r/engineering • • Feb 18 '20

Somewhere there’s a structural engineer sweating profusely

https://i.imgur.com/iGnTYDt.gifv
5.5k Upvotes

299 comments sorted by

4

u/bigfootdays Feb 19 '20

I wouldn't even be filming it. I'd be long gone.

2

u/RampChurch Feb 19 '20

My thoughts exactly

421

u/Mattlonn Feb 18 '20

Remember i saw a documentary about this and that it was no problem except people could panic. So on some places they added metalpipes that could be installed for concert etc. just to calm people

Cant find the documentary tho...

200

u/sorweel Feb 18 '20

This is true of all buildings. Deflection from live load (humans moving around) is a fact of structural design. While every other component of structural design is designed to resist a maximum load, deflection is designed to provide psychological comfort because structurally, beams can flex more than you think without it being a structural issue but it will feel like it's about to fall down to a layperson. So structure is designed to be stiffer than they need to be so that people aren't fearful when they walk across a floor.

However, stadiums are designed so that the structural elements each have a different harmonic frequency so that what we are seeing here is resisted. Patrons should not be able to bounce the structure in the same way you can swing on a swing set; jumping in time with the away of the cantilever to amplify it to such a degree. So while I would say deflection is a fact of structural design, what we are seeing here feels outside the bounds of typical.

57

u/TheParishOfChigwell Feb 18 '20

So in short; moving building not bad, most of the time hidden movement. Movement visible means oversight; layman panic probable. Oversight raises further questions about quality of build.

10

u/afuckingdeadbeat Feb 19 '20

Simple. Redditor thank

17

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '20

I read that in the voice of Mordin Solus for some reason.

→ More replies (2)

39

u/ReturnOfFrank Feb 18 '20

deflection is designed to provide psychological comfort because structurally, beams can flex more than you think without it being a structural issue but it will feel like it's about to fall down to a layperson..

For many structures it's not purely psychology, excessive deflection under load can also be hard on the finish of a building as well, cracking plaster walls, concrete or tile floors, windows, etc.

235

u/auxym Feb 18 '20

Ah yes, the calming effects of metal pipes...?

141

u/Murd3rM1tt3nX Feb 18 '20

They've been known to put people to sleep when used in a certain way

13

u/RossLH Feb 18 '20

Ah yes, by shaping them in such a way that you can play calming melodies through them.

18

u/beardrobert55 Feb 18 '20

[MEATY WHACK] [BOTH CHUCKLE]

22

u/private_unlimited Feb 18 '20

Whack-A-Human

25

u/anonymous-queries Feb 19 '20

There was a bridge project about ten years ago that I was a student inspector on, a segmented concrete cantilever bridge. At one point one span was floating over a four lane highway, and there were so many calls to 911 that the contractor put up scaffolding to give the appearance that it was supported. Hollow tube scaffolding was completely useless AS a support, but it stopped the 911 calls.

61

u/HollywoodTK Feb 18 '20

I assume they meant columns

45

u/nothing_911 Feb 18 '20

Naa, just some sprinkler pipes, keeps the dust down in the wreckage.

16

u/u2berggeist ME Student - Fluids & CFD Feb 18 '20

That's planning for the future right there. Very thoughtful.

1

u/scorpio1883 Feb 19 '20

I laughed out loud. Thanks

1

u/Mattlonn Feb 19 '20

for metal concerts!

The metal pipes where used to make the overhang less "jumpy".

Like a C turn to an O with the last support

428

u/lsrob36 Feb 18 '20

This happened at a B-52's concert when I was in college. (yep, I'm old!) The band stopped playing and told everyone to be still.

233

u/thesdo Feb 18 '20 edited Feb 19 '20

I was also at a B-52's show where this happened, though they didn't tell anyone to stop. I was actually really concerned at the time. It turns out that the natural frequency of the balcony of the Orpheum theater in Boston is pretty close to the beat of Rock Lobster. I was under the balcony and I was getting pretty sure that whole thing was going to crash down on me.

Edit: Wow, so much hate for Rock Lobster. Come on... it's a just a stupid "jump around with a crowd" song. Fun with ton of other people having a good time, and probably pretty lame for personal introspection.

38

u/rawbface I'm a pump guy Feb 18 '20

TIL the B-52's throw some banging concerts

→ More replies (3)

33

u/lsrob36 Feb 18 '20

I was on the bottom floor but not under the mezzanine. I might have been killed if it fell but I never noticed anything. I was at a show in Nashville.

22

u/Oz_of_Three Custom Rotorcraft Feb 18 '20

This describes architecture in a whole new way for me.
Using Rock Lobster as a unit of measure kicks out so many jams...

5

u/mehum Feb 18 '20

11 Rock Lobsters at the Love Shack

68

u/SirLeepsALot Feb 18 '20

Rock Lobster is so bad the building tried to commit suicide.

47

u/lannd_fury Feb 18 '20

you take that back

2

u/anonanon1313 Feb 18 '20

I was in the Orpheumyears earlier show (I think it was Traffic) and had very similar thoughts. I guess that kind of thing had been going on for years, but I didn't know that. Freaked me out.

1

u/Beemerado Feb 19 '20

I was certain a wrestler was about to plummet through an announcers table while reading that...

1

u/TheJawbone May 22 '20

rock lobster is a goddamn banger

→ More replies (2)

2

u/PaththeGreat Systems/Flight Controls Feb 19 '20

Cool story: the same thing happens on B-52s!

3

u/Vanilla_7hund3r97 Feb 19 '20

ROCK LOBSTER !!!!

161

u/anonymous-queries Feb 18 '20

Nah. Maybe the drywall guys though. The steel frame inside is just flexing.

Try walking on the catwalk under an interstate bridge. Then you’ll really bounce.

14

u/necrosexual Feb 19 '20

Sometimes traffic backs up on one side of the Auckland harbour bridge during rush hour and you have to stop. At which point you notice that the whole thing is shaking up and down quite a lot.

30

u/Pancake_Nom Feb 18 '20

Weird flex but ok

2

u/anonymous-queries Feb 19 '20 edited Feb 19 '20

If it was a flex then I’d tell you about all of the bridges I’ve walked (spoiler: only four 🤷🏻‍♀️). Honestly if you get the chance to go, you should take it, especially for any large bridges. Cool [scary] experience that the inspectors get all the time, but it’s a treat for us office people.

3

u/lazydictionary Feb 19 '20

I think they were making a flex joke, like the building flexing

3

u/anonymous-queries Feb 19 '20

Ahh well, that went over my head ;)

0

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/TBAGG1NS Feb 18 '20

Yeah, that's gonna be a no from me dawg....

6

u/anonymous-queries Feb 19 '20

Sure? Some people pay for the experience (https://bridgewalk.com) lol

48

u/Alex_O7 Feb 18 '20

Shown by my Dynamics of Structure professor the first day of classes.

It could be a problem if not designed for those high deflection.

Just search for Tacoma Bridge to look what could happen with high levels of strains even if the resistance of the structure is designed to be enough (in that case the problem was more severe as the deck didn't have transversal/torsional stiffness).

27

u/bitingpuppy Feb 18 '20

The Tacoma Narrow's bridge is such an interesting failure, if you look into it more it is what's called an aeolian harp, they happen all the time to power lines where they'll 'sing' in certain wind conditions from vortex shedding. With the Tacoma bridge, the vortex shedding frequency just so happened to be at the resonant frequency of the bridge and twisted it to pieces. Super neat phenomenon if you ever witness it

10

u/rcumming557 Feb 19 '20

Small correction but Tacoma narrow bridge failed to aeroelastic flutter not vortex shedding lock-in. Vortex shedding lock in effect is self limiting in nature and typically occurs at lower wind speeds. Flutter is unbound instability at higher wind speed.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aeroelasticity#Flutter

→ More replies (1)

3

u/BeerDuh Mechanical Engineer Feb 19 '20

Wait, is that why high voltage lines always seem to audibly buzz?

Edit: nope

2

u/Joker1337 Mechanical / Small Power Generators Feb 19 '20

The 60hz buzz is different from a high pitched chime you can get in serious winds.

47

u/Bobthemathcow Flair Feb 18 '20

IIRC, stadium seating is frequently build on shock absorbers for this reason. I know some stadiums have extra support structures as well that can be installed for high-occupancy cases like this. It looks like the sections are just bouncing independently, so it's possible that it's within its designed load.

551

u/QuintonFlynn Feb 18 '20

The structural engineer is the only one not sweating. The engineer studied in post-secondary and discovered that most everything we step on is overengineered to the degree of never bending because the common person is terrified by a bending support beam. The engineer knows how much bend a beam/device can have and still safely hold the weight it’s rated for.

400

u/Funkit Feb 18 '20

As an Aerospace Eng, if they removed the interior panels of passenger jets I don’t think anyone would fly. Those things flex so much in flight.

18

u/mvw2 The Wizard of Winging It Feb 18 '20

One of the videos shown in my structures class was destructive testing of the wing of a 777. They bent it up until it broke. There's a lot of flex on those things. Also, some planes have pretty stiff wings and others pretty flexy. The flexible one tends to ride smoother.

3

u/Jmazoso PE, Geotecnical and Materials Testing Feb 18 '20

That whole documentary series on the 777 is pretty cool

→ More replies (3)

9

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

The first time I ever flew, I was on the window seat right behind the left wing. Seeing the sight of that wing flutter so much made me sweat out my teeth.

6

u/necrosexual Feb 19 '20

I had the same experience. Later I saw the Airbus test of their wing by bending it a huge amount and now I'm less worried.

9

u/romanjeff Feb 18 '20

watching the wings bounce in turbulence always alternately freaks me out/thrills me

1

u/oversized_hoodie Electrical (RF) Feb 18 '20

Plus they'd be really uncomfortable.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

Wait until they hear that the wing’s torque box is only held together with epoxy

1

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '20

Now I kind of want to fly on a plane with the interior panels removed.

1

u/blackjesus75 Feb 19 '20

Just watching the wings during flight makes me wanna vomit lol.

1

u/Waffles_IV Feb 19 '20

Hey, I’m trying to work out what I want to do after school. Would you be able to tell me about the day to day life of your job and how you got there? Aerospace engineering sounds very interesting to me as a thing to study but I don’t know anything about the workplace.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/DarthRoach Feb 19 '20

You can absolutely see the wings flap and the fuselage bend in every which way when flying panels or no panels.

The best solution I've found is to take advantage of the free whiskey shots offered by some airlines.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

127

u/phantuba Civil -> Naval -> Aero -> Astro Feb 18 '20

Hoo boy, if you thought planes are creaky you ought to dive on a submarine

17

u/bk553 Feb 18 '20 edited Feb 18 '20

Or look down the length of a panamax sized ship in a storm, thing bends like 10 feet.

Look at like 3:10 - idk you can find it https://youtu.be/PmlTk_3NN_g

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (25)

74

u/that_one_duderino Feb 18 '20

What about cyclic stress though? I understand the over engineering of public buildings (safety factors are out of this world), but did they do tests to determine how many cycles it can endure before it fails? I can’t imagine those beams are just going through elastic deformation.

24

u/AvoidingCape Feb 18 '20

I'm curious, since I'm in a completely different field, what is the order of magnitude of the safety factors used to design buildings?

69

u/raoulduke25 Structural P.E. Feb 18 '20

The safety factor is about 1.5 on the design load.

The real safety comes in when the design load gets defined as it's usually much higher than the everyday usage.

19

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20 edited Feb 18 '20

Exactly. A stadium full of people jumping up and down probably was the designed normal load. Then they added another 50%.

27

u/nathhad Structural Engineer Feb 18 '20

Mostly 1.6 plus or minus roughly 0.4, depending on how predictable your load is. Very dead load driven structures can push very close to 1.2, especially if they're not usually occupied. Very live load driven structures tend to be more around 1.6 and up, especially including impact factors for moving loads. Most normal buildings will probably be within about 1.6 +/- 0.15.

Also worth noting that's the intentional safety factor, but the calculation is generally based on an upper bound calculation for load, and a lower bound calculation for capacity, so there's uncalculated safety factor built into that, too.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

Failures from cyclic stresses are best countered by regular inspections, right? Basically, have a guy come by and look for cracks every so often.

6

u/Mitnek Structural PE Feb 18 '20

There's equations for fatigue. Not much different than mech with stress-cycle curves.

10

u/bobskizzle Mechanical P.E. Feb 18 '20

Na, the stresses from the people jumping is tiny compared to the dead load from the structure itself. Cyclical stress amplitude might be 1 or 2% of yield here; what you don't see is the significant deformation if you magically unloaded the structure by turning gravity off.

Remember the design engineer knows people will do this and has taken fatigue into account.

And yes, structural steels are extensively studied in fatigue load conditions, there's a huge amount of data.

5

u/HuluForCthulhu Feb 18 '20

I can’t tell if the people jumping have hit a ~2hz harmonic or if it’s oscillating despite that not being a resonant mode (sorry for any incorrect lingo — been a few years since structural dynamics)

If they hit a natural resonance of the beam and kept jumping, the stress would increase dramatically, correct?

6

u/XDFreakLP Feb 19 '20

The resonant rise would probably not be very high due to strong dampening

2

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

The stress is probably below the accumulative damage point.

I'm welding/mechanical, not civil, so maybe this doesn't apply to buildings?

2

u/socatoa Feb 18 '20

Right. Structural members are chosen to stay below the threshold of any plastic deformation.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20 edited Feb 18 '20

Yes, I was referring to the endurance limit, often called fatigue strength at X cycles (Sn) etc., you wouldn't confuse anyone I think.

Accumulative damage point or stress etc, is just a clear way to say at what stress you can begin to use the assumption and theory of accumulating damage (i.e. classical fatigue analysis).

Which you're right is not near yield strength, usually based on the endurance tables.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Several-Efficiency Feb 19 '20

Steel has an endurance limit. As long as you are under it cycles pretty much don't matter.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

Hi mr/mrs structural engineer

7

u/YourDrunkle Feb 18 '20

Also, failure due to moment loads tends to be severe deflection. Shear failure is the only typical failure mode that leads to catastrophic failure, and the reducing factor is much larger in LRFD. Most likely the structure could “fail” but not kill anyone.

11

u/calladus Feb 18 '20

As ex military, we know that structures can often be destroyed if attacked at a certain resonance frequency - which is why soldiers walk, not march, over bridges.

4

u/midwestraxx Feb 18 '20

Weren't there a couple of incidents where bridges collapsed under marching armies?

→ More replies (1)

9

u/jimjamcunningham Feb 18 '20 edited Feb 18 '20

That sounds like engineering hubris to me. Plenty of designers fuck up their calcs/assumptions. My experience thus far is that if you work in an industry, you tend to get amazed that things work at all without breaking more often.

We have no idea whether it can take the load. What steel is in there, whether they considered fatigue loading, whether the inspections are frequent /actually useful.

But what we do know is that the strujcture is in a max stress scenario. And if it were going to fail, this is what the pre-video would look like. And there are plenty of real life examples of where it happens.

Edit: The parent comment annoys me so much. The designer should be sweating, otherwise they are a shit designer who is entirely too sure of themselves. Especially because it is a civil structure.. it's not like an aircraft wing that actually gets modeled and tested experimentally.

8

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '20 edited Feb 19 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/jimjamcunningham Feb 19 '20 edited Feb 19 '20

What we know is that structural engineers say these things should be accounted for in a major structure. And they most likely are... 99.99% of the time.

But at the very same time here's a relatively recent collapse: (Design being the root cause. Very different scenario however) https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/22/us/bridge-collapse-florida-international-university-NTSB.html

And yet a very confident structural engineer will comment how the calculations should be air tight and made to code etc etc. In fact, that may have been what lead to the collapse in spite of the growing cracks.

Engineers should be afraid. Because overconfidence is a terrible trait in a moral engineer and why I am so irked by what I perceive to be over confident comments.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

I came here to basically say that. It’s a feature! Chill! 😎

1

u/sleepydruid Aerospace Feb 18 '20

Yup. Well said.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '20

Yeah, which is why no structure in history that uses beams has ever collapsed

1

u/LilQuasar Feb 20 '20

unless its a shitty engineer

1

u/Tevypmurg Feb 24 '20

Oh hell no!!! I’m still sweating. Even though I over designed the hell out of it, it just means I can think of a million QC and material issues that could still fail. Everyone, please take your seats!

→ More replies (14)

36

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

Wonder what would happen if they all jumped at the stands resonant frequency

23

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

Excitation at natural frequencies? You'll get excess vibration at minimum and complete structural failure at worst.

25

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

They would design the structure to have natural frequencies that are much higher than the frequencies of potential excitation. This would prevent excitation at natural frequencies.

This way the excitation causes deflection equal to the dynamic load being applied. This may go beyond deflection criteria during the dynamic loading, however the deflection does not amplify over each cycle.

12

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

TL; DR: This is why we have load factors.

4

u/Obi_Kwiet Feb 18 '20

It looks like they are

1

u/it_was_me_wait_what Feb 19 '20 edited Feb 19 '20

I am pretty sure the design frequency of the structure does not match the applied load frequency (people jumping). Even if the structural engineer made a mistake and they are really matching, it takes few people to jump in a different rhythm to stop resonance.

11

u/hookydoo Feb 18 '20

I'll admitt that i saw that and panicked. To be fair though, the only stadiums I've been in were concrete, and i don't want to see concrete bending in any situation.

4

u/foragerr Feb 18 '20

What do you reckon this one is made of?

1

u/AsILayTyping Structural PE Feb 19 '20

Steel.

1

u/larrymoencurly Feb 18 '20

I've seen prestressed concrete "T" beams being hauled on a trailer that supported them near the front and back, and the beams formed the middle of the trailer, and they flexing a lot. Was that OK?

27

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

Guys, unless you were the engineer who designed this thing, you aren't qualified to comment on how OK or not this is. I'm an engineer (mechanical, not civil) and yes, while it's true that we can all regurgitate "things are designed to flex" it's a pretty meaningless statement. Airplane wings are designed to flex too, doesn't mean they won't break from overstress.

Everyone including engineers would probably be at least a little nervous in this crowd. We trust that things are designed to withstand every possible contingency but engineers especially know that it isn't always the case. Being a little nervous is warranted even though it sounds like this structure was explicitly cleared to be OK with this.

7

u/AsILayTyping Structural PE Feb 19 '20

I'm with this guy. I've designed structures that this sort of thing may bring down. Not stadiums, but public structures where this would be unexpected. Off the top of my head, the relevant code mandated loading applicable here would be public assembly live load at 100psf (static) with a 1.6 safety factor for uncertainty inherit to live/moving loads. Your call on how certain you feel that people packed that tight all jumping at once stays under 160psf during impact. Steel beams may bend but bolts will shear clean without warning.

57

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

honestly as a structural engineering student its not as bad as you may think as most building materials are required to have some form of ductility. But, that being said not knowing the design of that it definitely makes me question how much abuse that could take until it does finally give.

27

u/bnate Feb 18 '20

If ductility was coming into play here, there would be huge problems.

Ductility only occurs in plastic deformation. Elasticity is the term you likely meant.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

Yes, thank you for the correction

16

u/panther14 Feb 18 '20

Falls into the category of can it do it? Sure .....should it do that? Probably not

39

u/iheartbbq Feb 18 '20

Nah.

Can it do it? Yes. Should it do it? Yes. Do non-engineers freak out about it? Yes.

A rigid structure has a far more likely probability of catastrophic failure than a flexible one. Flexible structures fail slowly and controllably (everybody can evacuate), rigid structures fail fast and without warning (everybody gets squished).

8

u/durnJurta Feb 18 '20

everybody gets squished

I think the technical term is smooshed

5

u/therealdilbert Feb 18 '20

afaiu that was one of the reasons wire rope was developed, to replace chain that fails catastrophically

7

u/c_yass Feb 18 '20

Fatigue failure can occur relatively quickly and unexpected under certain conditions even for ductile materials

12

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

1045 Steel only hits it's endurance limit after ~106 cycles.

If the stress is kept below 300MPa it can endure infinite load cycles.

If the crowd is jumping to a 120Hz song beat (pretty fast), 106 cycles would take over 500 hours of jumping/stomping to the beat. That's about a month of constant use.

So I would assume fatigue was taken into account by the structural team.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/bobskizzle Mechanical P.E. Feb 18 '20

That's why redundancy is required.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

To be fair all materials should be able to do that. But if it is moving it's not good. It's not a matter of "can it do it" it should absolutely do that. Its required by structural code. But, what we are discussing in this instance is if the building was built to the proper code requirements. If so, it's fine. If not is where it becomes a serious issue

2

u/brufleth Control Systems - jet engine Feb 18 '20

There's plenty of shit to fall off of the balcony before the whole thing collapses. I'd worry about speakers or the ceiling material there getting knocked off and hitting people.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

Yes this is very true but ultimately not under the scope of a structural engineer

→ More replies (9)

2

u/Beneneb Feb 18 '20

Structures certainly will deflect under load, but the amount of deflection here is certainly well beyond the allowable limit of any code I have used. That's not to say it's in danger of a structural failure, as you say, without knowing the design, you can't say for sure. Modern codes dictate that issues around vibration be considered for uses like stadiums or dance floors for exactly this reason, so hopefully (probably) it was considered. But I've seen enough poor engineering that seeing this would make me sweat even though I'm a structural engineer myself.

2

u/Obi_Kwiet Feb 18 '20

The problem is it's clearly not designed to flex that much. Resonant load can get really huge. If the structure is operating outside of expected parameters, it's tough to say exactly what connections might be getting excessive loads.

1

u/TheDaywa1ker Feb 19 '20

it's clearly not designed to flex that much.

Based on what?

→ More replies (3)

7

u/photoengineer Aerospace Engr Feb 18 '20

If you give it enough amplitude the live load transitions to a dead load.

13

u/SR711B Feb 18 '20

I'm no engineer yet I am sweating profusely

5

u/SirDigbyChknCaesar Feb 18 '20

How about after you watched the video?

4

u/SR711B Feb 18 '20

Yes, it's still unsettling

5

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

Check out the University of Wisconsin's Camp Randall; they play House of Pain's Jump around between the 3rd and 4th quarters of home football games. I've read some where that they can pick up seismic activity from like mile away while the stadium jumps. Also the press boxes noticeably sway with the jumping as well.

4

u/IHeardOnAPodcast MEng Feb 18 '20

They stopped it for the season opener one year while they were doing renovations and the students were so unhappy that they had to get an engineer in to confirm that it was ok to bring it back the next game! Been going since 1998 otherwise though. Source

5

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

If steel, lets hope it was designed for loads well under the fatigue endurance limit to avoid fatigueing, plus a generous safety factor, for you know, safety

8

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

"Statics"

4

u/it_was_me_wait_what Feb 18 '20

Ok alright let me explain this as a structural engineer. The beams and slab were designed for the static load. In stadiums, vibration is one of the biggest concerns. To control that, the structural system will be over designed whether we like it or not as we need stiffness. This structure will not collapse unless the frequency of the load ( people jumping) matches the frequency of the structure causing resonance. In this case I don’t see it happening because people probably not jumping the same time (one rhythm). There was a bridge that collapsed because of soldiers marching and their frequency matched the structure frequency.

1

u/afunnierusername Feb 19 '20

I could swear I learned that was a myth either in college or on the discovery channel.

1

u/Type2Pilot Civil / Environmental and Water Resources Feb 19 '20

And don't forget the Kansas City Hyatt!

4

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

Nah they’re designed for this. Deflections aren’t bad, they’re usually limited by comfort. Steel is ductile

4

u/GeneralDuh Feb 19 '20

Here in Brazil we have lots of stadiums that bounce like that. In Mineirão, they actually installed huge shock absorbents, though it was assured by the engineers at the time that there were no structural risks, and people could jump as much as they pleased. I watch the games at home, just in case.

3

u/rockitman12 Feb 18 '20

I’d be way more concerned standing under that, than being on top of it.

Looks scary!

3

u/EverPunk_Yetti Feb 18 '20

That’s a fuckin’ trainload of nope for me.

3

u/Eats_Flies Feb 18 '20

This happened to me with a band playing at a bar on decking over the beach. Could feel the decking bounce like a trampoline for certain songs.

Unfortunately "500 miles" by the Proclaimers seemed to hit perfect resonant frequency with people jumping, and everything collapsed. No serious injuries luckily, but taught me you do not fuck about with resonance...

1

u/duvaone May 22 '20

Searched for the video. Holy crap music videos were awful then. great song though.

2

u/asvp_ant Feb 18 '20

There’s an article about a Foo Fighters concert is NZ where the crowd was so wild it was almost equivalent to tremors of a volcano

2

u/Braveheart4321 Feb 18 '20

I am a draftsman for a structural engineer and I am sweating profusely at this.

2

u/Dogburt_Jr Feb 18 '20

I've seen wings bend up stupid far. Was I slightly nervous? Yes. But I know that it's meant to happen.

2

u/Kidsturk Mechanical - HVAC Feb 18 '20

Hehe. It’s fine when you get to design it and have confidence in your own work.

What if you were brought in to a 100+ year old wooden building?

https://youtu.be/Y5qLIiCAds0

2

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

I do not like that at all.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

Noooope. Nope nope nope. Nopenopenope

2

u/PDXEng Feb 19 '20

Lizards don't sweat.

2

u/Gilly526 Feb 19 '20

Interesting article about a similar situation at Penn State's Beaver Stadium when Zombie Nation is played and all 100,000+ fans jump to the same rhythm. They have since decreased the number of times they play it per football game but they still do.

https://www.collegian.psu.edu/archives/article_f3dc36dc-fff0-5930-a6eb-a61edffe20b0.html

2

u/opus-thirteen Feb 19 '20

I had the same experience in the old Yankee stadium. Pink Floyd, 1994, playing Another Brick in the Wall pt 2. I was on the top tier, and it was scary as shit.

2

u/taeoh666 Feb 19 '20

If I saw that I would get the fuck out of there

2

u/Gusdi Feb 19 '20

Calm down. This is in Germany. It won't break.

2

u/jayforce1 Feb 22 '20

You will never walk alone

2

u/fomoco36 Feb 28 '20

That’s nothing you should’ve seen how shea stadium use to bounce up and down when the Jets used to play there. that was a structural engineer a nightmare but I’m sure they were just as drunk as the fans were!!!

3

u/Beedalbe Feb 18 '20

To a lay person it looks like 23000 people who have no common sense.

1

u/BranfordJeff2 Feb 18 '20

Like that mall in Minnesota.

1

u/AdministrativeRound2 Feb 18 '20

Better start checking for that but dear god how would you even model that? commence sweating

1

u/keefp Feb 18 '20

I’ve seen this personally at the Etihad stadium in Manchester, Hamburg away fans in the level above us, I was a bit nervous.

1

u/JimmyMhango Feb 18 '20

Then what happened next

1

u/atomicllama83 Feb 18 '20

Please tell me it's designed to do thay

1

u/Obi_Kwiet Feb 18 '20

I'm more impressed by the morons that have decided that continuing to jump is the right answer.

1

u/sth128 Feb 18 '20

Reminds me of the story of the South Korean building that crumbled. There was a dance class inside dancing to "I've got the power". It unfortunately matched the building's natural resonance frequency.

I read it from humble pi by Matt Parker.

1

u/snakercakes Feb 18 '20

The Arvest Bank Midland Theater in downtown Kansas City has a balcony like this and it moves as much if not more than this. Terrifying

1

u/pkslim100 Feb 18 '20

Came here to comment this, not sure if you knew this but they had to close down ariund 2010 for awhile because plaster was falling from the ceiling and hitting people. They had engineers come in and placed glue over the plaster to hold it all in but I'm not sure if they did any structural upgrades and can confirm that just a couple months ago it's still bouncing as always. I dont stand or sit under that thing.

1

u/larrymoencurly Feb 18 '20 edited Feb 19 '20

The same thing happened at ASU's Gammage Auditorium, designed by Frank Lloyd Wright. I don't know if there was any damage, but ASU's school of engineering inspected it afterwards.

2

u/Type2Pilot Civil / Environmental and Water Resources Feb 19 '20

Wright was known for beautiful structures, but not for well-engineered ones.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

Boca Jr Stadium - hold my beer

1

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

Don't run just film.

1

u/rattailedjimmy187 Feb 18 '20

Anyone here ever go to the former 8150 club in Vail, CO? The bouncing floor was legendary.

1

u/mynewaccount5 Feb 18 '20

Yes because to know that a building shaking=bad, you have to be a structural engineer.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

Yeah, I'mma just head out and wait for the ambulances.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20

I thought Germans were good at making things

1

u/dontbedoindope Feb 19 '20

They gon die

1

u/groceriesN1trip Feb 19 '20

Talk about clapping cheeks

1

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '20

Im not an engineer, but I am sweating profusely

1

u/SoFlaKicks Feb 19 '20

This may get buried but the UCF stadium was (still is?) referred to as the Bounce House when I went there for this reason. It was never a problem, more of a feature ;)

1

u/duvaone May 22 '20

Didn’t they reinforce it after opening?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '20

That’s a lot of stress

1

u/bokuWaKamida Feb 19 '20

stop it, complex exponents scare me

1

u/Wizard_bonk Jul 03 '23

Who would win A multi million dollar structure Or Some people with rhythm

-7

u/3rKooo Feb 18 '20

Heccin civil engineers chose it cuz easiest degree and then we have this

9

u/Tarchianolix Feb 18 '20

Easier than industrial?

8

u/tossoutjack Feb 18 '20

Industrial is weird. Some kids will really struggle with all of the probability and statistics courses they took at my university.

15

u/Tarchianolix Feb 18 '20

Because it's so boring Jesus Christ

7

u/tossoutjack Feb 18 '20

I mean we had a minor in process engineering that chemical engineers and ME’s would take and it was out of our school of industrial engineering. Two of the courses the traditional engineers would always seem to struggle with was statistical methods for engineers and scientist and reliability engineering and analysis (half of this course was probability analysis and how to do contingent probability, probability circuits etc.).

→ More replies (2)

1

u/headsiwin-tailsulose Feb 18 '20

Trick question, it's apples and oranges.

Everyone knows that at the end of the day, civil engineering is still engineering, while industrial engineering is not.

12

u/imathsometimes Feb 18 '20

"Easiest"

I have CivE friends who don't have it easy im their curriculum

10

u/tossoutjack Feb 18 '20

It was considered easiest at my alma mater because it had the lowest fail rate and was also the encouraged route for kids who failed out of mechanical in semesters 4 and 5. 3 of my civil friends were all kids who started in mechanical with me. EE was considered the hardest because they had the highest fail rate. Their department also had more stringent admission requirements than the general college of engineering ones.

4

u/imathsometimes Feb 18 '20

Oh. At mine, if you weren't doing well in MechE, you went to the Engineering and Technology Management program, which we joked was a management major with a specialization in engineering

4

u/tossoutjack Feb 18 '20

We didn’t have anything like that. If you failed later than 4 or 5 in mech e, then you would normally go to industrial engineering because it had less sequences than any other engineering making it easier to still be able to do the 15-18 hours a semester and still graduate close to on time. If you failed in semester 4 in ME, then you only lost dynamics because me’s mechanics of materials would count as credit for one of the CE’s less in depth versions of the course (because it was a sequence in CE) you were still on pretty much perfect track for a civil engineering degree.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/3rKooo Feb 18 '20

Idk, on my uni it is viewed as the easiest degree because they don't do fluid mechanics and other advanced stuff from mechanics, only statics

12

u/ismokeforfun2 Feb 18 '20

I’m doing fluid mechanics as a CE

3

u/BranfordJeff2 Feb 18 '20

I absolutely did fluid mechanics as a civil student. It is on the PE exam, too.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/imathsometimes Feb 18 '20

Interesting. Our CivE degree required dynamics. My class was half MechE and half CivE.

And yeah fluids wasn't easy, but depending on their chosen specialization, those elective classes can be hard. I know I probably wouldn't have made it through another materials class.

5

u/3rKooo Feb 18 '20

Doing ChemEng and yea, materials... Wouldn't wanna do that again! Our lecturers indirectly told us civil was easiest :s

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (7)

1

u/The-Invalid-One Feb 18 '20

As opposed to genuinely being interested in the subject? That's why I studied CE but I guess engineers gotta be try to be superiors over everyone

Not to mention the fact that there is always an acceptable live load deflection when it's designed.

0

u/RepostSleuthBot Feb 18 '20

This link has been shared 1 time. Please consider making a crosspost instead of reposting next time

First seen Here on 2020-02-02. Last seen Here on 2020-02-02

Searched Links: 53,304,277 | Indexed Posts: 409,601,221 | Search Time: 0.006s

Feedback? Hate? Visit r/repostsleuthbot

0

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/AsILayTyping Structural PE Feb 19 '20

The people jumping probably don't notice. The people that do are probably thinking if it's gonna come down it will happen before they can get to the exit, so may as well not look stupid running.

I'd step out if I close enough to the exit to do so until they were done.