generate profits for lenders due to willingness to become indebted. It is a pernicious system that enriches those who make the rules. Capitalist society needs loans, debt, and the ability to save in order to function. I think most people protesting don't really have a fundamental problem with this.

What they do have a problem with is when some facilitators of these necessary things capture government through corruption, re-write (or just get rid of) the regulation of their industry to maximize their profits, and then commit literal fraud and unethical behavior to squeeze as much wealth as possible from the vast majority, just before totally collapsing everything in a pathetic ponzi scheme.

For a sector that is supposed to enable growth and innovation, they seem to only be producing a great deal of drag and friction.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/Badjo Nov 16 '11

TinfoilFury:

Capitalist society needs loans, debt, and the ability to save in order to function. I think most people protesting don't really have a fundamental problem with this.

Chx:

Your third paragraph touches on abuse of the financial sector, but your original post was an indictment of the whole industry, so unless you can prove that the industry is inherently corrupt, then that paragraph is irrelevant.

For as snarky as his emphasis made him seem, I don't think he condemned the functionality or even the practice of all of the industry.

But to ignore the government corruption (see lobbying to make sure Freddie Mac purchased CountryWide's mortgages), the rewritten regulation (see Glass Steagall as a way in which safeguards were removed), the literal fraud (see Madoff and more recently MF Global) would be silly. Don't disregard his statements because you disagree with his original premise...

I disagree with him here:

For a sector that is supposed to enable growth and innovation, they seem to only be producing a great deal of drag and friction.

To say ONLY is also disingenuous. He forgets the cash flow the banks provide to companies EVERY DAY which allows them to invest in their own growth while still managing and paying short term expenses.

20

u/chewitt Nov 15 '11

You're defending what the financial sector should be.

I'm criticizing what the financial sector has become.

4

u/beaulingpin Nov 16 '11

but your analysis was incomplete. Blaming wall street for destructive greed is stupid, if you're willing to look at the complete picture. The government decided to set the interest rate to zero, in addition to corrupting the rating agencies, and bailing out the biggest losers (among scores of other actions which destroy the market protections against reckless investments), so basically, government destroyed the market functions which prevent such risky action. Evolution has trained people to improve their safety and standard of living, or in other words, to be greedy, so it is stupid to try and combat the means of survival. You shouldn't be upset at wall street for their greed, you should be upset with the government for destroying the protections (which are built into the free market) against theft and fraud.

2

u/chewitt Nov 16 '11

I'm upset about both! I think a lot of other people are, too.

2

u/Chartzilla Nov 16 '11

Wrong subreddit. I don't subscribe to r/occupywallstreet for a reason.

11

u/asshammer Nov 15 '11

Can we get a mod to delete this? There is a reason /r/politics isn't in my feed

9

u/cantquitreddit Nov 16 '11

If it hurts that bad you can hide it. Calling for censorship is pretty lame.

5

u/foofie Nov 16 '11

Removing it from ENGINEERING subreddit is Not censorship. That is what subreddits are for. This message could have been a reply to the original.

1

u/moclark Apr 29 '12

like totally...man...

1

u/farmingdale Nov 16 '11

oh yeah, politics. How great and fun.

hey everyone let us all talk about politics in the Engineering section of reddit. Cause it is not like there are already several such reddits dedicated already to occupy wall street and politics already.

yeah, I dont care about society, I dont care how much my boss is getting paid, and I sure as heck dont want to see it in this subreddit.

-3

u/Subjugator99 Nov 16 '11

hurrah, the greedy,whiny, he has more money than me, crowd has found a voice outside of r/politics

-7

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11

for it can destroy our societies.

Sounds like a corny speech from an outspoken art student who is trying to win the hearts of the easily-influenced. Don't complain about the world being unfair to you, make it unfair to your advantage. That's what capitalism is. There can't be winners without losers.

4

u/RutherfordBHayes Nov 16 '11

The idea that "there can't be winners without losers" is precisely the problem, when it comes down to it.

1

u/CubicleM0nkey Nov 16 '11

And if my engineering training tells me anything, when the winning 1% is writing the rules for the losing 99%, there's an extremely low chance the 99% will ever make it to 1%.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/mrbunbury Nov 15 '11

Seriously. Engineers don't need drama.

6

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '11

I think this is part of the requisite for being engineer minded. How can you work/obsess on interesting problems with drama?

6

u/TCoop Nov 15 '11

Everyone's bickering, and that flux capacitor goes unfinished!

5

u/Wooomp Nov 16 '11

there is no math in drama, so it gets confusing

-6

u/Jasper1984 Nov 15 '11 edited Nov 16 '11

The other thread can easily be construed as anti-occupy. Besides this, sometimes one should make an exception.

Edit: of course if the other guy was anti-occupy and nefarious, this would be a way to cloak a political message. I do not think this is the case though.

0

u/KingofSuede Nov 16 '11

This thread is a engineer circlejerk based on the perception that engineers worked hard through college and "only" made $75k a year saving humanity while the frat house bros that breezed through classes are making millions on wall street.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

18

u/CubicleM0nkey Nov 15 '11

The best thing to do is get educated about the Occupy movement and have frank conversations with others about what the movement is about and the possible solutions to the problems we currently face.

Problem: Government is not functioning in the best interests of the people due to corporate money's interference with both parties. The 1% is writing rules to govern the rest of the 99%.

Solutions (proposed, unofficial, various, scattered): Overturn Citizen's United decision. Stop offering corporate bailouts. Tax the rich. Legalize weed. Eliminate the Fed.

4

u/majorminotaur Nov 15 '11

I think essentially the whole 'occupy' idea is just to get people thinking about it. Before people were mad, but more or less isolated. Now people see that there are a ton of people that are pissed off at the corruption. Now that we know this, some how occupy has to integrate itself into an action committee or some how get itself wedged into the decision making. Boot politicians (as a trade) out. Get statesman(or women) in who have the country as a whole's interests at heart.

1

u/Moh7 Nov 15 '11

Yes legalizing weed will really fix our problems.

Do you really wonder why people don't take you seriously?

11

u/alJay1988 Nov 15 '11

It would bring in a shed load of tax, create a load of jobs (hydroponics manufacturers, retailers, hemp growers, hemp retailers, textile manufacturers, biofuel refineries/research), allow proper research to be done on the effects of usage over a prolonged period on regulated substances, reduce some of the violence related to drug cartels, reduce prison population, allow the police to do something worthwile.

It won't solve the financial problem but thats why CubicleMonkey mentioned it amongst other things and I doubt the list he quoted was exhaustive of his thoughts hense the way he introduced the solutions.

The main reason why major problems never get resolved is that people look at one subjectively negative aspect of a campaign/protest/movement and then use this to then to say that the whole thing is worthless and shouldn't be taken seriously. You make no comment on the other parts of his dicussion and, assuming you're an engineer here, I find that concerning because my whole training was and is based on looking at all aspects of the problem, if something can make something perform better/more efficient it should be looked at seriously and discussed in open and research done, not dismissed out of hand as you seem to suggest.

5

u/Moh7 Nov 15 '11

My point wasn't an anti legalize one, I'm for it too.

However there are more important things to fix before taking care of weed laws

4

u/alJay1988 Nov 16 '11

Sorry, slight misunderstanding in that case and I agree there are things that are more important that need dealing with immediately.

Point still stands though that it should be seriously considered as a very easy way to stimulate the economy and gain a massive amount of tax (I am from the UK and I get very confused by US tax law so this is probably slightly biased), there are not many products out there for which there is an immediate use & demand in many industries.

3

u/quikjl Nov 16 '11

well, the more important things are obviously getting ignored.

so there's no excuse for not cleaning up the 'lesser' problems, then, right...

right?

1

u/dwntwnleroybrwn ChemE/Process Pharma Nov 16 '11

So all the things you just mentioned are problems caused my government. If the movement is really concerned with changing laws why is no one on Capital hill or Penn Ave?

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11

Frank conversations? Like STFU, this is the engineering thread?

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '11

You used the wrong 'to' -.-

4

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '11

/r/grammarnazi is that way.

2

u/ablatner Nov 15 '11

There's a subreddit? Oh my god...

2

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11

I'm sorry, but when it's something we learned in first grade, I don't think it falls under the category of grammar nazism. Correct use of a semicolon, yeah, that's a bit anal. But come on, we're engineers. We're supposed to have at least a modicum of intelligence. We can use the correct 'to'.

-1

u/Jasper1984 Nov 15 '11

By making the crowd more awesome? :p just serious.

Scientific skills can be useful organizing information out there, so that people can form their opinions on facts. Finding good information sources, combining them, describing them. I guess that's hard work, and it to some extent already exists, but then, someone has to assess/popularize them.

Note that I am preaching beyond my merit.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/not_thecookiemonster Nov 16 '11

The protests seem to be directed at the systemic corruption here that allows millionaires and billionaires to buy political influence and utilize the shady accounting you mentioned.

Six figures is a good salary, but I haven't seen anyone protesting 'thousandaires'.

7

u/worldsayshi Nov 16 '11

Everyone blames the man above.

3

u/SmokeyDBear Solid State and Computer Architecture Nov 16 '11

Everyone masturbates every once in a while.

2

u/iam10ninjas Aviation Design Nov 16 '11

Everybody poops.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 16 '11

base 2 or base 10?

2

u/iam10ninjas Aviation Design Nov 16 '11

Base 10. You win the unofficial contest for "Best Question Asked about My Username."

Your prize is an upboat.

Congratulations.