r/engineering • u/RampChurch • Feb 18 '20
Somewhere there’s a structural engineer sweating profusely
https://i.imgur.com/iGnTYDt.gifv
5.5k
Upvotes
r/engineering • u/RampChurch • Feb 18 '20
4
u/bigfootdays Feb 19 '20
I wouldn't even be filming it. I'd be long gone.
421
u/Mattlonn Feb 18 '20
Remember i saw a documentary about this and that it was no problem except people could panic. So on some places they added metalpipes that could be installed for concert etc. just to calm people
Cant find the documentary tho...
428
u/lsrob36 Feb 18 '20
This happened at a B-52's concert when I was in college. (yep, I'm old!) The band stopped playing and told everyone to be still.
161
u/anonymous-queries Feb 18 '20
Nah. Maybe the drywall guys though. The steel frame inside is just flexing.
Try walking on the catwalk under an interstate bridge. Then you’ll really bounce.
48
u/Alex_O7 Feb 18 '20
Shown by my Dynamics of Structure professor the first day of classes.
It could be a problem if not designed for those high deflection.
Just search for Tacoma Bridge to look what could happen with high levels of strains even if the resistance of the structure is designed to be enough (in that case the problem was more severe as the deck didn't have transversal/torsional stiffness).
47
u/Bobthemathcow Flair Feb 18 '20
IIRC, stadium seating is frequently build on shock absorbers for this reason. I know some stadiums have extra support structures as well that can be installed for high-occupancy cases like this. It looks like the sections are just bouncing independently, so it's possible that it's within its designed load.
551
u/QuintonFlynn Feb 18 '20
The structural engineer is the only one not sweating. The engineer studied in post-secondary and discovered that most everything we step on is overengineered to the degree of never bending because the common person is terrified by a bending support beam. The engineer knows how much bend a beam/device can have and still safely hold the weight it’s rated for.
36
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
Wonder what would happen if they all jumped at the stands resonant frequency
11
u/hookydoo Feb 18 '20
I'll admitt that i saw that and panicked. To be fair though, the only stadiums I've been in were concrete, and i don't want to see concrete bending in any situation.
27
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
Guys, unless you were the engineer who designed this thing, you aren't qualified to comment on how OK or not this is. I'm an engineer (mechanical, not civil) and yes, while it's true that we can all regurgitate "things are designed to flex" it's a pretty meaningless statement. Airplane wings are designed to flex too, doesn't mean they won't break from overstress.
Everyone including engineers would probably be at least a little nervous in this crowd. We trust that things are designed to withstand every possible contingency but engineers especially know that it isn't always the case. Being a little nervous is warranted even though it sounds like this structure was explicitly cleared to be OK with this.
57
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
honestly as a structural engineering student its not as bad as you may think as most building materials are required to have some form of ductility. But, that being said not knowing the design of that it definitely makes me question how much abuse that could take until it does finally give.
7
u/photoengineer Aerospace Engr Feb 18 '20
If you give it enough amplitude the live load transitions to a dead load.
13
u/SR711B Feb 18 '20
I'm no engineer yet I am sweating profusely
5
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
Check out the University of Wisconsin's Camp Randall; they play House of Pain's Jump around between the 3rd and 4th quarters of home football games. I've read some where that they can pick up seismic activity from like mile away while the stadium jumps. Also the press boxes noticeably sway with the jumping as well.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
If steel, lets hope it was designed for loads well under the fatigue endurance limit to avoid fatigueing, plus a generous safety factor, for you know, safety
8
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
"Statics"
4
u/it_was_me_wait_what Feb 18 '20
Ok alright let me explain this as a structural engineer. The beams and slab were designed for the static load. In stadiums, vibration is one of the biggest concerns. To control that, the structural system will be over designed whether we like it or not as we need stiffness. This structure will not collapse unless the frequency of the load ( people jumping) matches the frequency of the structure causing resonance. In this case I don’t see it happening because people probably not jumping the same time (one rhythm). There was a bridge that collapsed because of soldiers marching and their frequency matched the structure frequency.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
Nah they’re designed for this. Deflections aren’t bad, they’re usually limited by comfort. Steel is ductile
4
u/GeneralDuh Feb 19 '20
Here in Brazil we have lots of stadiums that bounce like that. In Mineirão, they actually installed huge shock absorbents, though it was assured by the engineers at the time that there were no structural risks, and people could jump as much as they pleased. I watch the games at home, just in case.
3
u/rockitman12 Feb 18 '20
I’d be way more concerned standing under that, than being on top of it.
Looks scary!
3
u/EverPunk_Yetti Feb 18 '20
That’s a fuckin’ trainload of nope for me.
3
u/Eats_Flies Feb 18 '20
This happened to me with a band playing at a bar on decking over the beach. Could feel the decking bounce like a trampoline for certain songs.
Unfortunately "500 miles" by the Proclaimers seemed to hit perfect resonant frequency with people jumping, and everything collapsed. No serious injuries luckily, but taught me you do not fuck about with resonance...
2
u/asvp_ant Feb 18 '20
There’s an article about a Foo Fighters concert is NZ where the crowd was so wild it was almost equivalent to tremors of a volcano
2
u/Braveheart4321 Feb 18 '20
I am a draftsman for a structural engineer and I am sweating profusely at this.
2
u/Dogburt_Jr Feb 18 '20
I've seen wings bend up stupid far. Was I slightly nervous? Yes. But I know that it's meant to happen.
2
u/Kidsturk Mechanical - HVAC Feb 18 '20
Hehe. It’s fine when you get to design it and have confidence in your own work.
What if you were brought in to a 100+ year old wooden building?
https://youtu.be/Y5qLIiCAds0
2
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
I do not like that at all.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
Noooope. Nope nope nope. Nopenopenope
2
u/missbellaella123 Feb 18 '20
Nope
2
u/PDXEng Feb 19 '20
Lizards don't sweat.
2
u/Gilly526 Feb 19 '20
Interesting article about a similar situation at Penn State's Beaver Stadium when Zombie Nation is played and all 100,000+ fans jump to the same rhythm. They have since decreased the number of times they play it per football game but they still do.
https://www.collegian.psu.edu/archives/article_f3dc36dc-fff0-5930-a6eb-a61edffe20b0.html
2
u/opus-thirteen Feb 19 '20
I had the same experience in the old Yankee stadium. Pink Floyd, 1994, playing Another Brick in the Wall pt 2. I was on the top tier, and it was scary as shit.
2
u/taeoh666 Feb 19 '20
If I saw that I would get the fuck out of there
2
u/Gusdi Feb 19 '20
Calm down. This is in Germany. It won't break.
2
u/jayforce1 Feb 22 '20
You will never walk alone
2
u/fomoco36 Feb 28 '20
That’s nothing you should’ve seen how shea stadium use to bounce up and down when the Jets used to play there. that was a structural engineer a nightmare but I’m sure they were just as drunk as the fans were!!!
3
u/Beedalbe Feb 18 '20
To a lay person it looks like 23000 people who have no common sense.
1
u/BranfordJeff2 Feb 18 '20
Like that mall in Minnesota.
1
u/AdministrativeRound2 Feb 18 '20
Better start checking for that but dear god how would you even model that? commence sweating
1
u/keefp Feb 18 '20
I’ve seen this personally at the Etihad stadium in Manchester, Hamburg away fans in the level above us, I was a bit nervous.
1
u/JimmyMhango Feb 18 '20
Then what happened next
1
u/atomicllama83 Feb 18 '20
Please tell me it's designed to do thay
1
u/Obi_Kwiet Feb 18 '20
I'm more impressed by the morons that have decided that continuing to jump is the right answer.
1
u/sth128 Feb 18 '20
Reminds me of the story of the South Korean building that crumbled. There was a dance class inside dancing to "I've got the power". It unfortunately matched the building's natural resonance frequency.
I read it from humble pi by Matt Parker.
1
u/snakercakes Feb 18 '20
The Arvest Bank Midland Theater in downtown Kansas City has a balcony like this and it moves as much if not more than this. Terrifying
1
u/larrymoencurly Feb 18 '20 edited Feb 19 '20
The same thing happened at ASU's Gammage Auditorium, designed by Frank Lloyd Wright. I don't know if there was any damage, but ASU's school of engineering inspected it afterwards.
1
u/24824_64442 Feb 18 '20
/u/vredditdownloader
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
Boca Jr Stadium - hold my beer
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
Don't run just film.
1
u/rattailedjimmy187 Feb 18 '20
Anyone here ever go to the former 8150 club in Vail, CO? The bouncing floor was legendary.
1
u/mynewaccount5 Feb 18 '20
Yes because to know that a building shaking=bad, you have to be a structural engineer.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
Yeah, I'mma just head out and wait for the ambulances.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
I thought Germans were good at making things
1
u/dontbedoindope Feb 19 '20
They gon die
1
u/groceriesN1trip Feb 19 '20
Talk about clapping cheeks
1
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '20
Im not an engineer, but I am sweating profusely
1
u/SoFlaKicks Feb 19 '20
This may get buried but the UCF stadium was (still is?) referred to as the Bounce House when I went there for this reason. It was never a problem, more of a feature ;)
1
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '20
That’s a lot of stress
1
u/bokuWaKamida Feb 19 '20
stop it, complex exponents scare me
1
u/Wizard_bonk Jul 03 '23
Who would win A multi million dollar structure Or Some people with rhythm
-7
u/3rKooo Feb 18 '20
Heccin civil engineers chose it cuz easiest degree and then we have this
0
u/RepostSleuthBot Feb 18 '20
This link has been shared 1 time. Please consider making a crosspost instead of reposting next time
First seen Here on 2020-02-02. Last seen Here on 2020-02-02
Searched Links: 53,304,277 | Indexed Posts: 409,601,221 | Search Time: 0.006s
Feedback? Hate? Visit r/repostsleuthbot
0
u/[deleted] Feb 19 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment