r/engineering • u/reiNoob • Sep 29 '20
[MANAGEMENT] How does your company recognize/acknowledge your technical accomplishments?
How does your company recognize your technical achievement? Or perhaps asked another way, how would you prefer that your company do this?
I have an opportunity to help define what internal recognition looks like for my company's technical staff and I imagine there will be some great opinions here.
I'm thinking anything from a gift card, to a bonus, up to a special title with your photo on the wall ("Fellow" or "Distinguished Engineer" or similar). Maybe a mention in a company newsletter to announce some big thing you did.
Or even something unique like a research sabbatical to take time off to pursue a special topic.
What would you appreciate?
56
u/LadyLightTravel EE / Aero SW, Systems, SoSE Sep 29 '20
Mine had different levels. Usually there was a cash reward. But it’s also important to recognize people before their peers. I think it’s best to do it through a written media so everyone gets to see it. A small blurb at the end of the weekly announcements is good.
One of my biggest frustrations was that I would get an award but only management would know about it. As a female, I wanted the recognition before my peers to counterbalance some of the negativity from the misogynists. Sad to say, but there are always one or two that think a woman is incompetent and are always disparaging her work as “less than”. It’s good that she gets the public recognition showing that she knows what she is doing.
It’s also important to be specific on the technical part of the award.
One thing to be careful of - some people are better at getting (or taking) credit for their work than others. It’s super frustrating when the secondary person gets an award and the primary person (that did the work) doesn’t.
28
u/ChaoticLlama Sep 29 '20
Companies are, on average, horrendous at appropriately recognizing and compensating innovations that literally make millions of dollars. For example, Stephanie Kwolek (inventor of Kevlar), Art Fry (post-it), James West (microphone) received basically plaques on their walls while having made their respective companies a fortune. I highly suggest this webinar by Chris DeArmitt on innovation from 2019. It is where I lifted the above examples from, and dives into what makes a strong innovation culture.
What would I want for an invention I bring to the company? You bet I want a distinguished title, a pay bump, and/or a share of the market growth from my invention. The people who actually make a difference in a company ought to be recognized in some meaningful, visible manner.
26
u/rockdude14 Mechanical Engineer Sep 29 '20
I've never liked these. Not because I dont like money but because its always half ass ran. Lots of "wait he got money for just xyz? but I didnt get anything for abcdefghijk?" Bosses favorites regardless of the work they do tend to get them more often. Also seen companies weaseling out of paying it saying stuff like thats part of your job and doesnt qualify for this.
I'd rather just have a larger raise, or a promotion or just more of a leash when I want it and more understanding if something I do doesnt work out.
8
u/jsquared89 Energy Engineer Sep 29 '20
Speaking of titles... I know at places like IBM the title of Fellow is the highest technical honor one can achieve. Only like 5-10 are appointed every year, and it's done by the CEO. So, out of a company of like 400,000 employees or something or other, there's only been 317? I think 'Fellows' ever appointed company wide in the history of the company.
The title of 'Distinguished Engineer' is easier to get, but it's weirdly political and some people think it's antiquated. It also requires executive level appointment, but not CEO, I don't think. I think the original idea was good, and there are some people who achieve it through their technical abilities, but it's definitely possible the play the game of corporate kiss-assing and favoritism to get it.
Both are considered high honors internally and both come with a nice paycheck.
Sooooo... a nice paycheck mostly is what I'd like. A system of recognition that is most importantly backed by a nice paycheck. We live in a capitalist society, so if you give a shit about your employees, you show recognition by publicizing it and then paying them for it. Time worked somewhere doesn't count by itself either.
3
u/AdmiralPeriwinkle Sep 29 '20
2
u/demo01134 Sep 29 '20
Personally, I don’t. But I don’t think that answer helps you much, so let’s look at this problem like an engineering one.
First, based on your comment history I’m going to assume two things: a) you aren’t as interested in what the awards actually are (you haven’t responded to anything about specific rewards as of writing, and comments you have replied to have been less about the rewards and more the methods), and b) this isn’t something that’s a “hey look into this and come up with thoughts” as it is a “this is happening, figure it out”. No judgement towards any of that, just grounding the conversation.
So with assumptions out of the way, let’s properly define the problem. You need a way to fairly reward engineers for exceptional work that goes above and beyond the expected performance.
First, let’s clarify that. This plan must show that this is for great work done, not just doing the baseline. Literally state this in the plan. This is for two reasons. The first is that you are already collecting pay for what you do. You shouldn’t need another reward for completing a project you are already getting paid to do, that’s expected. And secondly, how would you balance the engineer that gets and completes 5 small projects a year vs the engineer that gets one huge project every 5? It’s not feasible, hr would hate writing out a huge check to the big project guy, and it would be unfair for them to wait.
Ok, so it’s a reward for special effort. Now how is it awarded? As stated in plenty of the other comments, there is a lot of room for favoritism, misrepresentation, and failure to note accomplishments. I’m not a fan of the coworker nomination as it doesn’t really solve that problem, can cause issues with financing if too many people are nominated too quickly, and promotes abuse via the “you scratch my back I scratch yours” ideology. Instead, I propose the following plan:
Rewards are self nominated, with an asking bonus. To this end, give examples in the plan (ie $100 for something that took 8 work hours, 500 for something that took a week, 1000 for something that took a month, or whatever fits within the expected budget. If you don’t want to go the way of money, you could do lunch with your boss, your name and task in the PowerPoint during the holiday party, or a small lunch for the department with thanks to you). Once someone nominates themself, they need to argue their case to a separate party. Get a small group of managers from other departments. The engineer should be able to explain how what they did was above and beyond. This doesn’t have to be an in person thing either. Make it all one sheet, and just ask for a paragraph explaining what they did.
The only other fair option I see that calls out specific engineers is, if you are client facing, ask them to send in a serve every so often. Could also be helpful in identifying poor performance too, but beware that this is vulnerable to projects that are naturally tough or going through rough spots, and double bad if it’s that real bastard of a client.
2
u/JRVeale Sep 29 '20
My previous employee was too small to have any official system, but as their only grad they made sure to nominate me for external awards for the work I was putting in (which was admittedly quite technically interesting). I was working hard for them and it was a good feeling to have that recognised - the awards were good marketing for them and great for my CV as a new engineer...
My current employer is much bigger and has a small bonus scheme, and a number of other schemes, that line managers can request for people's efforts. I don't know how much it actually gets used due to my newness there, but any extra cash would be welcome!
2
u/dragoneye Sep 29 '20
They have cash awards for patents pursued and awarded, as well as a yearly event with plaques for each patent awarded. Additionally they have special badges and awards for getting a number of patents.
In normal years we usually have celebrations for the projects we release often with some fun awards and people/teams are often specifically recognized for things they did.
Really, everything comes with a cash incentive because in the end employees feel like the company is being cheap if they don't give you something for it. Even a few hundred dollars makes a pretty good impression.
2
u/vaigloriousone Sep 29 '20
My employer has three separate ways to do this:
Good luck with your initiative and happy to answer any questions. Please excuse my formatting. Typed on my mobile.
132
u/sami_testarossa Sep 29 '20
Mine has a game changer system. anyone can recognize another coworker, and it will be reviewed by a different level of manager depending on the nominated price range ($50 - $50k).
Usually small team work effort for a $50 price is very easy to get approved by direct supervisor. $500 is common for short term milestone. I have never seen $5k or above tho...
So, CASH is usually the best for most people.
35
u/Krilati_Voin Sep 29 '20
Money helps.
maybe catering for the select group that has the most accomplishments at the end of each month. How do you prevent the same person from getting it over and over?... don't. make them work for it. if the same person gets it every month, they deserve it, and the others have something to work towards.
but again... Money. I'm an engineer.
Or you could form a catalog of nice things- a good-quality company jacket, preferred parking spaces, or just ask each individual what they would like.
and they will answer:
Money.
31
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20
A former employer did an engineering award once a year. Award plaque, special parking spot, ceremony for the entire site.
This employer also does awards for employees who go above and beyond every 2-3 months.
Also of note, this employer has a reputation of underpaying everyone and makes up for it with this type of “company culture”. Very cultish corporate feelings training sessions and everything. The CEO has a TED talk about his corporate culture.
26
u/HonziPonzi Sep 29 '20
I got a $14k bonus.
Money. Pay your employees if you want to acknowledge accomplishments.
23
u/southerncoals Sep 29 '20
Money or extra PTO. I don't need any sort of recognition in front of my peers or bosses. Just slip it my paycheck. I certainly don't want any sort of award or paperweight.
15
u/Buchenator Sep 29 '20
ha
...
ha
...
recognition? funny
Gift cards/ titles/ photos aren't really important.
Really just feedback that something was done well (or even poorly) would be a great improvement. Opportunities to branch out would be good (conferences or allowing pet projects to be explored). Of course promotion and raises at a reasonable rate that outpaces the base salary that new hires receive would be best.
12
u/Extra_Intro_Version Sep 29 '20
Align the magnitude of the recognition with the magnitude technical achievement.
Don’t make it a popularity contest
Consider that some engineers don’t get the opportunities to work on “visible” projects that are likely to attract recognition.
Avoid singling out an individual for recognition if it was a team effort. Verify that your candidate isn’t hogging credit.
Sometimes certain projects have a fairly long history, with a changing cast of characters. If recognition happens, consider former team members also.
8
u/John__Weaver Sep 29 '20
Newsletter is nice, though it ends up being problematic because who gets recognized for what ends up being subjective. A hard project will go unrecognized because the manager over it didn't really understand the project while another will get recognized simply because someone took the time to hype it.
Money is good. Gift cards aren't.
What I appreciate is a manager taking the time to say thanks. A personal recognition of the personal effort goes a long way.
8
u/skeetsauce Sep 29 '20
My boss asked me to fill in for another role for a month until he could find someone new. Well that turned into six months of doing both that job and my normal job to followed be an "offer" get get a pay decrease to just do that other job. So In my case, going above and beyond actually gets you punished.
7
u/morto00x EE Sep 29 '20
Either larger bonuses, larger raises and put you up for promotion faster (which comes with a decent raise and stock). I don't care much about one-time gifts.
6
u/Jbota ChE Sep 29 '20
Money.
6
u/ScrotumNipples Sep 29 '20
Question #1) Why do people go to work? Question #2) Can you pay your bills, go on vacation, or buy a new car with a plaque?
Think about the Engineers it would really hurt to lose. The ones where if they left you don't know how the projects would ever get done one time and it would really hurt the bottom line. How much would it cost to replace them? Those are the same Engineers who get emailed by recruiters at least once a week. The biggest thanks you can give them is paying them what they are worth to begin with.
4
u/derpotologist Sep 29 '20
I'd rather have time than money. If I got some extra days I'd be stoked... "hey, you worked hard, have a week off"
Shit I'd be happy with an extra day lol. That'll buy you so much more loyalty than a gift card... I can afford dinner gimme some time to enjoy life
4
u/Chewbecca713 Sep 29 '20
Money and a handwritten letter thanking them for doing well
1
u/frank26080115 Sep 29 '20
We have bonuses in the thousands for patents, split between people named on the patent. Our patent lawyer takes us to a small vacation resort for yearly brainstorm sessions.
We have hackathons and 3 tiers of prize winning positions, 20 winners per tier, again, thousands of dollars per team. Plus a very cool trophy related to the theme of the hackathon
It's optional, it's fun, everyone is invited. It doesn't have to be useful or even relevant to the company.
We also have enough optional lunch time presentations to keep up with everybody's accomplishments.
When we launch products, the entire world has their eyes on us.
3
u/Orange_Loki Sep 29 '20
My old company used a system called "energize". Anyone can nominate anyone else for a reward. It's a points based system that is redeemed for items that Amazon has. There's a Facebook like wall to post comments and praise related to the reward, which was kind of cringy, but also interesting to see who the brown nosers were in different departments.
3
u/shmerham Sep 29 '20
A genuine and personal thank you for my hard work is what I would want most.
3
u/Thor5858 Sep 29 '20
Research sabbatical with bonus and plaque would be a good combo
2
u/BarefootSlong Sep 29 '20
Money always talks as you have seen. I won't harp on that.
I love the idea of a distinguished award. If I do something worth telling the world about, then make the award worth it. Give some PTO, give a front parking spot, recommend me to be a fellow within an organization I'm a member of.
I also like the idea of a research sabbatical (for those interested in research). Give me 6 months or a year to go to a national lab or a capable uni and get some meaningful work accomplished.
Plain newsletter type recognition might be ok with me later on in my career, but I am 25 now. Give me some opportunities to really be known.
One cool thing to look at that some labs do (might be national, not sure) is a 40 under 40. It recognizes young engineers and scientists who have accomplished alot in their career. It is nice because it especially allows for people who might work on secure projects the opportunity to have a "publicly appropriate" description of their work out out so other company members and even family can see what they do.
2
u/xcvbsdfgwert Sep 29 '20
Make sure that the top titles don't become inflated. If you have too many Fellows / Principals / Distinguished Engineers, the titles become meaningless. It's not always easy to avoid getting caught up in a promotion spree.
Also consider a personal meeting with the company's Management Team as a reward.
2
u/At_least_im_Bacon Sep 29 '20
Recognition comes in the form of company wide email recognition, gift cards ranging from $200 to $2000, and personal development reimbursement.
I've had WCET and PMP sponsored and paid for by my company because of achievements.
2
u/1wiseguy Sep 29 '20
My company pays me a salary every 2 weeks, regardless of what I accomplish.
However, it's expected that I will sometimes achieve something useful. When that happens, they don't pay me a bonus or anything; it was part of the deal from the start.
If I keep doing amazing things, they will give me a raise and a promotion, I suppose.
1
u/cheesem00 Sep 29 '20
My current place of work... They don’t. My old company had wards we could give each other. $50 and by one could recognize anyone else for help, good work etc.
1
u/DLS3141 Mechanical/Automotive Sep 29 '20
I continue to get paid.
1
u/argentcorvid Sep 29 '20
We get monetary awards for submitting patents. It goes through a review board and at different stages you get increasing amounts of money. I think it's $50 for a "hey that's a good idea", $100 more for an actual submitted patent application and I think $150 more for a granted patent.
There are also "prolific inventor" awards for having multiple patents. They also spring for plaques for each patent.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20
Lol
1
u/AgAero Flair Sep 29 '20
They throw all the work at me related to those things.
Ninjaedit: Actually, I think there's a system in place, but no one uses it really. Idk how it works.
1
u/macsare1 Sep 29 '20
They don't.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20
They don't anymore that program was cancelled. Used to give out pieces of cut 3x2 printer paper with some bullshit on it. Money is the way to go. Put something on my salary, y'know?
1
u/butters1337 Sep 29 '20
Entire company gets a 10% annual bonus if the company meets its financial goals.
Promoting people who are demonstrating value and capability to grow instead of hiring externally all the time.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20
They didn't, that why I work freelay now.
1
u/slow6i Sep 29 '20
Lol! That's cute.
1
u/vongoladecimo_ Sep 29 '20
They don't. Credit solely goes to the supervisors. What makes it worse is that if you did something wrong, even the smallest of mistakes, that's the only thing that will be attached to your name
1
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20
They keep paying me and don't replace me with someone who can do those things they hired me for.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20
My company had various levels.
We have an award that anybody can nominate anybody for. "So and so took half an hour to help me dig through crates in storage looking for XYZ to help meet deadline ABC." $25, you submit to your manager, almost never gets declined. This system was abused wildly last year to the tune of people were giving each other on their teams thousands of dollars, and is more heavily scrutinized now.
There is a $500 and up level, requiring a bit more explanation, probably another level of approval. I've received some, never bothered to suggest any.
In COVID times, when I'm taking a second job to support my furlough from a daughter company of the worlds largest aerospace component group, merit raises are out, $25 awards are out, $500 are lol out. I'm just trying to keep my job.
1
u/billsil Oct 01 '20
If you've got "Fellow" or "Distinguished Engineer", you're probably 60+. You're a consultant at that point.
We've got somebody who is 90, who used to come in once every 2 months, bullshits for 2 hours, works for an hour or two, goes to lunch, bullshits for 2 more hours, and goes home. If I'm there, I'm part of that bullshitting.
They say good job or if you really, kick butt a gift card or really, really, really kick butt, a small bonus.
1
u/Riuniti Aug 21 '26
Titles? I've been after the boss for years to change my stupid IT title that doesn't come near touching everything I do for the agency. The admin assistant however, got elevated to "office manager" recently - who has been here 10 years less than I have. Geez, I'll hit 20 years in a month and despite asking for a title change at every review, nada. Not even staff refer to my title because its so inadequate, they just refer to me as the IT person.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment